Running Head: SUSTAINABILITY EDUCATION IN ELEMENTARY SCHOOLS Sustainability Education in Elementary Schools: Sustainability for Young Learners Courses Sydney D. V. Lund Arizona State University – School of Sustainability April 12, 2020 1 SUSTAINABILITY EDUCATION IN ELEMENTARY SCHOOLS 2 Table of Contents Abstract ...................................................................................................................................... 3 Introduction ................................................................................................................................ 4 Sustainability within Public Schools............................................................................................ 4 Sustainability for Young Learners Courses.................................................................................. 6 Idea Conception ...................................................................................................................... 6 Supporting Research ............................................................................................................... 7 Target Audience ...................................................................................................................... 8 Building the Project .................................................................................................................... 8 Strengths, Weaknesses, Opportunities, and Threats (SWOT) Analysis ...................................... 10 Project Schedule – Work Breakout Schedule ............................................................................. 11 Key Takeaways ......................................................................................................................... 14 Six Key Concepts to Create Successful Environmental Literacy Programs ............................ 14 Conclusion ................................................................................................................................ 17 References ................................................................................................................................ 18 Appendix A - Standards and Sustainability Topics per Grade Level .......................................... 21 Appendix B - Work Breakout Schedule – Sustainability for Young Learners Courses ............... 26 Appendix C - Third Grade Unit Plain – Ocean Plastics, The Problem and the Soultion.............. 27 Appendix D - Second Grade Unit Plan – Our Melting Oceans, Soild and Liquid Water............. 58 SUSTAINABILITY EDUCATION IN ELEMENTARY SCHOOLS 3 Abstract Children are our future businesspeople, policy makers, and educators. As such, during their careers and throughout their life, they will be the leaders making tough decisions on how to respond to extreme heat phenomenon, rising sea levels, changing weather patterns, and the increased presence of greenhouse gases, which could thrust our Earth into irreversible change if emissions are not reduced drastically over the next few decades. When evaluating the required Next Generation Science Standards for elementary school, these standards do not include environmental literacy or sustainability themes in either second, third, or fourth grades, with little mention via one standard in first, fifth, and sixth grades. Overall, the Next Generation Science Standards do not adequately prepare students for the sustainability problems of the future nor do the standards help connect students to the natural environment by not connecting the standards to real world climate issues. Not educating students about sustainability topics in elementary school passes the responsibility off to higher grades with optional science classes, where this sustainability education could be missed altogether. The Sustainability for Young Learners Courses were created to equip elementary school teachers with sustainability knowledge and resources to effectivity teach sustainability to their students. The Sustainability for Young Learners Courses infuse sustainability and environmental literacy into second through fifth grade science classes via the creation of detailed unit plans. Each course incorporates important sustainability themes into the required Next Generation Science Standards, to encourage teachers to adopt these unit plans without taking away limited class time to teach about sustainability. Rather than ending in doom and gloom, students finish each unit becoming the heroes of the story by creating their own solutions to combat climate change that they can implement into their own lives, communities, homes, and classroom. Sustainability and climate related issues are already sweeping our Earth and the problem is likely going to accelerate as today’s current elementary school students start their professional careers. Equipping young students with environmental literacy and sustainability knowledge can allow students to be ready to face real-world climate related issues in the future as well as today as these students serve as leaders within their communities and schools. By realizing the gap in the United States education system, the Sustainability for Young Learners courses is helping to create a more equitable, prosperous, and sustainable society through education and knowledge. SUSTAINABILITY EDUCATION IN ELEMENTARY SCHOOLS 4 Introduction Sustainability is a three-legged stool, containing three pillars needed for success. The three sustainability pillars are environment, social, and economic (UN General Assembly, 2015). The environmental pillar represents an understanding that in order for the human species to sustain ourselves, we must protect our environmental resources and natural spaces for future use and enjoyment. This pillar is similar to the “leave no trace” trail moto, where humans strive to leave as small of a trace as possible on our natural environment, in order for future generations to utilize, enjoy, and prosper alongside the natural environment. The second pillar represents the social side of sustainability, which firstly ensures that all basic human needs are met and secondly provides equitable, fair, and safe opportunities for people of all backgrounds and cultures. The third pillar of sustainability is the economic side of sustainability. This warrants that all individuals will be economically able to meet their daily needs while businesses and governments are able to continuously operate within the other two pillars. Sustainability leadership melds traditional leadership ideologies with the three pillars of sustainability to create leaders that are equipped with the skills needed to make decisions today with future-thinking in mind (Gallagher, 2012). As with any leader, sustainability leaders do not need a title to create change, and they can appear at any part of the organization or community. Sustainability leaders are individuals that understand the three pillars of sustainability and take science-based climate science into consideration when making decisions, actions, and progress towards creating a more equitable, healthy, and sustainable future. Sustainability within Public Schools Sustainability leadership is a relatively new field, only emerging as university majors over the past two decades. However, some companies have been following sustainability goals and values for over two decades, including arguably one of the best for-profit business in the sustainability game, Patagonia and others taking the field by storm including Unilever and Interface (Coulter & Lee, 2013). Despite the surge of businesses releasing sustainability reports and universities winning sustainability awards, the sustainability movement has not made its way into the K-12 public schools throughout the United States. Most students in the United States are required to be taught a multitude of standards for each subject, including the Common Core standards for Math and English Language Arts, which includes History, along with the Next Generation Science Standards for science (Common Core State Standards Initiative, 2019) (Next SUSTAINABILITY EDUCATION IN ELEMENTARY SCHOOLS 5 Generation Science Standards, 2019). Additionally, each state also has standards released by that state’s Department of Education, which can include additional subjects and standards. For example, Colorado has standards in Science, Music, Physical Education, Computer Science, and Reading, Writing and Communication that schools within Colorado must teach to their students in addition to the Common Core and Next Generation Science Standards (Colorado Department of Education, 2019). With schools required to teach so many different standards, teachers do not have class time to teach subjects or topics outside of those described within the required standards. Schools are designed to educate and prepare students for the future. But schools are failing to educate students for a life in a world with more extreme heat phenomenon, rising sea levels, changing weather patterns, and the increased presence of greenhouse gases, which could thrust our earth into irreversible change if emissions are not reduced drastically over the next few decades (NASA, 2019). The required elementary Next Generation Science Standards only educate about sustainability themes in kindergarten, fifth, and sixth grade, with just one sustainability or environmental literacy related standard in fifth grade (Next Generation Science Standards, 2019). Environmental literacy is when students are literate in environmental topics, including, having “knowledge about the environment, attitudes toward the environment, and environmental behavior” (Tal & Peled, 2017). Failing to educate students in elementary school about sustainability or environmental literacy causes three problems. First it puts this education onto parents’ shoulders, some of whom might not care about the issue or whom might deny it altogether. Secondly, the standards do not adequately prepare students for the future nor does it help connect students to the natural environment by not connecting the standards to real world issues (Chambers, 2007). By connecting the standards to real world issues, such as sustainability topics, students are more engaged and, “find the content more interesting” (Stratton, Hagevik, Feldman & Bloom, 2015). Lastly, not educating students about sustainability topics in elementary school passes the responsibility of education off to higher grades with optional science classes. Without allowing students to grow their environmental literacy within each grade, students are not able to reinforce their understanding of environmental literacy, which reduces long term knowledge obtainment (Villasmil, 2018). Sustainability education is not just lacking in the United States; countries such as Australia, Canada, and Israel only have optional sustainability standards that are not very present SUSTAINABILITY EDUCATION IN ELEMENTARY SCHOOLS 6 throughout classrooms across the country (Tal & Peled, 2017) (Fernandes, 2012). The UNESCO Education Sector also states that, “while many nations around the world have embraced the need for education to build capacity to achieve sustainability, only limited progress has been made on any level” (UNESCO Education Sector, 2005). Additionally, “a lack of vision or awareness of the role education could play in achieving sustainability has impeded progress” in both developing and developed countries throughout the world (UNESCO Education Sector, 2005). With the lack of sustainability education and resources for teachers in the United States, many organizations and school districts are creating environmental literacy programs. Various environmental literacy programs include district run environmental literacy websites, which often feature a resources page where teachers can download resources around environmental and sustainability themes. The San Mateo County Office of Education has an Environmental Literacy Program, which offers various environmental literacy trainings along with pre-made environmental literacy lesson plans for district teachers (San Mateo County Office of Education: Environmental Literacy and Sustainability Initiative, 2019). Additionally, certain cities are also seeing the importance of environmental education and are creating their own sustainability educational programs that focus specifically on the city’s sustainability goals. The Town of Gilbert, Arizona has a School Outreach and Education program where city staff go into Gilbert Elementary schools to teach about sustainability themes related to their city (Lund, 2019c). Sustainability for Young Learners Courses Idea Conception The idea for the Sustainability for Young Learners Courses was sparked by curiosity of when and how students are learning about sustainability. Growing up, my family participated in many environmentally friendly practices such as recycling, composting, and reusing resources. However, my first formal introduction into sustainability and environmental literacy took place during my first term of college, where I opted into a year-long environmentally themed English class called “Green House” through Southern Oregon University. Realizing that the first time I had learned about sustainability in the classroom was during my undergraduate studies left me curious if science standards in K-12 had changed to incorporate real-world climate related issues. After conducting research and learning that second, third, and fourth grade Next Generation Science Standards did not mention any sustainability themes, and only one standard mentioned sustainability in fifth grade, the Sustainability for Young Learners Courses were developed (Next SUSTAINABILITY EDUCATION IN ELEMENTARY SCHOOLS 7 Generation Science Standards, 2019). By connecting the required science standards to sustainability themes, this project allows students to learn about the importance of sustainability and how humans are negatively impacting our world, without taking away class time from learning about the required standards. Students also learn and discover ways in which they can change their behaviors to be more environmentally conscious. Supporting Research Colorado State University professors Camacho and Legare argue that teachers should be responsible for helping to provide student with the skills needed to “live sustainable lifestyles, help students develop knowledge, values, skills, and a worldview that may lead to sustainable patterns for living” (Camacho & Legare, 2018). The researchers found that partnerships between a school district and outside entities can allow the school district to create goals and outcomes for this sustainability education. Camacho and Legare also researched a similar project within the Town of Gilbert, Arizona who had partnered with the city’s public-school district (Town of Gilbert, Arizona, 2019). The Town of Gilbert’s Outreach Coordinator goes into classrooms, “to provide environmental education programs for K–6 students, such as a ‘What is your ecological footprint’ assignment and a pollution index exercise” (Camacho & Legare, 2018). Additionally, Bestelmeyer et al. research noted that students became more environmentally aware when the environmental education reading within their textbooks were reinforced through in-class projects (Bestelmeyer, et al., 2015). Research by Chambers, who studied elementary school ecological literacy materials utilization, found that classroom experiences and texts, “have the power to shape knowledge construction, student identity and an environmental consciousness” (Chambers, 2017). Therefore, each of the Sustainability for Young Learners Courses includes a hands-on activity or an experiment designed to reinforce the lesson’s learning outcomes. Another research project took place in the United Kingdom (UK) in 2005 at schools that had already committed to environmental education. The study interviewed students within 15 UK schools over the course of three years, who had attended schools that were committed to teaching and integrating sustainability into their classrooms and curriculum (Gayford, 2009). Gayford found that over the three-year study period, “there were improvements both in pupils’ knowledge of issues related to sustainability and their relevant abilities and competencies” (Gayford, 2009). Additionally, the study found that innovative teaching approaches which SUSTAINABILITY EDUCATION IN ELEMENTARY SCHOOLS 8 involved the students were much more well received than lecture style classes (Gayford, 2009). Each unit of the Sustainability for Young Learners Courses includes class discussions, videos, articles, photos, a final project, and a hands-on experiment that engage the students more than simply conducting a lecture style class. Target Audience An emphasis on elementary school students was decided upon for two main reasons. The first is that through Gayford’s study in the UK, the study found that “pupils in the primary schools have generally shown more enthusiasm for all aspects of learning for sustainability than most pupils in the secondary schools” (Gayford, 2009). Additionally, an energy study conducted by Craig and Allen found that younger people tend to value sustainability and environmentally friendly practices at a greater level than their parents do (Craig & Allen, 2014). In a different study about elementary curriculum learning around energy consumption, Craig and Allen found that educating students about energy consumption during school lead to, “a decrease in energy consumption of more than 15% in student homes and more than 30% at the local school” (Craig & Allen, 2015). This study also showed that students were able to take the environmental literacy knowledge that they learned inside the classroom and have discussions about this knowledge with their parents at home (Craig & Allen, 2015). Considering this, it was decided to focus the efforts for these classes on second through fifth grades. First grade was omitted from the project due to the student’s cognitive level. Building the Project There are many resources available that provide teachers with a short lesson plan on various sustainability topics. However, due to the magnitude of standards that teachers are required to teach, there is little time to include other materials outside of the required standards. Therefore, each of the units needed to incorporate sustainability themes into the required Next Generation Science Standards. Going into the project, there were certain topics that were identified that would be taught per grade level. However, after reviewing the required standards per grade level, the original topics needed to be modified to meet the required standards. Each grade’s unit plan has main standards, secondary standards, and sustainability topics clearly outlined to show how the standards connect to the sustainability topic presented (See Appendix SUSTAINABILITY EDUCATION IN ELEMENTARY SCHOOLS 9 A). Additionally, all three pillars of sustainability, including environmental, social, and economic, were covered in each of the unit plans to ensure that a holistic viewpoint of sustainability was presented in each unit plan (UNESCO Education Sector, 2005). The project conception and initial project proposal was intended to be primarily utilized by the Sustainability Department at Denver Public Schools (DPS) and by DPS teachers. The project would meet the goals of DPS and help teach their students about the most pressing sustainability topics that DPS identified. During the initial creation of the unit plans, it was identified that these unit plans would also be applicable to elementary teachers across the United States. This is because either the Next Generation Science Standards or the framework for K-12 Science Education is taught within 44 states and represents “71% of U.S. students” (National Science Teaching Association, 2019). A focus still remained on having the units meet the sustainability goals of DPS, by including themes on composting and energy reduction solutions. However, a broader audience was kept in mind when planning the activities and students’ worksheets to ensure that teachers across the county could seamlessly integrate these lesson plans into their classrooms. With the focus turning to the national stage, the Teachers Pay Teachers website was identified as the best way to get these lesson plans into the hands of teachers across the United States. The Teachers Pay Teachers website offers lesson plans and activities for every subject and grade level, some of which are free and others which cost money. In 2018, over five million teachers visited and used the site (Teachers Pay Teachers, 2019). The site has over three million resources that have been downloaded over a billion times (Teachers Pay Teachers, 2019). With the wide reach of teachers searching for lesson plans on this website, it was decided that posting each of the unit plans and PowerPoints for free onto the Teachers Pay Teachers website would greatly increase the reach of the program. After the lesson plans were completed, it was decided to conduct a pilot project, where each of the unit plans would be taught in a DPS classroom by the content creator. The goal was to teach each of the unit plans, which comprises of five different lessons, at least once in second through fifth grades. However, due to the timeframe of the project and the logistics needed to teach five, 45-minute classes per grade, it was decided that there would not be a pilot period for this project, in order to complete the project within the desired timeframe. SUSTAINABILITY EDUCATION IN ELEMENTARY SCHOOLS 10 Strengths, Weaknesses, Opportunities, and Threats (SWOT) Analysis A SWOT Analysis has been conducted to show the Strengths, Weaknesses, Opportunities, and Threats of the project from the initial project idea to project completion. Strength - A strength of this project is that all of the sustainability themed unit plans directly teaches either one or two of the Next Generation Science Standards. Therefore, teaching these unit plans does not take class time away from teaching the required standards, which could increase the adoption and utilization rate of these unit plans compared to if the unit plans did not teach the standards. Another strength is that each of the unit plans includes detailed descriptions of each lesson, a fully created PowerPoint, a student worksheet for each lesson, and an interactive activity or experiment which includes photos of each step of the experiment. Therefore, the lesson plans do not require any additional prep time from the teacher aside from having the materials ready for the lesson and printing out the student handouts. The last strength of this project is that all of the unit plans includes writing activities, with some of the units plans having literacy standards as connection standards. Bringing in writing components into science classes allows students to have a stronger sense of the topic and to utilize their writing skills outside of the typical Language Arts setting (Rogers & Abell, 2013). Weakness - One of the weaknesses of the project is that the content creator does not have a teaching credential. Therefore, teachers might not trust or utilize the teaching materials since the content creator is not a certified teacher. To make up for this weakness, the lesson plans have all been reviewed by three teachers that currently teach in elementary schools in the United States. Another weakness of the project is that the teachers searching for sustainability and environmental literacy unit plans might already be teachers that either incorporate some sustainability practices into their lives or who might informally teach about sustainability themes in their classrooms. Teachers who do not see climate change or sustainability as important likely will not search for or utilize sustainability unit plans. Opportunity - An opportunity for the Sustainability for Young Learners Courses is to connect, network, and create partnerships with other Environmental Literacy programs, such as those run by non-profits, cities, or Environmental Literacy Offices housed within a school district. Most of these organization’s websites features a teacher resource page, where teachers can browse through curated environmental literacy resources. There has been communication between two organizations that would be interested in seeing the completed unit lesson plans and SUSTAINABILITY EDUCATION IN ELEMENTARY SCHOOLS 11 would consider putting these unit lesson plans on their website. The opportunity would be to reach out to more environmental literacy organizations for their consideration of adding the unit plans onto their website. Another opportunity would be to create an informational printout or a sustainability board game that would be sent home with the students following the lesson plans. The informational printout would be a graphics heavy printout that would inform parents about the sustainability themes taught within the class. A sustainability board game could include sustainability themed tasks that students would complete at home with their parents. Once completed, the student could take it back to their teacher for a homework pass or other small classroom prize. Threat – The threat to the project turned out to be the timeline regarding teaching these unit plans within DPS schools. Considering logistics and time needed to teach these unit plans within DPS classrooms in conjunction with the project timeline and outbreak of COVID-19, it was decided not to teach these unit plans within a DPS classroom. Therefore, the threat to this project is that the lesson plans have not yet been tested to see how students respond to the activities and to understand if the flow of the classes are well received by teachers and students alike. Project Schedule – Work Breakout Schedule The timeline for completing the Sustainability for Young Learners Courses project took place over the course of nine months, from the initial project idea until the completion of the project closeout documents. There were four phases of the project, which have been displayed within the Work Breakout Schedule (See Appendix B). This section of the paper provides an overview of the project schedule and an accompanied Work Breakout Schedule (See Appendix B). The Work Breakout Schedule is provided in order to aid other sustainability leaders through the creation of a similar project (See Appendix B). Phase one of the project is titled Partnerships (See Appendix B). This phase has two parts, which includes setting up the partnerships and gathering the necessary goals and expected outcomes from the partners. Setting up the partnerships is the first part of the project, which was completed within the first month. Online research was conducted in order to find several viable partners to reach out to see which organization would like to partner on this project. During this preliminary research, the organization’s mission, sustainability goals, and context to the local community were considered. At the beginning of the project, the Sustainability Department for SUSTAINABILITY EDUCATION IN ELEMENTARY SCHOOLS 12 the City and County of Denver, Denver Waste Management, and the Sustainability Department at Denver Public Schools were identified as possible organizations to partner with. After identifying possible organizations to partner with, it was identified how the organization’s goals could be achieved through partnership. All three partners were contacted regarding possible interest in partnership. After communications with the partners, it was determined that DPS’s Sustainability Department was most interested in partnering on this project. Once DPS’s Sustainability Department agreed to partner on this project, a meeting was set up with the project lead and the representative from DPS. Prior to the meeting, the intention for the Sustainability for Young Learners Courses was to create one, 45-minute lesson plan for first through fourth grades which covered a certain sustainability topic. After meeting with DPS, it was decided that the project would create a week-long unit that incorporated a specific sustainability theme into the already required Next Generation Science Standards (Lund, 2019a). This meeting took place at the beginning of the second month of the project. After the meeting, the goals of the project were identified, and a rough project schedule was laid out. Phase two of the project included creating the project deliverables and receiving feedback on the deliverables from teachers and project partners. This part of the project took roughly three to four months. The deliverables for this project included creating the unit plans, PowerPoint, and the student worksheets for second, third, fourth, and fifth grades. Since elementary school teachers are not trained in sustainability topics during their teaching certificate, the use of articles and on-topic videos made for kids were heavily utilized throughout each of the lessons per unit (Stratton, Hagevik, Feldman, & Bloom, 2015). Including these detailed videos explaining complex issues such as composting and sea level rise that were age appropriate, takes away the stress and extra prep time required for the teacher to understand these topics at a level where they feel comfortable explaining to their students. A PowerPoint presentation was created for each unit plan. Each PowerPoint included the unit’s vocabulary words with photos for each word, links to the unit’s videos for easy access, and created a visual layout that allows teachers to easily follow along with each activity and lesson within the unit plan. Once the videos and articles were identified, all the information needed to be compiled together. First, a brief layout was created for each grade level, which included a brief description of the activities per lesson along with videos and other materials. These draft unit plans were completed during the third month of the project and were sent to the DPS Sustainability SUSTAINABILITY EDUCATION IN ELEMENTARY SCHOOLS 13 Department for review and feedback. DPS recommended that the units include more detailed description of each activity, while teachers who looked over the drafts recommended that students needed to complete a worksheet or deliverable for each lesson. Utilizing the feedback, month four and five of the project were dedicated to adding in more detailed explanations and time recommendations into each lesson and included a student deliverable per class. For example, in the third-grade unit plan within Lesson #2 tilted, “How Global Warming is Heating up our Earth”, featured a 35-minute ice cube experiment (See Appendix C). After receiving feedback from DPS, this activity was broken down into three subparts, each with time intervals to keep the lesson organized and to help the teacher keep time. After completing each grade level’s unit plan, the unit plans were sent to an elementary school teacher who reviewed the unit plans. Once all of the grade’s unit plans were completed, all of the unit plans were sent to DPS’s Sustainability Department for a final review, which brought the project into the beginning of the sixth month. Phase three of the project includes deliverable modifications and sharing of the unit plans, which took place during the sixth, seventh, and eight months of the project. This included taking the previous unit plans that were created in Word and redesigning all of the four-unit plans to have a professional look and layout via the design website Canva. Additionally, the lesson plans were sent to 40 environmental literacy organizations, including district ran Environmental Literacy programs, such as the San Mateo County Office of Education along with other environmental education organizations, such as the North American Association for Environmental Education. Each of the unit plans were also posted free of charge onto the Teachers Pay Teachers website in order to spread the reach of the program to a wider audience. Lastly, the content creator created a website in which to host these unit plans permanently. The last phase of the project is phase four, which is the project evaluation phase. This part of the project took place during the ninth and final month of the project. During this phase, feedback was collected from teachers and partners, in order to gauge the effectiveness of the Sustainability for Young Learners Courses. Feedback was collected off of the Teachers Pay Teachers website, after teachers downloaded and taught the unit plans. Once the feedback was collected, the project was evaluated, and a project closeout document were created. SUSTAINABILITY EDUCATION IN ELEMENTARY SCHOOLS 14 Key Takeaways Six Key Concepts to Create Successful Environmental Literacy Programs Environmental literacy programs for kids can range from after school garden classes, to stand-alone classes offered by a city, to in-class learning opportunities such as the Sustainability for Young Learners Courses. Whether a program is designed for one local school, or focuses on one topic to many sustainability topics, there are six key concepts that can help create a successful environmental literacy program. One – Include place-based learning into each unit. Create a program that is regionally specific, yet nationally scalable. Programs that are specific to a location allows students to participate in location-based, or place-based learning, which is learning designed to incorporate students’ surroundings and regional issues into the classroom (UNESCO Education Sector, 2005). By focusing on regional, location-based learning, students can become active young citizens who are more engaged in the learning process (Chambers, 2007). By incorporating location-based learning that focuses on the student’s local community, student’s feel more compelled to implement solutions because the learnings were directly related back to the student’s physical community and cultural context (UNESCO Education Sector, 2005). However, by highlighting regional topics while keeping scalability in mind, sustainability content designers can reach more students and classrooms to increase the program’s reach. For example, the third-grade unit plan contains a worksheet titled “How rivers and streams connect to the ocean”, which is an activity that can connect students from all over the United States to the ocean plastic pollution problem (See Appendix 3). This is done by having students identify where they live within the map provided and draw the route from their home to the ocean or large lakes via the rivers outlined in the map. Students then write a short description regarding how plastics thrown in a river near in the student’s community could end up in the ocean through interconnected streams and rivers across the United States. This activity allows land locked teachers the ability to show their students how ocean plastic problems relates to their community, even if the students do not have direct access to the ocean. Two – Incorporate the required standards and curriculum. When creating environmental literacy programs, it is important to incorporate the required curriculum or standards into any environmental literacy program. In the United Sates, teachers from 44 states must follow the Next Generation Science Standards or the framework for K-12 Science Education (National SUSTAINABILITY EDUCATION IN ELEMENTARY SCHOOLS 15 Science Teaching Association, 2019). Due to the number of standards, teachers have little room to teach any additional information. In an interview that Chambers conducted with elementary school teachers, “It was expressed that if teachers could not immediately see the curricular links, they would not use the resources” (Chambers, 2007). Research from Chambers shows that environmental literacy programs which focused on teaching a certain sustainability topic and not focusing on the required standards were not widely used by teachers. The Sustainability for Young Learners Courses infuses sustainability themes into the existing required Next Generation Science Standards via week-long, unit plans. Each unit plan covers one to two main science standards, followed by a few connecting standards, which are either science or literacy standards (See Appendix A). Three - Utilize subject matter experts. The optimal team for creating an environmental literacy program includes both sustainability professionals and teachers (Tal & Peled, 2017). Bringing in teaching subject matter experts, such as teachers, principals or curriculum experts, either as part of the project team or as a reviewer, can elevate a project (Tal & Peled, 2017). A sustainability leader’s job in this program will be to incorporate sustainability themes into the lesson plan in a grade appropriate manner that relies heavily on science-based findings. Teachers and principals will assist in providing guidance and feedback regarding the lessons and programs to make sure that they are viable for real world classrooms, student clubs, and after school events (Lund 2019b) (Lund 2019d). Since most sustainability professionals are not teachers, having teachers’ input will ensure that the lessons are grade appropriate, that the materials meet the standards included, and that the timing of the lesson is realistic for the grade level. Four - Never end with doom and gloom, make the students the heroes through solutions. Facts about climate change can be overwhelming for many adults to face, and children are no exception. By simply stating the facts about climate change without offering solutions, students can leave feeling hopeless and frustrated, or not knowing how to utilize the knowledge that they just obtained within their daily life. When facts are coupled with solutions that the student can implement, the student can take the newly gained knowledge about climate change and use the solutions to act on the problems that they are learning about (Elfin & Sheaffer, 2006). This can also allow students to practice using solutions thinking and problem-solving techniques during class and apply these solutions to their real life. Students are able to engage in small actions themselves every day, such as composting or recycling at school, bringing a reusable water bottle SUSTAINABILITY EDUCATION IN ELEMENTARY SCHOOLS 16 to school, or walking to school. Allowing students to come up with their own solutions shows the students that they can help to make a difference, because when more students are involved in sustainability, they can create a more sustainable school and community (Colbert, 2018). In addition to small solutions, allow the students to be the heroes of the story by having them personally come up with solutions to the problems presented (Lund, 2019e). This will allow the students to propose solutions that they think they can implement and will also engage the students by making them the superhero of the story. By making the students feel a part of the story and the lessons, the student will feel more engaged and ready to take action. Five – Consider different learning styles. Every student learns differently, therefore what engages and connects to some students might not engage or be completely understood by other students (Jones, 1996). Students can have one of the seven, or a combination of learning styles, including spatial, linguistic, auditory-musical, mathematical, intrapersonal, interpersonal and kinesthetic (Jones, 1996). When designing environmental literacy content, it is imperative to keep in mind these seven learning styles and create activities that will engage all types of learners. Using hands-on activities, experiments, videos, photos, and text within the same lesson or unit can help engage and activate all student’s minds throughout each lesson. Each of the units within the Sustainability for Young Learners Courses includes writing and reading activities, videos and PowerPoints with photos, and experiments to engage all types of learners. Key concept number three, which is to utilize subject matter experts, can be utilized to receive feedback from teachers on whether or not the program or unit plans includes a diverse array of activities that will engage all of the seven intelligence and learning styles. Six – Provide additional resources for the teachers. Teachers are subject matter experts in their field; however, they might not be experts in sustainability or environmental topics. Stratton and Feldman conducted a study on teachers’ knowledge of sustainability before and after the teachers underwent a sustainability training. Before the training, the teachers described their level of sustainability knowledge as “simply encompassing environmentally-friendly practices such as recycling and composting, not fully considering its multidimensional nature and its relevance to environment, economic, and sociocultural issues” (Stratton, Hagevik, Feldman, & Bloom, 2015). If an environmental literacy program or lessons will be taught by teachers, make sure to include a reference section for teachers to gain a more in-depth understanding of the topic. The San Mateo County Office of Education’s Environmental Literacy SUSTAINABILITY EDUCATION IN ELEMENTARY SCHOOLS 17 Program created pre-made lesson plans that includes additional resources geared at the teacher, whereas the resources in the lessons are geared at the student’s grade level (San Mateo County Office of Education: Environmental Literacy and Sustainability Initiative, 2019). Providing these resources will allow teachers to gain more sustainability knowledge and will act as reference in the event that teachers might doubt why certain themes are taught within the classroom. Each of the unit plans within the Sustainability for Young Learners Courses includes a section titled Teacher Resources, which is a curated resource list featuring videos and articles that are directly related to the teachings of that particular unit plan (See the “Teacher Resources” section within Appendix C and Appendix D). Conclusion With children being the next scientists, policy makers, businesspeople, and decision makers of the future, it is imperative to educate students about science-based sustainability themes from an early age within elementary school. Even though the Next Generation Science Standards do not cover sustainability themes in second, third, and fourth grade does not mean that sustainability cannot be taught within elementary school classrooms (Next Generation Science Standards, 2019). By infusing important sustainability themes into the Next Generation Science standards, teachers are able to meet the required science standards while providing their students with real world climate knowledge and solutions that students can implement into their daily lives at school, at home, and within their community. SUSTAINABILITY EDUCATION IN ELEMENTARY SCHOOLS 18 References Bestelmeyer, S. V., Elser, M. M., Spellman, K. V., Sparrow, E. B., Haan-Amato, S. S., & Keener, A. (2015). Collaboration, interdisciplinary thinking, and communication: New approaches to K–12 ecology education. Frontiers in Ecology and the Environment 13(1):37–43. doi:10.1890/140130 Camacho, D. J., & Legare, J. M. (2018). Sustainability Programs in Business, Universities, and K-12: Educating Students and Leaders Towards a Sustainability Mindset. Journal of Instructional Research, 7. Retrieved June 16, 2019, from https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext /EJ1188323.pdf Chambers, J. M. (2007). Ecological literacy materials for use in elementary schools: A critical analysis (Order No. NR32936). Available from ProQuest Dissertations & Theses Global. (304794592). Retrieved from http://login.ezproxy1.lib.asu.edu/login?url=https://searchproquest-com.ezproxy1.lib.asu.edu/docview/304794592?accountid=4485 Colbert, J. (2018). Evaluating Whole-School Sustainability. (Published Thesis). Arizona State University, Tempe, Arizona. Retrieved fromhttps://repository.asu.edu/items/46771 #embed Colorado Department of Education. (2019). 2020 Colorado Academic Standards Online. Retrieved December 1, 2019, from https://www.cde.state.co.us/apps/standards/. Common Core State Standards Initiative. (2019). Read the Standards. Retrieved December 1, 2019, from http://www.corestandards.org/read-the-standards/. Coulter, C., & Lee, M. (2013). Changing Track: Extending Corporate Leadership on Sustainable Development. Craig, C. A., & Allen, M. W. (2014). Enhanced understanding of energy ratepayers: Factors influencing perceptions of government energy efficiency subsidies and utility alternative energy use. Energy Policy, 66, 224–233. Retrieved fromhttps://doi.org/10.1016/j.enpol. 2013.10.074 Craig, C. A., & Allen, M. W. (2015). The impact of curriculum-based learning on environmental literacy and energy consumption with implications for policy. Elsevier. Retrieved from https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jup.2015.06.011 Elfin, J., & Sheaffer, A. (2006). Service-based learning in watershed-based initiatives: Keys to education for sustainability in geography? Journal of Geography, 105, 33–44. SUSTAINABILITY EDUCATION IN ELEMENTARY SCHOOLS 19 Fernandes, K. J. R. (2012). Hidden in plain view: A search for sustainability education in elementary schools (Order No. MR91764). Available from ProQuest Dissertations & Theses Global. (1321933216). Retrieved from https://search-proquestcom.ezproxy1. lib.asu .edu/docview/1321933216?accountid=4485 Gallagher, D. R. (2012). Why Environmental Leadership? In Environmental Leadership: A Reference Handbook. doi: http://dx.doi.org/10.4135/9781452218601.n1 Gayford, C., Dr. (2009). Learning for sustainability: From the pupils’ perspective (Rep.). Retrieved June 16, 2019, from World Wildlife Foundation website: http://www.seed.co.uk/sites/default/files/resources/WWF Learning_for_sustainability.pdf Jones, V. L. M. (1996). Exploring the theory of multiple intelligences in inclusive elementary classrooms (Order No. 9718134). Available from ProQuest Dissertations & Theses Global. (304284896). Retrieved from https://search-proquest-com.ezproxy1.lib.asu.edu /docview/304284896/66B7A53CA83C48DEPQ/1?accountid=4485 Lund, S. (2019a, August 23) In person interview with Eric Punkay: Sustainability Analyst at Denver Public Schools. Lund, S. (2019b, November 3) Personal Interview with Alvaro Munoz Conde, Elementary and High School Teacher in the United States. Lund, S. (2019c, September 14) Personal Interview with Kelli Collins: Town of Gilbert’s Educational Program. Lund, S. (2019d, November 3) Phone interview with Michele Lund, Third Grade Teacher in the United States. Lund, S. (2019e, February to November) Interviews with Alycia de Mesa, Faculty Instructor of Communications and Storytelling for the School of Sustainability at Arizona State University. NASA. (2019, September 30). The Causes of Climate Change. Retrieved December 1, 2019, from https://climate.nasa.gov/causes/. National Science Teaching Association. (2019). About the Next Generation Science Standards. Retrieved December 1, 2019, from https://ngss.nsta.org/About.aspx. Next Generation Science Standards. (2019). Read the Standards. Retrieved December 1, 2019, from https://www.nextgenscience.org/search-standards. SUSTAINABILITY EDUCATION IN ELEMENTARY SCHOOLS 20 Rogers, M. P., & Abell, S. K. (2013). Connecting with Other Disciplines. In Perspectives: Research and Tips to Support Science Education, K-6. Retrieved fromhttps://www. questia.com/library/journal/1G1-160813645/connecting-with-other-disciplines San Mateo County Office of Education: Environmental Literacy and Sustainability Initiative. (2019). Resources for Environmental Literacy. Retrieved November 30, 2019, from https://sites.google.com/smcoe.org/smcoe-environmental-literacy/resources?authuser=0. Stratton, S. K., Hagevik, R., Feldman, A., & Bloom, M. (2015). Educating Science Teachers for Sustainability. doi: 10.10007/978-3-319-16411-3 Tal, T. & Peled, E. (2017) The philosophies, contents and pedagogies of environmental education programs in 10 Israeli elementary schools, Environmental Education Research, 23:7, 1032-1053, DOI: 10.1080/13504622.2016.1153047 Teachers Pay Teachers. (2019). About Us. Retrieved November 17, 2019, from https://www.teacherspayteachers.com/About-Us?gclid=CjwKCAiA_MPuBRB5Ei wAHTTvMf_iR59b2iUKuFcTGqF1YOdJ1HkM1QXKCsg_qXvxdGiJxuRIhLjahoCxbAQAvD_BwE. Town of Gilbert, Arizona. (2019). School Outreach & Education. Retrieved November 30, 2019, from https://www.gilbertaz.gov/departments/public-works/solid-waste/trash-andrecycle/school-outreach-education. UNESCO Education Sector. (2005). Guidelines and Recommendations for Reorienting Teacher Education to Address Sustainability: Education for Sustainable Development in Action, Technical Paper No. 2. United Nations Decade of Education for Sustainable Development (2005-2014). Retrieved from https://unesdoc.unesco.org/ark:/48223 /pf000014337 UN General Assembly (2015) Transforming our world: The 2030 agenda for sustainable development, A/RES/70/1. Available at www.un.org/ga/search/view_doc.asp?symbol =A/RES/70/1&Lang=E. Accessed November 24, 2019. Villasmil, I. L. (2018). Promoting environmentally responsible behaviors in public elementary schools' children (Order No. 10837154). Available from ProQuest Dissertations & Theses Global. (2108530969). Retrieved from http://login.ezproxy1.lib.asu.edu/login?url=https:// search-proquest-com.ezproxy1.lib.asu.edu/docview/2108530969?accountid=4485 APA Format Style used SUSTAINABILITY EDUCATION IN ELEMENTARY SCHOOLS 21 Appendix A Standards and Sustainability Topics per Grade Level Figure A1 Second Grade Standards and Sustainability Topic Main Standards 2-ESS2-3: Obtain information to identify where water is found on Earth and that it can be solid or liquid. (Next Generation Science Standards, 2019) K-2-ETS1-1: Engineering Design - Ask questions, make observations, and gather information about a situation people want to change to define a simple problem that can be solved through the development of a new or improved object or tool. (Next Generation Science Standards, 2019) Secondary 2-ESS2-1 Earth’s Systems - Connections to the Nature of Science, Standards Crosscutting Concepts: Science addresses questions about the natural and material world. Scientists study the natural and material world. (Next Generation Science Standards, 2019) 2-ESS2-1 Crosscutting Concepts - Connection to Engineering, Technology, and Application of Science: Developing and using technology has impacts on the natural world. (Next Generation Science Standards, 2019) Colorado Academic Standards: Second Grade, Standard 1: Physical Science. Grade Level Expectations: Matter exists as different substances that have observable different properties. (Next Generation Science Standards, 2019) Sustainability Students will describe that there is both solid and liquid water in the ocean and Topic that ocean ice is melting faster due to climate change. Students will identify and learn about different solutions to mitigate climate change. Students will learn what composting is, why it is important, and how to compost. SUSTAINABILITY EDUCATION IN ELEMENTARY SCHOOLS 22 Figure A2 Third Grade Standards and Sustainability Topic Main Standards LS2.C: Ecosystem Dynamics, Functioning, and Resilience - When the environment changes in ways that affect a place’s physical characteristics, temperature, or availability of resources, some organisms survive and reproduce, others move to new locations, yet others move into the transformed environment, and some die. (Next Generation Science Standards, 2019) 3-LS4-4: Biological Evolution: Unity and Diversity - Make a claim about the merit of a solution to a problem caused when the environment changes and the types of plants and animals that live there may change. [Clarification Statement: Examples of environmental changes could include changes in land characteristics, water distribution, temperature, food, and other organisms.] [Assessment Boundary: Assessment is limited to a single environmental change. Assessment does not include the greenhouse effect or climate change.] (Next Generation Science Standards, 2019) Secondary RI.3.1: Literacy Common Core State Standards Connection: Ask and answer Standards questions to demonstrate understanding of a text, referring explicitly to the text as the basis for the answers. (3-LS4-1), (3-LS4-2), (3-LS4-3). (Next Generation Science Standards, 2019) Sustainability Our oceans are changing, and it is predicted that by 2050 there will be more Topic plastic in the ocean than fish. Students learn about the physical changes of increased plastic pollution into the ocean and how that is affecting ocean life. Student learn about and come up with several solutions to mitigate the problem. SUSTAINABILITY EDUCATION IN ELEMENTARY SCHOOLS 23 Figure A3 Fourth Grade Standards and Sustainability Topic Main Standards 4-ESS3-1: Earth and Human Activity - Obtain and combine information to describe that energy and fuels are derived from natural resources and that their uses affect the environment. [Clarification Statement: Examples of renewable energy resources could include wind energy, water behind dams, and sunlight; non-renewable energy resources are fossil fuels and fissile materials. Examples of environmental effects could include loss of habitat due to dams, loss of habitat due to surface mining, and air pollution from burning of fossil fuels.] (Next Generation Science Standards, 2019) SS3.A (4-ESS3-1): Disciplinary Core Ideas: Natural Resources - Energy and fuels that humans use are derived from natural sources, and their use affects the environment in multiple ways. Some resources are renewable over time, and others are not. (Next Generation Science Standards, 2019) Secondary 4-ESS3-2: Constructing Explanations and Designing Solutions - Generate and Standards compare multiple solutions to a problem based on how well they meet the criteria and constraints of the design solution. (Next Generation Science Standards, 2019) Literacy Common Core Standards Connections: RI.4.1 Refer to details and examples in a text when explaining what the text says explicitly and when drawing inferences from the text. (4-ESS3-2). (Next Generation Science Standards, 2019) Sustainability Students will learn that energy can either come from a renewable or Topic nonrenewable source and learn about the effects of burning fossil fuels has on our planet. Students learn about potential solutions to not burning and reducing their use of fossil fuels. SUSTAINABILITY EDUCATION IN ELEMENTARY SCHOOLS 24 Figure A4 Fifth Grade Standards and Sustainability Topic Main Standards 5-ESS3-1: Human Impacts on Earth Systems: Human activities in agriculture, industry, and everyday life have had major effects on the land, vegetation, streams, ocean, air, and even outer space. But individuals and communities are doing things to help protect Earth’s resources and environments. (Next Generation Science Standards, 2019) 5-ESS3-1: Obtain and combine information about ways individual communities use science ideas to protect the Earth’s resources and environment. (Next Generation Science Standards, 2019) Secondary RI.5.9 Literacy Connection – Integrate information from several texts on the Standards same topic in order to write or speak about the subject knowledgeably. (5ESS3-1). (Next Generation Science Standards, 2019) W.5.8 Literacy Connection – Recall relevant information from experiences or gather relevant information from print and digital sources; summarize or paraphrase information in notes and finished work, and provide a list of sources. (5-ESS3-1). (Next Generation Science Standards, 2019) 5-LS2-1 Science Connection – The food of almost any kind of animal can be traced back to plants. Organisms are related in food webs in which some animals eat plants for food and other animals eat the animals that eat plants. Some organisms, such as fungi and bacteria, break down dead organisms (both plants or plants parts and animals) and therefore operate as “decomposers.” Decomposition eventually restores (recycles) some materials back to the soil. Organisms can survive only in environments in which their particular needs are met. A healthy ecosystem is one in which multiple species of different types are each able to meet their needs in a relatively stable web of life. Newly introduced species can damage the balance of an ecosystem. (Next Generation Science Standards, 2019) SUSTAINABILITY EDUCATION IN ELEMENTARY SCHOOLS 25 Sustainability Students will learn about various environmental problems and how these Topic problems are impacting our world. Students will focus on the problems related to food waste and sending food to the landfill. Students will learn about backyard and industrial composting as a solution. SUSTAINABILITY EDUCATION IN ELEMENTARY SCHOOLS 26 Appendix B Figure B1: Work Breakout Schedule – Sustainability for Young Learners Courses Program Creation: Sustainability for Young Learners Courses Phase 2: Creation of the project Phase 1: Partnerships Part 1 - Setting up partnerships Part 2 - Gather necessary information from each partner Create the deliverables Phase 3: Deliverable modifications and sharing Deliverable Feedback Phase 4: Project Evaluation Modify the deliverables layout to have a professional look Send surveys to participating teachers and partner organizations Research organizations to partner with Set up a meeting with the desired partners Conduct preliminary research on similar projects and programs Receive feedback from teachers regarding the deliverables Conduct research on which organizations to send the unit plans to Collect feedback off of Teachers Pay Teachers See how collaboration could help serve the organization's sustainability goals Identify potential teachers to partner with Second grade: Unit Plans, PowerPoint, and Student Worksheets Modify the deliverables per the recommendations Create a personal website to host the unit plans Feedback collected from the organizations who received the unit plans Reach out to potential organizations to partner with Third grade: Unit Plans, PowerPoint, and Student Worksheets Receive feedback from the project partners regarding the deliverables Post the unit plans onto the content creator's personal website Complete project closeout documents Determine which organizations would like to partner Fourth grade: Unit Plans, PowerPoint, and Student Worksheets Modify the deliverables per the recommendations Send the finalized lesson plans to the partners and interested teachers Fifth grade: Unit Plans, PowerPoint, and Student Worksheets Deliverables re-sent out to the partenrs Upload the unit plans to Teachers Pay Teachers Partners approve the deliverables Send the unit plans to organizations that promote environmental literacy Post the unit plans onto LinkedIn SUSTAINABILITY EDUCATION IN ELEMENTARY SCHOOLS Appendix C Third Grade Unit Plan - Ocean Plastics, The Problem and the Solution 27 SUSTAINABILITY EDUCATION IN ELEMENTARY SCHOOLS 28 SUSTAINABILITY EDUCATION IN ELEMENTARY SCHOOLS 29 SUSTAINABILITY EDUCATION IN ELEMENTARY SCHOOLS 30 SUSTAINABILITY EDUCATION IN ELEMENTARY SCHOOLS 31 SUSTAINABILITY EDUCATION IN ELEMENTARY SCHOOLS 32 SUSTAINABILITY EDUCATION IN ELEMENTARY SCHOOLS 33 SUSTAINABILITY EDUCATION IN ELEMENTARY SCHOOLS 34 SUSTAINABILITY EDUCATION IN ELEMENTARY SCHOOLS 35 SUSTAINABILITY EDUCATION IN ELEMENTARY SCHOOLS 36 SUSTAINABILITY EDUCATION IN ELEMENTARY SCHOOLS 37 SUSTAINABILITY EDUCATION IN ELEMENTARY SCHOOLS 38 SUSTAINABILITY EDUCATION IN ELEMENTARY SCHOOLS 39 SUSTAINABILITY EDUCATION IN ELEMENTARY SCHOOLS 40 SUSTAINABILITY EDUCATION IN ELEMENTARY SCHOOLS 41 SUSTAINABILITY EDUCATION IN ELEMENTARY SCHOOLS 42 SUSTAINABILITY EDUCATION IN ELEMENTARY SCHOOLS 43 SUSTAINABILITY EDUCATION IN ELEMENTARY SCHOOLS 44 SUSTAINABILITY EDUCATION IN ELEMENTARY SCHOOLS 45 SUSTAINABILITY EDUCATION IN ELEMENTARY SCHOOLS 46 SUSTAINABILITY EDUCATION IN ELEMENTARY SCHOOLS 47 SUSTAINABILITY EDUCATION IN ELEMENTARY SCHOOLS 48 SUSTAINABILITY EDUCATION IN ELEMENTARY SCHOOLS 49 SUSTAINABILITY EDUCATION IN ELEMENTARY SCHOOLS 50 SUSTAINABILITY EDUCATION IN ELEMENTARY SCHOOLS 51 SUSTAINABILITY EDUCATION IN ELEMENTARY SCHOOLS 52 SUSTAINABILITY EDUCATION IN ELEMENTARY SCHOOLS 53 SUSTAINABILITY EDUCATION IN ELEMENTARY SCHOOLS 54 SUSTAINABILITY EDUCATION IN ELEMENTARY SCHOOLS 55 SUSTAINABILITY EDUCATION IN ELEMENTARY SCHOOLS 56 SUSTAINABILITY EDUCATION IN ELEMENTARY SCHOOLS 57 SUSTAINABILITY EDUCATION IN ELEMENTARY SCHOOLS Appendix D Second Grade Unit Plan - Our Melting Oceans, Solid and Liquid Water 58 SUSTAINABILITY EDUCATION IN ELEMENTARY SCHOOLS 59 SUSTAINABILITY EDUCATION IN ELEMENTARY SCHOOLS 60 SUSTAINABILITY EDUCATION IN ELEMENTARY SCHOOLS 61 SUSTAINABILITY EDUCATION IN ELEMENTARY SCHOOLS 62 SUSTAINABILITY EDUCATION IN ELEMENTARY SCHOOLS 63 SUSTAINABILITY EDUCATION IN ELEMENTARY SCHOOLS 64 SUSTAINABILITY EDUCATION IN ELEMENTARY SCHOOLS 65 SUSTAINABILITY EDUCATION IN ELEMENTARY SCHOOLS 66 SUSTAINABILITY EDUCATION IN ELEMENTARY SCHOOLS 67 SUSTAINABILITY EDUCATION IN ELEMENTARY SCHOOLS 68 SUSTAINABILITY EDUCATION IN ELEMENTARY SCHOOLS 69 SUSTAINABILITY EDUCATION IN ELEMENTARY SCHOOLS Activit 3.2: Student Worksheet (15 minutes) What Causes Climate Change and Ho 70 to Help SUSTAINABILITY EDUCATION IN ELEMENTARY SCHOOLS 71 SUSTAINABILITY EDUCATION IN ELEMENTARY SCHOOLS 72 SUSTAINABILITY EDUCATION IN ELEMENTARY SCHOOLS 73 SUSTAINABILITY EDUCATION IN ELEMENTARY SCHOOLS 74 SUSTAINABILITY EDUCATION IN ELEMENTARY SCHOOLS 75 SUSTAINABILITY EDUCATION IN ELEMENTARY SCHOOLS 76 SUSTAINABILITY EDUCATION IN ELEMENTARY SCHOOLS 77 SUSTAINABILITY EDUCATION IN ELEMENTARY SCHOOLS 78 SUSTAINABILITY EDUCATION IN ELEMENTARY SCHOOLS 79 SUSTAINABILITY EDUCATION IN ELEMENTARY SCHOOLS 80 SUSTAINABILITY EDUCATION IN ELEMENTARY SCHOOLS 81 SUSTAINABILITY EDUCATION IN ELEMENTARY SCHOOLS 82 SUSTAINABILITY EDUCATION IN ELEMENTARY SCHOOLS 83 SUSTAINABILITY EDUCATION IN ELEMENTARY SCHOOLS 84 SUSTAINABILITY EDUCATION IN ELEMENTARY SCHOOLS 85