SCHOOL TUITION ORGANIZATION INCOME TAX CREDITS IN ARIZONA SUMMARY OF ACTIVITY: FY 2015/2016 Arizona provides four income tax credits for taxpayer donations to certified school tuition organizations (STOs) for the purpose of providing scholarships to students to attend Arizona private schools. Two credits are for donations made by individual taxpayers (original and switcher)1 and two credits are for corporate donations (low-income and disabled/displaced)2. Corporate donations can be claimed as a tax credit against either the corporate income tax or the insurance premium tax. The tax credit programs have various start dates: the original individual tax credit program began in 1998, the low-income corporate program began in 2006, the disabled/displaced program began in 2009 and the switcher individual program began in 2012. Growth of All STO Tax Credit Programs Millions Donations Scholarships $1,200 $1,000 $800 $600 $400 $200 $0 *Reporting change TOTAL DONATIONS – ALL CREDIT PROGRAMS Reporting Year CY1998 CY1999 CY2000 CY2001 CY2002 CY2003 1 2 Original Individual Donations $1,815,798 $13,781,341 $17,701,284 $24,897,444 $26,512,683 $29,444,972 Switcher Individual Donations Low-Income Corporate Donations DisabledDisplaced Corporate Donations Total Donations $1,815,798 $13,781,341 $17,701,284 $24,897,444 $26,512,683 $29,444,972 A.R.S. §§ 43-1089 and 43-1089.03 A.R.S. §§ 20-224.06 and 20-224.07 or A.R.S. §§ 43-1089.04, 43-1183 and 43-1184 Arizona Department of Revenue, Office of Economic Research & Analysis, June 2017 1 TOTAL DONATIONS – ALL CREDIT PROGRAMS (continued) Reporting Year CY2004 CY2005 CY2006 CY2007 CY2008 CY2009 CY2010 3 2nd half FY2011 FY2012 FY2013 FY2014 FY2015 FY2016 TOTAL Original Individual Donations $31,846,494 $42,196,206 $51,012,326 $54,304,968 $55,260,728 $50,916,897 $43,163,214 $12,818,405 $51,918,033 $54,794,058 $58,129,582 $61,740,333 $65,436,399 $747,691,165 Switcher Individual Donations Low-Income Corporate Donations DisabledDisplaced Corporate Donations $23,975 $19,891,765 $26,060,133 $30,750,432 $35,522,660 $112,248,965 $7,260,800 $14,258,000 $9,122,121 $7,285,284 $11,123,657 $2,301,803 $19,135,987 $29,858,865 $35,831,808 $42,998,170 5 $51,597,869 $230,774,364 $781,000 $956,880 $770,000 $283,000 $3,505,350 $2,925,845 4 $5,031,920 $5,000,000 $19,253,995 Total Donations $31,846,494 $42,196,206 $58,273,126 $68,562,968 $64,382,849 $58,983,181 $55,243,751 $15,890,208 $71,360,995 $108,050,038 $122,947,368 $140,520,855 $157,556,928 $1,109,968,489 TOTAL SCHOLARSHIPS – ALL CREDIT PROGRAMS Reporting Year CY1998 CY1999 CY2000 CY2001 CY2002 CY2003 CY2004 CY2005 CY2006 CY2007 CY2008 CY2009 CY2010 nd 6 2 half of FY2011 FY2012 FY2013 FY2014 FY2015 FY2016 TOTAL Original Individual Scholarships $103,790 $2,196,734 $13,561,981 $16,484,958 $22,826,746 $24,428,197 $28,025,083 $30,863,153 $40,594,978 $48,561,687 $54,205,394 $52,127,262 $47,333,755 $27,881,253 $45,209,410 $48,873,359 $49,610,422 $54,656,554 $54,433,864 $661,978,580 Switcher Individual Scholarships $4,681,192 $17,561,453 $24,260,454 $28,523,504 $75,026,603 Low-Income Corporate Scholarships $49,380 $4,597,823 $7,615,639 $7,849,824 $9,259,078 $3,300,990 $11,294,842 $17,556,127 $24,148,068 $31,006,416 $43,465,758 $160,143,945 DisabledDisplaced Corporate Scholarships $625,335 $715,424 $66,837 $583,865 $731,231 $1,611,469 $3,581,873 $4,395,384 $12,311,418 Total Scholarships $103,790 $2,196,734 $13,561,981 $16,484,958 $22,826,746 $24,428,197 $28,025,083 $30,863,153 $40,644,358 $53,159,510 $61,821,033 $60,602,421 $57,308,257 $31,249,080 $57,088,117 $71,841,909 $92,931,412 $113,505,297 $130,818,510 $909,460,546 3 The reporting period was changed from calendar year to fiscal year. For FY11, the first 6 months of donations was included in CY10 figures. Total donations reported for FY15 were greater than the cap due to monies received at the end of FY14 that were not deposited until FY15. 5 Total donations reported for FY16 were greater than the cap due to a transfer of STO close-out monies from FY15. 6 The reporting period was changed from calendar year to fiscal year. For FY11, the first 6 months of scholarships was included in CY10 figures. 4 Arizona Department of Revenue, Office of Economic Research & Analysis, June 2017 2 SCHOOL TUITION ORGANIZATIONS Arizona law requires an STO to be certified by the Arizona Department of Revenue (ADOR) before it can begin collecting donations for tax credits. Separate individual and corporate certifications are required for an STO to collect donations from individual taxpayers and from corporation taxpayers. Table 1 (pg. 5) lists all STOs which were certified to collect individual and/or corporate donations during FY2016 and their initial certification date. A total of 65 STOs were certified to accept individual and/or corporate tax credit donations during FY2016. Six STOs that were certified for individual donations did not have corporate certification. Six STOs that were certified for corporate donations did not have individual certification. Four STOs dissolved in FY2016. STOs are required by statute to report the names, job titles and salaries of the three highest-paid employees. Of the STOs certified in FY2016, 40 (or 61.5%) were staffed by volunteers (one STO did not submit an annual report). Table 1 (pg. 5) identifies the 24 STOs that reported salaries. The STOs used 29 CPA firms to audit or review their FY20157 donation and scholarship activity, paying them $348,315 in fees. The audit or review cost is listed for each STO in Table 1 (pg. 5). STOs paid as little as $925 and as much as $22,420 for their audit or review. These costs include audits or reviews for both individual and corporate receipts if the STO participated in both programs. If an STO did not receive donations during the fiscal year or in a prior fiscal year, an audit or review is not required. STOs can allow individual donors to make recommendations when donating (although Arizona law prohibits STOs from awarding scholarships solely on the basis of donor recommendations). Only those STOs that have a CPA review are required to report information on the number and amount of donations with recommendations. In FY2016, 16 STOs reported accepting donations with recommendations which represented approximately 51% of their total individual donations. A review of the STO websites and donation forms shows that there are 30 STOs that allow individual donors to make recommendations. This information is summarized in Table 1 (pg. 5). Total Donations and Scholarships by STO – All Credit Programs Table 2 (pg. 7) shows every organization that has received donations, with the total received by credit type, since 1998. The STOs that are highlighted are no longer operational. Of all donations from both corporate and individual donors since 1998, Catholic Education Arizona has collected the most at $192.2 million or 17.3% of all donations. For FY2016, Arizona Christian School Tuition Organization collected the most from all four programs at $21.0 million or 13.3% of all donations. As with donations, Catholic Education Arizona has paid the most in scholarships since 1998 at $165.6 million, or 18.2% of all scholarships. For FY2016, Arizona Leadership Foundation paid the most in scholarships for all four programs at $18.6 million or 14.2% of all scholarships. The following chart shows the top 20 STOs by total donations received from CY 1998 through FY 2016 along with the total scholarships awarded. 7 STOs pay for the audit or review in the year following the year for which the audit or review was done. FY2015 audits and reviews were paid for in FY2016, the cost of which was reported on the FY2016 annual reports. Arizona Department of Revenue, Office of Economic Research & Analysis, June 2017 3 Top 20 STOs by Total Donations CY1998 - FY2016 Donations Scholarships Millions $192.2 Catholic Education Arizona $165.6 $178.7 $155.5 Arizona Christian School Tuition Organization $99.7 Arizona's Catholic Tuition Support… $81.2 $97.5 Institute for Better Education $74.7 $55.8 $48.2 $50.2 $41.9 $45.5 $39.4 $40.1 $29.7 $29.7 $26.2 $29.3 Arizona Scholarship Fund Arizona School Choice Trust Arizona Leadership Foundation Brophy Community Foundation Jewish Tuition Organization AAA Scholarship Foundation Arizona Private Education Scholarship Fund Tuition Organization for Private Schools School Choice Arizona Arizona Independent Schools Scholarship… Arizona Tuition Organization Arizona Episcopal Schools Foundation H.E.L.P. Scholarship Foundation Jewish Education Tax Credit Organization Arizona Tuition Connection Yuma’s Education Scholarship Fund for Kids $9.1 $28.0 $22.8 $24.2 $20.1 $21.7 $16.0 $19.0 $15.6 $18.1 $15.6 $16.9 $13.2 $13.8 $13.1 $11.0 $9.0 $10.5 $5.7 $8.2 $7.2 Reserving Scholarships for Students in Future Years STOs are required to allocate at least 90% of their tax credit donations to provide scholarships in each of the four donation programs. Tax credit donations received in a fiscal year must be allocated to scholarships within the following two fiscal years. Allocate means to both award scholarships in the current year and to reserve money for an award for the following year or a future multiyear scholarship for a specific student. In FY2016, STOs reported reserving $68.9 million in total from the four programs for specific students in future years. It should be noted that a portion of the reserved future year awards reported by STOs may be for scholarships to be awarded in the upcoming academic year. The breakdown of future reserved scholarships for each tax credit program by STO is included in the corresponding FY2016 tax credit program tables. Arizona Department of Revenue, Office of Economic Research & Analysis, June 2017 4 Table 1 School Tuition Organizations Certified to Receive Tax Credit Donations in FY2016 School Tuition Organization AAA Scholarship Foundation Academic Opportunity of Arizona Alumnus Student Tuition Organization Americas Scholarship Konnection INC Arizona Adventist Scholarships Arizona Christian School Tuition Organization Arizona Community Foundation School Tuition Organization Arizona Education and Scholarship Opportunity Program Arizona Education First Arizona Education Scholarship Foundation Arizona Episcopal Schools Foundation Arizona Independent Schools Scholarship Foundation Arizona International Academy Scholarship Fund Arizona Leadership Foundation Arizona Lutheran Scholarship Organization Arizona Private Education Scholarship Fund Arizona Scholarship Fund Arizona School Choice Trust Arizona Tax Credit Arizona Tax Credit for Education Arizona Tuition Connection Arizona Tuition Organization Arizona Waldorf Scholarship Foundation Arizona's Catholic Tuition Support Organization Best Student Fund Brophy Community Foundation Catholic Education Arizona Chabad Tuition Organization Christ Lutheran School Tuition Organization Christian Scholarship Foundation Christian Scholarship Fund of Arizona Cochise Christian School Tuition Organization Corporate Tax Foundation Corporations Reducing Student Tuition Dynamite Montessori Foundation Individual Certified 12/15/2015 1/27/2015 4/14/2016 1/01/2011 1/01/2011 4/02/2013 12/31/2013 10/31/2014 1/01/2011 1/01/2011 1/01/2011 1/01/2011 1/01/2011 1/01/2011 1/01/2011 1/01/2011 8/14/2014 12/08/2015 2/01/2013 1/01/2011 1/01/2011 1/01/2011 1/01/2011 1/01/2011 1/01/2011 1/01/2011 1/01/2011 1/01/2011 1/01/2011 1/01/2011 1/01/2011 Corporate Certified 12/10/2012 4/15/2014 1/26/2016 4/14/2016 4/02/2013 12/31/2013 10/31/2014 9/29/2010 7/29/2010 7/29/2010 6/30/2015 3/09/2011 6/01/2016 7/29/2010 7/01/2012 7/29/2010 11/05/2015 12/08/2015 2/01/2013 7/29/2010 7/01/2012 7/29/2010 7/01/2012 7/29/2010 7/29/2010 7/29/2010 Highest Paid Employees FY16 Salary 1 Salary 2 Salary 3 $61,824 $58,933 $54,562 $12,000 $6,218 $96,000 $15,000 $70,159 $20,000 $55,195 $58,780 $40,000 $40,000 $90,800 $75,000 $121,000 $22,500 $47,250 $22,631 $121,190 $4,500 not submitted $143,750 $47,821 $65,691 $40,106 $47,295 $19,860 $64,000 $9,884 $90,154 $45,474 $33,994 $43,720 $125,000 $33,165 $88,872 $9,220 $75,000 CPA for FY16 SGCash LLC Ullmann & Company Ullmann & Company not required Ullmann & Company Romek, Sanders & Co Mayer Hoffman McCann Ullmann & Company Dorothy Reinert CPA, PLLC Ullmann & Company Regier Carr & Monroe Roberts Alexonis Group Johnson Lawdahl, PLLC Rausch, Hermanson, Everroad & Rentschler Ullmann & Company Monica J. Stern not submitted HBL CPAs Romek, Sanders & Co not submitted Fester & Chapman Monica J. Stern Addington & Associates Beach Fleischman PC Eide Bailly Tull Forsberg & Olson Eide Bailly Seely, Mullins & Associates Cost of FY15 Audit/Review $9,700 $1,750 $2,498 Accepts Donation Recommendations ------- $3,949 $8,425 $18,000 $2,725 $3,125 $4,289 $13,300 $8,400 $4,300 yes yes yes $22,420 $2,860 $6,500 ------yes yes $16,999 $4,455 yes $5,300 $6,399 $5,000 $14,491 $8,500 $9,485 $13,900 $1,890 yes yes yes yes yes yes yes 7/29/2010 7/29/2010 7/29/2010 2/24/2011 4/14/2011 Rausch, Hermanson, Everroad & Rentschler Schutte & Hilgendorf Henry J Fortino Scott R. Meyers, CPA inc. Eide Bailly $8,994 $3,000 $1,000 $2,500 $9,300 yes yes yes ------- Not after 11/3/2015 8/18/2010 not required Khalsa McBrearty Accountancy $6,400 ------yes Arizona Department of Revenue, Office of Economic Research & Analysis, June 2017 5 Table 1 School Tuition Organizations Certified to Receive Tax Credit Donations in FY2016 School Tuition Organization Education Liberty Fund Financial Assistance for Independent Schools Foundation for Corporate Tax Credit Funds for Kids Individual Certified 5/15/2015 1/01/2011 Corporate Certified 5/15/2015 7/29/2010 4/15/2011 Not after 10/5/2015 Not after 10/5/2015 Not after 4/18/2016 Not after 4/18/2016 3/23/2011 7/29/2010 7/29/2010 6/14/2011 6/02/2016 7/29/2010 7/29/2010 7/01/2012 10/07/2010 Higher Education STO Independent Schools Corporate Tax Foundation Institute for Better Education Jewish Education Tax Credit Organization Jewish Tuition Organization Lexington Education Foundation Life Development Institute Education Fund Lutheran Education Foundation Montessori Scholarship Organization Northern Arizona Christian School Scholarship Fund Orme Primavera Schools Foundation Pappas Kids Schoolhouse Foundation Pinetop Tuition Support Organization Scholarships for Educational Excellence Foundation School Choice Arizona School Tuition Association of Yuma Schools With Heart Foundation Shepherd of the Desert Education Foundation Southern Arizona Foundation for Education-SAFE Lutheran Students First Foundation The Zisel Tovah Foundation Tuition Organization for Private Schools 1/01/2011 1/01/2011 1/01/2011 3/24/2016 1/01/2011 1/01/2011 1/01/2011 1/01/2011 1/01/2011 1/01/2011 1/01/2011 1/03/2011 1/01/2011 1/01/2011 1/01/2011 1/01/2011 1/01/2011 10/02/2015 12/01/2015 1/01/2011 Valley Lutheran Scholarship Organization Valley Tuition Organization White Mountain Tuition Support Foundation Yuma’s Education Scholarship Fund for Kids Not after 6/30/2016 6/01/2016 1/01/2011 1/01/2011 Highest Paid Employees FY16 Salary 1 Salary 2 Salary 3 $114,577 $57,208 $85,000 $60,000 $8,720 $8,000 $53,760 7/29/2010 7/29/2010 $35,923 $2,000 $6,813 7/29/2010 4/15/2014 Not after 6/30/2016 6/01/2016 9/02/2010 7/01/2012 Arizona Department of Revenue, Office of Economic Research & Analysis, June 2017 Cost of FY15 Audit/Review $0 $5,421 $3,560 not submitted 8/03/2010 9/15/2015 7/29/2010 CPA for FY16 Dorothy Reinert CPA, PLLC Ullmann & Company Roberts & Associates $60,000 $20,282 $25,000 $50,473 $4,500 $1,862 Accepts Donation Recommendations yes ------yes Monica J. Stern Eide Bailly Romek, Sanders & Co HBL CPAs Johnson Lawdahl, PLLC Ullmann & Company Ullmann & Company Ullmann & Company Grass Coffey & Scharlau Dorothy Reinert CPA, PLLC Schutte & Hilgendorf W. Bridgeman not submitted Law & Reed CPAs Romek, Sanders & Co R & A CPAs Kevin M. Allen Monica J. Stern Addington & Associates not required not required Romek, Sanders & Co $2,350 $9,100 $7,346 $13,005 $9,000 $0 $3,640 $2,503 $5,500 $5,530 $2,800 $5,900 $2,500 $925 $6,008 $4,170 $1,250 $3,700 $4,000 Romek, Sanders & Co not required Michael W. Wilber Romek, Sanders & Co $4,608 yes ------yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes $6,700 $2,810 $6,135 yes yes 6 Table 2 Donations and Scholarships by School Tuition Organization CY1998 - FY2016 School Tuition Organization AAA Scholarship Foundation Academic Opportunity of Arizona Alternative Schools Scholarship Fund Alumnus School Tuition Organization Americas Scholarship Konnection INC Arizona Adventist Scholarships Arizona Christian School Tuition Organization Arizona Community Foundation School Tuition Organization Arizona Education Alliance Arizona Education and Scholarship Opportunity Program Arizona Education First Arizona Education Scholarship Foundation Arizona Episcopal Schools Foundation 1ST Year 2012 2014 2003 2015 2016 1999 1998 Original Individual Donations Scholarships $0 $0 $6,800 $0 $114,156 $109,686 $13,819 $0 $0 $0 $6,017,943 $5,770,612 $157,502,413 $140,226,889 Switcher Individual Donations Scholarships $0 $0 $5,320 $0 $0 $0 $10,809 $0 $0 $0 $282,495 $200,490 $21,219,653 $15,294,215 Low-Income Corporate Donations Scholarships $26,565,662 $8,530,854 $0 $0 Disabled/Displaced Corporate Donations Scholarships $2,755,000 $592,527 $262,500 $57,090 $0 $0 $2,500 $0 $0 $2,250 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 TOTALS Donations Scholarships $29,320,662 $9,123,381 $274,620 $57,090 $114,156 $109,686 $24,628 $0 $0 $0 $6,302,938 $5,973,352 $178,722,066 $155,521,104 2013 2012 $398,693 $0 $165,031 $0 $264,592 $0 $88,398 $0 $2,145,000 $1,312,690 $1,275,750 $677,781 $4,084,035 $0 $2,243,900 $0 2013 2014 2010 1999 $60,286 $156,750 $1,336,581 $11,903,133 $26,573 $76,780 $968,637 $10,490,596 $42,310 $108,703 $785,795 $1,433,598 $6,386 $39,240 $303,602 $852,596 $1,550,000 $15,000 $64,000 $3,544,855 $851,889 $10,000 $15,855 $1,844,238 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $1,652,596 $280,453 $2,186,376 $16,881,586 $884,848 $126,020 $1,288,094 $13,187,430 Arizona Independent Schools Scholarship Foundation 1998 $12,157,624 $11,363,268 $2,149,593 $1,919,448 $4,644,053 $2,361,105 $0 $0 $18,951,270 $15,643,821 Arizona International Academy Scholarship Fund Arizona Leadership Foundation Arizona Lutheran Scholarship Organization Arizona Native Scholastic and Enrichment Resource Foundation Arizona Private Education Scholarship Fund Arizona Scholarship Fund Arizona Scholarship & Grants Organization Arizona Scholarships & Tuition Arizona School Choice Trust Arizona Tax Credit Arizona Tax Credit for Education Arizona Tuition Connection Arizona Tuition Organization Arizona Waldorf Scholarship Foundation Arizona Youth Education Scholarships Arizona's Catholic Tuition Support Organization Best Student Fund 2001 2011 2002 $819,016 $671,883 $95,724 $94,912 $2,212,742 $1,947,525 $363,663 $242,500 $0 $39,294,916 $0 $0 $35,293,847 $0 $0 $6,254,400 $0 $0 $4,139,329 $0 $914,740 $45,549,316 $2,576,405 $766,795 $39,433,176 $2,190,025 1999 1999 1998 1999 1998 1998 2014 2015 2013 2004 2001 2011 1999 2001 $402,996 $19,989,462 $50,471,527 $6,775 $23,075 $20,193,738 $585,898 $0 $5,292,327 $4,470,279 $0 $0 $2,455,807 $337,601 $0 $3,900,507 $3,230,752 $0 $0 $1,534,873 $247,656 $0 $2,057,000 $826,491 $0 $1,765,832 $703,999 $0 $660,600 $16,800 $0 $570,724 $13,744 $25,514,253 $0 $1,582,679 $0 $277,287 $22,838,985 $48,205,816 $0 $26,360 $41,894,473 $677,003 $1,934,832 $2,742,983 $310,334 $0 $8,927,414 $427,143 $951,725 $1,998,998 $201,004 $0 $5,757,227 $354,342 $5,465,000 $0 $150,000 $135,800 $27,962,891 $0 $19,134,031 $2,030,247 $0 $0 did not report $2,502,024 $60,000 $0 $0 $110,096 $0 $122,209 $0 $20,488,971 $780,500 $0 $0 $402,996 $27,999,389 $55,785,097 $6,775 $23,075 $50,194,045 $923,499 $0 $0 $0 $0 $412,116 $0 $10,493,900 $18,135,036 $2,464,896 $135,800 $99,709,868 $3,344,811 $5,657,356 $15,570,232 $2,033,534 $122,209 $81,152,406 $3,105,357 Bret Reed Freesmeyer Memorial Scholarship Fund Brophy Community Foundation Carden Schools Scholarship Fund Catholic Education Arizona Chabad Tuition Organization Chaparral Mission Scholarship Fund Children’s Scholarship Network of Arizona 2001 1998 1998 1998 2000 2001 2008 $426,736 $17,115,404 $57,980 $144,698,725 $2,225,748 $1,460,480 $164,211 $0 $3,348,817 $0 $19,269,166 $385,738 $0 $0 $0 $2,051,482 $0 $12,279,468 $353,884 $0 $0 $19,683,400 $13,182,230 $0 $0 $28,279,963 $500 $3,000 $330,000 $21,241,955 $450 $3,000 $323,438 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $426,736 $40,147,621 $57,980 $192,247,854 $2,611,986 $1,463,480 $494,211 $492,962 $29,692,414 $55,067 $165,596,949 $2,324,057 $1,530,304 $480,085 $3,034,068 $15,392,053 $2,004,562 $0 $62,039,062 $2,917,668 $277,287 $16,601,922 $44,257,321 $0 $26,360 $19,642,890 $429,347 did not report $2,203,607 $13,571,234 $1,722,434 $0 $54,494,092 $2,751,015 $492,962 $14,458,702 $55,067 $132,075,526 $1,969,723 $1,527,304 $156,647 Highlighted STOs are no longer operational. Arizona Department of Revenue, Office of Economic Research & Analysis, June 2017 7 Table 2 Donations and Scholarships by School Tuition Organization CY1998 - FY2016 School Tuition Organization Christ Lutheran School Tuition Organization Christian Scholarship Foundation Christian Scholarship Fund of Arizona Classical Christian Scholarship Fund Cochise Christian School Tuition Organization Corporate Tax Foundation Corporations Reducing Student Tuition Diversity Leadership Institute Dynamite Montessori Foundation Educare Scholarship Fund Education Liberty Fund Engelhardt/Pappas Foundation Financial Assistance for Independent Schools Flagstaff Scholarship Fund Foundation for Corporate Tax Credit Foundation for Lutherans Interested in Funding Education Foundation for Montessori Scholarships Funds for Kids H.E.L.P. Scholarship Foundation Higher Education STO Independent Schools Corporate Tax Foundation Institute for Better Education Investing in Children of Arizona Scholarship Fund Jewish Education Tax Credit Organization Jewish Tuition Organization Just Friends of Education Lexington Education Foundation Life Development Institute Education Fund Lutheran Education Foundation Maranatha Christian Co-Op Tuition Fund Montessori Centre School Tuition Organization Montessori Scholarship Organization Montessori School Tuition Organization 1ST Year 2000 1999 1998 2003 2002 2011 2014 2012 2001 1999 2015 1999 2000 2001 2011 Original Individual Donations Scholarships $2,953,620 $2,691,037 $3,516,267 $3,161,008 $5,469,867 $4,945,331 $249,968 $207,891 $5,023,779 $4,881,286 Switcher Individual Donations Scholarships $409,473 $337,473 $271,075 $179,999 $241,039 $128,327 $0 $0 $702,053 $664,673 $0 $602,213 $847,957 $3,210 $1,219,231 $4,002,593 $1,752,439 $0 $528,057 $817,733 $0 $1,123,034 $3,374,667 $1,610,865 $0 $134,419 $0 $2,258 $0 $836,568 $0 $0 $126,489 $0 $0 $0 $541,879 $0 2002 1999 2013 1998 2011 2011 1998 2003 1999 1999 2009 2016 2006 1998 1998 2000 2000 1999 $432,551 $522,654 $537,708 $13,032,282 $366,767 $428,851 $473,808 $485,461 $12,369,660 $317,748 $0 $0 $284,321 $806,204 $126,206 $0 $0 $255,588 $730,432 $116,169 $75,145,789 $6,875 $8,709,830 $24,058,220 $7,600 $3,817 $265,879 $2,968,102 $21,630 $361,549 $4,575,177 $43,400 $59,868,430 $0 $7,142,769 $22,574,085 $6,070 $0 $227,236 $2,797,245 $3,926 $349,867 $4,331,540 $38,900 $15,462,003 $0 $1,552,070 $4,651,880 $0 $2,128 $62,673 $97,302 $0 $0 $594,152 $0 $8,729,389 $0 $984,524 $3,074,034 $0 $0 $49,707 $82,631 $0 $0 $465,143 $0 Northern Arizona Christian School Scholarship Fund Orme Primavera Schools Foundation Pappas Kids Schoolhouse Foundation Parkside Christian Learning Center Patagonia Scholarship Fund Pinetop Tuition Support Organization 1998 1999 2005 2012 1999 2006 $4,664,409 $2,903,211 $2,720,315 $0 $76,154 $146,642 $3,901,589 $2,699,661 $2,375,260 $0 $62,713 $126,821 $737,173 $327,095 $938,997 $0 $0 $19,096 $474,691 $282,537 $851,890 $0 $0 $13,097 Scholarships for Educational Excellence Foundation School Choice Arizona 2009 2006 $564,518 $2,450,311 $560,705 $1,724,865 $145,817 $665,006 $82,770 $428,735 Low-Income Corporate Donations Scholarships $0 $0 $196,000 $162,480 $50,000 $50,107 Disabled/Displaced Corporate Donations Scholarships $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $135,000 $4,430,000 $0 $0 $0 $135,000 $1,434,758 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $6,920 $0 $0 $0 $0 $4,728 $0 $0 $0 $0 $320,000 $1,392,500 $677,000 $158,363 $1,316,020 $685,780 $785,000 $0 $0 $618,427 $0 $0 TOTALS Donations Scholarships $3,363,093 $3,028,510 $3,983,342 $3,503,487 $5,760,906 $5,123,765 $249,968 $207,891 $5,860,832 $5,680,959 $4,430,000 $1,434,758 $0 $0 $0 $0 $743,552 $659,274 $847,957 $817,733 $5,468 $0 $1,219,231 $1,123,034 $5,944,160 $4,693,336 $3,144,939 $2,926,885 $677,000 $685,780 $432,551 $522,654 $887,029 $13,849,091 $502,973 $5,225,000 $97,483,554 $6,875 $11,011,900 $29,683,200 $7,600 $5,945 $398,552 $3,065,404 $21,630 $361,549 $5,169,329 $43,400 $428,851 $473,808 $799,549 $13,109,572 $442,917 $2,201,281 $74,698,227 $0 $8,953,188 $26,208,180 $6,070 $0 $331,553 $2,879,876 $3,926 $349,867 $4,796,683 $38,900 $4,729,727 $2,982,198 $3,536,826 $0 $62,713 $139,918 $643,476 $15,955,172 $65,000 $10,605 $10,000 $5,225,000 $5,909,364 $58,500 $9,480 $9,000 $2,201,281 $5,379,747 $0 $0 $0 $0 $966,398 $0 $0 $0 $0 $720,662 $750,000 $973,100 $0 $0 $25,000 $0 $825,895 $560,061 $0 $0 $19,200 $0 $0 $0 $0 $45,000 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $35,410 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $380,226 $353,447 $0 $0 $340,000 $309,676 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $5,781,807 $3,230,306 $3,999,312 $0 $76,154 $165,738 $17,826,265 $13,171,084 $740,000 $630,488 $710,335 $21,681,583 Highlighted STOs are no longer operational. Arizona Department of Revenue, Office of Economic Research & Analysis, June 2017 8 Table 2 Donations and Scholarships by School Tuition Organization CY1998 - FY2016 School Tuition Organization 1ST Year School Tuition Association of Yuma 1999 Schools With Heart Foundation 1999 Shepherd of the Desert Education Foundation 2000 Southern Arizona Foundation for Education-SAFE Lutheran 1998 Students First Foundation 2015 Tempe Montessori Parent’s Organization 2000 Tempe Montessori School Tuition Organization 2011 Tesseract Tuition Organization 1998 The Leadership Consortium 2011 The Zisel Tovah Foundation 2016 Tuition Organization for Private Schools 2004 Valley Lutheran Scholarship Organization 2004 Valley Tuition Organization 2016 VVBC Christian Education Fund 1999 Walter T. Beamis Scholarship Foundation 1999 White Mountain Tuition Support Foundation 2004 Yo Creo 2011 Yuma’s Education Scholarship Fund for Kids 2003 TOTALS Original Individual Donations Scholarships $3,890,116 $3,546,809 $4,123,669 $3,773,495 $1,937,020 $1,814,635 Switcher Individual Donations Scholarships $395,925 $351,108 $696,277 $579,390 $314,566 $267,258 $4,193,008 $0 $1,327,668 $157,233 $146,315 $0 $535 $15,987,647 $1,148,000 $0 $324,519 $11,371 $1,723,404 $0 $6,584,002 $747,691,163 $135,696 $0 $0 $6,000 $0 $0 $500 $3,178,206 $137,641 $0 $0 $0 $396,695 $0 $1,253,757 $112,248,966 $4,072,485 $0 $1,285,596 $41,843 $24,250 $0 $0 $13,641,963 $1,149,711 $0 $317,182 $4,000 $1,507,529 $0 $6,060,044 $661,978,579 $103,530 $0 $0 $13,633 $0 $0 $0 $1,915,388 $124,572 $0 $0 $0 $283,461 $0 $884,379 $75,026,603 Low-Income Corporate Donations Scholarships $928,600 $847,661 $0 $0 $0 $0 Disabled/Displaced Corporate Donations Scholarships $0 $1,250 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $16,000 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $2,580,995 $130,000 $0 $2,387,354 $116,018 $0 $2,454,880 $0 $0 $2,133,966 $0 $0 $0 $0 $169,425 $230,774,364 $0 $0 $152,072 $160,143,945 $0 $0 $160,000 $19,253,995 $0 $0 $120,498 $12,311,419 TOTALS Donations Scholarships $5,214,641 $4,746,828 $4,819,946 $4,352,885 $2,251,586 $2,081,893 $4,328,704 $0 $1,327,668 $179,233 $146,315 $0 $1,035 $24,201,728 $1,415,641 $0 $324,519 $11,371 $2,120,099 $0 $8,167,184 $1,109,968,488 $4,176,016 $0 $1,285,596 $55,476 $24,250 $0 $0 $20,078,671 $1,390,301 $0 $317,182 $4,000 $1,790,991 $0 $7,216,993 $909,460,546 Highlighted STOs are no longer operational. Arizona Department of Revenue, Office of Economic Research & Analysis, June 2017 9 ORIGINAL INDIVIDUAL INCOME TAX CREDIT PROGRAM Arizona allows an individual income tax credit for donations made to STOs that provide scholarships to private schools. Fifty-nine STOs were certified to receive individual donations in FY2016. The original individual income tax credit for contributions to school tuition organizations is governed by A.R.S. § 431089 and Chapter 16 in Title 43. A taxpayer could receive an income tax credit for a donation of $535 (for single, unmarried head of household and married filing separate taxpayers) or $1,070 (for married filing joint taxpayers) in tax year 2015. The maximum credit amounts are adjusted each year for inflation. For tax year 2016 the original individual income tax credit increased to $545 and $1,090. The original individual scholarship is available to K-12 students and preschool students with disabilities. The scholarship amount cannot exceed the cost of tuition for an academic year. Growth in Original Individual Credit Program Millions Donations Scholarships $70 $60 $50 $40 $30 $20 $10 $0 *Reporting change The following table shows the number of STOs collecting original individual donations in each period, the number of donations and the amount of tax credit donations. Percent change is calculated for prior year amounts reported. No percent change is calculated for FY2011 as this is the first fiscal year reporting period. The table also shows the number of STOs providing original individual scholarships in each period, the number of scholarships and the amount of scholarships paid. (For calendar years prior to 2003, the numbers are soft; reporting was not statutorily-required at that time.) As with the donations data, no percent change is calculated for FY2011 as this was the first fiscal year reporting period. Please note that the number of scholarships paid does not equate to the number of students receiving scholarships. Many families seek scholarships from multiple STOs, resulting in one child being counted several times in the scholarship counts. Arizona Department of Revenue, Office of Economic Research & Analysis, June 2017 10 ORIGINAL INDIVIDUAL INCOME TAX CREDIT PROGRAM Reporting Year CY1998 CY1999 CY2000 CY2001 CY2002 CY2003 CY2004 CY2005 CY2006 CY2007 CY2008 CY2009 CY2010 8 FY2011 FY2012 FY2013 FY2014 FY2015 FY2016 # of STOs 16 33 36 43 43 51 53 53 56 55 55 54 53 50 49 48 49 52 55 Original Individual Donations # donations $ Amount 4,248 $1,815,798 32,023 $13,781,341 38,249 $17,701,284 46,696 $24,897,444 52,203 $26,512,683 58,122 $29,444,972 63,830 $31,846,494 69,239 $42,196,206 73,617 $51,012,326 76,065 $54,304,968 78,434 $55,260,728 73,430 $50,916,897 62,940 $43,163,214 74,681 $51,408,122 76,739 $51,918,033 76,098 $54,794,058 80,893 $58,129,582 80,930 $61,740,333 86,513 $65,436,399 % change 28.4% 40.7% 6.5% 11.1% 8.2% 32.5% 20.9% 6.5% 1.8% -7.9% -15.2% 1.0% 5.5% 6.1% 6.2% 6.0% # of STOs 4 19 32 39 43 49 51 51 52 55 54 52 54 50 50 47 48 50 50 Original Individual Scholarships # % scholarships $ Amount change 128 $103,790 3,207 $2,196,734 15,081 $13,561,981 517.4% 18,049 $16,484,958 21.6% 19,582 $22,826,746 38.5% 20,134 $24,428,197 7.0% 21,146 $28,025,083 14.7% 22,529 $30,863,153 10.1% 24,678 $40,594,978 31.5% 27,153 $48,561,687 19.6% 28,327 $54,205,394 11.6% 27,592 $52,127,262 -3.8% 26,430 $47,333,755 -9.2% 25,105 $46,091,539 23,828 $45,209,410 -1.9% 25,462 $48,873,359 8.1% 26,972 $49,610,422 1.5% 29,802 $54,656,554 10.2% 31,578 $54,433,864 -0.4% Top 10 STOs by FY2016 Original Individual Donations Donations Scholarships Arizona Christian School Tuition Organization $10.1 $12.0 Institute for Better Education $9.4 $9.0 $8.4 Catholic Education Arizona $4.5 $4.4 Arizona's Catholic Tuition Support Organization Arizona Private Education Scholarship Fund Arizona Tuition Connection Arizona Scholarship Fund Tuition Organization for Private Schools Arizona Tuition Organization Jewish Tuition Organization Millions $13.9 $3.1 $2.4 $2.3 $1.6 $2.0 $2.5 $1.9 $1.7 $1.8 $1.6 $1.8 $1.6 8 There are 6 months that overlap between CY2010 and FY2011. Some of the donations and scholarships showing for FY2011 are already included in CY2010. Arizona Department of Revenue, Office of Economic Research & Analysis, June 2017 11 FY2016 Original Individual Donations and Scholarships Table 3 (pg. 15) shows the number, amount and average of the FY2016 original individual donations received by STO. In addition, the number and amount of scholarships paid by STO as well as the average scholarships and number of schools receiving scholarships is included. This table also provides the number and amount of original individual future reserved scholarships reported by each STO. Arizona Christian School Tuition Organization received the most original individual donations in FY2016 of $13.9 million or 21.2% of the total donations. Cochise Christian School Tuition Organization reported the largest average donation amount of $1,183 for FY2016. Because STOs will receive donations in a fiscal year that will include two tax years, the average will fall between the two tax year donation caps. Arizona Christian School Tuition Organization paid the highest amount of original individual scholarships ($10.1 million or 18.6% of the total) and awarded the largest number of scholarships (5,717 scholarships or 18.1% of total). There were five STOs that received donations but did not pay scholarships in FY2016. All five were certified during FY2015 or FY2016. STOs must allocate 90% of the tax credit donations to scholarships within two fiscal years after receipt of the donations. The 50 STOs that paid original individual scholarships in FY2016 show an overall average scholarship of $1,724. The average original individual scholarship amounts paid by STOs in FY2016 ranged from $427 to $5,698. Note that the STO average scholarship calculation will include double counting if a student attends two different private schools during the year and an STO awards the student scholarships to both schools. The 50 STOs provided original individual scholarships to 330 private schools throughout Arizona. Institute for Better Education provided original individual scholarships to a total of 179 schools. There were 10 STOs that provided scholarships to the required minimum of two private schools. Future Reserved Original Individual Scholarships STOs also reserved scholarships for specific students for future years. Nineteen STOs reserved an additional $18.6 million in the original individual donation program for 10,476 students. In FY2016 Institute for Better Education reported reserving the largest amount of original individual donations for future year scholarships of $8.1 million for 4,433 students. It should be noted that a portion of the reserved future year awards reported by STOs may be for scholarships to be awarded in the upcoming academic year. STOs Reporting Future Reserved Original Individual Scholarships Greater than $500,000 in FY2016 Millions Institute for Better Education $8.1 Arizona Christian School Tuition Organization $2.8 Arizona's Catholic Tuition Support Organization $2.2 Arizona Private Education Scholarship Fund Brophy Community Foundation $1.5 $1.2 Tuition Organization for Private Schools $0.6 Arizona Tuition Organization $0.6 Arizona Department of Revenue, Office of Economic Research & Analysis, June 2017 12 FY2016 Original Individual Scholarships by Income Level STOs are required to report the percentage of scholarship dollars that go to families with income of 185% or less of poverty level and the percentage of scholarship dollars that go to families with income ranging from above 185% of poverty level to 342.25% of poverty level. For the 2015-2016 academic year, 342.25% of the federal poverty level for a household of four was $82,997. Overall Share of FY2016 Original Individual Scholarships by Family Income 32.4% $17.6m 35.1% $19.0m 32.6% $17.7m Families with income up to 185% of poverty level Families with income from 185% to 342.25% of poverty level Families with income greater than 342.25% of poverty level Table 4 (pg. 17) shows the income level percentages for each STO. Ten organizations gave 100% of their scholarships to children in families with income of 342.25% or less of poverty level. There were 10 STOs that gave more than 50% of their original scholarships to children of families with income greater than 342.25% of poverty level. Original Individual Credit Program 90/10 Calculation All STOs certified to collect original individual donations in FY2016 were evaluated as to their status in relation to the requirement that 90% of all revenue must be paid out in scholarships. From an administrative viewpoint, no STO is expected to pay out 90% of donations it receives in the current year for scholarships the same year. There will always be a lag between revenue received and revenue paid out and it does not mean that an STO with a percentage of less than 90% is in violation of the law. The 90% requirement is evaluated using two different methods: 1) a review of total donations and scholarships over the life of the STO and 2) calculating 90% of credit donations received in a particular fiscal year and tracking the amount to be awarded within the following two fiscal years. The following table shows the lifetime percentage calculated based on total donations and scholarships (method #1) for those STOs certified to receive original individual donations in FY2016. Original Individual Credit Program Lifetime 90/10 Ratios School Tuition Organization Academic Opportunity of Arizona Ratio 0.0 Alumnus School Tuition Organization Arizona Adventist Scholarships Arizona Christian School Tuition Organization Arizona Community Foundation STO 0.0 96.2 90.8 42.0 School Tuition Organization Arizona Education and Scholarship Opportunity Program Arizona Education First Arizona Education Scholarship Foundation Arizona Episcopal Schools Foundation Arizona Independent Schools Scholarship Foundation Arizona Department of Revenue, Office of Economic Research & Analysis, June 2017 Ratio 44.9 49.6 77.2 88.4 93.7 13 Original Individual Credit Program Lifetime 90/10 Ratios (continued) School Tuition Organization Arizona International Academy Scholarship Fund Arizona Lutheran Scholarship Organization Arizona Private Education Scholarship Fund Arizona Scholarship Fund Arizona School Choice Trust Arizona Tax Credit Arizona Tuition Connection Arizona Tuition Organization Arizona Waldorf Scholarship Foundation Ratio 83.8 93.1 90.8 87.7 99.4 83.4 72.8 92.4 86.7 Arizona's Catholic Tuition Support Organization BEST Student Fund Brophy Community Foundation Catholic Education Arizona 91.5 94.9 91.8 91.3 Chabad Tuition Organization Christ Lutheran School Tuition Organization Christian Scholarship Foundation Christian Scholarship Fund of Arizona Cochise Christian School Tuition Organization Dynamite Montessori Foundation Education Liberty Fund Financial Assistance for Independent Schools Funds for Kids 88.7 92.2 90.1 90.5 98.3 95.0 0.0 88.4 90.6 School Tuition Organization Higher Education STO Institute for Better Education Jewish Education Tax Credit Organization Jewish Tuition Organization Lexington Education Foundation Life Development Institute Education Fund Lutheran Education Foundation Montessori Scholarship Organization Northern Arizona Christian School Scholarship Fund Orme Primavera Schools Foundation Pappas Kids Schoolhouse Foundation Pinetop Tuition Support Organization Scholarships for Education Excellence Foundation School Choice Arizona School Tuition Association of Yuma Schools With Heart Foundation Shepherd of the Desert Education Foundation Southern Arizona Foundation for Education Tuition Organization for Private Schools Valley Lutheran Scholarship Organization White Mountain Tuition Support Foundation Yuma’s Education Scholarship Fund for Kids Ratio 90.1 90.5 83.4 94.0 0.0 89.2 94.6 95.2 84.0 93.1 87.8 93.2 107.3 76.8 91.5 91.6 94.4 97.9 89.5 101.8 88.0 92.2 Seven STOs have lifetime ratios below 50.0 because they are newer STOs; their scholarships should increase significantly within the next year or two. Two STOs have a percentage greater than 100% because scholarships were paid from revenue that was not tax credit donations or due to reserved scholarships for specific students in future years. These percentages are being monitored annually and if STOs with low percentages do not improve, ADOR will review that program to determine the reason. Based on the yearly 90% calculation (method #2), there are currently no STOs in violation of the 90% requirement. Arizona Department of Revenue, Office of Economic Research & Analysis, June 2017 14 Table 3 FY 2016 Original Individual Donations and Scholarships by School Tuition Organization School Tuition Organization Academic Opportunity of Arizona Alumnus School Tuition Organization Arizona Adventist Scholarships Arizona Christian School Tuition Organization Arizona Community Foundation School Tuition Organization Arizona Education and Scholarship Opportunity Program Arizona Education First Arizona Education Scholarship Foundation Arizona Episcopal Schools Foundation Arizona Independent Schools Scholarship Foundation Arizona International Academy Scholarship Fund Arizona Lutheran Scholarship Organization Arizona Private Education Scholarship Fund Arizona Scholarship Fund Arizona School Choice Trust Arizona Tax Credit Arizona Tuition Connection Arizona Tuition Organization Arizona Waldorf Scholarship Foundation Arizona's Catholic Tuition Support Organization Best Student Fund Brophy Community Foundation Catholic Education Arizona Chabad Tuition Organization Christ Lutheran School Tuition Organization Christian Scholarship Foundation Christian Scholarship Fund of Arizona Cochise Christian School Tuition Organization Dynamite Montessori Foundation Education Liberty Fund Financial Assistance for Independent Schools Funds For Kids Higher Education STO Institute for Better Education Jewish Education Tax Credit Organization Jewish Tuition Organization Lexington Education Foundation Life Development Institute Education Fund Lutheran Education Foundation Montessori Scholarship Organization Northern Arizona Christian School Scholarship Fund Orme Primavera Schools Foundation # 8 12 556 17,339 229 45 138 709 1,208 970 105 392 3,751 2,268 1,322 461 3,188 2,283 287 6,689 232 1,661 13,612 307 262 307 276 566 81 4 368 160 98 14,480 770 2,350 4 58 124 479 763 291 Donations $ Amount $6,800 $8,525 $329,587 $13,890,936 $194,835 $31,037 $113,931 $576,702 $836,011 $802,692 $90,660 $257,420 $3,080,016 $1,968,622 $907,145 $393,206 $2,318,103 $1,826,031 $201,616 $4,546,932 $199,279 $1,284,446 $8,986,612 $208,956 $195,315 $202,700 $184,306 $669,858 $71,841 $3,210 $287,429 $32,710 $65,772 $12,003,879 $585,252 $1,777,120 $3,817 $47,266 $82,244 $386,429 $556,657 $232,098 Arizona Department of Revenue, Office of Economic Research & Analysis, June 2017 Average $850 $710 $593 $801 $851 $690 $826 $813 $692 $828 $863 $657 $821 $868 $686 $853 $727 $800 $702 $680 $859 $773 $660 $681 $745 $660 $668 $1,183 $887 $803 $781 $204 $671 $829 $760 $756 $954 $815 $663 $807 $730 $798 # 0 0 306 5,717 33 27 17 395 214 214 25 262 1,220 1,813 136 242 1,054 849 67 2,625 48 509 5,394 30 74 179 86 355 28 0 26 192 38 5,325 125 528 0 7 29 110 200 46 Scholarships $ Amount Average $0 $0 $0 $0 $307,724 $1,006 $10,122,421 $1,771 $131,444 $3,983 $11,523 $427 $76,780 $4,516 $412,960 $1,045 $644,765 $3,013 $703,866 $3,289 $76,279 $3,051 $215,738 $823 $2,393,060 $1,962 $2,543,849 $1,403 $283,788 $2,087 $301,697 $1,247 $1,613,342 $1,531 $1,551,618 $1,828 $169,040 $2,523 $4,427,700 $1,687 $145,135 $3,024 $1,087,184 $2,136 $8,443,445 $1,565 $158,467 $5,282 $170,455 $2,303 $181,114 $1,012 $170,940 $1,988 $645,756 $1,819 $85,102 $3,039 $0 $0 $114,654 $4,410 $244,591 $1,274 $69,810 $1,837 $9,429,265 $1,771 $400,885 $3,207 $1,592,798 $3,017 $0 $0 $29,283 $4,183 $76,199 $2,628 $301,888 $2,744 $464,483 $2,322 $215,331 $4,681 # of Schools 0 0 13 120 19 3 3 66 5 3 6 8 90 138 39 33 107 8 2 25 2 21 37 4 3 2 9 17 2 0 2 22 5 179 2 6 0 2 6 7 5 2 Future Reserved Scholarships $ Amount # 0 $0 0 $0 0 $0 1,407 $2,793,757 0 $0 0 $0 0 $0 90 $52,323 0 $0 0 $0 0 $0 129 $102,611 913 $1,520,840 0 $0 185 $401,875 11 $56,907 0 $0 517 $624,827 0 $0 1,232 $2,240,274 0 $0 573 $1,241,922 0 $0 0 $0 0 $0 0 $0 0 $0 35 $47,145 16 $13,897 0 $0 47 $149,000 0 $0 0 $0 4,433 $8,140,067 29 $100,664 0 $0 0 $0 0 $0 0 $0 0 $0 0 $0 0 $0 15 Table 3 FY 2016 Original Individual Donations and Scholarships by School Tuition Organization School Tuition Organization Pappas Kids Schoolhouse Foundation Pinetop Tuition Support Organization Scholarships for Educational Excellence Foundation School Choice Arizona School Tuition Association of Yuma Schools With Heart Foundation Shepherd of the Desert Education Foundation Southern Arizona Foundation for Education-SAFE Lutheran The Zisel Tovah Foundation Tuition Organization for Private Schools Valley Lutheran Scholarship Organization White Mountain Tuition Support Foundation Yuma's Education Scholarship Fund for Kids TOTALS # 617 9 112 1,787 195 376 264 239 1 2,280 144 346 930 86,513 Donations $ Amount $476,338 $8,993 $90,545 $656,238 $142,198 $301,495 $142,973 $147,016 $535 $1,860,226 $100,281 $256,430 $805,128 $65,436,399 Arizona Department of Revenue, Office of Economic Research & Analysis, June 2017 Average $772 $999 $808 $367 $729 $802 $542 $615 $535 $816 $696 $741 $866 $756 # 293 7 69 357 187 54 72 49 0 1,238 149 88 470 31,578 Scholarships $ Amount Average $451,361 $1,540 $9,303 $1,329 $117,473 $1,703 $384,920 $1,078 $162,689 $870 $307,669 $5,698 $114,093 $1,585 $121,977 $2,489 $0 $0 $1,684,883 $1,361 $156,650 $1,051 $165,286 $1,878 $743,182 $1,581 $54,433,864 $1,724 # of Schools 27 2 3 66 9 3 4 2 0 104 3 4 14 Future Reserved Scholarships $ Amount # 0 $0 0 $0 17 $38,070 166 $155,178 0 $0 0 $0 0 $0 10 $4,097 0 $0 435 $643,191 0 $0 0 $0 231 $291,542 10,476 $18,618,187 16 Table 4 FY 2016 Original Individual Scholarships by Income Level School Tuition Organization Arizona Adventist Scholarships Arizona Christian School Tuition Organization Arizona Community Foundation School Tuition Organization Arizona Education and Scholarship Opportunity Program Arizona Education First Arizona Education Scholarship Foundation Arizona Episcopal Schools Foundation Arizona Independent Schools Scholarship Foundation Arizona International Academy Scholarship Fund Arizona Lutheran Scholarship Organization Arizona Private Education Scholarship Fund Arizona Scholarship Fund Arizona School Choice Trust Arizona Tax Credit Arizona Tuition Connection Arizona Tuition Organization Arizona Waldorf Scholarship Foundation Arizona's Catholic Tuition Support Organization Best Student Fund Brophy Community Foundation Catholic Education Arizona Chabad Tuition Organization Christ Lutheran School Tuition Organization Christian Scholarship Foundation Christian Scholarship Fund of Arizona Cochise Christian School Tuition Organization Dynamite Montessori Foundation Financial Assistance for Independent Schools Funds For Kids Higher Education STO Institute for Better Education Jewish Education Tax Credit Organization Jewish Tuition Organization Life Development Institute Education Foundation % of Scholarships to Families with Original Individual Income up to 185% of Income from 185% to Scholarships Poverty Level 342.25% of Poverty Level $307,724 55.1% 28.9% $10,122,421 21.2% 30.3% $131,444 70.3% 29.7% $11,523 42.5% 34.4% $76,780 9.5% 9.5% $412,960 13.0% 15.9% $644,765 47.1% 20.2% $703,866 34.2% 24.9% $76,279 28.7% 13.0% $215,738 38.7% 23.1% $2,393,060 12.1% 23.5% $2,543,849 39.0% 29.3% $283,788 38.9% 61.1% $301,697 14.3% 26.5% $1,613,342 19.2% 20.5% $1,551,618 15.0% 39.4% $169,040 84.5% 1.8% $4,427,700 40.4% 25.0% $145,135 96.9% 3.1% $1,087,184 70.9% 17.4% $8,443,445 27.3% 52.2% $158,467 86.1% 13.9% $170,455 59.8% 31.9% $181,114 71.7% 28.3% $170,940 69.9% 28.3% $645,756 26.4% 41.4% $85,102 27.5% 29.2% $114,654 40.5% 15.0% $244,591 did not report $69,810 39.7% 55.0% $9,429,265 41.0% 33.8% $400,885 29.6% 13.5% $1,592,798 32.9% 30.1% $29,283 57.3% 42.7% Arizona Department of Revenue, Office of Economic Research & Analysis, June 2017 Remaining % 16.0% 48.5% 0.0% 23.1% 81.0% 71.1% 32.7% 40.9% 58.3% 38.2% 64.4% 31.7% 0.0% 59.2% 60.3% 45.6% 13.7% 34.6% 0.0% 11.7% 20.5% 0.0% 8.3% 0.0% 1.8% 32.2% 43.3% 44.5% 5.3% 25.2% 56.9% 37.0% 0.0% 17 Table 4 FY 2016 Original Individual Scholarships by Income Level School Tuition Organization Lutheran Education Foundation Montessori Scholarship Organization Northern Arizona Christian School Scholarship Fund Orme Primavera Schools Foundation Pappas Kids Schoolhouse Foundation Pinetop Tuition Support Organization Scholarships for Educational Excellence Foundation School Choice Arizona School Tuition Association of Yuma Schools With Heart Foundation Shepherd of the Desert Education Foundation Southern Arizona Foundation for Education-SAFE Lutheran Tuition Organization for Private Schools Valley Lutheran Scholarship Organization White Mountain Tuition Support Foundation Yuma's Education Scholarship Fund for Kids TOTALS % of Scholarships to Families with Original Individual Income up to 185% of Income from 185% to Scholarships Poverty Level 342.25% of Poverty Level $76,199 34.1% 65.5% $301,888 21.6% 78.4% $464,483 51.9% 33.2% $215,331 34.3% 13.5% $451,361 98.8% 1.2% $9,303 94.6% 5.4% $117,473 53.3% 11.3% $384,920 44.4% 36.3% $162,689 19.4% 20.8% $307,669 40.6% 34.7% $114,093 41.8% 27.1% $121,977 71.6% 27.3% $1,684,883 24.2% 31.7% $156,650 80.8% 19.2% $165,286 41.6% 36.0% $743,182 13.7% 21.9% $54,433,864 32.4% 32.6% Arizona Department of Revenue, Office of Economic Research & Analysis, June 2017 Remaining % 0.4% 0.0% 14.9% 52.2% 0.0% 0.0% 35.4% 19.3% 59.8% 24.7% 31.1% 1.1% 44.1% 0.0% 22.4% 64.4% 35.0% 18 SWITCHER INDIVIDUAL INCOME TAX CREDIT PROGRAM Arizona allows a second individual income tax credit for individuals wishing to give more than the amount allowed for an individual income tax credit under the original individual income tax credit program. Fiftynine STOs were certified to receive individual donations in FY2016. The switcher individual income tax credit for contributions to school tuition organizations is governed by A.R.S. § 43-1089.03 and Chapter 16 in Title 43. After donating $535 or $1,070 for the original individual income tax credit, individuals could donate up to an additional $532 or $1,064 (depending on filing status) in tax year 2015 and take this additional credit. The maximum credit amounts are adjusted each year for inflation. Additional amounts that could be donated in tax year 2016 increased to $542 and $1,083. The switcher individual scholarship is available to K-12 students and preschool students with disabilities. Students receiving scholarships paid from the switcher individual donations must meet one of the following requirements: attended a public school as a full-time student for at least 90 days of the prior fiscal year and then transferred from a public school to a private school; OR is enrolling in a private school kindergarten; OR is enrolling in a private preschool program for students with disabilities; OR is a dependent of a member of the armed forces of the United States who is stationed in Arizona pursuant to military orders; OR received for any prior year a scholarship under one of the above criteria OR from the low-income corporate donation program or the disabled/displaced corporate donation program if the child continued to attend a private school in subsequent years. The scholarship amount cannot exceed the cost of tuition for an academic year. Growth in Switcher Individual Credit Program Millions Donations Scholarships $40 $35 $30 $25 $20 $15 $10 FY12 Donations = $23,975 $5 $0 FY2012 FY2013 FY2014 FY2015 FY2016 The following table shows the number of STOs collecting switcher individual donations in each period, the number of donations and the amount of tax credit donations. Percent change is calculated for prior year amounts reported. The table also shows the number of STOs providing switcher individual scholarships in each period, the number of scholarships and the amount of scholarships paid. Please note that the number of scholarships paid does not equate to the number of students receiving scholarships. Many families seek Arizona Department of Revenue, Office of Economic Research & Analysis, June 2017 19 scholarships from multiple STOs, resulting in one child being counted several times in the scholarship counts. SWITCHER INDIVIDUAL INCOME TAX CREDIT PROGRAM Reporting Year FY2012 FY2013 FY2014 FY2015 FY2016 # of STOs 7 48 49 52 55 Switcher Individual Donations # % donations $ Amount change 34 $23,975 25,713 $19,891,765 NA 32,460 $26,060,133 31.0% 37,673 $30,750,432 18.0% 42,345 $35,522,660 15.5% # of STOs 0 36 46 52 50 Switcher Individual Scholarships # % scholarships $ Amount change 0 $0 4,473 $4,681,192 13,261 $17,561,453 275.1% 16,286 $24,260,454 38.1% 20,976 $28,523,504 17.6% Top 10 STOs by FY2016 Switcher Individual Donations Donations Scholarships Millions $7.1 Arizona Christian School Tuition Organization $5.2 $5.5 Institute for Better Education $4.0 $5.4 Catholic Education Arizona $4.5 $2.5 $2.2 Arizona's Catholic Tuition Support Organization $2.0 $1.6 Arizona Private Education Scholarship Fund Arizona Tuition Connection Jewish Tuition Organization $1.5 $0.7 $1.3 $1.2 Arizona Scholarship Fund $1.0 $1.1 Tuition Organization for Private Schools $1.0 $0.7 Brophy Community Foundation $0.9 $0.7 FY2016 Switcher Individual Donations and Scholarships Table 5 (pg. 24) shows the number, amount and average of the FY2016 switcher individual donations received by STO. In addition, the number and amount of scholarships paid by STO as well as the average scholarships and number of schools receiving scholarships is included. This table also provides the number and amount of switcher individual future reserved scholarships reported by each STO. Arizona Christian School Tuition Organization received the most switcher individual donations in FY2016 of $7.1 million or 20.1% of the total donations. Brophy Community Foundation reported the largest average donation amount of $1,370 for FY2016. Because STOs will receive donations in a fiscal year that will incorporate two tax years, the average may fall between two tax year donation caps. Arizona Department of Revenue, Office of Economic Research & Analysis, June 2017 20 Arizona Christian School Tuition Organization paid the highest amount of switcher individual scholarships ($5.2 million or 18.2% of the total) and awarded the largest number of scholarships (3,986 scholarships or 19.0% of total). There were five STOs that received donations but did not pay scholarships in FY2016. All five were certified during FY2015 or FY2016. STOs must allocate 90% of the tax credit donations to scholarships within two fiscal years after receipt of the donations. The 50 STOs that paid switcher individual scholarships in FY2016 show an overall average scholarship of $1,360. The overall average switcher individual scholarship amounts paid by STOs in FY2016 ranged from $430 to $17,354 which was reported by Life Development Institute Education Fund. Note that the STO average scholarship calculation will include double counting if a student attends two different private schools during the year and an STO awards the student scholarships to both schools. The 50 STOs provided switcher individual scholarships to 321 private schools throughout Arizona. Institute for Better Education provided switcher individual scholarships to a total of 158 private schools. There were 10 STOs that provided scholarships to the required minimum of two private schools. There were seven STOs that provided switcher individual scholarships to only one private school. When verifying an STO’s compliance with the statutory requirement to not limit scholarships to only one school, both the original and switcher scholarship programs are reviewed together. Based on information provided by the STOs they are not considered in violation of statute at this time. Future Reserved Switcher Individual Scholarships STOs also reserved scholarships for specific students for future years. Nineteen STOs reserved an additional $11.2 million in the switcher individual donation program for 7,224 students. Institute for Better Education reported in FY2016 reserving the largest amount of switcher individual donations for future year scholarships of $4.7 million for 3,167 students. It should be noted that a portion of the reserved future year awards reported by STOs may be for scholarships to be awarded in the upcoming academic year. STOs Reporting Future Reserved Switcher Individual Scholarships Greater than $500,000 in FY2016 Millions Institute for Better Education $4.7 Arizona Christian School Tuition Organization $1.5 Arizona's Catholic Tuition Support Organization Arizona Private Education Scholarship Fund Brophy Community Foundation $1.4 $0.9 $0.8 FY2016 Switcher Individual Scholarships by Income Level STOs are required to report the percentage of scholarship dollars that go to families with income of 185% or less of poverty level and the percentage of scholarship dollars that go to families with income ranging from above 185% of poverty level to 342.25% of poverty level. For the 2015-2016 academic year, 342.25% of the federal poverty level for a household of four was $82,997. Arizona Department of Revenue, Office of Economic Research & Analysis, June 2017 21 Overall Share of FY2016 Switcher Individual Scholarships by Family Income 24.6% $7.0m 40.3% $11.5m 35.1% $10.0m Families with income up to 185% of poverty level Families with income from 185% to 342.25% of poverty level Families with income greater than 342.25% of poverty level Table 6 (pg. 26) shows the income level percentages for each STO. Ten organizations gave 100% of their scholarships to children in families with income of 342.25% or less of poverty level. Pappas Kids Schoolhouse Foundation gave 100% of their switcher individual scholarships to children in families with income less than 185% of poverty level. There were 6 STOs that gave more than 50% of their switcher scholarships to children of families with income greater than 342.25% of poverty level. Switcher Individual Credit Program 90/10 Calculation All STOs certified to collect switcher individual donations in FY2016 were evaluated as to their status in relation to the requirement that 90% of all revenue must be paid out in scholarships. From an administrative viewpoint, no STO is expected to pay out 90% of donations it receives in the current year for scholarships the same year. There will always be a lag between revenue received and revenue paid out and it does not mean that an STO with a percentage of less than 90% is in violation of the law. The 90% requirement is evaluated using two different methods: 1) a review of total donations and scholarships over the life of the STO and 2) calculating 90% of credit donations received in a particular fiscal year and tracking the amount to be awarded within the following two fiscal years. The following table shows the lifetime percentage calculated based on total donations and scholarships (method #1) for those STOs certified to receive switcher individual donations in FY2016. Switcher Individual Credit Program Lifetime 90/10 Ratios School Tuition Organization Academic Opportunity of Arizona Ratio 0.0 Alumnus School Tuition Organization Arizona Adventist Scholarships Arizona Christian School Tuition Organization Arizona Community Foundation STO Arizona Education and Scholarship Opportunity Program Arizona Education First Arizona Education Scholarship Foundation Arizona Episcopal Schools Foundation Arizona Independent Schools Scholarship Foundation 0.0 71.4 79.4 33.9 15.5 36.5 44.0 59.8 89.6 School Tuition Organization Arizona International Academy Scholarship Fund Arizona Lutheran Scholarship Organization Arizona Private Education Scholarship Fund Arizona Scholarship Fund Arizona School Choice Trust Arizona Tax Credit Ratio 102.4 Arizona Tuition Connection Arizona Tuition Organization Arizona Waldorf Scholarship Foundation Arizona's Catholic Tuition Support Organization 49.3 86.3 65.6 79.9 Arizona Department of Revenue, Office of Economic Research & Analysis, June 2017 82.7 91.4 72.3 80.0 90.7 22 Switcher Individual Credit Program Lifetime 90/10 Ratios (continued) School Tuition Organization BEST Student Fund Brophy Community Foundation Catholic Education Arizona Chabad Tuition Organization Ratio 84.3 84.4 63.8 92.2 Christ Lutheran School Tuition Organization Christian Scholarship Foundation Christian Scholarship Fund of Arizona Cochise Christian School Tuition Organization 84.3 66.7 53.4 97.7 Dynamite Montessori Foundation Education Liberty Fund Financial Assistance for Independent Schools Funds for Kids Higher Education STO Institute for Better Education Jewish Education Tax Credit Organization Jewish Tuition Organization Lexington Education Foundation 101.2 0.0 81.1 90.2 94.3 86.7 77.2 66.2 0.0 School Tuition Organization Life Development Institute Education Fund Lutheran Education Foundation Montessori Scholarship Organization Northern Arizona Christian School Scholarship Fund Orme Primavera Schools Foundation Pappas Kids Schoolhouse Foundation Pinetop Tuition Support Organization Scholarships for Education Excellence Foundation School Choice Arizona School Tuition Association of Yuma Schools With Heart Foundation Shepherd of the Desert Education Foundation Southern Arizona Foundation for Education Tuition Organization for Private Schools Valley Lutheran Scholarship Organization White Mountain Tuition Support Foundation Yuma’s Education Scholarship Fund for Kids Ratio 81.6 86.3 78.8 64.7 87.0 91.2 76.4 69.3 66.6 89.3 83.4 86.0 78.4 73.4 92.6 71.9 70.8 Nine STOs have lifetime ratios below 50.0 because they are newer STOs; their scholarships should increase significantly within the next year or two. Two STOs have a percentage greater than 100% because scholarships were paid from revenue that was not tax credit donations or due to reserved scholarships for specific students in future years. These percentages are being monitored annually and if STOs with low percentages do not improve, ADOR will review that program to determine the reason. Based on the yearly 90% calculation (method #2), there are currently no STOs in violation of the 90% requirement. Arizona Department of Revenue, Office of Economic Research & Analysis, June 2017 23 Table 5 FY 2016 Switcher Individual Donations and Scholarships by School Tuition Organization School Tuition Organization Academic Opportunity of Arizona Alumnus School Tuition Organization Arizona Adventist Scholarships Arizona Christian School Tuition Organization Arizona Community Foundation School Tuition Organization Arizona Education and Scholarship Opportunity Program Arizona Education First Arizona Education Scholarship Foundation Arizona Episcopal Schools Foundation Arizona Independent Schools Scholarship Foundation Arizona International Academy Scholarship Fund Arizona Lutheran Scholarship Organization Arizona Private Education Scholarship Fund Arizona Scholarship Fund Arizona School Choice Trust Arizona Tax Credit Arizona Tuition Connection Arizona Tuition Organization Arizona Waldorf Scholarship Foundation Arizona's Catholic Tuition Support Organization Best Student Fund Brophy Community Foundation Catholic Education Arizona Chabad Tuition Organization Christ Lutheran School Tuition Organization Christian Scholarship Foundation Christian Scholarship Fund of Arizona Cochise Christian School Tuition Organization Dynamite Montessori Foundation Education Liberty Fund Financial Assistance for Independent Schools Funds For Kids Higher Education STO Institute for Better Education Jewish Education Tax Credit Organization Jewish Tuition Organization Lexington Education Foundation Life Development Institute Education Fund Lutheran Education Foundation # 5 10 110 8,386 149 29 94 426 493 658 37 170 2,267 1,158 682 256 1,807 1,086 120 3,248 121 678 6,825 167 143 104 79 321 50 4 236 12 21 6,516 536 1,496 2 31 46 Donations $ Amount $5,320 $6,465 $86,702 $7,129,953 $133,271 $21,899 $85,716 $363,537 $428,500 $612,254 $26,808 $121,370 $1,959,718 $1,033,062 $572,492 $222,217 $1,464,637 $908,944 $93,486 $2,509,111 $107,083 $929,166 $5,402,658 $132,469 $117,933 $72,691 $60,173 $239,592 $47,750 $2,258 $201,201 $6,700 $14,589 $5,527,929 $448,825 $1,294,809 $2,128 $24,342 $34,699 Arizona Department of Revenue, Office of Economic Research & Analysis, June 2017 Average $1,064 $647 $788 $850 $894 $755 $912 $853 $869 $930 $725 $714 $864 $892 $839 $868 $811 $837 $779 $773 $885 $1,370 $792 $793 $825 $699 $762 $746 $955 $565 $853 $558 $695 $848 $837 $866 $1,064 $785 $754 # 0 0 86 3,986 21 2 11 285 109 140 27 139 875 1,259 469 215 730 499 52 1,520 36 282 3,976 12 42 154 16 192 22 0 41 105 18 3,043 73 454 0 2 13 Scholarships $ Amount Average $0 $0 $40,883 $5,200,477 $79,663 $4,386 $39,240 $134,527 $237,163 $531,308 $37,694 $112,296 $1,552,998 $1,055,771 $1,224,403 $182,601 $662,457 $734,959 $100,792 $2,220,618 $131,400 $698,800 $4,547,989 $127,113 $143,602 $66,291 $29,569 $217,515 $60,137 $0 $231,480 $127,644 $21,449 $3,964,324 $366,319 $1,155,939 $0 $34,707 $22,035 $0 $0 $475 $1,305 $3,793 $2,193 $3,567 $472 $2,176 $3,795 $1,396 $808 $1,775 $839 $2,611 $849 $907 $1,473 $1,938 $1,461 $3,650 $2,478 $1,144 $10,593 $3,419 $430 $1,848 $1,133 $2,734 $0 $5,646 $1,216 $1,192 $1,303 $5,018 $2,546 $0 $17,354 $1,695 # of Schools 0 0 10 118 10 1 2 69 4 3 5 8 95 145 76 41 98 8 1 26 2 16 37 2 1 2 8 12 2 0 3 16 6 158 2 6 0 1 6 Future Reserved Scholarships $ Amount # 0 0 0 984 0 0 0 61 0 0 0 85 640 0 151 8 0 323 0 932 0 302 0 0 0 0 0 29 3 0 45 0 0 3,167 20 0 0 0 0 $0 $0 $0 $1,543,728 $0 $0 $0 $40,037 $0 $0 $0 $56,678 $928,970 $0 $425,100 $19,186 $0 $362,828 $0 $1,369,882 $0 $769,982 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $19,687 $3,296 $0 $131,401 $0 $0 $4,673,634 $207,004 $0 $0 $0 $0 24 Table 5 FY 2016 Switcher Individual Donations and Scholarships by School Tuition Organization School Tuition Organization # Montessori Scholarship Organization Northern Arizona Christian School Scholarship Fund Orme Primavera Schools Foundation Pappas Kids Schoolhouse Foundation Pinetop Tuition Support Organization Scholarships for Educational Excellence Foundation School Choice Arizona School Tuition Association of Yuma Schools With Heart Foundation Shepherd of the Desert Education Foundation Southern Arizona Foundation for Education-SAFE Lutheran The Zisel Tovah Foundation Tuition Organization for Private Schools Valley Lutheran Scholarship Organization White Mountain Tuition Support Foundation Yuma's Education Scholarship Fund for Kids TOTALS Donations $ Amount Average Scholarships $ Amount Average # 209 360 102 407 3 47 276 112 239 85 43 1 1,217 49 168 448 $184,827 $255,055 $91,992 $336,268 $3,192 $36,427 $166,455 $85,022 $212,721 $71,122 $32,405 $500 $1,011,518 $38,934 $140,484 $403,282 $884 $708 $902 $826 $1,064 $775 $603 $759 $890 $837 $754 $500 $831 $795 $836 $900 34 135 14 257 8 23 62 133 34 28 39 0 839 83 69 312 $163,601 $203,343 $73,895 $323,489 $9,097 $18,663 $86,304 $73,721 $176,639 $46,900 $37,764 $0 $686,361 $61,224 $97,259 $366,695 $4,812 $1,506 $5,278 $1,259 $1,137 $811 $1,392 $554 $5,195 $1,675 $968 $0 $818 $738 $1,410 $1,175 42,345 $35,522,660 $839 20,976 $28,523,504 $1,360 Arizona Department of Revenue, Office of Economic Research & Analysis, June 2017 # of Schools 5 5 2 23 1 1 21 9 3 2 2 0 84 2 1 14 Future Reserved Scholarships $ Amount # 0 0 0 0 0 5 35 0 0 0 3 0 286 0 0 145 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $17,670 $13,257 $0 $0 $0 $903 $0 $414,344 $0 $0 $170,461 7,224 $11,168,048 25 Table 6 FY 2016 Switcher Individual Scholarships by Income Level School Tuition Organization Arizona Adventist Scholarships Arizona Christian School Tuition Organization Arizona Community Foundation School Tuition Organization Arizona Education and Scholarship Opportunity Program Arizona Education First Arizona Education Scholarship Foundation Arizona Episcopal Schools Foundation Arizona Independent Schools Scholarship Foundation Arizona International Academy Scholarship Fund Arizona Lutheran Scholarship Organization Arizona Private Education Scholarship Fund Arizona Scholarship Fund Arizona School Choice Trust Arizona Tax Credit Arizona Tuition Connection Arizona Tuition Organization Arizona Waldorf Scholarship Foundation Arizona's Catholic Tuition Support Organization Best Student Fund Brophy Community Foundation Catholic Education Arizona Chabad Tuition Organization Christ Lutheran School Tuition Organization Christian Scholarship Foundation Christian Scholarship Fund of Arizona Cochise Christian School Tuition Organization Dynamite Montessori Foundation Financial Assistance for Independent Schools Funds For Kids Higher Education STO Institute for Better Education Jewish Education Tax Credit Organization Jewish Tuition Organization Life Development Institute Education Fund Switcher Individual Scholarships $40,883 $5,200,477 $79,663 $4,386 $39,240 $134,527 $237,163 $531,308 $37,694 $112,296 $1,552,998 $1,055,771 $1,224,403 $182,601 $662,457 $734,959 $100,792 $2,220,618 $131,400 $698,800 $4,547,989 $127,113 $143,602 $66,291 $29,569 $217,515 $60,137 $231,480 $127,644 $21,449 $3,964,324 $366,319 $1,155,939 $34,707 Arizona Department of Revenue, Office of Economic Research & Analysis, June 2017 % of Scholarships to Families with Income up to 185% of Income from 185% to Poverty Level 342.25% of Poverty Level 55.6% 30.0% 30.1% 31.7% 81.4% 18.6% 0.0% 100.0% 3.4% 9.2% 10.6% 18.7% 40.0% 23.3% 39.9% 25.6% 45.3% 32.6% 49.6% 24.7% 24.4% 33.9% 47.2% 30.1% 62.2% 37.8% 21.8% 25.1% 12.6% 22.7% 25.3% 39.0% 93.9% 0.5% 56.1% 31.2% 97.0% 3.0% 86.6% 8.3% 23.9% 63.5% 85.3% 14.7% 57.3% 37.8% 47.8% 51.6% 89.1% 10.9% 27.9% 46.6% 24.1% 41.1% 19.5% 25.0% did not report 27.5% 38.2% 51.8% 28.0% 30.5% 43.3% 52.6% 32.7% 49.3% 50.7% Remaining % 14.4% 38.2% 0.0% 0.0% 87.4% 70.8% 36.8% 34.5% 22.1% 25.7% 41.7% 22.7% 0.0% 53.1% 64.6% 35.8% 5.6% 12.6% 0.0% 5.1% 12.7% 0.0% 4.9% 0.6% 0.0% 25.4% 34.8% 55.5% 34.4% 20.2% 26.2% 14.7% 0.0% 26 Table 6 FY 2016 Switcher Individual Scholarships by Income Level School Tuition Organization Lutheran Education Foundation Montessori Scholarship Organization Northern Arizona Christian School Scholarship Fund Orme Primavera Schools Foundation Pappas Kids Schoolhouse Foundation Pinetop Tuition Support Organization Scholarships for Educational Excellence Foundation School Choice Arizona School Tuition Association of Yuma Schools With Heart Foundation Shepherd of the Desert Education Foundation Southern Arizona Foundation for Education-SAFE Lutheran Tuition Organization for Private Schools Valley Lutheran Scholarship Organization White Mountain Tuition Support Foundation Yuma's Education Scholarship Fund for Kids TOTALS Switcher Individual Scholarships $22,035 $163,601 $203,343 $73,895 $323,489 $9,097 $18,663 $86,304 $73,721 $176,639 $46,900 $37,764 $686,361 $61,224 $97,259 $366,695 $28,523,504 Arizona Department of Revenue, Office of Economic Research & Analysis, June 2017 % of Scholarships to Families with Income up to 185% of Income from 185% to Poverty Level 342.25% of Poverty Level 65.3% 31.8% 43.6% 56.4% 51.7% 36.6% 37.6% 22.9% 100.0% 0.0% 94.0% 5.5% 56.7% 20.0% 65.6% 24.1% 24.1% 18.7% 57.8% 22.6% 38.6% 36.1% 64.3% 30.0% 32.2% 33.4% 94.0% 6.0% 24.4% 40.1% 24.1% 30.5% 40.8% 36.7% Remaining % 2.9% 0.0% 11.7% 39.5% 0.0% 0.5% 23.3% 10.3% 57.2% 19.6% 25.3% 5.6% 34.4% 0.0% 35.4% 45.4% 22.5% 27 LOW-INCOME CORPORATE INCOME TAX OR INSURANCE PREMIUM TAX CREDIT PROGRAM The low-income corporate income tax credit and insurance premium tax credit (low-income corporate) for contributions to school tuition organizations are governed by A.R.S. $§ 20-224.06, 43-1089.04, 43-1183, and Chapter 15 in Title 43. Fifty-eight STOs were certified to receive corporate donations in FY2016. Statute limits the total amount of low-income corporate tax credit donations that may be made to STOs in a fiscal year, but there is no cap on the tax credit donation amount that can be made by a single corporation. S corporations may make a donation to claim a tax credit on their corporate income taxes or the S corporation may pass the credit through to its individual shareholders. In order for the S corporation to pass the tax credit through to its individual shareholders, the sum of their corporate tax credit donations must be at least $5,000. The low-income corporate scholarship is available to K-12 students and preschool students with disabilities. To qualify for a low-income corporate scholarship the family income cannot exceed 342.25% of the poverty level AND one of the following requirements must be met: attended a public school as a full-time student for at least 90 days of the prior fiscal year or one full semester of the current or prior academic year and then transferred from the public school to a private school; OR is enrolling in a private school kindergarten; OR is enrolling in a private preschool program for students with disabilities; OR is a dependent of a member of the armed forces of the United States who is stationed in Arizona pursuant to military orders; OR received for any prior year a scholarship under one of the above criteria OR from the original individual donation program or the switcher individual donation program if the child continued to attend a private school in subsequent years. Additionally, the amount of a scholarship that can be awarded by an STO to a student is limited. For the 2015-2016 academic year, no more than $5,100 could be awarded by an STO to a student in kindergarten through grade 8 and preschool students with disabilities and no more than $6,400 could be awarded to a student in grades 9 through 12. Low-Income Corporate Donation Approval Donations to STOs for the purpose of receiving the low-income student corporate income tax credit or insurance premium tax credit are limited by statute for each fiscal year and the donations for the tax credit must be preapproved. For FY2007, the first year of the program, the limitation was $10 million. This limitation increases by 20% per year. In FY2016, the limitation was $51,597,804. The following table shows the statutory limitation compared to the donations approved and donations received by the STOs. The donations made by type of taxpayer are also included. Low-Income Corporate Donations Fiscal Year 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 Statutory Limitation $10,000,000 $12,000,000 $14,400,000 $17,280,000 $20,736,000 $24,883,200 $29,859,840 $35,831,808 $42,998,170 $51,597,804 $ Approved $9,740,800 $12,116,000 $10,816,006 $8,121,508 $11,376,351 $19,587,037 $30,041,114 $36,571,808 $43,983,170 $51,847,804 $ Received $9,535,800 $11,996,000 $10,495,506 $8,100,008 $11,324,351 $19,035,987 $29,858,865 $35,831,808 $42,998,170 $51,597,804 # corporations 108 73 98 56 60 72 87 65 59 55 # insurance companies # of S corporations 4 8 11 27 34 36 49 99 There were 282 donations approved and 276 donations received in FY2016 for the low-income corporate tax credit. The 276 donations received came from 203 corporations. Forty-nine of the 203 corporations were insurance companies donating $23.9 million and 99 were S corporations donating $5.2 million. For FY2016 the average low-income corporate donation received by STOs was $186,949. Arizona Department of Revenue, Office of Economic Research & Analysis, June 2017 28 The size of the 276 donations made to the STOs is shown in the following table. Note that there are companies that make donations to multiple STOs and this data summarizes the donations made and are not aggregated by corporation. Low-Income Corporate Donations by Size Donation Size $5,000 or less $5,001 to $10,000 $10,001 to $20,000 $20,001 to $25,000 $25,001 to $50,000 # of donations 43 40 21 15 32 Donation Size $50,001 to $100,000 $100,001 to $250,000 $250,001 to $500,000 $500,001 to $1,000,000 $1,000,001 and over # of donations 40 39 30 11 5 Growth in Low Income Corporate Credit Program Millions Donations Scholarships $60 $50 $40 $30 $20 $10 $0 CY2006 CY2007 *Reporting change CY2008 CY2009 CY2010 2nd half FY2011* FY2012 FY2013 FY2014 FY2015 FY2016 The following table shows the number of STOs collecting low-income corporate donations in each reporting period, the number of donations and the amount of tax credit donations. Percent change is calculated for prior year amounts reported. No percent change is calculated for FY2011 as this is the first fiscal year reporting period. The table also shows the number of STOs providing low-income corporate scholarships in each period, the number of scholarships and the amount of scholarships paid. As with the donations data, no percent change is calculated for FY2011 as this was the first fiscal year reporting period. Please note that the number of scholarships paid does not equate to the number of students receiving scholarships. Many families seek scholarships from multiple STOs, resulting in one child being counted several times in the scholarship counts. Arizona Department of Revenue, Office of Economic Research & Analysis, June 2017 29 LOW-INCOME CORPORATE INCOME TAX CREDIT PROGRAM Reporting Year CY2006 CY2007 CY2008 CY2009 CY2010 9 FY2011 FY2012 FY2013 FY2014 FY2015 FY2016 # of STOs 16 17 15 17 11 15 23 25 23 27 32 Low-Income Corporate Donations # % donations $ Amount change 86 $7,260,800 84 $14,258,000 96.4% 96 $9,122,121 -36.0% 93 $7,285,284 -20.1% 90 $11,123,657 52.7% 105 $11,227,351 133 $19,135,987 70.4% 179 $29,858,865 56.0% 156 $35,831,808 20.0% 154 $42,998,170 20.0% 276 $51,597,869 20.0% # of STOs 3 18 19 19 18 20 21 26 25 27 32 Low-Income Corporate Scholarships # % scholarships $ Amount change 35 $49,380 1,940 $4,597,823 NA 2,979 $7,615,639 65.6% 3,640 $7,849,824 3.1% 4,226 $9,259,078 18.0% 5,559 $9,111,210 5,828 $11,294,842 24.0% 11,096 $17,556,127 55.4% 12,968 $24,148,068 37.5% 16,487 $31,006,416 28.4% 20,076 $43,465,758 40.2% Top 10 STOs by FY2016 Low-Income Corporate Donations Donations Scholarships Arizona Leadership Foundation $16.9 $5.8 $4.8 $5.5 AAA Scholarship Foundation Arizona Tuition Connection Arizona's Catholic Tuition Support Organization Catholic Education Arizona Brophy Community Foundation Arizona School Choice Trust School Choice Arizona Independent Schools Corporate Tax Foundation Arizona Education and Scholarship Opportunity Program Millions $14.4 $2.5 $4.8 $3.1 $4.6 $2.8 $4.0 $3.0 $2.7 $2.3 $1.9 $2.4 $1.4 $0.6 $1.0 $0.6 FY2016 Low-Income Corporate Donations and Scholarships Table 7 (pg. 34) shows the number, amount and average of the FY2016 low-income corporate donations received by STO. In addition, the number and amount of scholarships paid by STO as well as the average scholarships and number of schools receiving scholarships is included. This table also provides the number and amount of low-income corporate future reserved scholarships reported by each STO. Arizona Leadership Foundation received the most low-income corporate donations in FY2016 of $14.4 million or 27.9% of the total donations. Arizona Leadership Foundation also paid the highest amount of 9 There are 6 months that overlap between CY2010 and FY2011. Some of the donations and scholarships showing for FY2011 are already included in CY2010. Arizona Department of Revenue, Office of Economic Research & Analysis, June 2017 30 low-income corporate scholarships ($16.9 million or 38.8% of the total) and awarded the largest number of scholarships (4,395 scholarships or 21.9% of total). The 32 STOs that paid low-income corporate scholarships in FY2016 show an overall average scholarship of $2,165. The overall average low-income corporate scholarship amounts paid by STOs in FY2016 ranged from $200 to $6,400 which was reported by Life Development Institute Education Fund. Note that the STO average scholarship calculation will include double counting if a student attends two different private schools during the year and an STO awards the student scholarships to both schools. The 32 STOs provided low-income corporate scholarships to 242 private schools throughout Arizona. Arizona Leadership Foundation provided low-income corporate scholarships to a total of 130 private schools. There were 8 STOs that provided scholarships to the required minimum of two private schools. There were two STOs that provided scholarships to only one private school (for both corporate programs). Both STOs were notified of their failure to award scholarships to more than one school in FY2016 and steps have been taken to insure the STOs have awarded corporate scholarships to more than one school during FY2017. Future Reserved Low-Income Corporate Scholarships STOs also reserved scholarships for specific students for future years. Sixteen STOs reserved an additional $36.0 million in the low-income corporate donation program for 6,285 students. AAA Scholarship Foundation reported in FY2016 reserving the largest amount of low-income corporate donations for future year scholarships of $16.0 million for 1,275 students. It should be noted that a portion of the reserved future year awards reported by STOs are for scholarships to be awarded in the upcoming academic year. STOs Reporting Future Reserved Low-Income Corporate Scholarships Greater than $1m in FY2016 Millions AAA Scholarship Foundation $16.0 Brophy Community Foundation $5.3 School Choice Arizona $2.9 Arizona's Catholic Tuition Support Organization $2.6 Arizona School Choice Trust $2.5 Corporate Tax Foundation Independent Schools Corporate Tax Foundation Arizona Episcopal Schools Foundation $2.2 $1.6 $1.2 FY2016 Low-Income Corporate Scholarships by Income Level Low-income corporate scholarships are to be awarded to families with income less than 342.25% of poverty level. For the 2015-2016 academic year, 342.25% of the federal poverty level for a household of four was $82,997. STOs are required to report the percentage of scholarship dollars that go to families with income of 185% or less of poverty level and the percentage of scholarship dollars that go to families with income ranging from above 185% of poverty level to 342.25% of poverty level. Arizona Department of Revenue, Office of Economic Research & Analysis, June 2017 31 Overall Share of FY2016 Low-Income Corporate Scholarships by Family Income 39.2% 60.8% $17.0m $26.4m Families with income up to 185% of poverty level Families with income from 185% to 342.25% of poverty level Table 8 (pg. 35) shows the income level percentages for each STO. Three organizations gave 100% of their scholarships to children in families with income of 185% or less of poverty level. Low-Income Corporate Credit Program 90/10 Calculation All STOs certified to collect low-income corporate donations in FY2016 were evaluated as to their status in relation to the requirement that 90% of all revenue must be paid out in scholarships. From an administrative viewpoint, no STO is expected to pay out 90% of donations it receives in the current year for scholarships the same year. There will always be a lag between revenue received and revenue paid out and it does not mean that an STO with a percentage of less than 90% is in violation of the law. The 90% requirement is evaluated using two different methods: 1) a review of total donations and scholarships over the life of the STO and 2) calculating 90% of credit donations received in a particular fiscal year and tracking the amount to be awarded within the following two fiscal years. The following table shows the lifetime percentage calculated based on total donations and scholarships (method #1) for those STOs certified to receive low-income corporate donations in FY2016. Low-Income Corporate Credit Program Lifetime 90/10 Ratios School Tuition Organization AAA Scholarship Foundation Arizona Community Foundation STO Ratio 92.2 61.8 Ratio 74.2 93.8 55.1 School Tuition Organization Arizona Waldorf Scholarship Foundation Arizona's Catholic Tuition Support Organization Brophy Community Foundation Arizona Education and Scholarship Opportunity Program Arizona Education First Arizona Education Scholarship Foundation Arizona Episcopal Schools Foundation Arizona Independent Schools Scholarship Foundation Arizona Leadership Foundation Arizona Private Education Scholarship Fund Arizona Scholarship Fund 66.7 25.0 87.4 67.0 Catholic Education Arizona Christian Scholarship Foundation Corporate Tax Foundation Financial Assistance for Independent Schools 76.8 81.0 81.0 87.5 90.0 94.9 84.8 Foundation for Corporate Tax Credits Funds for Kids Independent Schools Corporate Tax Foundation Institute for Better Education Jewish Education Tax Credit Organization 90.3 90.0 71.4 Arizona School Choice Trust Arizona Tuition Connection 84.8 45.8 Arizona Department of Revenue, Office of Economic Research & Analysis, June 2017 83.2 100.3 112.5 32 Low-Income Corporate Credit Program Lifetime 90/10 Ratios (continued) School Tuition Organization Jewish Tuition Organization Life Development Institute Fund Northern Arizona Christian School Scholarship Fund School Choice Arizona Ratio 52.3 76.8 93.6 School Tuition Organization School Tuition Association of Yuma Tuition Organization for Private Schools Valley Lutheran Scholarship Org. Ratio 91.7 92.7 91.3 90.1 Yuma’s Education Scholarship Fund for Kids 90.2 Two STOs have lifetime ratios below 50.0 because they are newer STOs; their scholarships should increase significantly within the next year or two. Two STOs have a percentage greater than 100% because scholarships were paid from revenue that was not tax credit donations or due to reserved scholarships for specific students in future years. These percentages are being monitored annually and if STOs with low percentages do not improve, ADOR will review that program to determine the reason. Based on the yearly 90% calculation (method #2), there are currently no STOs in violation of the 90% requirement. Arizona Department of Revenue, Office of Economic Research & Analysis, June 2017 33 Table 7 FY 2016 Low-Income Corporate Donations and Scholarships by School Tuition Organization School Tuition Organization AAA Scholarship Foundation Arizona Community Foundation School Tuition Organization Arizona Education and Scholarship Opportunity Program Arizona Education First Arizona Education Scholarship Foundation Arizona Episcopal Schools Foundation Arizona Independent Schools Scholarship Foundation Arizona Leadership Foundation Arizona Private Education Scholarship Fund Arizona Scholarship Fund Arizona School Choice Trust Arizona Tuition Connection Arizona Waldorf Scholarship Foundation Arizona's Catholic Tuition Support Organization Brophy Community Foundation Catholic Education Arizona Christian Scholarship Foundation Corporate Tax Foundation Financial Assistance for Independent Schools Foundation for Corporate Tax Credit Funds for Kids Independent Schools Corporate Tax Foundation Institute for Better Education Jewish Education Tax Credit Organization Jewish Tuition Organization Life Development Institute Education Fund Northern Arizona Christian School Scholarship Fund School Choice Arizona School Tuition Association of Yuma Tuition Organization for Private Schools Valley Lutheran Scholarship Organization Yuma's Education Scholarship Fund for Kids TOTALS Donations $ Amount # 20 3 2 2 8 2 4 27 10 3 18 6 1 36 42 42 1 1 2 3 3 3 5 1 7 1 1 10 7 3 1 1 276 $5,765,691 $545,000 $1,025,000 $15,000 $64,000 $750,000 $720,000 $14,385,000 $485,500 $272,500 $2,688,000 $5,465,000 $20,000 $4,752,000 $3,985,000 $4,571,113 $30,000 $1,000,000 $85,000 $60,000 $65,000 $1,350,000 $380,000 $50,000 $670,000 $25,000 $20,000 $1,889,565 $350,000 $104,500 $5,000 $5,000 $51,597,869 Arizona Department of Revenue, Office of Economic Research & Analysis, June 2017 Average $288,285 $181,667 $512,500 $7,500 $8,000 $375,000 $180,000 $532,778 $48,550 $90,833 $149,333 $910,833 $20,000 $132,000 $94,881 $108,836 $30,000 $1,000,000 $42,500 $20,000 $21,667 $450,000 $76,000 $50,000 $95,714 $25,000 $20,000 $188,957 $50,000 $34,833 $5,000 $5,000 $186,949 # 986 170 347 4 7 118 60 4,395 345 309 830 1,439 16 1,787 1,609 4,051 166 89 21 8 12 115 1,111 43 389 3 129 980 212 231 7 87 20,076 Scholarships $ Amount Average $4,776,299 $644,800 $602,934 $10,000 $15,855 $467,355 $326,700 $16,851,447 $443,644 $229,997 $2,258,856 $2,502,024 $39,153 $3,112,511 $3,005,209 $2,818,542 $33,177 $468,878 $94,863 $38,100 $58,500 $588,200 $699,944 $73,000 $344,862 $19,200 $56,136 $2,368,266 $319,280 $138,231 $4,500 $55,295 $43,465,758 $4,844 $3,793 $1,738 $2,500 $2,265 $3,961 $5,445 $3,834 $1,286 $744 $2,722 $1,739 $2,447 $1,742 $1,868 $696 $200 $5,268 $4,517 $4,763 $4,875 $5,115 $630 $1,698 $887 $6,400 $435 $2,417 $1,506 $598 $643 $636 $2,165 # of Schools 86 42 12 1 3 4 2 130 73 69 75 111 2 26 34 37 2 5 2 2 2 7 93 2 6 1 4 47 9 12 2 8 Future Reserved Scholarships $ Amount # 1,275 0 0 0 1 56 29 0 126 1 851 0 0 1,323 1,309 45 0 89 23 0 0 64 471 23 0 0 0 599 0 0 0 0 6,285 $15,951,325 $0 $0 $0 $145 $1,239,800 $540,000 $0 $182,724 $1,476 $2,472,050 $0 $0 $2,615,309 $5,250,572 $463,849 $0 $2,200,363 $120,000 $0 $0 $1,575,500 $541,322 $17,000 $0 $0 $0 $2,874,224 $0 $0 $0 $0 $36,045,659 34 Table 8 FY 2016 Low-Income Corporate Scholarships by Income Level School Tuition Organization AAA Scholarship Foundation Arizona Community Foundation Student Tuition Organization Arizona Education and Scholarship Opportunity Program Arizona Education First Arizona Education Scholarship Foundation Arizona Episcopal Schools Foundation Arizona Independent Schools Scholarship Foundation Arizona Leadership Foundation Arizona Private Education Scholarship Fund Arizona Scholarship Fund Arizona School Choice Trust Arizona Tuition Connection Arizona Waldorf Scholarship Foundation Arizona's Catholic Tuition Support Organization Brophy Community Foundation Catholic Education Arizona Christian Scholarship Foundation Corporate Tax Foundation Financial Assistance for Independent Schools Foundation for Corporate Tax Credit Funds for Kids Independent Schools Corporate Tax Foundation Institute for Better Education Jewish Education Tax Credit Organization Jewish Tuition Organization Life Development Institute Education Fund Northern Arizona Christian School Scholarship Fund School Choice Arizona School Tuition Association of Yuma Tuition Organization for Private Schools Valley Lutheran Scholarship Organization Yuma's Education Scholarship Fund for Kids TOTALS Arizona Department of Revenue, Office of Economic Research & Analysis, June 2017 Low-Income Corporate Scholarships $4,776,299 $644,800 $602,934 $10,000 $15,855 $467,355 $326,700 $16,851,447 $443,644 $229,997 $2,258,856 $2,502,024 $39,153 $3,112,511 $3,005,209 $2,818,542 $33,177 $468,878 $94,863 $38,100 $58,500 $588,200 $699,944 $73,000 $344,862 $19,200 $56,136 $2,368,266 $319,280 $138,231 $4,500 $55,295 $43,465,758 % of Scholarships to Families with Income up to 185% of Income from 185% to Poverty Level 342.25% of Poverty Level 92.2% 7.8% 65.1% 34.9% 25.0% 75.0% 51.2% 48.8% 41.0% 59.0% 83.8% 16.2% 47.0% 53.0% 54.4% 45.6% 55.7% 44.3% 60.2% 39.8% 75.0% 25.0% 53.8% 46.2% 100.0% 0.0% 58.8% 41.2% 78.0% 22.0% 30.5% 69.5% 50.5% 49.5% 66.5% 33.5% 45.9% 54.1% 25.5% 74.5% 100.0% 0.0% 60.1% 39.9% 100.0% 0.0% 20.2% 79.8% 61.5% 38.5% 66.7% 33.3% 58.6% 41.4% 44.3% 55.7% 45.3% 54.7% 63.5% 36.5% 73.3% 26.7% 68.0% 32.0% 60.8% 39.2% 35 DISABLED/DISPLACED CORPORATE INCOME TAX OR INSURANCE PREMIUM TAX CREDIT PROGRAM The corporate income tax credit and insurance premium tax credit for contributions to school tuition organizations for scholarships for disabled/displaced students (disabled/displaced corporate) are governed by A.R.S. §§ 20-224.7, 43-1089.04, 43-1184 and Chapter 15 in Title 43. Fifty-eight STOs were certified to receive corporate donations in FY2016. Statute limits the total amount of disabled/displaced corporate tax credit donations that may be made to STOs in a fiscal year, but there is no cap on the tax credit donation amount that can be made by a single corporation. S corporations may make a donation to claim a tax credit on their corporate income taxes or the S corporation may pass the credit through to its individual shareholders. In order for the S corporation to pass the tax credit through to its individual shareholders, the sum of their corporate tax credit donations must be at least $5,000. The disabled/displaced corporate scholarship is available to K-12 students and preschool students with disabilities. Students receiving scholarships from the disabled/displaced corporate donations must meet one of the following requirements: student has a current or expired Multidisciplinary Evaluation Team (MET) report or Individual Education Plan (IEP) from an Arizona public school (for preschool and K-12); OR student has a current or expired 504 plan from an Arizona public school (for K-12 only); OR student was placed at one time in the Arizona foster care system (for K-12 only and must be verified by the Arizona Department of Child Safety). Additionally, the total amount of scholarships that a student can be awarded by all STOs is limited to 90% of state aid or the cost of tuition, whichever is less. For the 2015-2016 academic year, the amount of 90% of state aid ranged from $1,971 to $28,871 depending on the student’s grade and additional state aid for a special education category. Disabled/Displaced Corporate Donation Approval Donations to STOs for the purpose of receiving the disabled/displaced student corporate income tax credit or insurance premium tax credit are limited by statute to $5 million in a fiscal year and the donations for the tax credit must be preapproved. The following table shows the statutory limitation compared to the donations approved and donations received by the STOs. The donations made by type of taxpayer are also included. Disabled/Displaced Corporate Donations Fiscal Year 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 Statutory Limitation $5,000,000 $5,000,000 $5,000,000 $5,000,000 $5,000,000 $5,000,000 $5,000,000 $ Approved $1,478,880 $1,079,000 $283,000 $3,580,350 $3,112,745 $5,025,000 $5,325,000 $ Received $1,478,880 $1,029,000 $283,000 $3,505,350 $2,957,765 $5,000,000 $5,000,000 # corporations 2 3 1 6 19 11 13 # insurance companies 4 5 5 8 8 17 12 # of S corporations 13 There were 44 donations approved and 40 donations received in FY2016 for the disabled/displaced corporate tax credit. The 40 donations received came from 38 corporations. Twelve of the 38 corporations were insurance companies donating $3.1 million and 13 were S corporations donating $0.1 million. For FY2016 the average disabled/displaced corporate donation received by STOs was $125,000. The range of the 40 donations made to the STOs is shown in the following table. Note that there are companies that make donations to multiple STOs and this data summarizes the donations made and are not aggregated by corporation. Arizona Department of Revenue, Office of Economic Research & Analysis, June 2017 36 Disabled/Displaced Corporate Donations by Size Donation Size $5,000 or less $5,001 to $10,000 $10,001 to $20,000 $20,001 to $50,000 # donations 9 5 4 5 Donation Size $50,001 to $100,000 $100,001 to $250,000 $250,001 and over # donations 4 6 7 Growth in Disabled/Displaced Corporate Credit Program Millions Donations Scholarships $5 $4 $3 $2 $1 $0 CY2009 CY2010 *Reporting change 2nd half FY2011* FY2012 FY2013 FY2014 FY2015 FY2016 The following table shows the number of STOs collecting disabled/displaced corporate donations in each reporting period, the number of donations and the amount of tax credit donations. Percent change is calculated for prior year amounts reported. No percent change is calculated for FY2011 as this is the first fiscal year reporting period. The table also shows the number of STOs providing disabled/displaced corporate scholarships in each period, the number of scholarships and the amount of scholarships paid. As with the donations data, no percent change is calculated for FY2011 as this was the first fiscal year reporting period. Please note that the number of scholarships paid does not equate to the number of students receiving scholarships. Many families seek scholarships from multiple STOs, resulting in one child being counted several times in the scholarship counts. DISABLED/DISPLACED CORPORATE INCOME TAX CREDIT PROGRAM Reporting Year CY2009 CY2010 10 FY2011 FY2012 FY2013 FY2014 Disabled/Displaced Corporate Donations # of # % STOs donations $ Amount change 4 6 $781,000 5 8 $956,880 22.5% 5 13 $1,204,000 3 6 $283,000 -76.5% 8 17 $3,505,350 1138.6% 11 29 $2,925,845 -16.5% Disabled/Displaced Corporate Scholarships # of # % STOs scholarships $ Amount change 5 114 $625,335 6 166 $715,424 14.4% 5 114 $559,333 5 119 $583,865 4.4% 6 217 $731,231 25.2% 8 346 $1,611,469 120.4% 10 There are 6 months that overlap between CY2010 and FY2011. Some of the donations and scholarships showing for FY2011 are already included in CY2010. Arizona Department of Revenue, Office of Economic Research & Analysis, June 2017 37 DISABLED/DISPLACED CORPORATE INCOME TAX CREDIT PROGRAM (continued) Reporting Year FY2015 FY2016 Disabled/Displaced Corporate Donations # of # % STOs donations $ Amount change 11 12 31 $5,031,920 72.0% 12 40 $5,000,000 -0.6% Disabled/Displaced Corporate Scholarships # of # % STOs scholarships $ Amount change 12 806 $3,581,873 122.3% 14 936 $4,395,384 22.7% Top 5 STOs by FY2016 Disabled/Displaced Corporate Donations Donations Scholarships Millions $1.8 AAA Scholarship Foundation $0.5 $0.7 Arizona Leadership Foundation Arizona Community Foundation School Tuition Organization Arizona Private Education Scholarship Fund Arizona's Catholic Tuition Support Organization $1.8 $0.5 $0.2 $0.5 $0.4 $0.3 $0.2 FY2016 Disabled/Displaced Corporate Donations and Scholarships Table 9 (pg. 41) shows the number, amount and average of the FY2016 disabled/displaced corporate donations received by STO. In addition, the number and amount of scholarships paid by STO as well as the average scholarships and number of schools receiving scholarships is included. This table also provides the number and amount of disabled/displaced corporate future reserved scholarships reported by each STO. AAA Scholarship Foundation received the most disabled/displaced corporate donations in FY2016 of $1.8 million or 35.8% of the total donations. Arizona Leadership Foundation paid the highest amount of disabled/displaced corporate scholarships ($1.8 million or 40.3% of the total) and awarded the largest number of scholarships (257 scholarships or 27.5% of total). The 14 STOs that paid disabled/displaced corporate scholarships in FY2016 show an overall average scholarship of $4,696. The overall average disabled/displaced corporate scholarship amounts paid by STOs in FY2016 ranged from $466 to $8,613 which was reported by Tuition Organization for Private Schools. Note that the STO average scholarship calculation will include double counting if a student attends two different private schools during the year and an STO awards the student scholarships to both schools. The 14 STOs provided disabled/displaced corporate scholarships to 148 private schools throughout Arizona. Institute for Better Education provided disabled/displaced corporate scholarships to a total of 64 private schools. There were two STOs that provided scholarships to the required minimum of two private schools. There was one STO that provided scholarships only one private school (for both corporate programs). The STO was notified of their failure to award scholarships to more than one school in FY2016 and steps have been taken to insure the STO has awarded corporate scholarships to more than one school during FY2017. 11 Total donations reported for FY15 were greater than the cap due to monies received at the end of FY14 that were not deposited until FY15. Arizona Department of Revenue, Office of Economic Research & Analysis, June 2017 38 Future Reserved Disabled/Displaced Corporate Scholarships STOs also reserved scholarships for specific students for future years. Seven STOs reserved an additional $3.1 million in the disabled/displaced corporate donation program for 286 students. AAA Scholarship Foundation reported in FY2016 reserving the largest amount of disabled/displaced corporate donations for future year scholarships of $2.5 million for 95 students. It should be noted that a portion of the reserved future year awards reported by STOs may be for scholarships to be awarded in the upcoming academic year. STOs Reporting Future Reserved Disabled/Displaced Corporate Scholarships in FY2016 Millions AAA Scholarship Foundation $2.5 Institute for Better Education $0.2 Academic Opportunity of Arizona $0.2 Arizona's Catholic Tuition Support Organization $0.1 Financial Assistance for Independent Schools $0.1 Arizona Private Education Scholarship Fund $0.1 FY2016 Disabled/Displaced Corporate Scholarships by Income Level STOs are required to report the percentage of scholarship dollars that go to families with income of 185% or less of poverty level and the percentage of scholarship dollars that go to families with income ranging from above 185% of poverty level to 342.25% of poverty level. For the 2015-2016 academic year, 342.25% of the federal poverty level for a household of four was $82,997. Overall Share of FY2016 Disabled/Displaced Corporate Scholarships by Family Income 25.5% $1.1m 36.0% $1.6m 38.5% $1.7m Families with income up to 185% of poverty level Families with income from 185% to 342.25% of poverty level Families with income greater than 342.25% of poverty level Table 10 (pg. 42) shows the percentages for each STO. Two organizations gave 100% of their scholarships to children in families with income of 342.25% or less of poverty level. There were two STOs that gave Arizona Department of Revenue, Office of Economic Research & Analysis, June 2017 39 more than 50% of their disabled/displaced corporate scholarships to children of families with income greater than 342.25% of poverty level. Disabled/Displaced Corporate Credit Program 90/10 Calculation All STOs certified to collect disabled/displaced corporate donations in FY2016 were evaluated as to their status in relation to the requirement that 90% of all revenue must be paid out in scholarships. From an administrative viewpoint, no STO is expected to pay out 90% of donations it receives in the current year for scholarships the same year. There will always be a lag between revenue received and revenue paid out and it does not mean that an STO with a percentage of less than 90% is in violation of the law. The 90% requirement is evaluated using two different methods: 1) a review of total donations and scholarships over the life of the STO and 2) calculating 90% of credit donations received in a particular fiscal year and tracking the amount to be awarded within the following two fiscal years. The following table shows the lifetime percentage calculated based on total donations and scholarships (method #1) for those STOs certified to receive disabled/displaced corporate donations in FY2016. Disabled/Displaced Corporate Credit Program Lifetime 90/10 Ratios School Tuition Organization AAA Scholarship Foundation Academic Opportunity Arizona Arizona Community Foundation STO Arizona Leadership Foundation Arizona Private Education Scholarship Fund Arizona Scholarship Fund Arizona School Choice Trust Arizona Tuition Connection Ratio 111.8 92.5 53.4 66.3 95.4 86.9 78.1 0.0 School Tuition Organization Arizona's Catholic Tuition Support Organization Dynamite Montessori Foundation Financial Assistance for Independent Schools Institute for Better Education Life Development Institute Education Fund School Choice Arizona Tuition Organization for Private Schools Yuma's Education Scholarship Fund for Kids Ratio 49.7 73.2 88.5 94.0 82.1 85.3 87.1 75.3 Two STOs have lifetime ratios below 50.0 because they are relatively new to the disabled/displaced program; their scholarships should increase significantly within the next year or two. One STO has a percentage greater than 100% because scholarships were paid from revenue that was not tax credit donations or due to reserved scholarships for specific students in future years. These percentages are being monitored annually and if STOs with low percentages do not improve, ADOR will review that program to determine the reason. Based on the yearly 90% calculation (method #2), there are currently no STOs in violation of the 90% requirement. Arizona Department of Revenue, Office of Economic Research & Analysis, June 2017 40 Table 9 FY 2016 Disabled/Displaced Corporate Donations and Scholarships by School Tuition Organization School Tuition Organization AAA Scholarship Foundation Academic Opportunity of Arizona Arizona Community Foundation School Tuition Organization Arizona Leadership Foundation Arizona Private Education Scholarship Fund Arizona Scholarship Fund Arizona School Choice Trust Arizona Tuition Connection Arizona's Catholic Tuition Support Organization Financial Assistance for Independent Schools Institute for Better Education Life Development Institute Education Fund School Choice Arizona Tuition Organization for Private Schools Yuma's Education Scholarship Fund for Kids TOTALS # 5 2 1 8 2 0 1 8 4 1 6 0 0 1 1 40 Donations $ Amount $1,790,000 $256,250 $475,750 $700,000 $450,000 $0 $200,000 $60,000 $320,000 $100,000 $238,000 $0 $0 $250,000 $160,000 $5,000,000 Arizona Department of Revenue, Office of Economic Research & Analysis, June 2017 Average $358,000 $128,125 $475,750 $87,500 $225,000 $0 $200,000 $7,500 $80,000 $100,000 $39,667 $0 $0 $250,000 $160,000 $125,000 # 88 7 49 257 109 19 46 0 71 18 169 7 9 43 44 936 Scholarships $ Amount Average # of Schools $515,815 $5,862 46 $57,090 $8,156 2 $244,784 $4,996 30 $1,773,471 $6,901 50 $424,472 $3,894 31 $8,850 $466 13 $303,201 $6,591 21 $0 $0 0 $237,375 $3,343 21 $63,275 $3,515 2 $171,964 $1,018 64 $35,410 $5,059 1 $68,837 $7,649 5 $370,341 $8,613 10 $120,498 $2,739 7 $4,395,384 $4,696 Future Reserved Scholarships $ Amount # 95 $2,486,724 6 $184,000 0 $0 0 $0 17 $59,341 1 $1,476 0 $0 0 $0 34 $104,868 19 $74,623 114 $187,073 0 $0 0 $0 0 $0 0 $0 286 $3,098,105 41 Table 10 FY 2016 Disabled/Displaced Corporate Scholarships by Income Level School Tuition Organization AAA Scholarship Foundation Academic Opportunity of Arizona Arizona Community Foundation Student Tuition Organization Arizona Leadership Foundation Arizona Private Education Scholarship Fund Arizona Scholarship Fund Arizona School Choice Trust Arizona's Catholic Tuition Support Organization Financial Assistance for Independent Schools Institute for Better Education Life Development Institute Education Fund School Choice Arizona Tuition Organization for Private Schools Yuma's Education Scholarship Fund for Kids TOTALS Disabled/Displaced Corporate Scholarships $515,815 $57,090 $244,784 $1,773,471 $424,472 $8,850 $303,201 $237,375 $63,275 $171,964 $35,410 $68,837 $370,341 $120,498 $4,395,384 Arizona Department of Revenue, Office of Economic Research & Analysis, June 2017 % of Scholarships to Families with Income up to 185% of Income from 185% to Poverty Level 342.25% of Poverty Level 42.0% 18.5% 6.9% 93.1% 41.0% 27.3% 41.6% 37.4% 33.5% 32.2% 33.9% 53.7% 0.0% 100.0% 42.2% 33.9% 7.0% 30.1% 52.4% 30.8% 65.1% 23.6% 44.5% 32.3% 27.8% 42.3% 24.3% 25.2% 36.0% 38.5% Remaining % 39.4% 0.0% 31.6% 21.1% 34.3% 12.4% 0.0% 24.0% 63.0% 16.8% 11.3% 23.1% 29.9% 50.5% 25.4% 42 SCHOLARSHIPS BY PRIVATE SCHOOL STOs provide scholarships from the tax credit donations to students attending qualified Arizona private schools. A qualified school is a preschool that offers services to students with disabilities, and a nongovernmental primary or secondary school (K-12) that is located in this state and that does not discriminate based on race, color, disability, familial status or national origin. All teaching staff and personnel that have unsupervised contact with students are required to be fingerprinted. A qualified school does not include a charter school or any program operated by a charter school. In terms of where the scholarship money went within Arizona, 63.1% of the scholarships and 60.8% of the scholarship money went to schools located in Maricopa County. The following map shows the number of scholarships, the amount of scholarships and the average scholarship paid out by county in FY2016. Table 11 (pg. 44) shows the cities or towns within which scholarship money was received, the number of scholarships, total scholarships and the average scholarship amount. The majority of scholarship money and number of scholarships went to students attending private schools within the City of Phoenix. Private schools located in Phoenix received $39.0 million or 29.9% of the total scholarship amount from all credit programs. The largest total average scholarship of $12,004 was for a school located in Cornville. Arizona Department of Revenue, Office of Economic Research & Analysis, June 2017 43 Table 11 FY 2016 Total Scholarships - All Credit Programs by Location of Private School City/Town Ajo Anthem Anthem/Peoria Avondale Bapchule Benson Bisbee Buckeye Bullhead City Bylas Camp Verde Casa Grande Cave Creek Chandler Chinle Chino Valley Cornville Cottonwood Douglas Flagstaff Florence Fountain Hills Gilbert Gilbert/Goodyear Glendale Globe Goodyear Holbrook Kingman Kykotsmovi Lake Havasu City Laveen Litchfield Park Maricopa Mayer Mesa Nogales Oro Valley Page Paradise Valley Payson Peoria Peridot Phoenix Picacho Pinetop Prescott # $ Amount 3 110 19 589 566 14 16 200 6 34 251 330 430 3,538 9 2 1 657 194 866 8 54 1,989 10 3,809 15 1,587 49 246 82 258 11 336 3 22 2,657 488 539 11 694 136 2,268 48 22,508 25 11 1,694 $2,152 $186,936 $29,093 $719,163 $536,173 $10,683 $45,940 $188,594 $13,766 $22,931 $345,478 $732,643 $718,887 $6,763,120 $2,834 $1,000 $12,004 $891,175 $820,002 $1,090,954 $8,021 $77,778 $5,258,553 $17,210 $4,541,494 $8,155 $1,850,908 $9,331 $162,851 $130,057 $407,938 $6,500 $514,068 $5,301 $155,082 $3,285,687 $734,398 $933,654 $7,131 $2,085,369 $187,224 $3,787,619 $19,687 $39,048,396 $12,747 $19,610 $1,889,594 Arizona Department of Revenue, Office of Economic Research & Analysis, June 2017 Average $717 $1,699 $1,531 $1,221 $947 $763 $2,871 $943 $2,294 $674 $1,376 $2,220 $1,672 $1,912 $315 $500 $12,004 $1,356 $4,227 $1,260 $1,003 $1,440 $2,644 $1,721 $1,192 $544 $1,166 $190 $662 $1,586 $1,581 $591 $1,530 $1,767 $7,049 $1,237 $1,505 $1,732 $648 $3,005 $1,377 $1,670 $410 $1,735 $510 $1,783 $1,115 44 Table 11 FY 2016 Total Scholarships - All Credit Programs by Location of Private School City/Town Queen Creek Rock Point Safford San Carlos San Tan Valley Scottsdale Sedona Show Low Sierra Vista St. Michael Sun Valley Surprise Tempe Tucson Waddell Whiteriver Wickenburg Willcox Winslow Youngtown Yuma # TOTAL 31 63 3 159 206 3,226 15 485 559 599 31 136 1,931 15,517 7 83 269 49 113 16 2,664 73,555 $ Amount $41,047 $193,440 $2,427 $378,624 $274,158 $7,090,571 $49,746 $753,077 $899,536 $408,937 $50,600 $101,552 $2,890,194 $33,763,951 $40,380 $33,874 $316,824 $98,100 $98,578 $43,500 $4,991,508 $130,818,514 Arizona Department of Revenue, Office of Economic Research & Analysis, June 2017 Average $1,324 $3,070 $809 $2,381 $1,331 $2,198 $3,316 $1,553 $1,609 $683 $1,632 $747 $1,497 $2,176 $5,769 $408 $1,178 $2,002 $872 $2,719 $1,874 $1,779 45 FY2016 Scholarships by Private School STOs provided scholarships from all four credit programs to 352 private schools in FY2016. There were 53 private schools that received scholarship money from 11 or more STOs. One private school, Brophy College Preparatory, received scholarships from 21 STOs. Of the 352 private schools, 83 received scholarship money from only one STO. Table 12 (pg. 49) lists the 352 private schools with students that received scholarship money from one or more of the four credit programs in FY2016. In addition, the total average scholarship for all credit programs and the sum of future reserved scholarships for all credit programs are provided. Top 10 Private Schools by Original Individual Scholarships in FY2016 Salpointe Catholic High School $2.1 Northwest Christian School (P) $2.0 Brophy College Preparatory $1.7 Xavier College Preparatory $1.7 Cornerstone Christian Academy/Pusch Ridge $1.6 Seton Catholic High School $1.3 Gilbert Christian Schools $1.2 St. Mary's High School $1.2 Notre Dame Preparatory Valley Christian High School Millions $1.1 $1.0 Original Individual Scholarships – Ten private schools received more than $1.0 million in original individual scholarships in FY2016. Northwest Christian School received the largest number of scholarships totaling 1,179 while Latch School-ACCEL had the largest average scholarship of $17,495. Top 10 Private Schools by Switcher Individual Scholarships in FY2016 Millions Northwest Christian School (P) $0.88 Xavier College Preparatory $0.88 Salpointe Catholic High School $0.79 Cornerstone Christian Academy/Pusch Ridge $0.75 Gilbert Christian Schools Scottsdale Christian Academy $0.62 $0.60 Notre Dame Preparatory $0.58 St. Mary's High School $0.57 Torah Day School of Phoenix $0.55 Brophy College Preparatory $0.54 Switcher Individual Scholarships – Ten private schools received more than $500,000 in switcher individual scholarships in FY2016. Northwest Christian School received the largest number of scholarships totaling 730 while Life Development Institute had the largest average scholarship of $17,354. Arizona Department of Revenue, Office of Economic Research & Analysis, June 2017 46 Top 10 Private Schools by Low-Income Corporate Scholarships in FY2016 San Miguel High School St. John the Evangelist School St. Mary's High School Yuma Catholic High School Salpointe Catholic High School Santa Cruz Catholic School Scottsdale Christian Academy Phoenix Christian Preparatory Schools Brophy College Preparatory Imago Dei Middle School Millions $2.7 $2.3 $2.1 $1.9 $1.7 $1.4 $1.2 $1.2 $1.1 $1.0 Low-Income Corporate Scholarships – Nine private schools received more than $1.0 million in low-income corporate scholarships in FY2016. St. Mary’s High School received the largest number of scholarships totaling 890. Lauren’s Institute for Education School had the largest average scholarship amount of $7,448. Several private schools will show a calculated average scholarship from an individual STO that is greater than the $6,400 low-income scholarship cap. Due to current reporting requirements, the annual scholarship data reported by the STOs contains scholarships paid during the fiscal year which may include scholarships for both the 15/16 and the 16/17 academic years. Since the net number of scholarships reported are by student and do not account for two academic years, the calculated average is distorted. Based on the data provided by the STOs, there were no scholarships awarded greater than the statutory cap. Top 10 Private Schools by Disabled/Displaced Corporate Scholarships in FY2016 Millions Lauren's Institute for Education School (LIFE) Intermountain Academy New Way Learning Academy Autism Academy for Education & Development Pieceful Solutions The Jones-Gordon School Desert Christian Schools Abbie Loveland Tuller Lexis Preparatory School Yuma Lutheran School $1.00 $0.69 $0.35 $0.33 $0.22 $0.10 $0.10 $0.09 $0.07 $0.06 Disabled/Displaced Corporate Scholarships – Two private schools received more than $500,000 in disabled/displaced corporate scholarships in FY2016. Lauren’s Institute for Education School received the largest number of scholarships totaling 76. The largest average scholarship by private school was $22,247 for both Chapel Haven West and Neurologic Music Therapy Services of Arizona. Arizona Department of Revenue, Office of Economic Research & Analysis, June 2017 47 Top 10 Private Schools by Total Average Scholarship in FY2016 Oak Creek Ranch School $12,004 Foundation for Blind Children $11,553 Intermountain Academy $10,611 Latch School - ACCEL $10,191 The Family School $10,103 Neurologic Music Therapy Services of Arizona $9,259 Montessori West Preparatory $8,300 St. Dominic Savio Academy $8,035 Lauren's Institute for Education School (LIFE) $7,741 Montessori Center School $7,544 Total Average Scholarships – The FY2016 total overall average scholarship for all credit programs was $1,779. Five private schools received scholarships from one or more of the credit programs that provided an overall average scholarship greater than $10,000. Top 10 Private Schools with Future Reserved Scholarships in FY2016 Millions Brophy College Preparatory $4.5 Salpointe Catholic High School $3.6 All Saints' Episcopal Day School $3.1 Phoenix Country Day School $2.7 Brophy Loyola Academy Northwest Christian School (P) $1.8 $1.6 St. Matthew School $1.6 St. Ambrose School $1.5 Desert Christian Schools $1.3 Loretto Catholic School $1.3 Future Reserved Scholarships for All Credit Programs – In FY2016 STOs reported future reserved scholarships for students attending 285 private schools. Those students that have not identified a private school to the STO at the time of the report (scholarships for new applicants reserved for following academic year or students that will be transitioning to different middle or high school) are included in the “Undecided” category. Seventeen private schools were reported by STOs to have students with future reserved scholarships greater than $1 million from one or more of the credit programs. Salpointe Catholic High School has the largest number of students with future reserved scholarships at 1,488. It should be noted that a portion of the reserved future year awards reported by STOs may be for scholarships to be awarded in the upcoming academic year. Arizona Department of Revenue, Office of Economic Research & Analysis, June 2017 48 Table 12 FY 2016 Scholarships by Private School Private School 2nd Street Children's School 91st Psalm Christian School Abbie Loveland Tuller Ace Academy ACES (Austin Centers for Exceptional Students) Adobe Adventist Christian School Ahwatukee Foothills Montessori Ajo Calvary Christian Academy Aldea Montessori Aleph Bet Kindergarten Al-Huda School All Saints Catholic School (Our Lady Of The Mountains) All Saints' Episcopal Day School Ambassador Christian Academy American Family Education American Indian Christian School Angels in Autism (AZ Behavior & Autism) Annunciation Catholic School Apache Baptist Academy Apostolic Faith Center Christian Arcadia Christian School Arcadia Montessori Arizona Cultural Academy Arizona International Academy Arizona Language Preparatory Arizona Lutheran Academy Arrowhead Christian Academy Arrowhead Montessori School Ascension Lutheran School Atonement Lutheran School Autism Academy for Education & Development Awakening Seed School AZ Aspire Academy Banner Children's Academy Bayer Private School Beautiful Savior Academy Bella Vista College Preparatory School Bethany Christian School Original Individual Switcher Individual Low-Income Corporate Number $ Amount Number $ Amount Number $ Amount 10 $36,783 8 $12,875 2 $1,450 52 $40,528 77 $73,477 53 $127,170 9 $20,963 6 $13,100 6 $3,350 12 $9,046 8 $1,751 4 $450 0 $0 0 $0 0 $0 6 $8,760 4 $3,000 0 $0 9 $33,082 10 $23,904 1 $500 3 $2,152 0 $0 0 $0 16 $28,619 13 $17,692 6 $9,200 0 $0 8 $47,830 3 $2,750 11 $38,435 7 $28,000 0 $0 68 $170,903 32 $87,933 27 $51,225 181 $367,274 114 $204,150 162 $813,778 24 $29,401 7 $11,646 0 $0 22 $22,317 9 $13,426 0 $0 30 $58,028 8 $32,524 0 $0 0 $0 0 $0 1 $125 158 $198,442 98 $136,324 50 $40,539 15 $13,112 10 $6,510 8 $3,250 0 $0 4 $11,100 12 $32,400 1 $950 0 $0 0 $0 6 $21,600 7 $23,350 0 $0 106 $268,846 81 $213,909 92 $217,500 7 $18,900 7 $12,985 0 $0 0 $0 0 $0 0 $0 170 $310,226 88 $101,699 48 $61,179 153 $186,898 100 $87,541 85 $74,132 4 $8,578 2 $2,050 0 $0 19 $37,944 28 $25,029 0 $0 90 $128,093 51 $66,931 16 $14,919 18 $42,082 25 $22,482 13 $59,210 22 $87,048 14 $34,987 3 $7,150 3 $3,355 3 $2,784 0 $0 2 $11,025 1 $6,995 0 $0 24 $32,464 11 $14,699 4 $4,500 8 $9,242 9 $5,481 2 $1,525 16 $50,185 12 $52,942 5 $21,900 191 $386,353 153 $255,132 72 $128,439 Arizona Department of Revenue, Office of Economic Research & Analysis, June 2017 Disabled/Displaced Sum of All Future Corporate Total Average Reserved Scholarship Number $ Amount Number $ Amount 0 $0 $2,555 19 $39,739 0 $0 $1,325 76 $181,675 19 $85,021 $3,061 18 $80,294 1 $1,500 $510 3 $3,804 0 $0 $0 2 $25,338 0 $0 $1,176 0 $0 0 $0 $2,874 8 $35,631 0 $0 $717 2 $300 0 $0 $1,586 0 $0 0 $0 $4,598 1 $3,000 0 $0 $3,691 0 $0 0 $0 $2,441 98 $253,712 0 $0 $3,031 182 $3,106,140 0 $0 $1,324 21 $34,314 0 $0 $1,153 12 $11,743 0 $0 $2,383 0 $0 0 $0 $125 0 $0 6 $10,485 $1,237 48 $122,822 1 $58 $674 7 $1,440 0 $0 $2,719 12 $32,400 0 $0 $950 0 $0 0 $0 $3,458 0 $0 0 $0 $2,510 88 $250,375 0 $0 $2,278 0 $0 0 $0 $0 2 $948 1 $4,159 $1,555 69 $117,402 1 $1,000 $1,031 71 $145,444 0 $0 $1,771 1 $25 0 $0 $1,340 5 $1,006 0 $0 $1,337 27 $42,841 31 $326,859 $5,180 22 $683,610 0 $0 $3,312 8 $27,662 5 $15,902 $2,004 5 $21,995 3 $11,936 $4,993 1 $68,625 0 $0 $1,325 16 $25,285 0 $0 $855 4 $6,842 2 $7,265 $3,780 29 $108,085 8 $6,000 $1,830 143 $316,371 49 Table 12 FY 2016 Scholarships by Private School Private School Beyond Autism Big Dreams Preschool & Kindergarten Black Mountain Science Academy Blessed Sacrament Kindergarten Bourgade Catholic High School Breakthrough Academy Bridges Preschool & Kindergarten (G) Brightmont Academy Brophy College Preparatory Brophy Loyola Academy Calvary Baptist School Calvary Chapel Christian School Calvary Christian Academy (LH) Calvary Christian School Calvary Shadows Assembly of God Camelback Christian School Camelback Desert School Camp Verde United Christian School Carden Christian Academy Central Casa del Nino Bilingual Montessori School Casa Ninos School of Montessori Casas Christian School Castlehill Country Day School Cave Creek Montessori Cedar Tree Montessori Chandler Christian Academy Chandler Christian School Chaparral Christian Preschool & Kindergarten Chapel Haven West Cheder Lubavitch Chinle Adventist Elementary Christ Church School Christ Lutheran School Christ the King Academy Christ the King Catholic School Christian Academy of Prescott Christ's Greenfield Lutheran School Chrysalis Academy Original Individual Switcher Individual Low-Income Corporate Number $ Amount Number $ Amount Number $ Amount 1 $1,289 0 $0 0 $0 0 $0 0 $0 0 $0 6 $22,480 6 $16,703 0 $0 1 $975 2 $13,675 1 $1,400 523 $852,163 388 $479,972 444 $764,868 5 $16,112 4 $13,263 0 $0 3 $2,730 2 $1,790 1 $500 3 $15,058 1 $7,348 0 $0 526 $1,736,570 201 $538,697 201 $1,061,482 0 $0 71 $317,250 71 $359,550 31 $26,827 15 $7,929 39 $52,550 147 $207,843 131 $130,173 47 $39,511 110 $191,215 80 $110,568 6 $19,155 0 $0 0 $0 0 $0 6 $3,194 9 $4,961 0 $0 12 $21,364 12 $12,874 0 $0 6 $7,856 9 $7,955 0 $0 117 $235,457 68 $88,681 66 $21,341 42 $31,206 25 $15,278 15 $20,250 13 $15,172 15 $15,686 6 $15,950 2 $3,400 1 $3,306 0 $0 248 $497,700 215 $220,416 153 $177,699 37 $81,418 23 $45,978 2 $3,000 10 $52,680 6 $17,800 0 $0 0 $0 1 $50 1 $4,460 113 $249,764 77 $144,254 0 $0 0 $0 0 $0 22 $42,200 6 $19,220 7 $9,075 0 $0 2 $1,474 1 $968 0 $0 16 $98,982 15 $95,643 12 $9,800 9 $2,834 0 $0 0 $0 29 $54,316 18 $45,996 3 $13,377 319 $492,493 199 $327,734 21 $34,953 0 $0 0 $0 0 $0 222 $266,791 137 $125,367 103 $54,990 136 $128,629 135 $75,589 119 $86,201 247 $490,101 160 $231,630 30 $55,250 8 $26,280 9 $11,095 1 $411 Arizona Department of Revenue, Office of Economic Research & Analysis, June 2017 Disabled/Displaced Sum of All Future Corporate Total Average Reserved Scholarship Number $ Amount Number $ Amount 0 $0 $1,289 0 $0 0 $0 $0 1 $945 0 $0 $3,265 0 $0 0 $0 $4,013 0 $0 12 $51,830 $1,572 285 $644,567 5 $17,549 $3,352 8 $63,813 0 $0 $837 0 $0 1 $3,628 $5,207 4 $48,840 0 $0 $3,596 851 $4,475,762 0 $0 $4,766 124 $1,794,182 2 $5,270 $1,064 3 $2,134 1 $880 $1,161 164 $185,201 0 $0 $1,637 90 $186,569 0 $0 $0 2 $628 0 $0 $544 1 $500 0 $0 $1,427 6 $4,183 0 $0 $1,054 5 $6,345 0 $0 $1,376 10 $4,279 7 $11,271 $876 49 $79,175 0 $0 $1,377 0 $0 0 $0 $2,235 2 $5,012 21 $23,370 $1,443 297 $465,961 0 $0 $2,103 47 $96,896 0 $0 $4,405 0 $0 1 $1,975 $2,162 1 $10,400 0 $0 $2,074 73 $132,552 0 $0 $1,918 0 $0 0 $0 $2,177 3 $917 1 $22,247 $6,172 0 $0 0 $0 $4,754 5 $14,700 0 $0 $315 0 $0 0 $0 $2,274 14 $21,677 2 $2,479 $1,585 155 $207,585 0 $0 $0 1 $931 1 $500 $967 180 $476,679 4 $4,069 $747 73 $39,166 1 $5 $1,774 176 $282,850 8 $59,349 $3,736 4 $77,590 50 Table 12 FY 2016 Scholarships by Private School Original Individual Switcher Individual Low-Income Corporate Private School Number $ Amount Number $ Amount Number $ Amount Clear View Academy 0 $0 0 $0 0 $0 Cochise SDA Christian School 4 $1,009 2 $4,000 4 $19,125 Community Montessori 2 $3,375 4 $27,636 0 $0 Congregation Anshei Israel Preschool & Kindergarten 7 $350 7 $18,645 5 $1,625 Cornerstone Christian Academy/Pusch Ridge 749 $1,605,578 372 $754,452 210 $310,689 Creative Castle Preschool & Kindergarten 10 $13,923 9 $15,170 0 $0 Creo School 46 $118,979 36 $54,658 16 $63,620 Cross of Glory Lutheran Elementary School 28 $37,828 24 $20,268 4 $8,448 Cross Roads Preschool & Kindergarten 1 $664 0 $0 0 $0 Crossroads Community School (Hope Christian Academy) 96 $176,412 62 $108,050 7 $14,000 Darkaynu (Tucson Jewish Montessori) 0 $0 0 $0 0 $0 Dayspring Kindergarten 17 $70,575 17 $23,289 0 $0 Desert Christian Schools 352 $813,715 220 $367,865 187 $388,755 Desert Garden Montessori 125 $230,597 93 $109,067 46 $148,856 Desert Jewish Academy 27 $76,599 21 $63,721 14 $12,381 Desert Sky Montessori 1 $6,950 1 $50 0 $0 Desert Sun Child Development Center 21 $46,374 20 $29,855 5 $9,000 Desert Valley Christian School 17 $23,501 5 $2,597 5 $9,872 Desert View Learning Center 28 $123,245 16 $68,677 4 $5,950 Desert Voices Oral Learning Center 6 $45,732 6 $37,725 0 $0 Dobson Montessori School 75 $120,451 32 $24,115 9 $23,050 Downtown Community School 2 $2,950 2 $1,640 0 $0 Dynamite Montessori School 28 $83,712 21 $59,906 0 $0 East Fork Lutheran School 62 $26,748 21 $7,126 0 $0 El Dorado Private School 14 $31,884 7 $20,519 3 $3,900 Emmanuel Christian Academy 114 $103,981 82 $31,848 49 $23,385 Emmanuel Lutheran School 95 $120,809 55 $49,082 11 $21,528 Emmaus Lutheran School 54 $48,530 21 $18,070 14 $10,646 Esther B Feldman Kindergarten 1 $984 0 $0 0 $0 Faith Christian Academy (FH) 27 $24,666 7 $5,950 20 $47,162 Faith Christian School 91 $138,053 48 $41,755 9 $15,850 Faith Community Academy 85 $118,627 76 $55,507 50 $54,655 Faith Lutheran School (M) 83 $120,442 80 $33,360 43 $36,020 Family Life Academy 103 $143,443 49 $48,864 48 $71,085 Family of Christ Learning Center 14 $21,518 12 $12,745 0 $0 First Baptist Christian Academy (SV) 112 $149,508 88 $64,691 10 $15,200 First Southern Christian School 71 $110,005 41 $14,027 15 $14,407 Flagstaff Community Christian School 146 $178,322 141 $119,067 123 $180,509 Arizona Department of Revenue, Office of Economic Research & Analysis, June 2017 Disabled/Displaced Sum of All Future Corporate Total Average Reserved Scholarship Number $ Amount Number $ Amount 0 $0 $0 10 $2,791 6 $21,805 $2,871 11 $141,153 0 $0 $5,168 1 $360 0 $0 $1,085 30 $115,715 4 $5,503 $2,005 590 $1,024,366 0 $0 $1,531 3 $2,307 0 $0 $2,421 0 $0 2 $3,789 $1,213 12 $15,680 0 $0 $664 1 $1,781 2 $4,387 $1,813 99 $235,457 0 $0 $0 4 $6,874 0 $0 $2,761 0 $0 29 $95,313 $2,114 557 $1,328,672 6 $10,195 $1,847 10 $17,722 3 $11,197 $2,522 0 $0 0 $0 $3,500 0 $0 0 $0 $1,853 0 $0 0 $0 $1,332 10 $42,411 0 $0 $4,122 0 $0 6 $25,500 $6,053 0 $0 5 $20,342 $1,553 33 $76,850 0 $0 $1,148 0 $0 0 $0 $2,931 17 $16,354 0 $0 $408 14 $3,975 1 $12,265 $2,743 14 $34,927 1 $3,637 $662 66 $35,719 0 $0 $1,189 44 $80,004 1 $50 $859 15 $15,026 0 $0 $984 1 $979 0 $0 $1,440 22 $21,394 1 $500 $1,316 18 $37,073 5 $4,322 $1,079 164 $346,991 1 $500 $919 46 $20,186 2 $1,500 $1,311 93 $105,999 0 $0 $1,318 6 $5,536 0 $0 $1,092 30 $28,762 5 $3,171 $1,073 34 $40,201 3 $10,619 $1,166 156 $358,609 51 Table 12 FY 2016 Scholarships by Private School Private School Florence Baptist Academy Foundation for Blind Children Fourteen Six Christian Academy Freedom Christian Academy Gary K. Herberger Young Scholar's Academy Gateway Academy Gateway Baptist Academy (G) Gethsemane Lutheran School Gilbert Christian Schools Glendale Christian Academy Glenview Adventist Academy Good Earth Montessori Gospel Outreach Christian School Grace Christian Academy Grace Community Christian School Grace Fellowship Academy Grace Lutheran School GracePointe Christian Academy (Chapel in the Hills) Graysmark Academy Green Fields Country Day School Guiding Light Christian Educational Center (GLCP) Hand in Hand Christian School Harvest Kidz School Heritage Montesori Holbrook Adventist Indian School Holy Cross Evangelical Lutheran School Holy Trinity Academy Hopi Mission School Imago Dei Middle School Immaculate Conception School Immaculate Heart Academy Immaculate Heart High School Inspire Kids Montessori Intermountain Academy International School of Arizona International School of Tucson Ironwood Hill School Joanne Todd Christian School Original Individual Switcher Individual Low-Income Corporate Number $ Amount Number $ Amount Number $ Amount 5 $6,100 2 $921 1 $1,000 2 $19,825 2 $22,668 1 $5,000 12 $7,463 3 $1,592 0 $0 54 $44,657 53 $32,530 94 $170,583 25 $54,578 16 $21,557 7 $26,151 2 $3,758 1 $2,937 0 $0 59 $44,223 47 $30,719 21 $9,068 136 $184,190 97 $125,555 3 $6,901 554 $1,189,216 317 $619,573 139 $334,457 63 $64,685 43 $23,043 68 $75,142 62 $47,540 18 $11,791 28 $116,755 0 $0 1 $231 0 $0 13 $1,770 2 $2,116 0 $0 12 $9,580 2 $1,102 0 $0 124 $225,904 82 $134,877 15 $89,000 75 $85,752 59 $46,492 65 $55,784 103 $99,816 45 $32,574 9 $17,966 17 $16,685 26 $12,628 12 $26,200 2 $5,184 1 $117 0 $0 73 $173,801 55 $119,783 55 $144,596 13 $24,688 13 $8,912 3 $5,330 6 $4,016 5 $4,017 6 $5,842 1 $354 3 $2,420 0 $0 0 $0 7 $19,865 0 $0 46 $8,827 3 $504 0 $0 7 $5,975 2 $2,459 1 $500 6 $13,419 9 $12,890 0 $0 31 $85,396 49 $35,041 2 $9,620 69 $251,073 14 $28,627 193 $959,650 149 $134,091 96 $68,992 173 $261,615 152 $227,995 90 $101,160 121 $165,259 51 $132,325 27 $86,864 30 $84,480 3 $20,263 1 $1,150 0 $0 4 $8,600 13 $9,200 32 $233,800 33 $157,408 29 $28,788 2 $7,100 50 $77,656 39 $48,104 68 $217,511 0 $0 0 $0 0 $0 30 $58,382 19 $39,718 0 $0 Arizona Department of Revenue, Office of Economic Research & Analysis, June 2017 Disabled/Displaced Sum of All Future Corporate Total Average Reserved Scholarship Number $ Amount Number $ Amount 0 $0 $1,003 1 $1,000 4 $56,487 $11,553 0 $0 0 $0 $604 16 $3,241 5 $26,389 $1,331 85 $249,579 1 $3,973 $2,169 23 $22,100 2 $17,279 $4,795 3 $58,961 0 $0 $661 26 $23,201 0 $0 $1,342 102 $167,385 7 $13,390 $2,121 375 $1,006,979 0 $0 $936 79 $125,929 0 $0 $1,630 36 $422,354 0 $0 $231 1 $479 0 $0 $259 0 $0 0 $0 $763 2 $800 0 $0 $2,035 58 $206,772 1 $566 $943 18 $71,384 0 $0 $958 31 $38,421 1 $500 $1,000 28 $140,136 0 $0 $1,767 16 $8,101 4 $15,450 $2,426 37 $101,912 0 $0 $1,342 9 $9,000 0 $0 $816 3 $2,590 0 $0 $694 0 $0 0 $0 $2,838 0 $0 0 $0 $190 0 $0 0 $0 $893 2 $725 0 $0 $1,754 7 $4,433 0 $0 $1,586 6 $25,460 0 $0 $4,490 2 $6,038 8 $18,134 $1,133 176 $145,896 8 $19,125 $1,384 254 $615,482 10 $14,147 $2,693 62 $215,459 0 $0 $5,353 2 $3,306 40 $692,790 $10,611 67 $81,805 0 $0 $3,020 10 $5,501 3 $2,250 $2,160 116 $258,863 1 $3,147 $3,147 0 $0 0 $0 $2,002 57 $99,996 52 Table 12 FY 2016 Scholarships by Private School Private School Joy Christian School Joyful Beginnings Academy KASL Academy for Deaf and Hard of Hearing Kingdom Preparatory Academy Kino Learning Center Lamb's Gate Christian School Latch School - ACCEL Lauren's Institute for Education School (LIFE) Lexington Life Academy Lexis Preparatory School Life Academy Life Christian Academy Life Development Institute Logos Christian Academy Loretto Catholic School Lourdes Catholic School Magical Journey Learning Center Maranatha Christian Academy Maricopa Village Christian School Mesa Christian Academy Mesa Montessori Mis Manos Montesorri School Montessori Center School Montessori Educare Academy Montessori in the Park Montessori International School Montessori Kingdom of Learning Montessori Learning Center Montessori Matters Montessori Preparatory Academy Montessori West Preparatory Most Holy Trinity Catholic School Mount Calvary Lutheran School Mountain Christian School Navajo Evangelical Lutheran Mission School Neurologic Music Therapy Services of Arizona New Covenant Lutheran Preschool & Kindergarten New Vistas Center for Education Original Individual Switcher Individual Low-Income Corporate Number $ Amount Number $ Amount Number $ Amount 425 $566,707 278 $265,815 285 $564,304 21 $30,539 16 $29,947 0 $0 2 $4,690 1 $2,390 3 $15,300 5 $644 5 $100 0 $0 43 $51,591 34 $25,642 34 $59,985 9 $17,644 9 $8,768 1 $3,825 5 $87,478 5 $32,267 2 $11,500 34 $59,354 28 $28,688 54 $402,200 0 $0 0 $0 18 $93,600 35 $97,478 26 $96,696 5 $20,340 0 $0 0 $0 1 $4,600 12 $29,142 11 $15,158 6 $5,420 6 $26,283 2 $34,707 3 $19,200 24 $27,387 12 $12,648 41 $146,232 46 $141,127 19 $60,625 129 $618,250 96 $140,773 29 $48,721 79 $204,276 24 $90,158 23 $60,198 0 $0 2 $580 1 $93 1 $3,399 11 $6,500 0 $0 0 $0 16 $12,554 3 $5,699 5 $11,250 4 $15,792 4 $12,607 0 $0 0 $0 0 $0 0 $0 0 $0 8 $60,350 0 $0 6 $18,710 6 $3,020 0 $0 65 $137,957 0 $0 0 $0 53 $96,243 42 $64,504 42 $168,087 33 $132,050 0 $0 0 $0 4 $4,074 4 $3,941 0 $0 0 $0 13 $39,150 0 $0 6 $13,766 0 $0 0 $0 0 $0 2 $16,600 0 $0 86 $134,759 63 $89,987 159 $429,773 10 $19,630 15 $7,371 6 $13,559 96 $159,168 58 $57,065 9 $36,275 40 $133,114 23 $60,325 0 $0 2 $20,351 2 $12,457 1 $500 19 $28,365 21 $19,238 0 $0 47 $172,332 29 $54,296 2 $2,100 Arizona Department of Revenue, Office of Economic Research & Analysis, June 2017 Disabled/Displaced Sum of All Future Corporate Total Average Reserved Scholarship Number $ Amount Number $ Amount 20 $39,021 $1,424 159 $386,707 0 $0 $1,635 2 $2,729 1 $18,000 $5,769 0 $0 0 $0 $74 0 $0 8 $19,356 $1,316 70 $85,539 2 $750 $1,476 16 $30,888 5 $41,997 $10,191 0 $0 76 $996,100 $7,741 13 $194,443 3 $47,036 $6,697 7 $367,637 20 $66,556 $3,268 46 $153,667 0 $0 $4,600 0 $0 0 $0 $1,714 10 $7,438 7 $35,410 $6,422 0 $0 0 $0 $2,419 41 $303,331 0 $0 $4,227 136 $1,315,394 0 $0 $1,930 142 $450,465 1 $750 $3,148 45 $90,714 0 $0 $1,018 6 $13,984 0 $0 $591 0 $0 0 $0 $1,229 12 $39,498 0 $0 $3,550 0 $0 0 $0 $0 3 $9,662 0 $0 $7,544 0 $0 0 $0 $1,811 0 $0 0 $0 $2,122 0 $0 4 $12,887 $2,424 1 $900 0 $0 $4,002 0 $0 0 $0 $1,002 0 $0 0 $0 $3,012 0 $0 0 $0 $2,294 0 $0 0 $0 $8,300 0 $0 1 $3,628 $2,130 160 $1,092,889 0 $0 $1,308 13 $84,417 1 $3,637 $1,562 24 $28,622 0 $0 $3,070 0 $0 1 $22,247 $9,259 0 $0 1 $1,521 $1,198 1 $2,930 0 $0 $2,932 70 $167,522 53 Table 12 FY 2016 Scholarships by Private School Private School New Way Learning Academy Noah's Ark Preschool & Kindergarten Noor Academy of Arizona North Phoenix Baptist Kindergarten North Valley Christian Academy (Cross of Christ) Northland Christian School Northminster Christian School Northwest Christian School (P) Notre Dame Preparatory Oak Creek Ranch School On-Track Academy Our Lady of Mt. Carmel School Our Lady of Perpetual Help Catholic School (G) Our Lady of Perpetual Help Catholic School (S) Our Lady of Sorrows Academy Our Lady of the Lake Our Mother of Sorrows Catholic School Our Saviour Lutheran School Page Christian School Palm Valley Montessori Palms Christian School Paradise for Tots Christian Kindergarten Paradise Valley Christian Preparatory Pardes Jewish Day School Parkway Children's School of Excellence Pathways School Payson Community Christian School Peridot Lutheran Elementary Phoenix Christian Academy Phoenix Christian Preparatory Schools Phoenix Christian School K-8 Phoenix Country Day School Phoenix Hebrew Academy Pieceful Solutions Pilgrim Lutheran School Pleasantview Christian Elementary Prescott Adventist Christian School Primavera School Original Individual Switcher Individual Low-Income Corporate Number $ Amount Number $ Amount Number $ Amount 94 $316,720 101 $395,341 56 $251,013 8 $6,343 10 $5,774 0 $0 64 $139,585 51 $138,483 17 $11,000 7 $14,413 9 $8,641 0 $0 69 $110,196 38 $67,740 3 $9,000 22 $21,507 19 $8,430 6 $5,250 24 $45,219 28 $26,992 18 $13,935 1,179 $2,017,139 730 $883,914 228 $587,397 422 $1,075,439 287 $578,992 117 $269,927 1 $12,004 0 $0 0 $0 0 $0 0 $0 1 $1,250 283 $352,141 194 $180,152 147 $57,240 364 $428,663 261 $165,069 394 $338,536 254 $376,825 139 $189,880 98 $34,245 27 $23,685 28 $40,335 1 $500 9 $26,839 9 $19,836 9 $90 289 $246,277 152 $101,589 273 $367,501 4 $1,265 2 $40 0 $0 8 $5,211 3 $1,920 0 $0 125 $124,424 91 $72,001 55 $244,800 54 $35,720 38 $13,461 12 $25,200 1 $142 0 $0 0 $0 239 $437,022 149 $190,313 17 $26,500 157 $876,287 112 $302,635 77 $72,553 5 $5,447 5 $3,549 0 $0 5 $12,777 3 $12,509 0 $0 71 $97,515 50 $59,483 15 $30,227 30 $3,305 14 $10,022 4 $6,360 0 $0 0 $0 0 $0 267 $288,750 154 $150,723 293 $1,162,014 73 $120,641 53 $72,804 4 $13,820 207 $489,571 137 $350,022 173 $789,380 126 $344,494 116 $291,720 88 $82,043 21 $31,925 14 $13,052 8 $28,900 28 $22,239 19 $12,306 1 $50 0 $0 3 $6,010 8 $27,500 10 $4,182 3 $1,382 3 $7,000 42 $113,830 15 $42,260 11 $25,275 Arizona Department of Revenue, Office of Economic Research & Analysis, June 2017 Disabled/Displaced Sum of All Future Corporate Total Average Reserved Scholarship Number $ Amount Number $ Amount 71 $347,374 $4,070 222 $891,857 0 $0 $673 2 $1,567 0 $0 $2,190 2 $18,600 0 $0 $1,441 11 $7,523 0 $0 $1,699 20 $50,168 0 $0 $749 22 $6,339 3 $6,071 $1,263 39 $144,874 10 $21,957 $1,635 933 $1,600,963 2 $1,500 $2,326 247 $525,617 0 $0 $12,004 0 $0 0 $0 $1,250 0 $0 0 $0 $945 136 $268,475 7 $12,956 $921 169 $242,432 0 $0 $1,224 123 $128,407 0 $0 $1,152 63 $89,223 0 $0 $1,732 0 $0 15 $23,046 $1,013 316 $443,928 0 $0 $218 0 $0 0 $0 $648 3 $1,788 0 $0 $1,628 2 $2,530 3 $6,087 $752 9 $4,598 0 $0 $142 1 $1,010 4 $5,751 $1,613 129 $220,242 0 $0 $3,617 9 $24,090 0 $0 $900 3 $2,885 2 $5,926 $3,121 1 $2,000 0 $0 $1,377 53 $58,161 0 $0 $410 52 $44,552 0 $0 $0 5 $4,275 10 $13,761 $2,231 233 $1,043,942 5 $2,867 $1,557 53 $116,715 0 $0 $3,151 152 $2,718,525 0 $0 $2,177 14 $42,000 25 $217,475 $4,285 5 $28,832 0 $0 $721 4 $3,404 1 $3,637 $3,096 21 $85,898 0 $0 $785 0 $0 0 $0 $2,667 25 $30,238 54 Table 12 FY 2016 Scholarships by Private School Private School Promiseland Christian Preschool Quality Interactive Montessori Queen of Peace Catholic School Rancho Solano Schools Red Mountain Montessori Academy Red Sands Christian School Redeemer Christian School (Stapley) Redeemer Lutheran School Resurrection Lutheran Child Development Center Risen Savior Lutheran School River of Life Christian School Running River School S A R R C Community School Sacred Heart Catholic School Sacred Heart School Saguaro Hills Adventist Christian School Saguaro Hills Christian School Salpointe Catholic High School San Francisco de Asis Catholic School San Miguel High School San Xavier Mission School Santa Cruz Catholic School Satori Scottsdale Christian Academy Sedona Sky Academy Seton Catholic High School Shearim Torah High School Sheila's Christian Academy "Minds in Motion" Shepherd of the Desert Lutheran School Sierra Academy of Scottsdale Sonshine Christian School Sonshine Preschool Southwest Christian School Southwest Indian School Southwestern Christian School Spirit of Hope Montessori Spondeo Montessori Ss. Peter and Paul Catholic School Original Individual Switcher Individual Low-Income Corporate Number $ Amount Number $ Amount Number $ Amount 0 $0 0 $0 0 $0 27 $53,910 18 $44,889 8 $20,200 238 $175,271 164 $75,962 263 $239,832 68 $191,029 41 $99,833 0 $0 1 $4,825 1 $50 0 $0 23 $12,996 30 $18,249 60 $67,332 71 $67,804 40 $42,976 39 $35,276 88 $127,110 60 $61,357 14 $34,600 24 $71,980 26 $30,320 0 $0 17 $25,941 17 $7,053 0 $0 31 $33,240 15 $6,574 44 $121,250 5 $15,985 0 $0 1 $1,250 3 $21,900 2 $3,000 0 $0 99 $93,770 62 $59,500 103 $166,325 121 $310,905 78 $198,520 74 $37,970 22 $24,050 12 $1,489 21 $98,827 1 $1,000 0 $0 0 $0 879 $2,052,637 424 $786,551 552 $1,704,199 163 $220,026 111 $144,160 101 $162,506 437 $377,622 257 $221,610 516 $2,681,173 110 $270,311 61 $137,216 152 $550,550 77 $123,076 48 $64,831 324 $1,380,904 17 $54,267 17 $29,578 0 $0 523 $933,895 387 $604,489 223 $1,181,540 0 $0 0 $0 0 $0 558 $1,334,119 250 $410,912 134 $163,139 32 $109,062 28 $68,960 42 $55,823 3 $7,708 3 $6,469 0 $0 137 $236,753 97 $129,955 33 $68,311 2 $1,779 1 $5,000 0 $0 13 $15,710 5 $4,773 2 $550 0 $0 0 $0 0 $0 0 $0 0 $0 0 $0 0 $0 0 $0 0 $0 121 $177,555 80 $66,559 47 $89,468 2 $1,615 0 $0 0 $0 4 $9,385 2 $4,084 0 $0 234 $318,377 136 $154,615 210 $283,100 Arizona Department of Revenue, Office of Economic Research & Analysis, June 2017 Disabled/Displaced Sum of All Future Corporate Total Average Reserved Scholarship Number $ Amount Number $ Amount 1 $750 $750 0 $0 0 $0 $2,245 7 $7,375 2 $4,242 $743 208 $1,211,608 2 $3,982 $2,656 56 $85,823 1 $1,000 $1,958 1 $460 0 $0 $872 67 $190,353 1 $1,154 $975 22 $26,005 1 $1,100 $1,375 45 $103,334 0 $0 $2,046 0 $0 0 $0 $970 0 $0 5 $6,703 $1,766 35 $116,954 0 $0 $2,873 9 $12,775 3 $12,446 $4,668 8 $38,213 0 $0 $1,211 176 $287,000 0 $0 $2,005 1 $483 2 $7,265 $2,309 33 $326,624 0 $0 $1,000 0 $0 18 $25,175 $2,439 1,488 $3,621,730 0 $0 $1,405 95 $97,060 0 $0 $2,711 574 $746,448 5 $5,500 $2,938 45 $96,400 1 $230 $3,487 176 $516,021 0 $0 $2,466 26 $63,824 3 $2,250 $2,396 395 $889,468 0 $0 $0 2 $5,708 2 $2,736 $2,024 266 $632,228 0 $0 $2,293 9 $26,700 0 $0 $2,363 10 $19,006 1 $1,971 $1,631 33 $47,226 0 $0 $2,260 3 $1,915 0 $0 $1,052 22 $47,015 1 $2,271 $2,271 0 $0 0 $0 $0 58 $92,436 6 $15,248 $2,541 0 $0 0 $0 $1,345 0 $0 0 $0 $808 0 $0 0 $0 $2,245 0 $0 3 $1,875 $1,300 340 $425,269 55 Table 12 FY 2016 Scholarships by Private School Private School Ss. Simon and Jude School St. Agnes Catholic School St. Ambrose School St. Andrew's Kindergarten St. Anthony Catholic School St. Anthony of Padua Catholic School St. Augustine Catholic High School St. Catherine of Sienna Catholic School St. Charles Apache School St. Cyril Catholic School St. Dominic Savio Academy St. Elizabeth Ann Seton Catholic School St. Francis of Assisi School St. Francis Xavier Elementary School St. Gregory Catholic School St. Jerome K-8 School St. John Bosco Catholic School St. John the Evangelist School St. John Vianney Catholic School St. John XXIII Catholic School St. Joseph Catholic School St. Joseph's Catholic Montessori School St. Louis the King Catholic School St. Maria Goretti School St. Mark's Early Childhood Center St. Mark's Preschool & Kindergarten St. Mary Basha Catholic Elementary School St. Mary's High School St. Matthew School St. Maximilian Mary Kolbe School St. Michael Indian School St. Michael's Parish Day School St. Peter Mission School St. Peter's Montessori St. Theresa Elementary School St. Thomas Aquinas School St. Thomas the Apostle Catholic Pre-School & Kindergarten Original Individual Switcher Individual Low-Income Corporate Number $ Amount Number $ Amount Number $ Amount 389 $494,200 299 $230,417 385 $391,499 186 $277,196 148 $100,083 197 $199,635 138 $187,402 114 $147,459 288 $757,725 29 $59,903 33 $50,917 0 $0 87 $168,327 70 $98,759 125 $138,227 89 $207,934 69 $92,633 87 $230,509 239 $311,684 162 $166,143 301 $525,554 177 $230,922 138 $84,598 214 $225,110 65 $240,662 42 $101,556 52 $36,406 190 $330,279 131 $187,560 127 $160,742 2 $20,140 0 $0 0 $0 234 $332,749 153 $166,841 136 $277,611 217 $173,735 128 $93,224 235 $414,127 340 $465,321 233 $284,744 300 $325,783 303 $240,213 242 $145,640 372 $593,743 210 $226,113 181 $137,930 197 $167,618 317 $441,973 194 $250,428 98 $31,785 91 $180,943 47 $103,056 470 $2,285,296 318 $279,163 260 $213,695 415 $369,278 164 $294,272 96 $214,693 31 $56,964 144 $178,746 118 $109,667 146 $303,264 164 $278,687 96 $132,415 103 $55,501 202 $243,434 160 $118,504 351 $508,047 3 $2,465 4 $17,765 3 $15 8 $12,098 6 $4,402 0 $0 15 $30,700 11 $8,746 2 $600 358 $391,056 200 $185,008 144 $66,402 769 $1,182,677 519 $572,956 890 $2,059,149 232 $291,385 127 $148,871 391 $515,870 0 $0 0 $0 0 $0 285 $252,052 146 $113,462 168 $43,423 187 $466,472 101 $229,526 17 $42,200 131 $144,503 226 $166,220 209 $225,450 30 $85,382 20 $31,429 0 $0 180 $264,729 99 $171,546 90 $77,385 293 $448,770 161 $204,800 135 $65,593 1 $1,176 1 Arizona Department of Revenue, Office of Economic Research & Analysis, June 2017 $2,650 1 $5,100 Disabled/Displaced Sum of All Future Corporate Total Average Reserved Scholarship Number $ Amount Number $ Amount 16 $32,977 $1,055 319 $407,643 0 $0 $1,086 83 $243,584 5 $9,337 $2,022 299 $1,509,134 1 $750 $1,771 60 $105,954 0 $0 $1,437 60 $52,850 8 $15,300 $2,160 144 $632,258 22 $46,356 $1,450 352 $711,242 0 $0 $1,022 39 $143,939 0 $0 $2,381 78 $160,950 5 $11,697 $1,524 359 $660,143 2 $12,000 $8,035 0 $0 4 $2,750 $1,480 338 $582,770 7 $13,626 $1,183 78 $124,291 0 $0 $1,232 266 $885,095 0 $0 $1,068 274 $305,684 1 $299 $903 126 $329,732 0 $0 $1,189 184 $404,870 1 $750 $4,220 154 $809,868 12 $19,120 $877 210 $271,969 0 $0 $1,945 113 $199,431 9 $18,028 $1,462 189 $596,574 0 $0 $1,285 88 $356,058 5 $17,150 $1,236 199 $1,246,520 1 $5,500 $2,340 0 $0 0 $0 $1,179 10 $8,356 0 $0 $1,430 28 $50,034 1 $750 $915 158 $210,779 6 $11,014 $1,752 225 $463,289 0 $0 $1,275 235 $1,552,233 0 $0 $0 5 $3,377 0 $0 $683 185 $155,730 1 $750 $2,415 40 $115,870 0 $0 $947 103 $96,600 0 $0 $2,336 0 $0 2 $10 $1,385 90 $92,300 0 $0 $1,221 185 $241,747 0 $0 $2,975 4 $7,513 56 Table 12 FY 2016 Scholarships by Private School Private School St. Thomas the Apostle Catholic School St. Timothy Catholic Academy (Alma School) St. Timothy Catholic School St. Vincent de Paul School Summit School of Ahwatukee Sun Valley Indian School Sunrise Montessori School Tanque Verde Lutheran Preschool/Kindergarten Tempe Montessori Tesseract School The Beginning School The Caepe School The Family School The French American School of Arizona The Goddard School The Gregory School/St. Gregory College Preparatory The IDEA School The Jones-Gordon School The Learning Lab The Learning Pad The Orme School The Vine Preparatory Academy Thunderbird Adventist Academy Thunderbird Christian Elementary School Torah Day School of Phoenix Tri-City Christian Academy Trinity Christian School (CV) Trinity Christian School (M) Trinity Christian School (P) Trinity Lutheran School Trinity United Methodist Kindergarten Truly Free School Truthful Beginnings Tucson Baptist Academy Tucson Community School Tucson Hebrew Academy Tucson Waldorf School UNDECIDED Original Individual Switcher Individual Low-Income Corporate Number $ Amount Number $ Amount Number $ Amount 348 $434,000 177 $205,726 116 $70,797 0 $0 0 $0 30 $22,450 182 $304,391 119 $137,618 72 $26,897 428 $393,452 314 $141,030 374 $149,180 124 $390,701 62 $232,417 13 $17,900 19 $28,582 12 $22,018 0 $0 12 $32,529 11 $13,839 0 $0 11 $27,757 10 $10,643 0 $0 34 $59,683 15 $27,508 8 $17,200 34 $59,501 12 $21,105 9 $29,991 7 $21,076 6 $15,377 0 $0 0 $0 0 $0 0 $0 10 $113,439 9 $78,527 0 $0 13 $15,752 10 $10,468 0 $0 5 $11,225 5 $5,986 0 $0 101 $427,560 60 $236,785 59 $294,900 26 $25,336 14 $16,077 9 $9,585 23 $119,466 30 $107,480 9 $18,250 2 $2,151 1 $953 0 $0 1 $1,027 8 $5,598 1 $3,985 17 $118,800 5 $36,282 0 $0 4 $6,130 6 $6,670 8 $35,400 98 $163,433 16 $24,074 15 $54,347 54 $59,233 54 $31,647 4 $10,210 251 $233,622 347 $549,015 622 $745,658 233 $301,703 157 $114,493 143 $317,592 0 $0 0 $0 2 $1,000 20 $34,850 15 $10,525 0 $0 414 $431,844 297 $191,174 225 $219,887 149 $231,811 81 $78,683 53 $66,534 7 $9,974 7 $3,767 5 $14,750 2 $6,145 2 $2,010 0 $0 3 $2,427 0 $0 0 $0 49 $49,237 37 $32,496 25 $27,087 12 $33,590 12 $17,212 5 $755 160 $437,619 90 $372,940 93 $317,550 102 $204,380 87 $156,243 75 $262,001 0 $0 0 $0 0 $0 Arizona Department of Revenue, Office of Economic Research & Analysis, June 2017 Disabled/Displaced Sum of All Future Corporate Total Average Reserved Scholarship Number $ Amount Number $ Amount 3 $510 $1,104 131 $207,839 0 $0 $748 31 $32,600 0 $0 $1,257 48 $87,238 3 $7,625 $618 97 $145,936 2 $1,500 $3,197 208 $516,976 0 $0 $1,632 0 $0 0 $0 $2,016 0 $0 0 $0 $1,829 12 $16,158 2 $800 $1,783 0 $0 0 $0 $2,011 12 $6,625 0 $0 $2,804 7 $14,572 0 $0 $0 1 $463 0 $0 $10,103 0 $0 0 $0 $1,140 0 $0 0 $0 $1,721 3 $1,905 3 $1,130 $4,307 91 $328,013 5 $8,791 $1,107 59 $153,533 29 $101,672 $3,812 56 $169,719 6 $5,100 $912 0 $0 0 $0 $1,061 2 $687 0 $0 $7,049 0 $0 0 $0 $2,678 0 $0 2 $3,982 $1,877 24 $258,306 1 $4,950 $938 38 $222,612 14 $10,441 $1,247 107 $317,000 5 $7,712 $1,378 237 $531,729 0 $0 $500 0 $0 0 $0 $1,296 10 $8,878 4 $4,392 $901 270 $336,803 1 $3,628 $1,340 132 $120,556 1 $2,271 $1,538 5 $54,816 0 $0 $2,039 0 $0 0 $0 $809 0 $0 0 $0 $980 32 $23,919 0 $0 $1,778 12 $25,214 1 $500 $3,281 74 $238,013 4 $5,512 $2,344 67 $72,165 0 $0 $0 16 $437,591 57 Table 12 FY 2016 Scholarships by Private School Private School Valley Baptist School Valley Christian High School Valley Lutheran High School Verde Valley Adventist School Verde Valley Christian School Verde Valley School Veritas Academy of Tucson Veritas Christian Community School Ville de Marie Academy Vision Christian Academy West Valley Christian School Western Hills Baptist School White Mountain Christian School White Mountain Montessori School Wickenburg Christian Academy (Legacy High) Wings on Words Woodbridge Private School Word of Life Christian School Xavier College Preparatory Yeshiva High School Yeshiva High School of Arizona Young Disciples Christian Academy Yuma Adventist School Yuma Catholic High School Yuma Lutheran School Original Individual Switcher Individual Low-Income Corporate Number $ Amount Number $ Amount Number $ Amount 2 $1,034 7 $1,367 0 $0 345 $1,036,014 215 $484,175 116 $574,100 312 $344,377 193 $160,574 44 $52,065 7 $6,345 1 $800 0 $0 121 $243,018 98 $119,563 66 $50,905 6 $21,511 2 $8,000 1 $3,000 102 $115,112 77 $86,003 51 $64,400 124 $242,076 84 $99,450 14 $18,550 97 $164,636 80 $101,148 27 $41,500 40 $36,745 28 $12,630 20 $6,300 103 $145,782 71 $71,259 65 $152,558 2 $2,345 0 $0 0 $0 1 $1,067 0 $0 0 $0 6 $8,803 5 $10,807 0 $0 117 $160,784 92 $84,636 43 $60,262 7 $10,310 2 $5,848 2 $800 5 $5,828 5 $1,675 0 $0 6 $8,884 8 $3,145 0 $0 742 $1,704,010 446 $875,873 394 $754,538 0 $0 0 $0 12 $25,000 20 $88,614 23 $37,584 23 $29,895 10 $3,821 6 $2,797 2 $6,500 47 $28,168 12 $6,007 18 $25,159 208 $363,535 175 $196,019 342 $1,939,917 199 $310,406 162 $165,972 97 $249,622 TOTALS 31,578 $54,433,866 20,964 $28,523,502 20,077 $43,465,758 Arizona Department of Revenue, Office of Economic Research & Analysis, June 2017 Disabled/Displaced Sum of All Future Corporate Total Average Reserved Scholarship Number $ Amount Number $ Amount 0 $0 $267 1 $375 6 $12,587 $3,089 189 $957,631 0 $0 $1,015 62 $151,353 0 $0 $893 0 $0 1 $3,941 $1,460 25 $86,438 0 $0 $3,612 4 $18,000 0 $0 $1,154 89 $145,842 0 $0 $1,622 36 $28,441 1 $2,900 $1,513 114 $163,968 0 $0 $633 7 $4,967 7 $20,872 $1,587 90 $405,033 0 $0 $1,172 0 $0 0 $0 $1,067 0 $0 0 $0 $1,783 0 $0 2 $7,256 $1,232 89 $141,988 4 $4,600 $1,437 5 $6,516 0 $0 $750 2 $3,841 0 $0 $859 10 $5,333 1 $10,000 $2,113 409 $1,118,016 0 $0 $2,083 0 $0 0 $0 $2,365 7 $20,700 0 $0 $729 9 $87,137 0 $0 $771 1 $7,578 9 $17,836 $3,430 225 $591,116 20 $60,680 $1,646 114 $130,912 936 $4,395,388 $1,779 24,271 $68,930,000 58 Top 20 Private Schools by Estimated Total Scholarships Since 1998 Millions St. Mary's High School $25.6 Salpointe Catholic High School $24.5 Brophy College Preparatory $23.6 Northwest Christian School $21.5 Cornerstone Christian Academy/Pusch Ridge $19.8 Xavier College Preparatory $19.0 Scottsdale Christian Academy $19.0 Valley Christian High School $17.2 Bourgade Catholic High School $15.4 Desert Christian Schools $13.2 Phoenix Christian Preparatory Schools $12.7 Seton Catholic High School $12.1 Joy Christian School $11.9 San Miguel High School $11.0 Yuma Catholic High School $10.3 Gilbert Christian Schools $10.2 Notre Dame Preparatory $9.9 Phoenix Country Day School $9.2 Grace Community Christian School $8.9 The Gregory School/St. Gregory College Preparatory $8.9 Estimated Total Scholarships Received by Private Schools Since 1998 Table 13 (pg. 60), lists every private school that has received scholarship revenue from the private school tuition organization income tax credit programs and the estimated amounts received from all four programs since 1998. Over 600 private schools are on this list which does include schools that are no longer in operation. School name changes and merging of schools has been incorporated when the information has been provided by the STOs. These scholarship amounts are estimated for two reasons. For the first several years of the private school tuition organization tax credit program (original individual only), there was no requirement for the STOs to report. Although some did report at ADOR request, some did not or only reported partially. Therefore, the early year figures are incomplete. Secondly, the reporting period changed from calendar year to fiscal year, beginning with FY2011. The amount of scholarships by school that were duplicated in the CY2010 and FY2011 numbers was estimated. For additional information or questions, contact Karen Jacobs/Caitlin Wooten at the Arizona Department of Revenue at 602-716-6923 or 602-716-6072. Arizona Department of Revenue, Office of Economic Research & Analysis, June 2017 59 Table 13 Estimated Total Scholarships by Private School CY1998 - FY2016 Private School 2nd Street Children's School 91st Psalm Christian School A Child's View Abbie Loveland Tuller Abiding Savior School Academy of Destiny ACCEL (Latch School) Ace Academy ACES (Austin Centers for Exceptional Students) Adobe Adventist Christian School Adobe Montessori Agape Youth Ranch Academy Ahwatukee Foothills Montessori Ajo Calvary Christian Academy Aldea Montessori Aleph Bet Kindergarten Alethia Academy Al-Huda School All Saints Catholic School (Our Lady Of The Mountains) All Saints' Episcopal Day School Alpha Omega Academy Ambassador Christian Academy American Christian Academy American Family Education American Indian Christian School Anderson Adventist Elementary School Angels in Autism (AZ Behavior & Autism) Annunciation Catholic School Apache Baptist Academy Apache Kids Academy Apostolic Faith Center Christian Arcadia Christian School Arcadia Montessori Arizona Center for Autism Original Individual $316,432 $1,080,123 $5,676 $886,275 $140,275 $17,881 $575,074 $20,825 $31,449 $184,321 $14,172 $4,794 $261,977 $11,291 $453,039 $305,838 $174,678 $662,426 $2,172,800 $4,479,824 $20,043 $116,855 $3,420 $24,127 $1,596,922 $4,593 $24,257 $984,110 $62,088 $9,503 $101,168 $126,164 $159,735 $0 Arizona Department of Revenue, Office of Economic Research & Analysis, June 2017 Switcher Individual $39,510 $115,755 $0 $36,780 $0 $0 $54,843 $3,581 $5,225 $8,700 $0 $0 $70,514 $1,489 $42,722 $261,901 $0 $108,667 $225,537 $464,031 $0 $46,705 $0 $13,991 $109,579 $0 $13,717 $332,218 $11,460 $874 $11,100 $0 $69,851 $0 Low-Income Corporate $29,370 $917,605 $0 $453,931 $0 $0 $32,600 $14,835 $0 $0 $0 $0 $550 $0 $9,200 $52,200 $0 $0 $408,914 $2,503,084 $0 $7,000 $0 $0 $3,700 $0 $630 $78,245 $7,467 $0 $162,326 $0 $0 $20,000 Disabled/Displaced Corporate $0 $19,959 $0 $142,531 $0 $0 $114,223 $1,500 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $100 $0 $0 $0 $0 $54,080 $12,150 $58 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 Total Scholarships $385,313 $2,133,442 $5,676 $1,519,516 $140,275 $17,881 $776,741 $40,742 $36,674 $193,021 $14,172 $4,794 $333,040 $12,780 $504,961 $619,939 $174,678 $771,093 $2,807,251 $7,446,939 $20,043 $170,661 $3,420 $38,118 $1,710,201 $4,593 $92,684 $1,406,723 $81,074 $10,377 $274,594 $126,164 $229,586 $20,000 60 Table 13 Estimated Total Scholarships by Private School CY1998 - FY2016 Private School Arizona Community Childhood Academy Arizona Cultural Academy Arizona International Academy Arizona Language Preparatory Arizona Lutheran Academy Armstrong Academy Arrowhead Christian Academy Arrowhead Montessori School ASCEND Ascension Lutheran School Atonement Lutheran School Augustana Academy Autism Academy for Education & Development Avondale Montessori Awakening Seed School AZ Assist Academy AZ Aspire Academy Back to Basics Christian School Banner Children's Academy Barness Family Jewish Community Center Day School Bayer Private School Beautiful Savior Academy Begin to Dream Christian Academy Bella Vista College Preparatory School Berean Christian Academy Beth El Center for Early Childhood Education Kindergarten Bethany Christian School Big Dreams Preschool & Kindergarten Bios Christian Academy Black Mountain Science Academy Blessed Sacrament Kindergarten Beyond Autism Bourgade Catholic High School Boys Hope/Girls Hope Original Individual $14,203 $2,844,775 $426,412 $40,310 $4,439,615 $214,067 $2,024,556 $48,880 $18,500 $1,281,291 $1,585,245 $7,043 $60,728 $3,668 $1,005,512 $1,892 $3,355 $892 $28,973 $465,164 $57,629 $341,203 $450 $356,020 $141,146 $119,138 $5,837,587 $2,177 $1,317,878 $94,520 $545,127 $1,289 $10,758,053 $13,551 Arizona Department of Revenue, Office of Economic Research & Analysis, June 2017 Switcher Individual $0 $577,433 $57,824 $12,941 $318,261 $0 $198,167 $19,333 $0 $44,736 $178,874 $4,900 $34,265 $0 $121,319 $0 $2,784 $0 $6,995 $0 $38,094 $13,861 $0 $79,642 $0 $0 $679,831 $1,571 $90,191 $32,192 $40,914 $0 $1,144,411 $0 Low-Income Corporate $0 $861,195 $0 $11,260 $201,859 $0 $473,553 $5,580 $3,500 $3,510 $129,025 $0 $61,210 $0 $13,400 $0 $900 $0 $0 $0 $6,305 $1,600 $0 $128,300 $0 $0 $377,471 $0 $131,354 $0 $11,390 $0 $3,317,281 $0 Disabled/Displaced Corporate $0 $0 $0 $0 $8,132 $0 $43,131 $5,226 $18,000 $6,130 $0 $0 $816,503 $0 $12,955 $3,859 $15,902 $0 $12,773 $0 $0 $0 $0 $14,565 $0 $0 $16,933 $0 $45,737 $0 $1,854 $42,780 $135,652 $0 Total Scholarships $14,203 $4,283,403 $484,236 $64,511 $4,967,867 $214,067 $2,739,407 $79,019 $40,000 $1,335,668 $1,893,144 $11,943 $972,706 $3,668 $1,153,186 $5,750 $22,941 $892 $48,741 $465,164 $102,028 $356,663 $450 $578,527 $141,146 $119,138 $6,911,822 $3,748 $1,585,160 $126,712 $599,285 $44,069 $15,355,396 $13,551 61 Table 13 Estimated Total Scholarships by Private School CY1998 - FY2016 Private School Breakthrough Academy Bridges Preschool & Kindergarten Bridges Preschool & Kindergarten Brightmont Academy Brophy College Preparatory Brophy Loyola Academy Brown Road Christian Academy Calvary Baptist School Calvary Central Christian Academy Calvary Chapel Christian School Calvary Christian Academy Calvary Christian Academy Calvary Christian School Calvary Shadows Assembly of God Camelback Christian School Camelback Desert School Camp Verde United Christian School Canyon State Academy Carden Christian Academy Central Carden of the Peaks Casa del Nino Bilingual Montessori School Casa Ninos School of Montessori Casas Adobe Christian School Casas Christian School Castlehill Country Day School Cathedral Christian Academy Cathedral of Praise Christian School Cave Creek Montessori Cedar Tree Montessori Central Christian Academy Chandler Christian Academy Chandler Christian School Chaparral Christian Preschool & Kindergarten Chapel Haven West Original Individual $34,381 $5,609 $8,430 $36,271 $17,687,180 $103,350 $7,322 $287,516 $19,884 $2,164,969 $2,365,678 $364,367 $370,064 $7,136 $144,812 $244,888 $1,576,120 $13,523 $402,633 $51,510 $28,115 $36,271 $36,103 $6,754,962 $1,218,171 $723,275 $36,270 $258,321 $0 $128,978 $2,248,666 $0 $199,980 $57,257 Arizona Department of Revenue, Office of Economic Research & Analysis, June 2017 Switcher Individual $27,040 $1,790 $0 $13,353 $895,104 $1,491,294 $0 $29,843 $4,823 $389,437 $311,113 $0 $16,733 $6,125 $31,676 $22,511 $190,995 $0 $34,677 $0 $26,605 $8,398 $0 $572,957 $161,901 $0 $0 $136,969 $50 $0 $350,695 $0 $31,077 $2,880 Low-Income Corporate $0 $500 $0 $6,500 $5,040,049 $1,468,050 $0 $106,060 $0 $454,802 $277,284 $0 $90,540 $3,550 $0 $1,850 $81,940 $0 $112,042 $0 $15,950 $6,250 $0 $432,245 $13,580 $0 $10,780 $0 $11,524 $0 $90,452 $187,822 $2,035 $0 Disabled/Displaced Corporate $30,322 $0 $0 $10,944 $21,203 $0 $0 $5,270 $0 $3,505 $0 $0 $0 $3,525 $5 $3,500 $10,515 $0 $21,271 $0 $0 $0 $0 $61,346 $700 $0 $0 $0 $1,975 $0 $0 $3,515 $0 $26,997 Total Scholarships $91,743 $7,899 $8,430 $67,067 $23,643,536 $3,062,694 $7,322 $428,689 $24,707 $3,012,714 $2,954,076 $364,367 $477,337 $20,336 $176,493 $272,749 $1,859,570 $13,523 $570,623 $51,510 $70,670 $50,920 $36,103 $7,821,510 $1,394,352 $723,275 $47,050 $395,290 $13,549 $128,978 $2,689,813 $191,337 $233,092 $87,134 62 Table 13 Estimated Total Scholarships by Private School CY1998 - FY2016 Private School Cheder Lubavitch Chinle Adventist Elementary Christ Church School Christ Lutheran School Christ the King Academy Christ the King Catholic School Christ the Redeemer Lutheran School Christian Academy of Prescott Christian Challenge Academy Christ's Community Christian Academy Christ's Greenfield Lutheran School Chrysalis Academy Clear View Academy Cochise SDA Christian School Colossal Cave Learning Center Community Christian School Community Montessori Concordia Lutheran Schools Congregation Anshei Israel Preschool & Kindergarten Copper Canyon Academy Copper Canyon Christian School Cornerstone Christian Academy Cornerstone Christian Academy Cornerstone Christian Academy Cornerstone Christian Academy/Pusch Ridge Cornerstone Christian School Cornerstone Kidz Covenant Child Care Center Covenant Christian School Covenant of Faith School Creative Bridges Cooperative Preschool Creative Castle Preschool & Kindergarten Creo School Cross of Glory Lutheran Elementary School Original Individual $185,082 $7,415 $485,018 $5,487,350 $94,099 $3,272,117 $722,786 $2,064,586 $2,314 $165,828 $4,348,362 $129,720 $26,895 $1,009 $600 $10,335 $204,010 $156,346 $114,136 $2,257 $42,452 $720 $139,565 $1,000 $16,690,359 $144,033 $106,926 $5,434 $20,714 $3,055 $0 $101,804 $127,674 $497,452 Arizona Department of Revenue, Office of Economic Research & Analysis, June 2017 Switcher Individual $108,443 $0 $117,367 $908,235 $9,248 $284,291 $0 $284,338 $0 $0 $520,481 $37,018 $14,879 $4,000 $0 $0 $31,348 $0 $62,389 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $2,009,947 $0 $8,324 $4,069 $0 $0 $0 $39,686 $76,611 $99,948 Low-Income Corporate $17,656 $0 $16,177 $135,977 $1,763 $330,103 $18,880 $256,141 $0 $0 $186,868 $411 $6,546 $19,125 $0 $0 $0 $0 $31,088 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $1,022,155 $0 $1,500 $0 $0 $0 $0 $3,500 $63,620 $45,622 Disabled/Displaced Corporate $0 $0 $0 $4,979 $0 $12,143 $0 $84,822 $0 $0 $5 $186,744 $0 $21,805 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $28,769 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $1,710 $0 $0 $17,032 Total Scholarships $311,181 $7,415 $618,561 $6,536,541 $105,110 $3,898,655 $741,666 $2,689,887 $2,314 $165,828 $5,055,715 $353,893 $48,320 $45,940 $600 $10,335 $235,358 $156,346 $207,613 $2,257 $42,452 $720 $139,565 $1,000 $19,751,230 $144,033 $116,750 $9,503 $20,714 $3,055 $1,710 $144,990 $267,905 $660,054 63 Table 13 Estimated Total Scholarships by Private School CY1998 - FY2016 Private School Cross Roads Preschool & Kindergarten Crossroads Christians Academy Crossroads Community School (Hope Christian Academy) David Ricardo School Dayspring Kindergarten Desert Christian Schools Desert Garden Montessori Desert Hills Christian Academy Desert Jewish Academy Desert Life Academy Desert Marigold School Desert Montessori Desert Quest Private School Desert Shadows Montessori Desert Sky Montessori Desert Springs Christian Kindergarten Desert Sun Child Development Center Desert Valley Christian School Desert View Learning Center Desert Voices Oral Learning Center Desert Willow Educational Services Dobson Montessori School Dove Christian School Downtown Community School Dynamite Montessori School Early Light Academy East Fork Lutheran School East Valley Adventist Education Program East Valley Christian Academy East Valley Jewish Day School Eastside Christian School Educational Special Needs Services El Dorado Private School Emmanuel Christian Academy Original Individual $18,842 $5,146 $2,222,856 $11,060 $945,326 $10,144,473 $1,542,478 $6,703 $286,226 $1,463 $44,611 $17,652 $13,895 $101,336 $21,643 $238,640 $539,026 $326,528 $1,444,439 $587,744 $11,746 $1,122,284 $285,598 $3,085 $511,130 $4,900 $518,952 $225 $23,610 $346,214 $1,665 $1,560 $300,734 $491,429 Arizona Department of Revenue, Office of Economic Research & Analysis, June 2017 Switcher Individual $0 $0 $308,464 $0 $71,304 $829,349 $323,438 $0 $152,907 $0 $0 $0 $0 $15,600 $5,371 $0 $65,695 $15,345 $243,157 $101,410 $0 $93,123 $0 $2,183 $121,068 $0 $53,340 $0 $0 $670 $0 $0 $57,276 $93,509 Low-Income Corporate $0 $0 $29,277 $0 $4,895 $1,877,886 $210,936 $0 $24,241 $0 $0 $0 $1,505 $3,284 $9,900 $0 $10,900 $22,368 $7,460 $0 $0 $96,766 $875 $0 $0 $0 $0 $2,653 $0 $54,803 $0 $0 $22,844 $95,079 Disabled/Displaced Corporate $0 $0 $5,387 $0 $500 $314,919 $29,590 $0 $11,197 $0 $0 $0 $2,000 $0 $6,550 $0 $505 $0 $0 $25,500 $0 $20,642 $0 $0 $4,728 $0 $0 $0 $0 $5,266 $0 $0 $12,265 $3,837 Total Scholarships $18,842 $5,146 $2,565,984 $11,060 $1,022,025 $13,166,627 $2,106,442 $6,703 $474,572 $1,463 $44,611 $17,652 $17,400 $120,220 $43,464 $238,640 $616,126 $364,242 $1,695,056 $714,654 $11,746 $1,332,814 $286,473 $5,268 $636,926 $4,900 $572,292 $2,878 $23,610 $406,953 $1,665 $1,560 $393,119 $683,854 64 Table 13 Estimated Total Scholarships by Private School CY1998 - FY2016 Private School Emmanuel Lutheran School Emmaus Lutheran School Enchanted Desert School Enrichment Academy Esther B Feldman Kindergarten Ethos School Experimental Schools Corp of AZ Faith Baptist School Faith Christian Academy Faith Christian Academy Faith Christian Academy Faith Christian School Faith Community Academy Faith Life Christian Academy Faith Lutheran School Faith Lutheran School Family Life Academy Family of Christ Learning Center Family of God Lutheran School Father's Heart Christian School Fellowship Child Development Center Fenster School Firm Foundation Christian School First Baptist Christian Academy First Baptist Christian Academy First Baptist Christian School First Baptist of Mesa Christian Academy First Southern Christian School Flagstaff Adventist School Flagstaff Community Christian School Florence Baptist Academy Foundation for Blind Children Founders Classical Academy Fountain of Life Lutheran School Original Individual $1,642,351 $855,328 $591,497 $1,301 $1,956 $101,172 $7,794 $1,078 $40,876 $76,186 $4,388 $1,075,455 $1,047,946 $450 $149,878 $1,002,857 $1,501,411 $141,812 $70,557 $1,000 $63,080 $900 $189,254 $1,090,556 $5,093 $47,980 $12,367 $1,144,090 $462,015 $905,517 $25,973 $677,946 $3,000 $1,702,094 Arizona Department of Revenue, Office of Economic Research & Analysis, June 2017 Switcher Individual $130,920 $53,103 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $5,950 $9,110 $0 $141,427 $113,404 $0 $33,360 $44,124 $113,596 $38,255 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $143,902 $0 $0 $0 $50,351 $0 $236,336 $3,340 $185,731 $0 $18,798 Low-Income Corporate $36,620 $12,146 $0 $150 $0 $0 $0 $0 $47,162 $32,535 $0 $65,591 $244,400 $0 $36,020 $40,134 $149,665 $0 $9,009 $0 $0 $0 $11,789 $22,802 $0 $0 $0 $96,727 $0 $1,964,189 $4,000 $5,000 $0 $9,175 Disabled/Displaced Corporate $0 $50 $0 $0 $0 $20,570 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $33,301 $10,947 $0 $500 $2,000 $3,250 $0 $0 $0 $0 $21,260 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $4,671 $10,619 $10,538 $0 $460,157 $0 $0 Total Scholarships $1,809,891 $920,627 $591,497 $1,451 $1,956 $121,742 $7,794 $1,078 $93,988 $117,831 $4,388 $1,315,774 $1,416,697 $450 $219,758 $1,089,115 $1,767,922 $180,067 $79,566 $1,000 $63,080 $22,160 $201,043 $1,257,260 $5,093 $47,980 $12,367 $1,295,839 $472,634 $3,116,580 $33,312 $1,328,834 $3,000 $1,730,067 65 Table 13 Estimated Total Scholarships by Private School CY1998 - FY2016 Private School Fourteen Six Christian Academy Freedom Christian Academy Freedom Christian School Friendship Christian School Full Gospel Christian Academy Gan Yeladim Gary K. Herberger Young Scholar's Academy Gateway Academy Gateway Baptist Academy Gateway Baptist Academy Gateway Bible Church Christian Training Center Gateway Fellowship Preschool & Kindergarten Gateway Independent School Gateways School Gethsemane Lutheran School Gila Mountain Christian Academy Gilbert Christian Schools Gilson Wash Baptist Academy Glendale Christian Academy Glenview Adventist Academy God's Garden Child Development Center God's World Golf Links Christian School Good Earth Montessori Good Shepherd Lutheran School Good Steps Christian Academy Gospel Light Christian Academy Gospel Outreach Christian School Grace Christian Academy Grace Christian School Grace Community Christian School Grace Fellowship Academy Grace Garden Christian Preschool Grace Lutheran School Original Individual $8,940 $619,950 $35,600 $15,848 $4,474 $13,000 $197,110 $63,873 $358,099 $18,460 $6,703 $11,225 $110,885 $16,063 $2,552,509 $8,680 $7,491,454 $44,388 $1,068,970 $684,455 $3,446 $870 $25,564 $7,348 $120,574 $5,303 $5,235 $4,071 $65,604 $63,527 $8,292,439 $791,845 $0 $1,481,260 Arizona Department of Revenue, Office of Economic Research & Analysis, June 2017 Switcher Individual $1,592 $108,932 $1,647 $0 $0 $0 $65,548 $4,262 $52,902 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $332,137 $0 $1,813,987 $0 $50,412 $47,041 $0 $0 $0 $1,221 $0 $0 $0 $2,202 $7,704 $0 $409,851 $120,487 $20 $121,018 Low-Income Corporate $0 $895,121 $0 $0 $0 $0 $64,202 $300 $77,324 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $38,195 $0 $830,162 $0 $311,080 $173,878 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $1,325 $0 $0 $0 $217,137 $388,624 $0 $24,556 Disabled/Displaced Corporate $0 $68,272 $0 $0 $0 $0 $3,973 $68,129 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $500 $0 $42,493 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $3,828 $566 $0 $14,811 Total Scholarships $10,532 $1,692,275 $37,247 $15,848 $4,474 $13,000 $330,832 $136,563 $488,326 $18,460 $6,703 $11,225 $110,885 $16,063 $2,923,340 $8,680 $10,178,096 $44,388 $1,430,462 $905,374 $3,446 $870 $25,564 $8,569 $120,574 $5,303 $6,560 $6,272 $73,309 $63,527 $8,923,255 $1,301,522 $20 $1,641,645 66 Table 13 Estimated Total Scholarships by Private School CY1998 - FY2016 Private School GracePointe Christian Academy (Chapel in the Hills) Graysmark Academy Green Fields Country Day School Guiding Light Christian Educational Center (GLCP) Guiding Light Christian School Hand in Hand Christian School Happy Trails Harvest Christian Academy Harvest Kidz School Heritage Christian Academy Heritage Montesori Hermosa Montessori Highland Free School Holbrook Adventist Indian School Holy Angels School Holy Cross Evangelical Lutheran School Holy Trinity Academy Hopi Mission School Howard S. Gray Education Program Imago Dei Middle School Immaculate Conception School Immaculate Heart Academy Immaculate Heart High School Immaculate Heart Preparatory School (K-8) Inspire International Preschool Inspire Kids Montessori Intermountain Academy International Christian Academy Online International School for Peace International School of Arizona International School of Tucson Ironwood Hill School Jess Schwartz College Preparatory Joanne Todd Christian School Original Individual $364,637 $24,367 $3,386,011 $92,206 $339,702 $75,852 $40,133 $91,237 $13,951 $1,463,449 $91,332 $88,619 $70,908 $171,909 $984,962 $68,355 $295,188 $2,388,988 $85,527 $2,084,719 $1,330,420 $627,796 $3,156,366 $93,383 $0 $42,241 $25,100 $8,044 $14,095 $667,391 $779,580 $1,781 $2,984,869 $410,609 Arizona Department of Revenue, Office of Economic Research & Analysis, June 2017 Switcher Individual $28,186 $117 $437,434 $27,104 $0 $12,636 $0 $0 $4,201 $5,563 $32,387 $0 $0 $3,304 $0 $2,459 $29,666 $195,457 $3,611 $382,915 $150,506 $236,140 $145,789 $10,951 $0 $13,197 $16,700 $0 $1,177 $120,772 $178,169 $0 $0 $70,988 Low-Income Corporate $92,337 $6,000 $795,705 $122,869 $0 $15,472 $5,234 $0 $0 $16,485 $0 $0 $0 $0 $100,000 $500 $1,000 $116,216 $100 $1,984,420 $852,084 $333,809 $539,217 $20,170 $2,700 $0 $408,700 $0 $0 $82,101 $547,061 $0 $19,000 $2,740 Disabled/Displaced Corporate $505 $41,152 $16,700 $500 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $100 $0 $20,405 $19,625 $34,856 $0 $0 $0 $1,088,867 $0 $0 $0 $15,098 $10,271 $0 $0 Total Scholarships $485,664 $71,636 $4,635,850 $242,679 $339,702 $103,960 $45,367 $91,237 $18,153 $1,485,497 $123,719 $88,619 $70,908 $175,213 $1,084,962 $71,314 $325,853 $2,700,661 $89,338 $4,452,054 $2,353,415 $1,217,370 $3,876,227 $124,504 $2,700 $55,438 $1,539,367 $8,044 $15,272 $870,264 $1,519,908 $12,052 $3,003,869 $484,337 67 Table 13 Estimated Total Scholarships by Private School CY1998 - FY2016 Private School Journeys Academy Joy Christian School Joyful Beginnings Academy Kachina Country Day School KASL Academy for Deaf and Hard of Hearing Keystone Montessori Kingdom Khalsa Montessori Khalsa Montessori Kids' Discovery Club Christian Kindergarten Kimber Academy King David School Kingdom Preparatory Academy Kingman Adventist Christian School King's Academy Kino Learning Center Kyrene del Norte La Paz Montessori La Tierra Community School Lamad Preparatory Academy Lamb's Gate Christian School Lambs of God School Lauren's Institute for Education School (LIFE) Learning Unlimited Legacy Classical Christian Academy Lestonnac School Lexington Academy Lexington Life Academy Lexis Preparatory School Liberty Christian Academy (formerly Bethany) Life Academy Life Christian Academy Life Development Institute Light and Life Elementary School Lighthouse Academy Original Individual $9,900 $7,698,675 $366,276 $6,725 $4,690 $268,868 $20,544 $99,487 $17,076 $136,576 $2,994,954 $644 $96,992 $4,000 $845,154 $540 $540 $25,445 $2,955 $538,115 $10,213 $340,559 $0 $350,352 $88,461 $73,609 $0 $415,548 $99,564 $5,899 $72,244 $218,236 $345,718 $49,140 Arizona Department of Revenue, Office of Economic Research & Analysis, June 2017 Switcher Individual $0 $799,716 $62,434 $0 $6,090 $0 $0 $0 $0 $74,984 $0 $260 $0 $0 $96,081 $0 $535 $0 $0 $26,119 $0 $72,047 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $207,999 $0 $0 $28,402 $49,707 $0 $0 Low-Income Corporate $10,000 $3,322,326 $900 $9,500 $16,800 $0 $0 $0 $0 $6,000 $22,319 $180,340 $0 $0 $179,404 $0 $0 $0 $0 $17,498 $0 $642,610 $4,000 $0 $0 $0 $93,600 $79,501 $16,601 $4,600 $5,420 $19,200 $0 $0 Disabled/Displaced Corporate $0 $99,240 $0 $7,050 $51,000 $0 $0 $0 $0 $1,500 $0 $0 $0 $0 $85,764 $0 $0 $0 $0 $6,665 $0 $3,227,230 $6,000 $0 $0 $0 $54,836 $173,289 $2,000 $0 $0 $35,410 $0 $0 Total Scholarships $19,900 $11,919,957 $429,610 $23,275 $78,580 $268,868 $20,544 $99,487 $17,076 $219,060 $3,017,273 $181,244 $96,992 $4,000 $1,206,404 $540 $1,075 $25,445 $2,955 $588,397 $10,213 $4,282,446 $10,000 $350,352 $88,461 $73,609 $148,436 $876,337 $118,165 $10,499 $106,066 $322,553 $345,718 $49,140 68 Table 13 Estimated Total Scholarships by Private School CY1998 - FY2016 Private School Little Angels Montessori School Little Palms School Logos Christian Academy Loretto Catholic School Lourdes Catholic School Magical Journey Learning Center Maranatha Christian Academy Maricopa Village Christian School Marina Montessori Martin Luther Lutheran School Mesa Christian Academy Mesa Montessori Messiah Lutheran Open Arms Millennium Worldwide Academy Mis Manos Montesorri School Mission Christian School Mission Montessori Mission View Academy Montessori 2000 Montessori Center School Montessori Centre Main Montessori Centre North Montessori Children's Home Montessori Christian Academy Montessori Day School Montessori Educare Academy Montessori Education Center Montessori in the Park Montessori International School Montessori Kingdom of Learning Montessori Learning Center Montessori Matters Montessori of Surprise Montessori Preparatory Academy Original Individual $930 $12,576 $188,666 $1,450,372 $1,539,208 $144,876 $14,869 $52,248 $465 $1,233,008 $84,137 $82,864 $88,363 $133,605 $3,216 $494,561 $164,546 $1,367 $7,173 $550,613 $139,381 $78,438 $290,345 $186,337 $147,040 $140,174 $14,885 $527,960 $998,505 $1,507,531 $71,620 $70,715 $34,060 $30,627 Arizona Department of Revenue, Office of Economic Research & Analysis, June 2017 Switcher Individual $0 $174 $39,161 $180,402 $127,316 $98,392 $93 $4,394 $0 $0 $17,661 $28,412 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $77,230 $0 $0 $0 $31,810 $0 $4,870 $0 $17,010 $130,698 $20,363 $9,740 $41,910 $14,252 $3,100 Low-Income Corporate $0 $0 $372,927 $1,513,121 $541,961 $5 $3,399 $0 $0 $0 $23,125 $80 $0 $187,236 $0 $221,699 $0 $0 $0 $10,500 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $503,882 $11,331 $0 $0 $3,544 $0 Disabled/Displaced Corporate $0 $0 $0 $0 $1,020 $750 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $5,582 $0 $0 $0 $5 $39,716 $0 $0 $0 $0 $250 Total Scholarships $930 $12,750 $600,753 $3,143,895 $2,209,505 $244,023 $18,361 $56,642 $465 $1,233,008 $124,923 $111,356 $88,363 $320,841 $3,216 $716,260 $164,546 $1,367 $7,173 $638,343 $139,381 $78,438 $290,345 $223,729 $147,040 $145,044 $14,885 $544,975 $1,672,801 $1,539,225 $81,360 $112,625 $51,856 $33,977 69 Table 13 Estimated Total Scholarships by Private School CY1998 - FY2016 Private School Montessori Schoolhouse Charter Montessori West Preparatory Montezuma Indian School Morning Glory Montessori Most Holy Trinity Catholic School Mount Calvary Lutheran School Mountain Christian School Mountain View Lutheran School Navajo Evangelical Lutheran Mission School Navajo Trails Nehemiah Ministries Nellie P. Covert School Neurologic Music Therapy Services of Arizona New Covenant Lutheran Preschool & Kindergarten New Hope Christian Academy New Horizons Christian Academy New Life Christian Academy New Life Wesleyan Academy New School for the Arts New Vistas Center for Education New Way Learning Academy Noah's Ark Preschool & Kindergarten Nogales Christian Academy Noor Academy of Arizona North Phoenix Baptist Kindergarten North Phoenix Christian Montessori School North Valley Christian Academy (Cross of Christ) Northland Christian School Northminster Christian School Northwest Christian School Northwest Christian School Notre Dame Preparatory Oak Creek Ranch School Oasis Christian School Original Individual $38,633 $259,970 $6,333 $31,535 $2,527,691 $553,950 $1,284,916 $61,105 $2,274,282 $1,725 $2,484 $296,042 $180,243 $290,794 $172,644 $137,409 $3,200 $3,240 $563 $1,052,484 $2,652,790 $164,522 $33,118 $3,101,028 $162,909 $5,907 $1,417,322 $46,763 $456,814 $2,151,844 $18,995,907 $7,216,843 $14,912 $900 Arizona Department of Revenue, Office of Economic Research & Analysis, June 2017 Switcher Individual $0 $31,771 $0 $0 $205,168 $34,611 $189,228 $0 $201,587 $0 $0 $0 $37,780 $53,201 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $120,603 $884,398 $16,738 $0 $311,852 $32,953 $0 $247,222 $19,365 $67,196 $883,914 $1,421,124 $1,282,293 $1,533 $0 Low-Income Corporate $0 $0 $0 $0 $1,229,757 $71,709 $263,262 $1,750 $132,453 $0 $0 $0 $500 $0 $0 $0 $9,325 $0 $0 $33,319 $516,297 $0 $7,500 $908,373 $0 $0 $88,107 $34,750 $72,116 $681,792 $958,440 $1,408,536 $0 $0 Disabled/Displaced Corporate $0 $0 $0 $0 $4,628 $0 $9,065 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $43,804 $1,521 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $1,394,390 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $7,071 $21,957 $110,176 $2,250 $0 $0 Total Scholarships $38,633 $291,741 $6,333 $31,535 $3,967,244 $660,270 $1,746,471 $62,855 $2,608,323 $1,725 $2,484 $296,042 $262,327 $345,517 $172,644 $137,409 $12,525 $3,240 $563 $1,206,405 $5,447,874 $181,260 $40,618 $4,321,253 $195,862 $5,907 $1,752,651 $100,878 $603,197 $3,739,507 $21,485,647 $9,909,922 $16,445 $900 70 Table 13 Estimated Total Scholarships by Private School CY1998 - FY2016 Private School Olga and Bob Strauss Center for Early Childhood Development On-Track Academy Opincar Study Center Our Lady of Guadalupe Our Lady of Joy School Our Lady of Mt. Carmel School Our Lady of Perpetual Help Catholic School Our Lady of Perpetual Help Catholic School Our Lady of Sorrows Academy Our Lady of the Lake Our Mother of Sorrows Catholic School Our Savior's Lutheran School Our Saviour Lutheran School Outer Limits School Page Christian School Palm Valley Montessori Palms Christian School Palo Verde Christian School Paradise for Tots Christian Kindergarten Paradise Mountain Christian Academy Paradise Valley Christian Preparatory Pardes Jewish Day School Parker Apostolic Christian School Parkside Christian Learning Center Parkway Children's School of Excellence Patagonia Montessori Pathways School Pax Academy Payson Community Christian School Peace Lutheran Church School Pentecostal of Phoenix Christian Academy Peridot Lutheran Elementary Phillips Christian School Phoenix Christian Academy Original Individual $1,380 $194,161 $1,425 $157,428 $281,754 $4,920,921 $4,103,119 $5,514,126 $354,855 $221,985 $2,822,753 $95,069 $305,961 $781 $98,337 $245,438 $248,073 $363,368 $69,112 $139,332 $6,712,385 $6,479,796 $15,551 $3,324 $52,823 $67,069 $40,209 $14,830 $1,376,774 $63,095 $21,399 $98,558 $26,921 $70,257 Arizona Department of Revenue, Office of Economic Research & Analysis, June 2017 Switcher Individual $0 $101,437 $0 $18,430 $0 $466,425 $364,578 $498,583 $42,868 $42,268 $219,707 $10,766 $6,777 $0 $10,984 $107,290 $28,875 $0 $6,167 $0 $640,929 $755,096 $0 $1,296 $8,370 $0 $19,493 $0 $142,315 $0 $0 $10,022 $0 $0 Low-Income Corporate $14,382 $34,750 $0 $19,197 $14,273 $520,146 $1,756,739 $316,534 $238,661 $9,442 $1,462,708 $2,550 $4,985 $0 $17,697 $244,800 $43,975 $3,640 $2,500 $0 $418,413 $221,578 $8,326 $0 $0 $0 $0 $7,000 $250,720 $0 $0 $18,174 $0 $121,935 Disabled/Displaced Corporate $0 $201,713 $0 $0 $0 $950 $25,551 $1,914 $0 $0 $41,477 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $8,337 $0 $0 $0 $23,708 $6,000 $0 $0 $0 $0 $9,451 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 Total Scholarships $15,762 $532,061 $1,425 $195,055 $296,027 $5,908,442 $6,249,987 $6,331,157 $636,384 $273,695 $4,546,644 $108,385 $317,723 $781 $127,018 $597,527 $329,260 $367,008 $77,779 $139,332 $7,795,435 $7,462,470 $23,877 $4,620 $61,193 $67,069 $69,153 $21,830 $1,769,808 $63,095 $21,399 $126,755 $26,921 $192,192 71 Table 13 Estimated Total Scholarships by Private School CY1998 - FY2016 Private School Phoenix Christian Preparatory Schools Phoenix Christian School K-8 Phoenix Country Day School Phoenix Hebrew Academy Phoenix Preparatory High School for Boys Phoenix Preparatory High School for Girls Phoenix Rising Free School Phoenix, Special Programs and Academies Pieceful Solutions Pilgrim Lutheran School Pleasantview Christian Elementary Potter's House Precious Lamb Christian School Prescott Adventist Christian School Primavera School Primrose School at Palm Valley Primrose School of Fletcher Heights Promiseland Christian Preschool Providence Classical School Quality Interactive Montessori Queen of Peace Catholic School Rainbow Academy Rainbow Montessori Rancho Solano Schools Red Mountain Montessori Academy Red Rock Christian School Red Sands Christian School Redeemer Christian Academy (Southern) Redeemer Christian School (Stapley) Redeemer Lutheran School Resurrection Lutheran Child Development Center Rise & Shine Exceptional Services Risen Savior Lutheran School Rising Sun Montessori Original Individual $8,721,381 $1,776,054 $4,280,473 $7,648,059 $70,900 $88,850 $8,079 $4,669 $86,751 $701,613 $35,263 $13,826 $89,613 $217,023 $1,210,786 $27,973 $4,770 $0 $641,359 $197,821 $2,077,101 $191,766 $17,051 $3,428,888 $36,121 $83,621 $19,833 $84,922 $1,480,054 $2,266,646 $815,009 $11,640 $1,706,220 $1,615 Arizona Department of Revenue, Office of Economic Research & Analysis, June 2017 Switcher Individual $487,284 $241,210 $1,011,571 $903,870 $0 $0 $0 $0 $21,812 $52,553 $6,958 $0 $0 $8,793 $152,218 $0 $0 $0 $0 $114,196 $187,143 $0 $0 $324,296 $8,585 $0 $20,603 $0 $112,737 $230,600 $65,661 $4,060 $89,101 $0 Low-Income Corporate $3,433,651 $111,637 $3,920,158 $282,697 $0 $0 $0 $0 $28,900 $60 $97,205 $0 $8,925 $7,000 $67,585 $0 $0 $0 $4,534 $35,060 $651,904 $0 $0 $17,590 $0 $0 $143,431 $17,058 $62,289 $91,230 $6,772 $500 $3,650 $0 Disabled/Displaced Corporate $102,087 $15,328 $0 $500 $0 $0 $0 $0 $480,573 $0 $3,637 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $750 $0 $0 $6,125 $0 $0 $3,982 $1,000 $0 $0 $0 $4,152 $5,600 $0 $2,500 $0 $0 Total Scholarships $12,744,403 $2,144,229 $9,212,202 $8,835,126 $70,900 $88,850 $8,079 $4,669 $618,036 $754,226 $143,063 $13,826 $98,538 $232,816 $1,430,589 $27,973 $4,770 $750 $645,893 $347,077 $2,922,274 $191,766 $17,051 $3,774,756 $45,706 $83,621 $183,867 $101,980 $1,659,232 $2,594,076 $887,442 $18,700 $1,798,971 $1,615 72 Table 13 Estimated Total Scholarships by Private School CY1998 - FY2016 Private School River of Life Christian School Rose Garden School Running River School S A R R C Community School Sacred Heart Catholic School Sacred Heart School Safford Adventist Christian School Safford Christian Academy Saguaro Hills Adventist Christian School Saguaro Hills Christian School Sahuarita Christian Academy Salpointe Catholic High School San Francisco de Asis Catholic School San Miguel High School San Tan Christian Academy San Xavier Mission School Santa Cruz Catholic School Satori Scottsdale Christian Academy Scottsdale Country Day School Scottsdale United Methodist Co-Op Sedona Christian School Sedona Montessori Seton Catholic High School Shalom Montessori School Shearim Torah High School Sheila's Christian Academy "Minds in Motion" Shepherd of the Desert Lutheran School Shepherd's Christian Academy Sherwood Village Shiloh Christian School Show Low Adventist Christian School Sierra Academy of Scottsdale Skyway Christian School Original Individual $468,912 $540 $19,545 $239,178 $722,864 $5,145,251 $61,008 $238,031 $389,672 $326,468 $313,479 $16,638,538 $2,238,096 $2,669,126 $49,958 $3,539,627 $2,145,827 $924,745 $14,318,732 $44,572 $16,876 $86,615 $4,378 $10,315,382 $363,452 $844,755 $64,237 $2,215,197 $6,388 $25,802 $359,760 $4,699 $58,163 $11,680 Arizona Department of Revenue, Office of Economic Research & Analysis, June 2017 Switcher Individual $13,774 $0 $0 $38,570 $137,723 $478,550 $0 $1,243 $9,364 $0 $0 $1,920,188 $375,825 $548,480 $0 $333,245 $181,518 $71,844 $1,886,057 $2,115 $1,960 $0 $0 $979,062 $26,294 $166,550 $15,064 $465,754 $0 $0 $0 $0 $12,428 $0 Low-Income Corporate $323,405 $0 $1,250 $0 $585,380 $404,690 $0 $0 $121,597 $10,625 $384,878 $5,834,448 $502,548 $7,823,630 $9,400 $1,069,568 $3,507,046 $6,831 $2,774,830 $9,600 $1,725 $0 $0 $821,288 $104,461 $124,854 $0 $85,457 $0 $0 $2,821 $0 $0 $0 Disabled/Displaced Corporate $12,103 $0 $0 $24,505 $0 $0 $0 $0 $10,724 $0 $0 $69,631 $0 $2,100 $0 $14,319 $88,022 $5 $2,350 $0 $0 $0 $0 $10,335 $0 $0 $0 $1,971 $0 $0 $0 $0 $5 $0 Total Scholarships $818,194 $540 $20,795 $302,253 $1,445,967 $6,028,491 $61,008 $239,274 $531,357 $337,093 $698,357 $24,462,805 $3,116,469 $11,043,336 $59,358 $4,956,759 $5,922,413 $1,003,425 $18,981,968 $56,287 $20,561 $86,615 $4,378 $12,126,066 $494,207 $1,136,159 $79,302 $2,768,379 $6,388 $25,802 $362,581 $4,699 $70,596 $11,680 73 Table 13 Estimated Total Scholarships by Private School CY1998 - FY2016 Private School Son Life Christian School Sonoran International School SonRise Christian School Sonshine Christian School Sonshine Preschool Southwest Christian School Southwest Indian School Southwestern Christian School Spectrum Private School Spirit of Hope Montessori Spondeo Montessori Ss. Peter and Paul Catholic School Ss. Simon and Jude School St. Agnes Catholic School St. Alban's Pre-School & Kindergarten St. Ambrose School St. Andrew's Kindergarten St. Anne's Little Flower Montessori St. Anthony Catholic School St. Anthony of Padua Catholic School St. Augustine Catholic High School St. Catherine of Sienna Catholic School St. Charles Apache School St. Cyril Catholic School St. Daniel the Prophet School St. Dominic Savio Academy St. Elizabeth Ann Seton Catholic School St. Francis Kindergarten St. Francis of Assisi School St. Francis Xavier Elementary School St. Gregory Catholic School The Gregory School/St. Gregory College Preparatory St. James Preschool & Kindergarten St. Jerome K-8 School Original Individual $2,205 $11,781 $79,037 $74,502 $0 $307,989 $230 $2,439,815 $11,768 $161,512 $9,385 $3,438,372 $6,150,379 $3,567,183 $32,968 $2,470,230 $720,415 $769,870 $1,616,413 $1,985,427 $2,583,022 $3,512,354 $3,306,153 $3,765,639 $1,617,520 $176,534 $3,642,725 $2,740 $1,554,022 $5,372,998 $4,165,394 $5,884,651 $52,997 $2,692,277 Arizona Department of Revenue, Office of Economic Research & Analysis, June 2017 Switcher Individual $0 $0 $0 $7,565 $0 $0 $0 $201,918 $0 $7,354 $4,084 $342,565 $575,829 $262,122 $0 $266,435 $110,682 $0 $284,961 $245,342 $341,171 $233,424 $351,791 $447,077 $0 $16,183 $374,554 $0 $208,045 $661,659 $358,128 $866,293 $0 $301,948 Low-Income Corporate $0 $0 $0 $2,550 $0 $54,899 $0 $296,666 $0 $0 $0 $961,219 $1,852,372 $1,411,381 $3,550 $3,093,169 $19,724 $33,010 $628,275 $934,029 $2,461,278 $1,372,983 $391,393 $774,154 $84,044 $0 $945,129 $0 $1,074,078 $1,496,941 $1,821,184 $2,080,479 $0 $1,249,642 Disabled/Displaced Corporate $0 $0 $0 $0 $2,271 $0 $15,248 $8,073 $0 $0 $0 $10,018 $64,474 $0 $0 $40,482 $1,113 $0 $0 $15,300 $71,647 $7,779 $0 $14,467 $0 $97,030 $14,213 $0 $14,126 $5,851 $3,524 $21,878 $0 $299 Total Scholarships $2,205 $11,781 $79,037 $84,617 $2,271 $362,888 $15,478 $2,946,472 $11,768 $168,866 $13,469 $4,752,174 $8,643,054 $5,240,685 $36,518 $5,870,317 $851,934 $802,880 $2,529,649 $3,180,099 $5,457,118 $5,126,539 $4,049,337 $5,001,337 $1,701,564 $289,747 $4,976,620 $2,740 $2,850,271 $7,537,449 $6,348,230 $8,853,300 $52,997 $4,244,166 74 Table 13 Estimated Total Scholarships by Private School CY1998 - FY2016 Private School St. Joan of Arc Kindergarten St. John Bosco Catholic School St. John the Evangelist School St. John Vianney Catholic School St. Joseph Catholic School St. Joseph's Catholic Montessori School St. Louis the King Catholic School St. Luke's Lutheran School St. Luke's School St. Maria Goretti School St. Mark's Early Childhood Center St. Mark's Preschool & Kindergarten St. Mary Basha Catholic Elementary School St. Mary's Catholic High School St. Mary's High School St. Matthew School St. Maximilian Mary Kolbe School St. Michael Indian School St. Michael's Parish Day School St. Odilia St. Paul Lutheran School St. Paul's Preparatory Academy St. Peter Mission School St. Peter's Montessori St. John XXIII Catholic School St. Theresa Elementary School St. Thomas Aquinas School St. Thomas Lutheran School St. Thomas the Apostle Catholic Pre-School & Kindergarten St. Thomas the Apostle Catholic School St. Timothy Catholic Academy (Alma School) St. Timothy Catholic School St. Vincent de Paul School Stone Creek Christian Kindergarten Original Individual $168,407 $4,831,293 $2,845,196 $4,617,235 $2,202,960 $2,029,623 $3,553,432 $9,951 $192,955 $886,044 $177,030 $324,900 $6,878,463 $1,208,808 $15,255,168 $4,336,290 $587,634 $2,846,826 $4,788,027 $187,405 $39,087 $1,197,014 $2,808,053 $373,209 $4,304,697 $4,405,372 $4,227,688 $101,149 $42,190 $4,848,331 $2,885,701 $597,539 $4,334,674 $1,598 Arizona Department of Revenue, Office of Economic Research & Analysis, June 2017 Switcher Individual $0 $569,613 $217,027 $374,685 $202,317 $348,586 $277,984 $0 $0 $83,374 $27,637 $24,417 $618,251 $0 $1,725,924 $441,441 $10,206 $301,471 $616,950 $0 $0 $0 $303,222 $87,711 $479,543 $478,498 $513,767 $0 $4,546 $486,309 $101,398 $298,770 $287,265 $0 Low-Income Corporate $0 $438,014 $4,805,643 $1,413,737 $1,122,687 $651,637 $2,290,940 $0 $0 $34,656 $10,668 $40,223 $497,499 $2,008,963 $8,623,450 $1,740,462 $44,688 $407,890 $450,049 $0 $0 $0 $866,361 $8,015 $208,370 $311,929 $245,062 $0 $27,192 $276,780 $206,139 $35,337 $1,381,242 $0 Disabled/Displaced Corporate $0 $1,883 $34,077 $58,352 $32,278 $7,500 $20,670 $0 $0 $5,500 $500 $0 $750 $0 $21,520 $0 $0 $0 $10,279 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $1,240 $15 $0 $0 $0 $1,735 $0 $0 $11,125 $0 Total Scholarships $168,407 $5,840,802 $7,901,943 $6,464,009 $3,560,242 $3,037,346 $6,143,026 $9,951 $192,955 $1,009,574 $215,835 $389,540 $7,994,963 $3,217,771 $25,626,062 $6,518,193 $642,528 $3,556,187 $5,865,305 $187,405 $39,087 $1,197,014 $3,977,636 $468,935 $4,993,850 $5,195,814 $4,986,517 $101,149 $73,928 $5,613,155 $3,193,238 $931,646 $6,014,306 $1,598 75 Table 13 Estimated Total Scholarships by Private School CY1998 - FY2016 Private School Summit School of Ahwatukee Sun and Shield Christian Academy Sun Valley Indian School Sun Valley Learning Center (Bethany Learning Center) Sunrise Montessori School Suriya Montesori Surrey Garden Christian School Sylvan Learning Center Tanque Verde Lutheran Preschool/Kindergarten Tatum Ranchette Montessori Tempe Adventist Christian School Tempe Christian School Tempe Montessori Tesseract School The Angel's Academy The Beginning School The Caepe School The Family School The French American School of Arizona The Goddard School The IDEA School The Jones-Gordon School The Learning Lab The Learning Pad The Orme School The Scottsdale School The Vine Preparatory Academy The Weekday School The Wiser Choice Thunderbird Adventist Academy Thunderbird Christian Elementary School Torah Day School of Phoenix Tree of Life Christian School Tri-City Christian Academy Original Individual $2,994,232 $364,324 $166,536 $596,505 $437,039 $563 $3,718,332 $1,440 $515,930 $22,135 $154,464 $197,715 $618,458 $2,009,836 $4,357 $142,077 $195,541 $1,406,688 $55,404 $31,988 $35,773 $121,356 $26,336 $47,991 $1,593,518 $0 $6,130 $11,318 $3,897 $2,476,861 $779,918 $1,182,927 $33,423 $4,190,354 Arizona Department of Revenue, Office of Economic Research & Analysis, June 2017 Switcher Individual $575,091 $1,174 $25,275 $22,154 $40,289 $0 $0 $0 $32,569 $0 $0 $0 $55,214 $255,881 $0 $21,041 $36,485 $232,368 $19,583 $15,707 $18,251 $107,480 $4,315 $16,775 $146,239 $950 $6,670 $0 $0 $102,442 $53,156 $1,336,690 $0 $361,512 Low-Income Corporate $31,062 $39,833 $95,260 $59,477 $1,360 $0 $60,985 $0 $12,790 $0 $0 $0 $64,160 $228,641 $76 $550 $152,125 $0 $0 $0 $9,585 $18,250 $2,200 $17,290 $10 $0 $35,400 $0 $3,365 $68,104 $12,960 $1,501,971 $0 $586,410 Disabled/Displaced Corporate $6,000 $2,250 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $800 $14,928 $0 $0 $3,821 $0 $0 $0 $8,791 $121,743 $7,700 $2,221 $4,184 $0 $0 $0 $0 $3,982 $6,950 $22,385 $0 $18,267 Total Scholarships $3,606,385 $407,581 $287,071 $678,136 $478,688 $563 $3,779,317 $1,440 $561,288 $22,135 $154,464 $197,715 $738,632 $2,509,286 $4,433 $163,668 $387,972 $1,639,056 $74,986 $47,694 $72,400 $368,830 $40,551 $84,277 $1,743,951 $950 $48,200 $11,318 $7,262 $2,651,388 $852,984 $4,043,973 $33,423 $5,156,544 76 Table 13 Estimated Total Scholarships by Private School CY1998 - FY2016 Private School Tri-City Jewish Community Center Day School Trinity Christian School Trinity Christian School (M) Trinity Christian School (P) Trinity Classical Academy Trinity Classical and Christian Academy Trinity Kindergarten Trinity Lutheran School Trinity United Methodist Kindergarten Truly Free School Truthful Beginnings Tucson Baptist Academy Tucson Community School Tucson Hebrew Academy Tucson Jewish Community Center Tucson Waldorf School Turning Point School Tutor Time PreSchool & Kindergarten Valley Baptist School Valley Cathedral Christian School Valley Child Care & Learning Center Valley Christian High School Valley Classical Christian Academy Valley Lutheran High School Valley of the Sun Jewish Community Center School Verde Valley Adventist School Verde Valley Christian School Verde Valley School Veritas Academy of Tucson Veritas Christian Community School Victorious Preschool & Kindergarten Village Christian School Ville de Marie Academy Vision Christian Academy Original Individual $300,794 $1,172,924 $235,798 $1,969,740 $563 $151,899 $178,602 $3,328,344 $220,691 $6,145 $6,106 $169,138 $566,762 $6,527,928 $120,821 $1,244,572 $382,031 $3,500 $38,741 $334,046 $6,638 $13,554,073 $1,006,816 $3,840,231 $106,600 $160,813 $2,038,886 $607,356 $511,729 $2,034,095 $45,880 $19,911 $1,549,934 $221,876 Arizona Department of Revenue, Office of Economic Research & Analysis, June 2017 Switcher Individual $0 $0 $32,809 $435,624 $0 $0 $3,840 $296,326 $21,654 $2,010 $0 $59,052 $31,153 $952,289 $0 $276,541 $0 $0 $4,576 $0 $0 $1,270,871 $0 $426,624 $0 $800 $293,991 $16,680 $187,935 $331,538 $1,423 $4,089 $237,153 $23,944 Low-Income Corporate $0 $115,068 $87,072 $548,215 $0 $0 $0 $122,370 $71,225 $0 $0 $67,587 $64,606 $1,182,139 $53,073 $865,125 $10,100 $3,500 $0 $0 $0 $2,318,683 $17,592 $218,743 $0 $0 $319,664 $29,000 $257,711 $221,670 $6,105 $0 $115,015 $42,727 Disabled/Displaced Corporate $0 $0 $0 $5,392 $0 $0 $0 $3,628 $2,271 $0 $0 $0 $0 $500 $0 $32,772 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $40,841 $0 $6,415 $0 $0 $42,711 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $2,900 $0 Total Scholarships $300,794 $1,287,992 $355,680 $2,958,970 $563 $151,899 $182,442 $3,750,668 $315,842 $8,155 $6,106 $295,778 $662,521 $8,662,857 $173,894 $2,419,011 $392,131 $7,000 $43,317 $334,046 $6,638 $17,184,467 $1,024,408 $4,492,013 $106,600 $161,613 $2,695,252 $653,036 $957,374 $2,587,303 $53,408 $24,000 $1,905,001 $288,547 77 Table 13 Estimated Total Scholarships by Private School CY1998 - FY2016 Private School Wellspring Education Center West Side Private School West Valley Adventist School West Valley Christian School Western Hills Baptist School Westminster Academy White Mountain Christian School White Mountain Montessori School Wickenburg Christian Academy (Legacy High) Wings on Words Woodbridge Private School Word International Christian School Word of Grace School for Young Children Word of Life Christian School Xavier College Preparatory Yeshiva High School Yeshiva High School of Arizona Young Disciples Christian Academy Yuma Adventist School Yuma Catholic High School Yuma Lutheran School Original Individual TOTALS $12,610 $16,101 $35,403 $1,229,647 $9,100 $4,984 $3,426 $149,942 $1,077,323 $82,290 $18,252 $15,824 $18,503 $40,829 $13,975,106 $355,834 $301,785 $14,509 $210,951 $4,626,500 $3,362,168 $657,500,700 Arizona Department of Revenue, Office of Economic Research & Analysis, June 2017 Switcher Individual $0 $0 $0 $187,988 $0 $0 $0 $14,807 $222,171 $18,014 $6,305 $2,090 $0 $3,165 $1,940,343 $1,025 $119,341 $5,225 $19,301 $473,289 $488,565 $75,026,601 Low-Income Corporate $0 $0 $0 $443,826 $0 $0 $0 $0 $408,556 $5,815 $0 $6,829 $0 $0 $3,108,406 $50,160 $62,246 $9,500 $27,989 $5,226,277 $745,892 $160,080,736 Disabled/Displaced Corporate $0 $0 $0 $48,653 $0 $0 $0 $0 $7,256 $24,639 $0 $0 $0 $0 $17,211 $0 $0 $0 $0 $17,836 $66,844 $12,311,419 Total Scholarships $12,610 $16,101 $35,403 $1,910,115 $9,100 $4,984 $3,426 $164,749 $1,715,307 $130,758 $24,557 $24,743 $18,503 $43,994 $19,041,066 $407,019 $483,372 $29,234 $258,241 $10,343,902 $4,663,470 $904,919,456 78