Background Report of Target Areas In Phoenix, Tempe, and Mesa, Arizona For use in the development of a Sustainable Communities and Transit Oriented Development Public Education Project Prepared for The Arizona Department of Housing Prepared by Drachman Institute College of Architecture and Landscape Architecture The University of Arizona Tucson, Arizona July 2011 Updates May 2012 2 Central and Camelback, Phoenix Background Report of Target Areas In Phoenix, Tempe, and Mesa, Arizona For use in the development of a Sustainable Communities and Transit Oriented Development Public Education Project Prepared for The Arizona Department of Housing By Bill Mackey, RA Chris Sharp, Graduate Student Kayla Truss, Architecture Student David Corcoran, Graduate Student Erin Besold, Graduate Student Kelly Eitzen Smith, PhD, Sociologist Marilyn Robinson, Project Director Drachman Institute College of Architecture and Landscape Architecture The University of Arizona, Tucson, Arizona R. Brooks Jeffery, Director Marilyn Robinson, Associate Director The Drachman Institute is the research-based outreach arm of the College of Architecture and Landscape Architecture (CALA) at The University of Arizona. The Institute is dedicated to environmentally-sensitive and resource-conscious planning and design with a focus on underserved and vulnerable communities. As an interdisciplinary collaborative, we engage students, staff, faculty, and citizens to work towards making our communities healthier, safer, more equitable, and more beautiful places to live. We embrace a service-learning model of education serving the needs of communities while providing an outreach experience for students. This model is a fundamental educational goal consistent with the mission of CALA and The University of Arizona. The Drachman Institute acts as a nexus between community needs and the College’s skills and knowledge in architecture, landscape architecture, and planning with a specific focus on sustainable affordable housing, design-build, community and neighborhood planning, and historic preservation. All photos, renderings, drawings, charts, GIS layers, or other content were generated by Drachman Institute staff and students unless otherwise noted. Electronic files have been provided by Maricopa Association of Governments and Metro Light Rail. The contents of this report reflect the views of Drachman Institute which is responsible for the facts and accuracy of the data presented herein. The contents do not necessarily reflect the official views or policies of METRO or MAG and have not been approved or endorsed by them. 3 4 Apache and McClintock, Tempe TABLE OF CONTENTS I INTRODUCTION 7 II RESEARCH AND METHODOLOGY 9 III THE SITES PHOENIX CENTRAL & CAMELBACK 11 CENTRAL & OSBORN 37 CENTRAL & THOMAS 63 CENTRAL & McDOWELL 89 WASHINGTON & 12TH 115 TEMPE APACHE & McCLINTOCK 141 APACHE & PRICE 167 MESA IV MAIN & SYCAMORE RESOURCES 193 219 5 6 Sycamore and Main, Mesa I. INTRODUCTION This report provides base information on the square half mile area surrounding sites selected by the Arizona Department of Housing (ADOH) and the Sustainable Communities Working Group (SCWG). The eight sites are transit stops for the Valley Metro light rail line in the cities of Phoenix, Tempe, and Mesa. PHOENIX CENTRAL & CAMELBACK 11 CENTRAL & OSBORN 37 CENTRAL & THOMAS 63 CENTRAL & McDOWELL 89 WASHINGTON & 12TH 115 TEMPE APACHE & McCLINTOCK 141 APACHE & PRICE 167 MESA MAIN & SYCAMORE 193 Contents: Description and Impressions Photographs Stakeholder Information Location Map Market/Demographic Information Aerial Image Parcel Map Building Footprints Zoning Proposed/Future Zoning Land Use Residential Single Family Housing Multi-Family Housing 7 Retail Office Religious Medical Educational Civic / Cultural (Police, Fire, Library, Museum, Government Facilities) Plaza/park/open space Warehouse Surface parking Structured parking Vacant Historic Districts and Properties Political and Neighborhood Boundaries Landmarks and Natural/Man-made Features Transportation and Circulation Floodplain and Environmental Ownership Vacant Land and Parking Business Districts and Development Organizations 8 Events and Temporary Installations Utilities and Planned Public Improvements Housing and Transportation Affordability Median Household Income Housing and Transportation Costs Housing Costs Transportation Costs Transit Ridership Household Transportation Cost Vehicle Miles Traveled per Household Travel Time to Work II. RESEARCH AND METHODOLOGY The Drachman Institute began work on this project in May 2011. The first task was to understand the sites on a physical, political, social, and cultural level. Site visits May 19, 2011 – A visit to the Phoenix light rail station areas. The visit included a walk around each selected light rail station followed by a meeting with the City of Phoenix Planning and Housing staff, and staff from Metro Light Rail. June 13, 2011 - A visit to the station at Sycamore and Main in Mesa. The visit included a drive-by of the entire area preceded by a meeting with the City of Mesa Planning, Housing, Transportation, and Economic Development staff. June 23, 2011 - A visit to the Tempe light rail station areas and a meeting with City of Tempe Planning and Housing staff. July 01, 2011 - A return visit to the Phoenix, Tempe, and Mesa sites. Drive-by investigations verifying land use and circulation (bus stops, pedestrian crossings). Additional visits were made after July 2011 for updates. Resources Aerial and map online review GIS analysis and documentation Discussions with Special interest groups Organizations Associations City staff 9 Online review of Special interest groups Organizations Associations This report represents the information obtained during this discovery process. The purpose of this base information report is to provide a comprehensive picture of the target areas to be followed by a series of outreach activities and events to help area residents become more informed participants in development decisions that will impact them. 10 Central & Camelback Description and Impressions 12 Photographs 13 Stakeholder Information 14 Location Map 15 Market/Demographic Information 16 Aerial Image 17 Parcel Map 18 Building Footprint 19 Zoning 20 Proposed/Future Zoning 21 Land Use 22 Historic Districts and Properties 23 Political and Neighborhood Boundaries 24 Landmarks and Natural/Man-made Features 25 Transportation and Circulation 26 Floodplain and Environmental 27 Ownership 28 Vacant Land and Parking 29 Business Districts and Development Organizations 30 Events and Temporary Installations 31 Utilities and Planned Public Improvements 32 Housing and Transportation Affordability 33 11 Central and Camelback Description and Impressions Colloquially known as the “4 Corners,” this is a mixed-use area; there is residential, retail, and office use located in the half-mile area surrounding the light rail stop. Located at the intersection of Camelback and Central is an L-shaped strip mall with little vacancy, a 12-story office tower, vacant land, and small businesses on individual lots. Further east and west along Camelback is a continuation of businesses located in single buildings on single parcels. Some businesses have recently remodeled their structures and added site landscaping; other businesses have abandoned the properties and left the buildings vacant. The properties immediately surrounding this commercial activity are single-family residential. Further out is a continuation of the residential and the large land holdings of Brophy and Xavier College 12 Preparatory schools to the south. The immediate area is deficient of public facilities - there is no library, school, or park located within the 1/2 mile area. The area immediately adjacent to the light rail stop is not pedestrian friendly. Narrow sidewalks are placed at the edge of the streets with very fast automobile traffic. In order to cross Camelback at 3rd Avenue as a pedestrian, it is necessary to activate a crossing light; otherwise the light is too short to safely cross. The businesses located within the half-mile area offer a variety of goods and services – banking, restaurants, drive-thru coffee, a large chain grocery store, art supplies, and barber shops to name a few. The immediate area has at least four active historic neighborhood organizations. A majority of the housing is one story single-family with well-maintained landscaping. Camelback looking west towards 3rd Avenue Pierson Place Historic District sign, Southwest corner of Camelback and 3rd Avenue 13 Medlock Drive, looking east Camelback looking north at 3rd Avenue Parking Lot at northeast corner of Central and Camelback Pasedena Avenue, looking south Central and Camelback Photographs Stakeholders The following is a list of individuals or groups to contact to participate in planning or other events for the half mile area surrounding the light rail stop. The list was created through searches on the internet and conversations with city of Phoenix staff. City Offices Alhambra City Village Planning Committee City of Phoenix Historic Preservation Office City Council District 4 Business Groups and Individuals Windsor Square Conservation District Windsor Square Special Planning District Pierson Residents Development Oversight Medlock Business Group Phoenix Community Alliance CAN-DO 14 Coalition of East Phoenix Sunbelt Holdings Wayne Howard Reid Butler Neighborhood Associations St. Francis Neighborhood Association Windsor Square Historic Neighborhood Pierson Place Historic Neighborhood Medlock Place Neighborhood Association Brophy Concerned Neighborhoods Colter Street Alliance Central Park North Schools and Churches Brophy Preparatory School Xavier Preparatory School Central and Camelback Stakeholders 15 Phoenix Tempe Mesa north light rail stop Central and Camelback Location Map 16 north City of Phoenix Census Tract 1075 / 1088.2 Population 1,536,632 Median Household Income $47,085 Homeowner Occupied 59.1% Renter Occupied 40.9% Public Transportation Use 3.2% Personal Vehicle Use 74.5% Travel Time 24.2 4,403 / 2,292 $65,743 / $29,077 68.2% / 24.8% 31.8% / 75.2% 7.7% / 11.5% 72.1% / 67.9% 20.5 / 22.7 2009 American Community Survey 2005-2009 American Community Survey 5-year Estimates Central and Camelback Demographics 1/2 mile area 1075 1088.2 2nd St 1st St CENTRAL 1st Ave 3rd Ave E Oregon E Colter E Orange E Medlock E Pasedena CAMELBACK E Mariposa E Pierson 17 E Elm E Highland E Coolidge light rail stop north light rail one quarter mile Central and Camelback Aerial 2nd St 1st St CENTRAL 1st Ave 3rd Ave E Oregon E Colter E Orange E Medlock E Pasedena CAMELBACK E Mariposa E Pierson 18 E Elm E Highland E Coolidge light rail stop north light rail one quarter Central and Camelback Parcel Map mile 2nd St 1st St CENTRAL 1st Ave 3rd Ave E Oregon E Colter E Orange E Medlock E Pasedena CAMELBACK E Mariposa E Pierson 19 E Elm E Highland E Coolidge light rail stop light rail north structures one quarter mile Central and Camelback Building Footprint C-1 2nd St 1st St CENTRAL 1st Ave 3rd Ave C-O R1-3 R1-10 E Oregon P-1 R1-6 E Colter P-1 E Orange R-3 R-4 E Medlock E Pasedena P-1 C-2 P-1 CAMELBACK C-2 HR R-5 P-1 P-1 P-1 R-3 P-1 E Mariposa R-3 20 R-3 R-5 R-5 HR R-5 E Pierson C-2 HR C-2 E Elm R1-6 P-1 E Highland R-5 E Coolidge Source: City of Phoenix Planning Department. September 2011 commercial residential light rail C-O R1-10 For information on Phoenix zoning and overlay descriptions, see pg 222. C-1 R1-6 C-2 R-3 C-2 HR R-4 overlays R-5 historic zone R-5 HR TOD-1 parking north light rail stop one quarter Central and Camelback Zoning mile P-1 2nd St 1st St CENTRAL 1st Ave 3rd Ave E Oregon E Colter E Orange E Medlock E Pasedena CAMELBACK E Mariposa E Pierson 21 E Elm E Highland E Coolidge Information obtained through internet searches and conversations with City of Phoenix staff According to current data, there is no proposed rezoning for this area. light rail stop north light rail one quarter mile Central and Camelback Proposed / Future Zoning 2nd St 1st St CENTRAL 1st Ave 3rd Ave E Oregon E Colter E Orange E Medlock E Pasedena CAMELBACK E Mariposa E Pierson 22 E Elm E Highland E Coolidge Drachman Institute. June 2011. surface parking light rail stop light rail structured parking residential - single family housing vacant residential - multifamily housing civic/cultural office north plaza/park/open space retail one quarter Central and Camelback Land Use mile medical educational religious 2nd St 1st St CENTRAL 1st Ave 3rd Ave E Oregon E Colter E Orange E Medlock E Pasedena CAMELBACK E Mariposa E Pierson 23 E Elm E Highland E Coolidge Information obtained through internet searches and conversations with City of Phoenix staff light rail stop light rail Medlock Place - local and national district Windsor Square - local and national district Modifications to structures located within Local Historic Districts require review by City of Phoenix planning staff. Modifications to structures located within National Historic Districts may or may not require review by the State Historic Preservation Office. north Pierson Place - local district Brophy College Temple - national district Brophy College Temple - individual listing one quarter mile Central and Camelback Historic Districts and Properties 2nd St 1st St CENTRAL 1st Ave 3rd Ave E Oregon E Colter E Orange E Medlock E Pasedena CAMELBACK E Mariposa E Pierson 24 E Elm E Highland E Coolidge Information obtained through internet searches and conversations with City of Phoenix staff Entire half mile area includes: light rail stop City of Phoenix Council District 4 light rail Maricopa County District 3 Pierson Place Neighborhood Association Alhambra City Village Planning District St Francis Neighborhood Association north Windsor Square District Medlock Place one mile Central and Camelback Political and Neighborhood Boundaries Colter Street Alliance Central Park North 2nd St 1st St CENTRAL 1st Ave 3rd Ave E Oregon E Colter E Orange E Medlock E Pasedena CAMELBACK E Mariposa E Pierson 25 E Elm St Francis Xavier Grade School Brophy College Preparatory light rail stop light rail E Highland Xavier College Preparatory E Coolidge Additional landmarks may be added through various activities to be held in the area. school shopping center north religious/church one quarter mile Central and Camelback Landmarks and Natural / Man-made Features 2nd St 1st St CENTRAL 1st Ave 3rd Ave E Oregon E Colter E Orange E Medlock E Pasedena CAMELBACK E Mariposa E Pierson 26 E Elm E Highland E Coolidge Drachman Institute. June 2011. traffic signal light rail stop light rail plazas/parks/open space striped pedestrian crossing surface parking bicycle structured parking north bus route streets one quarter Central and Camelback Transportation and Circulation mile sheltered bus stop unsheltered bus stop 2nd St 1st St CENTRAL 1st Ave 3rd Ave E Oregon E Colter E Orange E Medlock E Pasedena CAMELBACK E Mariposa E Pierson 27 E Elm E Highland E Coolidge Information obtained through internet searches and conversations with City of Phoenix staff light rail stop light rail There are no known floodplains or environmental sites other than what is indicated. floodplain 10 year floodplain 100 year north brownfield site landfill recycling center waste center This page last revised November 30, 2012 one quarter mile Central and Camelback Floodplain and Environmental 2nd St 1st St CENTRAL 1st Ave 3rd Ave E Oregon E Colter E Orange E Medlock E Pasedena CAMELBACK E Mariposa E Pierson 28 E Elm E Highland E Coolidge Source: Maricopa County Assessor’s Office. July 2011. light rail stop light rail private individual private LLC - multiple owners north private LLC - individual owner City of Phoenix one quarter Central and Camelback Ownership mile private multiple holdings religious contiguously owned properties 2nd St 1st St CENTRAL 1st Ave 3rd Ave E Oregon E Colter E Orange E Medlock E Pasedena CAMELBACK E Mariposa E Pierson 29 E Elm E Highland E Coolidge Drachman Institute. June 2011. light rail stop light rail vacant land surface parking north structured parking one quarter mile Central and Camelback Vacant and Parking 2nd St 1st St CENTRAL 1st Ave 3rd Ave E Oregon E Colter E Orange E Medlock E Pasedena CAMELBACK E Mariposa E Pierson 30 E Elm E Highland E Coolidge Information obtained through internet searches and conversations with City of Phoenix staff Entire half mile area includes: light rail stop Phoenix Communities United light rail Phoenix Community Alliance Pierson Residents Development Oversight Committee CAN-DO Windsor Square Conservation District Windsor Square Special Planning District north Coalition of East Phoenix Medlock Business Group one quarter mile Central and Camelback Business Districts and Development Organizations 2nd St 1st St CENTRAL 1st Ave 3rd Ave E Oregon E Colter E Orange E Medlock E Pasedena CAMELBACK E Mariposa E Pierson 31 E Elm E Highland E Coolidge Information obtained through internet searches and conversations with City of Phoenix staff light rail According to current data, there are no known temporary installations or events in this area. The Avenue Street Fair occurs 1/2 mile east of the station. north light rail stop one quarter mile Central and Camelback Events and Temporary Installations 2nd St 1st St CENTRAL 1st Ave 3rd Ave E Oregon E Colter E Orange E Medlock E Pasedena CAMELBACK E Mariposa E Pierson 32 E Elm E Highland E Coolidge Source: City of Phoenix Water Services Department. September 2011. This map includes: light rail stop water and wastewater utility lines light rail north water wastewater one quarter mile Central and Camelback Utilities and Planned Public Improvements Xavier College Parker Row N 10th Pl N 11th Pl N 11th Pl N 11th Pl N 10th Way N 11thNPl11th St N Mitchell St N 11th St N 11th StN 11th St N 9th Pl N 10th Pl N 11th Pl N 11th St N 10th Pl N 8th St N 10th Pl N 11th St N 11th St al E Turney Ave Central and Camelback E Glenrosa Ave Housing and Transportation Affordability t E Montecito Ave W Glenrosa Ave E Midway St dC an E Devonshire Ave t N 11th Pl N 4 ro s Gr an N 10th S te Data Not Available Less than 45% 45% and Greater E Campbell Ave E Roma Ave t on e M N 2nd Dr N W N 10th Way N 11th St N 11th St t N 10th S N 8th St N 8th St N 9th St N 8th Pl N 7th St N Central Ave N 2nd Ave N 5th Ave N 1st Ave W Roma Ave N 11th St N 10th Pl N 9th St N 8th Pl N 8th St N 5th St N 4th St N 5th St N N5th 6thStSt N 6th St Target Area58.13% LightE Rail Minnezona Ave Stop Map and Data from Center for Neighborhood Technology www.cnt.org. May 2012. Maps and data from the Center for Neighborhood Technology (CNT) using Regional Moderate data as this target area has a W Turney Ave median income which is less than 80% of the regional median. For W Montecito Ave an explanation of their methods 49.68% and data as well as links to their N/A website, see pgs 225-226. 57.35% W Glenrosa Ave www.cnt.org E Elm St N 11th St N 2nd Dr N Valerie Pl E Mitchell Dr E Mitchell Dr E Meadowbrook Ave Grand Canal W Minnezona Ave N 8th Pl W Hazelwood St 44.67% E Whitton Ave N 5th St E Mitchell Dr a H+T Costs, % Income E Weldon Ave% Income 55.7 Target Area, Average 63.2 Phoenix E Whitton Ave 66.2 Maricopa County College Rd E Weldon Ave E Weldon Ave E Highland Ave E Highland Ave N 4th St E Columbus Ave W Coolidge St N 3rd St N 2nd Ave W Highland Ave W Campbell Ave Shodes Cir N 3rd St N 2nd St N 3rd Ave W Weldon Ave 53.38% sr Grand C E Pierson St $31,013E Elm St E Clarendon Ave 45.44% E Weldon Ave E Pierson St dC an l Housing and Transportation Cost E Denton Ln E Turney Ave as a Percentage of Income E Vermont Ave E Montecito Ave H+T has58.07% been developed as Ave E Glenrosa a more complete measure of E Oregon Ave affordability beyond the standard E Colter St Ave E Devonshire method of assessing only Housing E Orange Dr Costs. It takes into account both the cost of housing as well as the 46.53% cost of transportation associated with the location of the home. E Camelback Rd E Amelia Ave CNT has defined an affordable Ave as the combined rangeE Fairmount for H+T costs consuming no more than E Indianola Ave E Pierson St 45% of 47.52% income. N 8th St N 1st Ave t $42,232 N 1st St N 4th Ave E P as adenaRd E Indian School Ave nd S N2 N 6th Ave Scattergood 4th Ave NW W N $31,337 E Orange Dr E Mariposa St E Indianola Ave W Pierson St W Whitton Av e 61.00% Parker Row E Orange Dr W Mariposa St nola Ave W India 44.04% E Oregon Ave E Medlock Dr W Amelia Ave W Camelback Rd W Elm St N/A an N 6th St e Av NW h 6t e Av W Monterosa St W Medlock Dr W Pasadena Ave W Indian School Rd W Clarendon Ave N 6th Ave E Midway St Redwine St 45.29% ve N 2nd St W Colter St a e Av N 6th Dr h 4t ro s N 2nd Ave te N h 5t d W In la A iano E Oregan Ave W Glenrosa Ave 62.34% N 2nd Dr on E Georgia Ave W Glenrosa Ave Ave W Oregon N 3rd Ave N 7th Ave M N Fountain Cir $46,818 $60,852 N W N Fountain Cir W Montecito AveW Georgia Ave N 1st Ave N 1st Ave N 5th Ave N 8th Ave Turney Ave W VermontW Ave N 1st Dr Roma Ave W Missouri Ave E Missouri Map and DataWfrom Center for Neighborhood Technology www.cnt.org. MayAve 2012. N 6th St N 6th St N 3rd St N 2nd St N Central Ave N 2nd Dr E Marshall Ave Data Not Available Target Area Light Rail Less 32,000 $/year E Meadowbrook Ave Stop St 32,000 to 42,000 $/year h E San Juan Ave $51,912 E San Juan Ave 6t N E Minnezona Ave 42,000 to 53,000 $/year E Luke Ave 53,000 to Ave 69,000 $/year E Campbell 69,000 G$/year and greater E Roma Ave r $18,175 N la Plaza Cir N 2nd Ave Grand Canal N 1st St N Valerie Pl N 4th Ave W Marshall Ave N 1st Ave N 5th Ln N 5th Ave N 4th St W San Juan Ave Ave W Minnezona N 4th St W Hazelwood St W San Juan Ave sr Grand C W Marshall Ave College Rd E Highland Ave W Coolidge St W Campbell Ave N 10th St $40,481 W Highland Ave www.cnt.org Median Household Income Income, $ $34,299 57,868 Target Area, Average E Elm St 54,791 Phoenix 61,016 Maricopa County E Highland Ave E Elm St N 10th St E Pierson St N 5th St $42,443 E Pierson St E Pierson St N 10th St N 1st St W Elm St W Luke Ave N 11th St N 5th St N 3rd St E Mariposa St W Pierson St N 11th St E Camelback Rd t W Mariposa St N 11th St N 8th St nd S N2 W Camelback Rd $21,449 Ave N 9th St E P as adena N 10th Pl E Medlock Dr W Pasadena Ave N 8th St N 3rd Ave E Orange Dr N 6th St $23,304 E Orange Dr W Medlock Dr N 10th St W Colter St $79,939 N 9th St $68,608 E Oregon Ave N 8th Pl E Oregan Ave E Denton Ln Median Household E Vermont Ave $57,500 Income Median household income E Oregon Ave includes the income of the E Colter St householder and all other E Orange individuals 15Dryears old and over in the household, whether they $26,359 are related to the householder or not. This value represents the median income within a block group. N 9th St E Georgia Ave N 2nd St W Oregon Ave N 3rd St N 2nd St N 1st St N 1st Dr W Georgia Ave N 1st Ave N 1st Ave N 7th Ave N 5th Ave N 8th Ave W Vermont Ave E Missouri Ave N Fountain Cir N Fountain Cir W Missouri Ave E Luke Ave N 4t E Marshall Ave N 6th St N 6th St W Marshall Ave N la Plaza Cir N 5th Ln N 4th Ave W Marshall Ave 33 nd S N2 N 1st St N 5th St St h E San Juan Ave 6t E Meadowbrook Ave N N 6th St N 6th St N 5th St N 4th St N 4th St N 3rd St N 2nd St N 1st St EM N 2nd Dr N Valerie Pl N 8th Pl N 9th St N 7th St N 8th St N 8th St 24.00% E Highland E Weldon Av E Whitton Ave E Meadowbrook Ave Grand Canal E Mitchell Dr N 8th Pl E Weldon Ave N 8th St N 6th St College E Clarendon Ave Rd E Highland Ave N 8th St N 5th St N 6th St N 5th St E Elm St N 5th St E Mitchell Dr N 4th St N 3rd St N 2nd St W Minnezona Ave E Mitc EM N Central Ave W Roma Ave N 2nd Ave Map and Data from Center for Neighborhood Technology www.cnt.org. May 2012. N 1st Ave N 5th Ave Shodes Cir Redwine E Columbus Ave W Whitton Av e W Hazelwood St W Campbell Ave 29.93% N/A E Weldon Ave E Ame E Pierson St E Pierson St N 4th St N 4th Ave N 2nd Ave W HighlandWAve Weldon Ave sr Grand C E Camelback Rd N 8th St N Fountain Cir N Central Ave 28.11% N 3rd St N 2nd Dr N 2nd Ave N 6th Ave N 6th Ave N 3rd Ave N 1st St E Indianola Ave E Pierson St W Coolidge St N/A Ave E Indian School Rd E Mariposa St e W Pierson St nola Av W India N/A E P as adena t W Amelia Ave W Mariposa St 28.50% 30.25% e Dr E Orang Parker Row E Medlock Dr Scattergood W N 4th Ave NW W Pasadena Ave W Indian School Rd W Camelback Rd W Clarendon Ave N/A nd S N2 e Av NW h 6t e Av e Av 27.80% St Dr E Midway E Orange W Medlock Dr W Monterosa St St E Montecito E Oregon Ave W Glenrosa Ave N 1st Ave h 4t a N 3rd Ave N ro s E Oregan Ave E Rom N 6th St te E Georgia Ave N 2nd St W Colter St N Fountain Cir W Oregon23.57% Ave 29.82% W Glenrosa Ave 27.64% on N 1st Ave N 1st Dr W Montecito Ave M N 1st Ave N 2nd Ave N 7th Ave N 2nd Dr N Valerie Pl N 4th Ave N 5th Ln N 5th AveN 5th Ave W Roma Ave W Turney Ave W Georgia Ave N W N 6th Dr Grand Canal W Minnezona Ave W Marshall Ave E Marshall Ave N 8th Pl 20.67% N la Plaza Cir N 8th Ave E Highland W Missouri E Missouri Ave Map and Data fromAve Center for Neighborhood Technology www.cnt.org. May 2012. W Vermont Ave % Income 29.5 30.9 Ave nola India St 32.1 WWElm College Rd E Highland Ave W San Juan Ave WsrMarshall Ave Grand C W Campbell Ave Target Area Light Rail Stop E Elm St 15.51% W Coolidge St h 5t Data Not Available Less than 15% 15 to 18% 18 to 20% 20 to 28% 28% and Greater E Pierson St E Pierson St E Pierson St W Highland Ave W San Juan Ave W Hazelwood St www.cnt.org Transportation Costs, % Income Target Area, Average Phoenix Maricopa County 25.27% 15.54% W Luke Ave Transportation Cost as a Percentage of Income Household Transportation Costs are calculated as the sum of auto ownership costs, auto use costs, and public transit costs. Dividing these costs by representative regional incomes illustrates the cost burden placed on a typical household by transportation costs. N 6th St N 6th St E Mariposa St W Pierson St Target Area Light Rail Stop N 5th St N 3rd St W Mariposa St N 1st Ave E Ro Maps and data from the Center for Neighborhood Technology W Turney (CNT) using Ave Regional Moderate data as this target area has a median income which is less than 80% of the regional median. For W Montecito Ave an explanation of their methods and data as well as links to their Central and Camelback 26.11% N/A 29.71% website, see pgs 225-226. Housing and Transportation Affordability W Glenrosa Ave on te N 5 h 4t ro s a S E Montecito W Glenrosa Ave E Midway St Parker Row St M ine N W N 2nd Dr 34 E Camelback Rd t W Camelback Rd Ave N 8th St E P as adena N 8th St N 3rd Ave E Medlock Dr W Pasadena Ave W Elm St Data Not Available Less than 20% 20 to 30% 30 to 40% 40 to 45% 45% and Greater 30.75% E Orange Dr www.cnt.org Housing Costs, % Income % Income Target Area, Average 26.0 Phoenix 32.2 Maricopa County 34.1 E Oregon Ave E Orange Dr W Medlock Dr E San Juan Ave N 8th Pl E Oregan Ave W Colter St 17.49% N 4th St E Georgia Ave N 2nd St W Oregon Ave 32.52% E Missouri Ave N Fountain Cir N 1st Ave N 1st Dr N 1st Ave N 7th Ave N 5th Ave N 8th Ave W Vermont Ave W Georgia Ave N 2nd St N 1st St W Missouri Ave N 3rd St E Marshall Ave 6t N 6th St Housing Cost as a Percentage of Income Housing costs factored as a percent of income has widely been utilized as a measure of affordability. Traditionally, a home is considered affordable when the costs consume no more than 30% of household income. W Marshall Ave N N la Plaza Cir N 5th Ln N 4th Ave W Marshall Ave N Fountain Cir W Luke Ave nd S N2 te N 4 ro s a E Midway St N 11th Pl N 11th St N 10th Way N 11th St Parker Row N 11th Pl N 11th St N 8th Pl N 8th St N 11th Pl N 11th St N 11th St N 11th St N 10th Way N 11th Pl N Mitchell St N 10th Pl N 10th Pl N 10th St N 9th St N 10th S t W Glenrosa Ave N 11th St N 11th St N 10th Pl N 10th St N 10th St N 9th Pl E Elm St E Weldon Ave N 11th St N 11th Pl N 11th St N 8th St Data Not Available Target Area Light Rail Less than 8750 $/year E Whitton Ave Stop 8750 to 9600 $/year E Mitchell Dr 9600 to 10500 $/year 13356/yr E Minnezona Ave 10500 to 11250 $/year 11250 $/year and greater E Campbell Ave Gr an E Roma Ave dC an al E Turney Ave Central and Camelback E Glenrosa Ave Housing and Transportation Affordability E Montecito Ave E Devonshire Ave St N 11th Pl on ne M N 2nd Dr N W N 8th St N 8th St N 7th St N 5th St N 5th St N 6th St N 6th St N Central Ave N 2nd Ave N 5th Ave N 1st Ave W Roma Ave Maps and data from the Center for Neighborhood Technology Turney Ave Moderate data as this target area has a (CNT) usingWRegional median income which is less than 80% of the regional median. For W Montecito 10612/yr an explanationAve of their methods and data as well as links to their N/A 12188/yr website, see pgsW225-226. Glenrosa Ave E Weldon Ave E Highland Ave N 11th St N 2nd Dr N Valerie Pl W Campbell Ave Map and Data from Center for Neighborhood Technology www.cnt.org. May 2012. E Fairmount Ave Annual Transportation Costs $ Target Area, Average 11,545 E Indianola Ave Phoenix 12,732 11275/yr Maricopa County 13,217 t Grand Canal W Minnezona Ave 11960/yr E Mitchell Dr www.cnt.org E Amelia Ave N 10th S E Mitchell Dr E WhittonXavier Ave College N 6th St W Coolidge St College Rd E Weldon Ave E Highland Ave N 5th St E Columbus Ave E Elm St E Clarendon Ave N 4th St W Highland Ave sr Grand C N 4th St N 3rd St N 2nd St N 3rd Ave N 2nd Ave N 4th Ave N 2nd St t N/A 9689/yr E Weldon Ave W Hazelwood St E Pierson St E Pierson St N 8th St N Fountain Cir nd S N2 N 1st St N 6th Ave W Whitton Av e W Weldon Ave 11488/yr E Pierson St dC an al Household Annual E Denton Ln E Turney Ave Transportation Cost E Vermont Ave E Montecito Ave Household Annual Transportation E Glenrosa Ave 11869/yr Costs are calculated as the sum of E Oregon Ave Auto Ownership Costs, Auto Use EEDevonshire Colter St Ave Costs and Public Transit Costs. E Orange Dr On average, Transportation Costs are the second largest household 11556/yr expenditure. E Camelback Rd E Mariposa E Indianola Ave St N/A N/A E P as E Indian adena Rd School Ave N 3rd St W N W Mariposa Stianola Ave W Ind 11661/yr E Orange Dr E Medlock Dr W Pasadena Ave W Indian School Rd W Pierson St W Clarendon Ave W Elm St Scattergood N 3rd Ave NW e Av 4th Ave NW E Orange Dr W Medlock Dr 12426/yr Parker Row Shodes Cir W Monterosa St E Oregon Ave N 6th St Redwine St W Amelia Ave W Camelback Rd N 6th Ave N Fountain Cir E Midway St W Colter St a e Av N 6th Dr h 4t e Av h 6t dia ro s N 1st Ave te N 2nd Ave on 12237/yr 11353/yr Ave nola N/A E Georgia Ave W Glenrosa Ave W Oregon Ave E Oregan Ave W Glenrosa Ave N h 5t W In N 1st Ave 15.26% N 2nd Dr M N 1st Dr N 5th Ave N 7th Ave N W N 1st Ave N 8th Ave W Montecito Ave W Georgia Ave ran N la Plaza Cir Roma Ave for Neighborhood Technology www.cnt.org. May 2012. Map and Data W from Center W Missouri Ave E Missouri Ave W Turney Ave W Vermont Ave Target Area Light Rail Stop 10.34% N 11th St Data Not Available Less than 1% E Meadowbrook Ave 1 to 4% t S h E San Juan Ave E San Juan Ave 6t E Minnezona Ave N 4 to 8% E Luke Ave 8 to 14% E Campbell Ave G 14% and Greater E Roma Ave N 6th St N 6th St N 5th St N 4th St N 4th St N 3rd St N 2nd St N Central Ave N 2nd Ave E Marshall Ave N 1st St N 2nd Dr N Valerie Pl N 4th Ave W Marshall Ave N 1st Ave N 5th Ln N 5th Ave Grand Canal W Minnezona Ave W San Juan Ave W San sr Juan Ave Grand C 10.34% N 11th St 16.30% W Hazelwood St W Marshall Ave W Campbell Ave E Highland Ave E Elm St N 10th Pl W Highland Ave W Coolidge St W Luke Ave N 11th St College Rd E Highland Ave N 10th St E Elm St 10.52% N 9th St 11.12% E Pierson St E Pierson St E Pierson St N 5th St N 1st St W Elm St Transit Ridership, % of Workers % of Workers Target Area, Average 9.9 Phoenix 5.7 12.67% Maricopa County 4.1 N 9th St E Mariposa St W Pierson St 10.25% N 5th St N 3rd St W Mariposa St www.cnt.org E Camelback Rd t W Camelback Rd Ave N 8th St E P as adena N 10th Pl E Medlock Dr W Pasadena Ave N 8th St N 3rd Ave E Orange Dr N 8th Pl E Orange Dr W Medlock Dr N 6th St 9.96% 9.27% N 9th St N 8th Pl W Colter St E Oregon Ave N 8th Pl E Oregan Ave E Denton Ln Transit Ridership as a E Vermont Ave Percentage of Workers 9.19% Transit Ridership represents E Oregon Ave the percentage of workers in a E Colter St Block Group who utilize Public E Orange Dr (Transit) as their Transportation primary mode of transportation to 10.65% work. N 9th St E Georgia Ave N 2nd St W Oregon Ave 8.71% N 3rd St N 2nd St N 1st St N 1st Ave W Georgia Ave N 1st Dr N 1st Ave N 7th Ave N 5th Ave N 8th Ave W Vermont Ave E Luke Ave E Missouri Ave N Fountain Cir N Fountain Cir W Missouri Ave N 4th E Marshall Ave N 6th St N 6th St W Marshall Ave N la Plaza Cir N 5th Ln N 4th Ave W Marshall Ave 35 N 6th St N 6th St 15330 Miles E Orange Dr N 6th St nd S N2 N 5th St N 3rd St E Mariposa St W Pierson St N 1st St W Elm St 14381 Miles 14739 Miles E Camelback Rd t W Mariposa St E Pierson St E Pierson St E Pierson St 15344 Miles N 4th St W Hazelwood St E Meadowbrook Ave N 8th St Grand Canal W Minnezona Ave N 2nd Dr E Highland 11960 Miles W Coolidge St N Valerie Pl 1 E Elm St E Highland Ave College Rd E Highland Ave W Highland Ave sr Grand C 1 Ave N 8th St E P as adena N 8th Pl N 3rd Ave 1 E Medlock Dr W Pasadena Ave E San Juan Ave N 8th Pl E Orange Dr W Medlock Dr 6t E Oregon Ave W Colter St W Camelback Rd Target Area Light Rail Stop N 4th St N 3rd St N 2nd St E Georgia Ave E Oregan Ave 15136 Miles E Missouri Ave N 2nd St W Oregon Ave N Fountain Cir N 1st Ave N 1st Dr N 1st Ave N 5th Ave W Georgia Ave 14406 Miles 1 EM N Central Ave N 2nd Ave W Turney Ave E Rom W Montecito Ave 13240 Miles 15148 Miles W Glenrosa Ave N 9th St N 7th St E Clarendon Ave E Weldon Ave E Columbus Ave E Mitchell Dr N 8th St N/A N 6th St E Indianola Ave E Weldon Ave E Whitton Ave E Mitchell Dr Map and Data from Center for Neighborhood Technology www.cnt.org. January 2012. Maps and data from the Center for Neighborhood Technology (CNT) using Regional Moderate data as this target area has a median income which is less than 80% of the regional median. For an explanation of their methods and data as well as links to their website, see pgs 225-226. E Weldon Av N 8th St W Weldon Ave N 8th St Shodes Cir E Am N 4th St N/A N 3rd Ave E Indian School Rd N 3rd St N 4th Ave W Whitton Av e e nola Av N 2nd Ave N 6th Ave N 6th Ave N/A Parker Row N 6th St W Indian School Rd W India ve ola A Central and Camelback Housing and Transportation Affordability W Monterosa St W Amelia Ave W Clarendon Ave Target Area Light Rail Stop St E Midway St Scattergood NW W N 4th Ave NW e Av e Av dian a N 2nd St h 4t e Av h 6t N 6th Dr N h 5t W In ro s W Glenrosa Ave Redwine te E Montecito N/A N 1st Ave on N 2nd Ave M N 2nd Dr N W www.cnt.org Travel Time to Work Minutes Target Area, Average 16.1 Phoenix 26.0 Maricopa County 26.0 W Roma Ave N 1st Ave N 5th Ave W Campbell MapAve and Data from Center for Neighborhood Technology www.cnt.org. May 2012. Travel Time to Work Travel time to work is measured in minutes and represents an average of the total time it takes commuters in a block group to get to work by their primary mode used. Includes auto, biking, walking, and public transit. Data Not Available Less than 22 minutes 22 to 25 minutes 25 to 29 minutes 29 to 33 minutes 33 minutes and greater N 1st St N 4th Ave N 5th Ln N 7th Ave N 8th Ave W Vermont Ave Vehicle Miles Traveled/Household Annual Miles Target Area, Average 15,214 Phoenix 16,732 Maricopa County 17,937 36 E Marshall Ave W Missouri Ave www.cnt.org Data Not Available Less than 12,000 annual miles 12,000 to 14,000 annual miles 14,000 to 16,000 annual miles 16,000 to 18,000 annual miles 18,000 annual miles and greater W Marshall Ave N N la Plaza Cir Vehicle Miles Traveled per Household Vehicle miles traveled per household models the average annual auto travel by households in a block group. This includes commute travel, but also all other daily auto trips made by all members of the household. W Marshall Ave N Fountain Cir W Luke Ave E Mitc Central & Osborn Description and Impressions 38 Photographs 39 Stakeholder Information 40 Location Map 41 Market/Demographic Information 42 Aerial Image 43 Parcel Map 44 Building Footprint 45 Zoning 46 Proposed/Future Zoning 47 Land Use 48 Historic Districts and Properties 49 Political and Neighborhood Boundaries 50 Landmarks and Natural/Man-made Features 51 Transportation and Circulation 52 Floodplain and Environmental 53 Ownership 54 Vacant Land and Parking 55 Business Districts and Development Organizations 56 Events and Temporary Installations 57 Utilities and Planned Public Improvements 58 Housing and Transportation Affordability 59 37 Central and Osborn Description and Impressions The half-mile area at the Osborn light rail stop is mostly comprised of office towers, hotels, parking lots and garages, a regional mall, strip malls, and vacant land. There is very little retail or housing. However, “OneLexington” is located in this area and is referred to as a transit oriented development project. The scale of the buildings and sheer number of vast parking areas immediately adjacent to the transit stop is not pedestrian friendly. The sidewalks, though, are incorporated with wellmaintained landscaping that provide a buffer between the automobile and the walking path and, at times, shade. Most of the buildings are nondescript glass office towers with little or no signage. There is 38 approximately a 30 percent vacancy rate in the office buildings. Central Avenue and Osborn, looking north Parking lot 39 Osborn and 3rd Avenue, looking west Central Avenue and Osborn, looking northwest Parking lots and office towers Osborn, looking west Central and Osborn Photographs Stakeholders The following is a list of individuals or groups to contact to participate in planning or other events for the half mile area surrounding the light rail stop. The list was created through searches on the internet and conversations with city of Phoenix staff. City Offices Encanto Village Planning Committee City Council District 4 Business Groups and Individuals 3rd Street Business Association Phoenix Community Alliance Phoenix Community United Coalition of East Phoenix Neighborhood Associations Midtown Museum District Neighborhood 40 Association Phoenix Central Neighborhood Association Central and Osborn Stakeholders 41 Phoenix Tempe Mesa north light rail stop Central and Osborn Location Map 42 north City of Phoenix Census Tract 1105 Population 1,536,632 Median Household Income $47,085 Homeowner Occupied 59.1% Renter Occupied 40.9% Public Transportation Use 3.2% Personal Vehicle Use 74.5% Travel Time 24.2 5,164 $33,802 19.9% 90.1% 3.9% 69.7% 16.6 2009 American Community Survey 2005-2009 American Community Survey 5-year Estimates Central and Osborn Demographics 1/2 mile area 1105 3rd St 1st Pl CENTRAL 2nd Ave 3rd Ave E Clarendon W Weldon E Columbus E Mitchell OSBORN E Mulberry E Lexington 43 E Monterey E Cheery Lynn E Earll light rail stop north light rail one quarter mile Central and Osborn Aerial 3rd St 1st Pl CENTRAL 2nd Ave 3rd Ave E Clarendon W Weldon E Columbus E Mitchell OSBORN E Mulberry E Lexington 44 E Monterey E Cheery Lynn E Earll light rail stop north light rail one quarter Central and Osborn Parcel Map mile 3rd St 1st Pl CENTRAL 2nd Ave 3rd Ave E Clarendon W Weldon E Columbus E Mitchell OSBORN E Mulberry E Lexington 45 E Monterey E Cheery Lynn E Earll light rail stop light rail north structures one quarter mile Central and Osborn Building Footprint R-5 HR C-O P-2 C-2 R-5 C-2 HR C-2 R-4 C-O HR P-1 R-5 C-O R1-6 C-2 P-1 R-4 R-5 R-5 C-2 HR C-1 R-4 P-2 HR C-O C-2 C-O P-2 R-5 C-O P-1 C-2 C-1 E Columbus C-O P-1 W Weldon C-2 HR R-4 C-2 E Mitchell C-1 HR C-O OSBORN C-1 HR C-1 C-O C-O HR P-2 E Mulberry R1-6 E Lexington C-2 R-5 C-2 HR C-2 R-5 P-1 46 C-2 E Clarendon P-1 C-2 R-5 C-2 HR 3rd St C-3 1st Pl C-1 CENTRAL 2nd Ave 3rd Ave C-1 C-2 E Monterey C-1 E Cheery Lynn C-2 HR C-2 HR R-5 C-2 C-1 HR P-2 R-5 HR E Earll Source: City of Phoenix Planning Department. September 2011 light rail stop light rail north For information on Phoenix zoning and overlay descriptions, see pg 222. one quarter Central and Osborn Zoning mile overlays commercial residential TOD-1 C-O R1-6 C-O HR R-4 C-1 R-5 C-1 HR R-5 HR C-2 parking C-2 HR P-1 C3 P-2 P-2 HR 3rd St 1st Pl CENTRAL 2nd Ave 3rd Ave E Clarendon W Weldon E Columbus E Mitchell OSBORN E Mulberry E Lexington 47 E Monterey E Cheery Lynn E Earll Information obtained through internet searches and conversations with City of Phoenix staff light rail stop According to current data, there is no proposed rezoning for this area. north light rail one quarter mile Central and Osborn Proposed / Future Zoning 3rd St 1st Pl CENTRAL 2nd Ave 3rd Ave E Clarendon W Weldon E Columbus E Mitchell OSBORN E Mulberry E Lexington 48 E Monterey E Cheery Lynn E Earll Drachman Institute. June 2011 surface parking light rail stop light rail structured parking residential - single family housing vacant residential - multifamily housing civic/cultural office north plaza/park/open space retail one quarter Central and Osborn Land Use mile medical educational religious 3rd St 1st Pl CENTRAL 2nd Ave 3rd Ave E Clarendon W Weldon E Columbus E Mitchell OSBORN E Mulberry E Lexington 49 E Monterey E Cheery Lynn E Earll Information obtained through internet searches and conversations with City of Phoenix staff light rail There are no historic neighborhoods or properties in this area. Modifications to structures located within Local Historic Districts require review by City of Phoenix planning staff. Modifications to structures located within National Historic Districts may or may not require review by the State Historic Preservation Office. north light rail stop one quarter mile Central and Osborn Historic Districts and Properties 3rd St 1st Pl CENTRAL 2nd Ave 3rd Ave E Clarendon W Weldon E Columbus E Mitchell OSBORN E Mulberry E Lexington 50 E Monterey E Cheery Lynn E Earll Information obtained through internet searches and conversations with City of Phoenix staff Entire half mile area includes: light rail stop Encanto Village Planning District light rail City Council District 4 City District 4 County District 3 City District 7 north Midtown Museum District Neighborhood Association one quarter mile Central and Osborn Political and Neighborhood Boundaries 3rd St 1st Pl CENTRAL 2nd Ave 3rd Ave E Clarendon W Weldon E Columbus E Mitchell OSBORN E Mulberry E Lexington 51 E Monterey E Cheery Lynn E Earll Park Central Shopping Center light rail stop Additional landmarks may be added through various activities to be held in the area. light rail north shopping center one quarter mile Central and Osborn Landmarks and Natural / Man-made Features 3rd St 1st Pl CENTRAL 2nd Ave 3rd Ave E Clarendon W Weldon E Columbus E Mitchell OSBORN E Mulberry E Lexington 52 E Monterey E Cheery Lynn E Earll Drachman Institute. June 2011 traffic signal light rail stop light rail plazas/parks/open space surface parking striped pedestrian crossing structured parking bicycle north bus route streets one quarter mile sheltered bus stop unsheltered bus stop Central and Osborn Transportation and Circulation 3rd St 1st Pl CENTRAL 2nd Ave 3rd Ave E Clarendon W Weldon E Columbus E Mitchell OSBORN E Mulberry E Lexington 53 E Monterey E Cheery Lynn E Earll Information obtained through internet searches and conversations with City of Phoenix staff light rail stop There are no known floodplains or environmental sites. light rail floodplain 10 year floodplain 100 year north superfund site landfill recycling center waste center one quarter mile Central and Osborn Floodplain and Environmental 3rd St 1st Pl CENTRAL 2nd Ave 3rd Ave E Clarendon W Weldon E Columbus E Mitchell OSBORN E Mulberry E Lexington 54 E Monterey E Cheery Lynn E Earll Source: Maricopa County Assessor’s Office. July 2011. light rail stop light rail private individual private LLC - multiple owners north private LLC - individual owner City of Phoenix one quarter mile private multiple holdings religious Central and Osborn Ownership properties with contiguous ownership 3rd St 1st Pl CENTRAL 2nd Ave 3rd Ave E Clarendon W Weldon E Columbus E Mitchell OSBORN E Mulberry E Lexington 55 E Monterey E Cheery Lynn E Earll Drachman Institute. June 2011. light rail stop light rail vacant land surface parking north structured parking one quarter mile Central and Osborn Vacant Land and Parking 3rd St 1st Pl CENTRAL 2nd Ave 3rd Ave E Clarendon W Weldon E Columbus E Mitchell OSBORN E Mulberry E Lexington 56 E Monterey E Cheery Lynn E Earll Information obtained through internet searches and conversations with City of Phoenix staff Entire half mile area includes: light rail stop Phoenix Communities United light rail Phoenix Community Alliance 3rd Street Business Association north Coalition of East Phoenix one quarter mile Central and Osborn Business Districts and Development Organizations 3rd St 1st Pl CENTRAL 2nd Ave 3rd Ave E Clarendon W Weldon E Columbus E Mitchell OSBORN E Mulberry E Lexington 57 E Monterey E Cheery Lynn E Earll Information obtained through internet searches and conversations with City of Phoenix staff light rail According to current data, there are no known temporary installations or events in this area. Each spring, the annual Melrose on 7th Avenue Street Fair occurs 1/2 mile east of the station. north light rail stop one quarter mile Central and Osborn Events and Temporary Installations 3rd St 1st Pl CENTRAL 2nd Ave 3rd Ave E Clarendon W Weldon E Columbus E Mitchell OSBORN E Mulberry E Lexington 58 E Monterey E Cheery Lynn E Earll Source: Phoenix Water Services Department. September 2011. This map includes: light rail stop water and wastewater utility lines. light rail north water wastewater one quarter mile Central and Osborn Utilities and Planned Public Improvements a W Catalina Dr St W Monterosa St N 2nd Ave N 1st Ave NW N 3rd Ave W Indian School Rd N 10th St N 9th St N 10th St N 8th St Shodes Cir E Verde Ln E Thomas Rd E Indian School Rd N 1st Ave Map and Data from Center for Neighborhood Technology www.cnt.org. May 2012. W Edgemont Ave W Amelia Ave N 10th St N 9th Pl N 7th St Parker Row E Catalina Dr N 10th St N 8th St N 6th St N 4th St N 5th St N 3rd St E Midway St W Merrell St NW N 6th Dr N 6th Ave e Av Av e ro s N 10th St te h 4t 6t h e Av W Thomas Rd h 5t ackenzie Dr Data Not Available Target Area Light Rail Less 32,000 $/year EStop Devonshire Ave 32,000 to 42,000 $/year 42,000 to 53,000 $/year E Country Club Dr 53,000 to 69,000 $/year 69,000 $/year and greater N 10th St on N/A E Earll Dr E E dg emon t Ave N 10th St M E Cheery Lynn Rd $38,179 Median Household Income Income, $ 34,589 Target Area, Average E Turney Ave 54,791 Phoenix 61,016 Ave Maricopa County E Montecito N 9th St N W E Flower St E Monterey Way www.cnt.org E Roma Ave N Country Club Dr Dr $26,934 49.68% W Earll Dr N 2nd Dr lina W United Bank Dr W Glenrosa Ave N N 8th Ave a ta WC E Mulberry St N 8th St Dr 57.35% W Earll E Morris Dr E Lexington Ave Redwine N 5th Ave t wer S W Flo W Turney Ave Rd ry Lynn W Chee W Montecito Ave N 6th Ave N 8th Ave Dr W Avalon Dr W Roma Ave N 2nd Ave N 9th Ave arll Dr Glenrosa Ave erry D r E Osborn Rd N 1st Ave Montecito Ave N 1st Ave W Osborn Rd W Campbell Ave W Mulb E Mitchell Dr N Central Ave l N Valerie Pl 44.04% ana dC E Weldon Ave E Columbus Ave N 2nd Ave N 2nd Ave Dr N 4th Ave $31,337 n Ave $31,013 Shodes Cir N 5th Ave W Weldon Ave N 2nd Ave N 7th Ave N 8th Ave N 6th Ave n Ave e nola Av $42,232 W Clarendon Ave Median Household Income E Fairmount Ave Median household income includes the income of the E Clarendon Ave householder and all other individuals 15 years old and over E Weldon Ave E Weldon Ave in the household, whether they E Whitton Ave E Whitton Ave are related to the householder orE Mitchell not. Dr This value represents the E Mitchell Dr 45.44% 44.67% 58.13% median income within a block Grand Cana group. l E Amelia Ave N 2nd St W India unt Ave N 2nd Dr y Rd N 2nd Ave W Amelia Ave N 6th Ave Ave E Indian School Rd N 2nd St Scattergood NW W Indian School Rd Scattergood W Monterosa St Redw Av e St NW N 6th Dr e Av e Av 6t h a h 4t h 5t enzie Dr N 5th St N 9th Pl N 10th St N 9th St N 10th St N 8th St N Richland St N 8th St N 7th St N 6th St N 4th St N 2nd St N 3rd St N 5th Ave N 7th Ave N 2nd Ave N 4th Ave N 8th Ave E Roanoke Ave N 6th Ave W W Earll Dr W Avalon Dr W Earl lina l Dr 43.08% W Earll Dr E Earll Dr W Catalina Dr N 2nd St E Catalina Dr N 1st Ave W Merrell St N 3rd Ave W Thomas Rd E Cheery Lynn Rd Dr N 6th Ave E Verde Ln E Thomas Rd W Edgemont Ave H+T Costs, % Income % Income 42.7 Target Area, Average 50.5 Phoenix 52.9 Maricopa County Data Not Available Target Area Dr Club Country E Light Rail Less than 45% Stop 45% and Greater E E dg E Roanoke Ave emon t Ave E Woodward Dr W Wilshire Dr W Wilshire Dr W Lewis Ave E Ashland Ave E Sheridan St t N 8th St N 5th Ave E Roanoke Ave Maps and data from the Center for Neighborhood W Windsor Ave Technology (CNT) using Regional Typical data as this target E Windsor Ave W Cambridge Ave income which is greater than 80% of area has a median E Cam 52.56% bridge Ave E Virginia Cir Central and Osborn the regional median. For an explanation of their methods 52.14% West Virginia Ave E Virginia Ave Housing and Transportation Affordability and data as well as links to their website, see pgs 225-226. 36.89% N 9th St 8th Ave N 8th Ave Map and Data from Center for Neighborhood Technology www.cnt.org. May 2012. www.cnt.org Richland St N 9th Ave N 8th Ave a ta WC 36.90% N Country Club Dr WC am p us D r N 8th Ave N 6th Ave N 8th Ave N 8th Ave e N 5th Ave N 6th Ave Housing Transportation Cost E Amelia and Ave E Roanoke Ave W Windsor Ave adilly R as a Percentage of Income d e E Fairmount Ave E Windsor Ave nola Av ia d In W Cambridge AveW rmount E Ca H+T Ave mbridg has been developed as $33,795 e Ave E Virginia Cir $87,917 a more complete measure of 41.96% West Virginia Ave W Clarendon Ave 47.04% E Virginia Ave $55,776 E Clarendon Ave affordability beyond the standard E Woodward Dr W Weldon Ave W Wilshire Dr E Weldon Ave W Wilshire Dr method ldon A E Weldon Aveof assessing only Housing E Weldon Ave ve E Ashland Ave W Lewis Ave Costs. It takes into account both E Sheridan St E Columbus Ave hitton Ave 37.93% E Whitton Ave E Vernon Ave E Whitton the cost ofAvehousing as well as the W Vernon Ave chell Dr E Mitchell Dr cost EofMitchell transportation associated E Hoover Ave E Mitchell Dr Dr W Encanto Blvd E Oak St with the location of the home. W Osborn Rd Rd $52,616 E Osborn E Alvarado Rd $52,464 CNT has defined an affordable E Morris Dr Dr y rr E Mulberry e St lb range for H+T as the combined W Mu E Lexington Ave St r e w costs consuming no more than E Flower St W Flo E Monterey Way W United Bank Dr 45% of income. Lynn Rd Cheery elia Av 59 N 4th St 22.54% N 9th St E E Am E Roanoke Ave E N 6th St N 8th St N 8th St E Windsor Ave E Cam E Clarendon Ave 15.41% bridg E N 8th St N Richland St E Virginia Cir E Weldon Ave E Weldon Av E St E Sheridan Whitton Ave E E Alvarado Rd E Mulberry St E Mitc E Oak St E N 7th St N 5th St E Mitchell Dr E Flower St E Cheery Lynn Rd E Earll Dr N 2nd St E Catalina Dr N 1st Ave W Merrell St W Thomas Rd N 8th Pl N Country Club Dr EC r aD W Catalina Dr N 8th St N 7th St E Verde Ln N 3rd St W Earll Dr E Monterey Way ED N 8th St N 2nd St N 2nd St 20.92% r Earll D N 9th St N 8th St N 6th St N 5th St Parker Row N 4th St N 2nd Ave W United Bank Dr E Rom N Country Club Dr N 6th Ave W lin E Morris Dr r St Flowe Grand C E Montecito E Thomas E Indian School Rd E Lexington Ave N 3rd Ave e N 8th Ave N 11th Ave a ta WC N 8th St Shodes Cir N 2nd St E Catalina Dr N 2nd Ave N 4th Ave Ave N 5th N 5th Ave N 6th Ave N 7th Ave N 8th Ave N 10th Ave N 11th Ave N 11th Ave N 8th Ave N 8th Ave N 8th Ave N 12th Ave N 13th Ave N 13th Ave N 14th Ave th Av W Edgemont Ave erry D r E Mit E E Cheery Lynn Rd E Earll Dr Redwine N Central Ave 20.54%N/A N/A N/A Rd ry Lynn W Chee Target Area W Avalon Dr Light Rail StopDr W Catalina N 8th Ave N 13 Data Not Available Less than 15% 15 to 18% W Verde Ln 18 to 20% 20 to 28% 28% and Greater N 6th Ave W Mulb W Earll Dr 24.00% E Mitchell Dr E Flower St E Midway St St N 1st Ave N 1st Ave W N www.cnt.org W E Wh E Mulberry St E Monterey Way Scattergood N 2nd Ave E Morris Dr W Amelia Ave W Edgemont Ave W Amelia Ave melia Transportation CostW Aas aAve E Roanoke Ave W Pica Percentage of Incomedilly Rd W Windsor Ave e v A nola W Fairm W India ount Ave Household Transportation Costs W Cambridge Ave 29.85% W India are calculated as the sum ofnauto ola Ave 21.46% 29.34% 21.48% W Clarendon Ave ownership costs, auto use costs, West Virginia Ave W Weldon AveE Woodward Dr E Weldon Ave Weldo W Wilshire Dr and public transit costs.WDividing W Wilshire Dr n Ave E Ashland Ave W Wh these costs by representative E Columbus Ave itton A W Lewis Ave ve 20.43% regional incomes illustrates the W Mit E Vernon Ave chell E Mitchell Dr W Vernon Ave cost burden placed on a typicalDr E Hoover Ave W Osborn Rd household by transportation costs. W Encanto Blvd E Oak St Transportation Costs, % Income % Income W Flower St Target Area, Average 21.6 Phoenix W Campus Dr 24.8 Maricopa County 25.7 E Whitton Ave Rd Map and Data from Center for Neighborhood Technology www.cnt.org. May 2012. N 3rd Ave N 6th Ave N 2nd Dr W Catalina Dr W Monterosa St E Weldon A 29.93% E Lexington Ave W Merrell St 4th Ave NW NW e Av N 6th Ave a e Av e Av h 6t N 6th Dr h 4t ro s E Mitchell Dr E Weldon Ave E Osborn Rd W United Bank Dr N 2nd Ave te N h 5t N 8th Ave on E Clarendon Ave N 3rd St N Valerie Pl N 5th Ave 28.11% 26.11% 15.98% 29.71% l Dr W Glenrosa rl a W Earll Dr E Ave W lin E Fairm E Weldon Ave E Columbus Ave Rd ery Lynn heMon W CW tecito Ave a ta WC Scattergood N N 1st Ave W Weldon Ave Shodes Cir N 2nd Ave 20.48% W Campbell Osborn Rd W Ave r Roma Ave erry DW N rW aD M E Indian School Rd 25.58% N 4th Ave N 5th Ave e nola Av t wer S Ave Turney WWFlo W Earll Dr N 9th Ave N 9th Ave N 2nd Ave N 6th Ave N 8th Ave us D r WC am p W Mulb E Devo Parker Row E Am N 1st Ave N 10th Ave Redwine N 6th Dr N 7th Ave N 8th Ave N 11th Ave N 12th Dr N 13th Ave NW al W Montecito Ave N 13th Ave e Av e Av N 14th Ave h 4t W India N 6th Ave N 12th Ave N 14th Ave N N N W Monterosa St W Amelia Ave Av Data Not Available Target Area Less than 20%W Heatherbrae Dr Light Rail W Avalon Dr Stop 20 to 30% W Mackenzie Dr 30 to 40% W Monterosa St 40 to 45% 45% and Greater W Thomas Rd W Indian School Rd E Verde Ln E Thomas Rd E Map and Data from Center for Neighborhood Technology www.cnt.org. May 2012. W Edgemont Ave E Roanoke Ave Maps and data from the Center for E Roanoke AveNeighborhood Technology (CNT) using Regional Typical data as this target E Windsor area is greater than 80% Ave of W Cambridge Ave has a median income which 22.71% E Virginia Cir the 22.80% regional median. For an explanation of their methods and data as well as links to their website, see pgs 225-226. 21.49% E Woodward Dr W Wilshire Dr W Wilshire Dr W Lewis Ave E Ashland Ave E Sheridan St E Cam N 8th St Central and Osborn West Virginia Housing and Transportation AffordabilityAve N 5th Ave N 8th Ave W Windsor Ave N 8th Ave 60 St 17.50% 28.50% Grand Csr 28.11% an Housing Costs, % IncomeW %ranIncome dC G r D s ll Target Area, e W Se Average v20.6 aA om Phoenix 25.8 WR Maricopa County 27.3 W Glenrosa Ave NW W Clarendon Ave www.cnt.org e m Ca Av e a W Indian School Rd Housing Cost as aW A melia Ave Percentage of Income W Pica dilly Rd Housing costs factored asWaF airm percent of income has widely ount Ave been utilized as a measure of affordability. Traditionally, a home W We ldon A ve is considered affordable when the W Wh it to n Ave costs consume no more than 30% W Mit c h e of household income. ll Dr ll pbe h 5t 6t h ro s Ave te W Mackenzie Dr bridge E Virgin WC am p us D r erry D r W Mulb wer W Flo St ry Lynn Rd N 6th Ave W Chee W Earll Dr W Avalon Dr a ta WC N 8th Ave lin E Oak St N/A E Morris Dr W United Bank Dr E Monterey Way 12330/yr 11443/yr Dr W Earll Dr E Mulberry St E Flower St E Cheery Lynn Rd E Earll Dr N 2nd St N 1st Ave N 3rd Ave E Thomas Rd N 10th St N 10th St N 10th St E Roanoke Ave E Windsor Ave E Cam Ave Central and Osborn 12900/yrHousing and Transportation Affordability E Virginia Cir E Ashland Ave E Sheridan St bridge Ave E Virginia Ave N Richland St W Lewis Ave mont N 8th St N 5th Ave N 8th Ave 8th Ave E Woodward Dr W Wilshire Dr W Wilshire Dr N 10th St Data Not Available Less than 8750 $/year 8750 to 9600 $/year 9600 to 10500 $/year E Country Club Dr 10500 to 11250 $/year E Edg 11250 $/year and greater e E Verde Ln Maps and data from the Center for Neighborhood E Roanoke Ave W Windsor Ave Technology (CNT) using Regional Typical data as this target area has a Wmedian income which is greater than 80% of Cambridge Ave 12423/yr the regional median. 12475/yr For an explanation of their methods West Virginia and Ave data as well as links to their website, see pgs 225-226. N 9th Pl Annual Transportation Costs $ Target Area, Average 11,815 Phoenix 12,732 Maricopa County 13,217 Map and Data from Center for Neighborhood Technology www.cnt.org. May 2012. W Edgemont Ave N 10th St www.cnt.org Target Area Light Rail Stop E Catalina Dr W Merrell St N 10th St N 6th St E Oak St E Alvarado Rd E Lexington Ave W Catalina Dr W Thomas Rd E Osborn Rd E Mitchell Dr r aD N 6th Ave N 9th Ave W Earll W Osborn Rd N/A EESheridan St Whitton Ave Household Annual Transportation bridge Ave Costs are calculated as the sum of E Virginia Ave Auto Ownership Costs, Auto Use E Weldon Ave Costs and Public Transit Costs. On average, Transportation Costs E Whitton Ave are the second largest household E Mitchell Dr expenditure. E Cam t E Vernon Ave E Mitchell Dr E Hoover Ave W Encanto Blvd E Weldon Ave E Ashland Ave E Columbus Ave W Vernon Ave N 8th Ave E Weldon Ave N 7th St hell D r W Lewis Ave W Wilshire Dr N 5th St 11176/yr N 4th Ave itton A ve N 2nd Ave W Wilshire Dr tA ve Household Annual Transportation Cost E Amelia Ave N 9th St N 4th St 15.50% E Virginia Cir 11750/yr E Clarendon Ave 16.09% W Weldon Ave E Woodward Dr N 3rd St N 5th Ave N 5th Ave N 7th Ave N 8th Ave N 8th Ave N 6th Ave ldon A ve emon Data Not Available Less than 1% 1 to 4% 4 to 8% 8 to 14% 14% and Greater E Fairmount Ave E Windsor Ave 14.20% W Clarendon Ave 11740/yr West Virginia Ave E E dg N 9th St N 2nd Ave N 3rd Ave W India W Cambridge Ave ve E Roanoke Ave e nola Av N 10th St E Country Club Dr E Roanoke Ave N 2nd St N 8th Ave m ount A W Windsor Ave N 10th St N Country Club Dr E Verde Ln W Amelia Ave W Edgemont Ave N 6th Ave adilly R d N 10th St N 7th St N 5th St Parker Row Target Area Light Rail Stop E Devonshire Ave N 9th St E Catalina Dr N 9th Pl N 8th St N 6th St N 4th St E Midway St W Merrell St E Montecito Ave N/A E Thomas Rd W Indian Rd E Indian School Rd Map and DataSchool from Center for Neighborhood Technology www.cnt.org. May 2012. lia Ave N 9th St N 8th St N 1st Ave W Catalina Dr W Monterosa St E Earll Dr E Turney Ave E Cheery Lynn Rd N Richland St NW W Thomas Rd St NW Av e a 15.04% N 8th St N 6th Dr N 6th Ave e Av e Av h 5t 6t h ro s E Flower St E Mitchell Dr 13356/yr GranRidership, d Canal Transit % of Workers % of Workers Target Area, Average 15.1 E Roma Ave Phoenix 5.7 Maricopa County 4.1 N 8th St N 8th St te h 4t ackenzie Dr 11960/yr N Country Club Dr on www.cnt.org E Mitchell Dr E Mulberry St E Monterey Way Redwine M W Glenrosa Ave N Central Ave lin N N 8th Ave a ta WC rN aD W 15.93% 10612/yr W Earll Dr N 2nd Dr W Avalon Dr l Dr W Earl 12188/yr W United Bank Dr N 2nd Ave N 6th Ave Earll Dr Glenrosa Ave E Morris Dr E Lexington Ave N 2nd St Rd ry Lynn W Chee W Montecito Ave E Whitton Ave E Osborn Rd N 1st Ave N 1st Ave N 8th Ave s Dr m pu W Roma Ave t wer S W FloW Turney Ave Montecito Ave N 9th Ave erry D r W Osborn Rd N 1st Ave N 5th Ave W Campbell Ave W Mulb E Weldon Ave E Columbus Ave Shodes Cir N Valerie Pl l E Clarendon Ave E Weldon Ave E Mitchell Dr 11661/yr ana dC W Weldon Ave N 3rd St N 2nd Ave N 4th Ave N 5th Ave 16.19% ell Dr 14.85% N 2nd Dr N 7th Ave N 8th Ave e on Av e e nola Av 14.57% W Clarendon Ave N 6th Ave on Av N 2nd St W India ount Ave Transit Ridership as a Percentage of Workers E Fairmount Ave Transit Ridership represents the percentage of workers in a Block Group who utilize Public Transportation (Transit) as their E Weldon Ave primary mode of transportation to work. E Whitton Ave E Amelia Ave N 2nd Ave N 2nd Ave illy Rd N 2nd Ave W Amelia Ave N 6th Ave a Ave E Indian School Rd Scattergood NW W Indian School Rd Parker Row Shodes Cir W Monterosa St Scattergood Redwin e Av St NW N 6th Dr h 4t Av e e Av 6t h a e ro s N h 5t kenzie Dr 61 W Earll Dr N 8th St N 6th St E Mitchell Dr N 7th St EM E Mulberry St E Flower St E Cheery Lynn Rd E Earll Dr r aD N 2nd St E Catalina Dr N 1st Ave W Merrell St E Verde Ln E W Edgemont Ave E Roanoke Ave 15436 Miles 15675 Miles W Vernon Ave E Windsor Ave E Cam E Virginia Cir E Woodward Dr W Wilshire Dr W Lewis Ave E Roanoke Ave 16295 Miles E Ashland Ave E Sheridan St E Vernon Ave E Hoover Ave W Encanto Blvd N/A E Oak St N/A E Oak St E Alvarado Rd Map and Data from Center for Neighborhood Technology www.cnt.org. January 2012. Maps and data from the Center for Neighborhood Technology (CNT) using Regional Typical data as this target area has a median income which is greater than 80% of the regional median. For an explanation of their methods and data as well as links to their website, see pgs 225-226. brid E N Richland St N 3rd Ave Map and Data from Center for Neighborhood TechnologyEwww.cnt.org. May 2012. Thomas Rd Target Area Light Rail Stop Central and Osborn Housing and Transportation Affordability N 9th St N 8th St N 4th St N 5th St N 3rd St E Monterey Way 15426 Miles 14597 Miles W Wilshire Dr Travel Time to Work Minutes Target Area, Average 16.1 Phoenix 26.0 Maricopa County 26.0 Shodes Cir Red N 1st Ave N 2nd Ave N 2nd Ave W United Bank Dr EW N Country Club Dr N 6th Ave E Osborn Rd E Lexington Ave W Cambridge Ave West Virginia Ave E Whitton Ave N 8th St N 8th Ave E Mitchell Dr W Windsor Ave www.cnt.org Data Not Available Less than 22 minutes 22 to 25 minutes 25 to 29 minutes 29 to 33 minutes 33 minutes and greater lin E Weldon A E Weldon Ave W Catalina Dr N 8th Ave N 8th Ave a ta WC E Clarendon Ave E Columbus Ave erry D r Dr E Fai E Weldon Ave E Morris Dr N 5th Ave N 9th Ave W Thomas Rd W Earll 15426 Miles W Osborn Rd t wer S W Flo N 6th Ave W Avalon Dr on Ave W Weldon Ave N 4th Ave W Mulb us D r N 10th Ave WC am p Target Area Light WRail Earll Dr Stop E Am 14951 Miles Rd ry Lynn W Chee N 8th Ave 62 W Clarend 13991 Miles Vehicle Miles Traveled/Household Annual Miles Target Area, Average 15,100 Phoenix 17,866 Maricopa County 19,071 Travel Time to Work Travel time to work is measured in minutes and represents an average of the total time it takes commuters in a block group to get to work by their primary mode used. Includes auto, biking, walking, and public transit. e nola Av E Indian School Rd N 2nd St W India N 5th Ave N 7th Ave N 6th Ave N 8th Ave N 6th Ave W Amelia Ave Scattergood NW W Indian School Rd ell Dr www.cnt.org Data Not Available Less than 12,000 annual miles 12,000 to 14,000 annual miles 14,000 to 16,000 annual miles 16,000 to 18,000 annual miles 18,000 annual miles and greater W Monterosa St NW N 6th Dr e Av e Av Av e St th h 5t Vehicle Miles Traveled per Household W Amelia Ave Vehicle miles traveled per W Picadilly Rd W Fairm ount Ave household models the average annual auto travel by households in a block group. This includes W We commute travel, but also all ldon A ve other daily auto trips madeWby all Whitto n Ave members of the household. W Mit ch 6t h Central & Thomas Description and Impressions 64 Photographs 65 Stakeholder Information 66 Location Map 67 Market/Demographic Information 68 Aerial Image 69 Parcel Map 70 Building Footprint 71 Zoning 72 Proposed/Future Zoning 73 Land Use 74 Historic Districts and Properties 75 Political and Neighborhood Boundaries 76 Landmarks and Natural/Man-made Features 77 Transportation and Circulation 78 Floodplain and Environmental 79 Ownership 80 Vacant Land and Parking 81 Business Districts and Development Organizations 82 Events and Temporary Installations 83 Utilities and Planned Public Improvements 84 Housing and Transportation Affordability 85 63 Central and Thomas Description and Impressions Like the half-mile area at the Osborn light rail stop, the land use around Thomas and Central is mostly comprised of office towers, hotels, parking lots and garages, a regional mall, strip malls, and vacant land. The distinctive character of this area can be attributed to the large hospital facility of St. Joseph’s and the very large historic neighborhood, Willo. The addition of the hospital enables successful support retail services along Thomas. The scale of the buildings and sheer number of vast parking areas immediately adjacent to the light rail stop is not pedestrian friendly. The sidewalks, though, are incorporated with wellmaintained landscaping that provide a buffer between the automobile and the walking path and, at times, shade. 64 Like Osborn, the buildings in the area are nondescript glass office towers with little or no signage. Aside from a small strip center, it is difficult to understand what services are provided in the area. The bus ridership for the route along Thomas boasts the highest ridership in the city. These bus lines serve the hospital and a number of community colleges east and west of Central. Thomas and Third Avenue, looking northwest 3rd Avenue and Edgemont, looking south 65 Apartments Virginia, looking west Thomas and Third Avenue, looking east Central and Virginia, looking west Central and Thomas Photographs Stakeholders The following is a list of individuals or groups to contact to participate in planning or other events for the half mile area surrounding the light rail stop. The list was created through searches on the internet and conversations with city of Phoenix staff. City Offices Encanto City Village Planning Committee City of Phoenix Historic Preservation Office City Council District 4 City Council District 7 Business Groups and Individuals 3rd Street Business Association Phoenix Community Alliance Phoenix Community United Coalition of East Phoenix Phoenix Central Neighborhood Association 66 Dale Jensen St. Joseph’s Hospital Neighborhood Associations Midtown Museum District Neighborhood Association Willo Neighborhood Association Catalina Verde Lane Home Owners Association Crossroads Neighborhood Association La Hacienda Historic Neighborhood Central and Thomas Stakeholders 67 Phoenix Tempe Mesa north light rail stop Central and Thomas Location Map 68 north City of Phoenix Census Tract 1105 / 1118 Population 1,536,632 Median Household Income $47,085 Homeowner Occupied 59.1% Renter Occupied 40.9% Public Transportation Use 3.2% Personal Vehicle Use 74.5% Travel Time 24.2 5,164 / 3,573 $33,802 / $72,926 19.9% / 63.0% 80.1% / 37.0% 3.9% / 6.3% 69.7% / 72.4% 16.6 / 18.2 2009 American Community Survey 2005-2009 American Community Survey 5-year Estimates Central and Thomas Demographics 1/2 mile area 1105 1118 3rd St 2nd St 1st St CENTRAL 1st Ave E Catalina THOMAS 69 E Roanoke E Virginia light rail stop light rail north 3rd Ave 2nd Ave E Earll one quarter mile Central and Thomas Aerial 3rd St 2nd St 1st St CENTRAL 1st Ave 2nd Ave 3rd Ave E Earll E Catalina THOMAS 70 E Roanoke E Virginia light rail stop north light rail one quarter Central and Thomas Parcel Map mile 3rd St 2nd St 1st St CENTRAL 1st Ave E Catalina THOMAS 71 E Roanoke E Virginia light rail stop light rail structures north 3rd Ave 2nd Ave E Earll one quarter mile Central and Thomas Building Footprint P-1 C-1 3rd St 2nd St 1st St CENTRAL 1st Ave 2nd Ave R1-6 3rd Ave R-5 C-2 C-O C-2 HR R-5 R-5 C-2 HR E Earll C-2 HR C-1 HR R-5 HR P-2 C-2 C-O P-2 HR P-1 E Catalina P-2 C-O R-5 P-1 C-O C-2 HR R-3 RI C-1 HRI C-1 HRI C-2 HRI R-5 HRI P-1 P-1 72 R1-6 P-1 P-1 C-2 R-O C-O C-2 HRI C-1 R1-6 R-4 P-1 R1-6 C-2 HR C-2 C-2 R-5 THOMAS C-1 P-2 P-1 P-1 P-2 R-5 RI E Roanoke P-2 HRI C-2 HR P-2 P-1 R-4 RI P-2 C-1 R1-6 C-2 HRI C-2 HRI C-O HR C-O R-4 HRI C-O P-1 HRI C-O R-5 C-O/G-O R-5 RI E Virginia Source: City of Phoenix Planning Department. September 2011. light rail stop north light rail parking P-2 C-1 HR R-4 RI P-1 P-2 HR C-1 HRI R-4 HRI P-1 HRI P-2 HRI C-2 R-5 commercial C-2 HR R-5 RI R-O C-2 HRI R-5 HR C-O residential R-5 HRI C-O HR R1-6 overlays C-O/G-O R-3 RI TOD-1 C-1 R-4 historic zone For information on Phoenix zoning and overlay descriptions, see pg 222. one quarter Central and Thomas Zoning mile 3rd St 2nd St 1st St CENTRAL 1st Ave 2nd Ave 3rd Ave E Earll E Catalina THOMAS 73 E Roanoke E Virginia Information obtained through internet searches and conversations with City of Phoenix staff. light rail stop According to current data, there is no proposed rezoning for this area. north light rail one quarter mile Central and Thomas Proposed / Future Zoning 3rd St 2nd St 1st St CENTRAL 1st Ave 2nd Ave 3rd Ave E Earll E Catalina THOMAS 74 E Roanoke E Virginia Drachman Institute. June 2011 surface parking light rail stop light rail structured parking residential - single family housing vacant residential - multifamily housing civic/cultural office north plaza/park/open space retail one quarter Central and Thomas Land Use mile medical educational religious 3rd St 2nd St 1st St CENTRAL 1st Ave 2nd Ave 3rd Ave E Earll E Catalina THOMAS 75 E Roanoke E Virginia Information obtained through internet searches and conversations with City of Phoenix staff. light rail Willo - local and national district La Hacienda - local and national district Modifications to structures located within Local Historic Districts require review by City of Phoenix planning staff. Modifications to structures located within National Historic Districts may or may not require review by the State Historic Preservation Office. north light rail stop one quarter mile Central and Thomas Historic Districts and Properties 3rd St 2nd St 1st St CENTRAL 1st Ave 2nd Ave 3rd Ave E Earll E Catalina THOMAS 76 E Roanoke E Virginia Information obtained through internet searches and conversations with City of Phoenix staff. Entire half mile area includes: light rail stop Encanto City Village Planning District light rail City of Phoenix Ward 4 Maricopa County District 3 north City of Phoenix Ward 7 Maricopa County District 5 Crossroads Neighborhood Association one quarter mile Central and Thomas Political and Neighborhood Boundaries Willo Neighborhood Association Midtown Museum District Neighborhood Association 3rd St 2nd St 1st St 1st Ave 2nd Ave 3rd Ave CENTRAL E Earll Park Central Shopping Center E Catalina St. Joseph’s Hospital and Medical Center THOMAS 77 E Roanoke Wayland Baptist University E Virginia Additional landmarks may be added through various activities to be held in the area. light rail stop light rail higher education shopping center north hospital one quarter mile Central and Thomas Landmarks and Natural / Man-made Features 3rd St 2nd St 1st St CENTRAL 1st Ave 2nd Ave 3rd Ave E Earll E Catalina THOMAS 78 E Roanoke E Virginia Drachman Institute. June 2011. traffic signal light rail stop light rail plazas/parks/open space surface parking striped pedestrian crossing structured parking bicycle north bus route streets one quarter mile sheltered bus stop unsheltered bus stop Central and Thomas Transportation and Circulation 3rd St 2nd St 1st St CENTRAL 1st Ave 2nd Ave 3rd Ave E Earll E Catalina THOMAS 79 E Roanoke E Virginia Information obtained through internet searches and conversations with City of Phoenix staff. light rail stop There are no known floodplains or environmental sites. light rail floodplain 10 year floodplain 100 year north superfund site landfill recycling center waste center one quarter mile Central and Thomas Floodplain and Environmental 3rd St 2nd St 1st St CENTRAL 1st Ave 2nd Ave 3rd Ave E Earll E Catalina THOMAS 80 E Roanoke E Virginia Source: Maricopa County Assessor’s Office. July 2011. light rail stop light rail private individual private LLC - multiple owners north private LLC - individual owner City of Phoenix one quarter mile private multiple holdings religious Central and Thomas Ownership contiguously owned properties 3rd St 2nd St 1st St CENTRAL 1st Ave 2nd Ave 3rd Ave E Earll E Catalina THOMAS 81 E Roanoke E Virginia Drachman Institute. June 2011. light rail stop light rail vacant land surface parking north structured parking one quarter mile Central and Thomas Vacant Land and Parking 3rd St 2nd St 1st St CENTRAL 1st Ave 2nd Ave 3rd Ave E Earll E Catalina THOMAS 82 E Roanoke E Virginia Information obtained through internet searches and conversations with City of Phoenix staff. Entire half mile area includes: light rail stop Phoenix Communities United light rail Phoenix Community Alliance Phoenix Central Neighborhood Association north Coalition of East Phoenix one quarter mile Central and Thomas Business Districts and Development Organizations 3rd St 2nd St 1st St CENTRAL 1st Ave 2nd Ave 3rd Ave E Earll E Catalina THOMAS 83 E Roanoke E Virginia Information obtained through internet searches and conversations with City of Phoenix staff. light rail According to current data, there are no known temporary installations or events in this area. north light rail stop one quarter mile Central and Thomas Events and Temporary Installations 3rd St 2nd St 1st St CENTRAL 1st Ave 2nd Ave 3rd Ave E Earll E Catalina THOMAS 84 E Roanoke E Virginia Source: City of Phoenix Water Services Department. September 2011. This map includes: light rail stop water and wastewater utility lines. light rail north water wastewater one quarter mile Central and Thomas Utilities and Planned Public Improvements W United Bank Dr N 6th Ave W Avalon Dr N 8th Ave a ta WC W lin 36.90% r Earll D 43.08% W Earll Dr N 2nd St E Catalina Dr N 1st Ave N 6th Ave N 3rd Ave W Edgemont Ave E Roanoke Ave N 5th Ave W Cambridge Ave 52.14% 52.56% E Woodward Dr W Wilshire Dr W Wilshire Dr W Lewis Ave W Vernon Ave E Verde Ln E Thomas Rd E Roanoke Ave 36.89% E Sheridan St E Vernon Ave E Hoover Ave N/A Maps and dataN/A from the Center for Neighborhood E Alvarado Rd Technology (CNT) using Regional Typical data as this target area has a median income which is greater than 80% of the regional median. For an explanation of their methods and data as well as links to their website, see pgs 225-226. N 10th St N 10th St N 9th St N 10th St N 10th St N 9th St N 9th Pl N Richland St E Cam E Virginia Cir E Ashland Ave E Oak St www.cnt.org E Windsor Ave Map and Data from Center for Neighborhood Technology www.cnt.org. January 2012. W Encanto Blvd N 10th St N Country Club Dr N 8th St N 8th St N 8th St N 7th St N 5th St E Cheery Lynn Rd E Earll Dr W Merrell St W Windsor Ave West Virginia Ave E Flower St r aD W Catalina Dr W Thomas Rd N 8th Ave E Monterey Way N Country Club Dr r St Flowe Housing and Transportation Cost as a Percentage of Income H+T has been developed as a more complete measure of affordability beyond the standard method of assessing only Housing Costs. It takes into account both the cost of housing as well as the cost of transportation associated with the location of the home. E Country Club Dr CNT has defined an affordable range Efor H+T as the combined E dge mont Ave costs consuming no more than 45% of income. E Mulberry St E Lexington Ave Rd ry Lynn W Chee W Earll Dr E Osborn Rd E Morris Dr erry D r E Mitchell Dr N 8th St us D r WC am p W N 8th Ave N 6th St Map and Data from Center for Neighborhood Technology www.cnt.org. May E2012. $52,616 Alvarado Rd W Mulb E Virginia Ave Target Area Light Rail Stop H+T ACosts, % Income % Income ve 46.2 Target Area, Average E Virginia Ave 50.5 Phoenix 52.9 Maricopa County bridge Target Area Light Rail Stop N 10th St E Hoover Ave E Mitchell Dr www.cnt.org N 10th St N 4th St N 2nd St E Vernon Ave E Columbus Ave W Encanto Blvd t Ave Data Not Available Less 32,000 $/year E Clarendon Ave 32,000 to 42,000 $/year E Sheridan St E Weldon Ave E Weldon Ave 42,000 to 53,000 $/year E Whitton Ave E Whitton Ave 53,000 to 69,000 $/year E Oak St 69,000 $/year and greater E Mitchell Dr Ave W Weldon Ave E Ashland E Weldon Ave W Osborn Rd N 8th Ave $55,776 emon Median Household Income Income, $ 46,706 Area, Average ETarget Amelia Ave 54,791 Phoenix E Cam bridge Ave Ave County 61,016 E Fairmount Maricopa E Virginia Cir 41.96% E Woodward Dr W Wilshire Dr E Roanoke Ave E Windsor Ave $52,464 N 9th Ave N 7th St N 3rd St Shodes Cir N 2nd St Scattergood E Thomas Rd N 9th St N 8th Ave 37.93% hell D r W Vernon Ave Parker Row E Verde Ln N Richland St W Lewis Ave N 4th Ave itton A ve N 5th Ave N 7th Ave N 8th Ave ldon A ve E Catalina Dr $33,795 Ave 47.04% E Cheery Lynn Rd E Indian School Rd E Roanoke Ave nola $87,917 W India W Clarendon W Wilshire Ave Dr N 6th Ave N 8th Ave mount A West Virginia Ave ve W Cambridge Ave N 2nd Ave N 8th Ave adilly R d W Windsor WAve Amelia Ave N 5th Ave N 6th Ave lia Ave Redwine W Edgemont Ave W Indian School Rd Income Median household income includes the income of the E Turney Ave householder and all other Ave Montecito E individuals 15 years old and over in the household, whether they are related to the householder Devonshire Ave orEnot. This value represents the E Country Club Dr median income within a block group.E Edg E Roma Ave E Earll Dr E Midway St N 1st Ave NW W Merrell St W Monterosa St St N 3rd Ave NW Av e a e Av W Thomas Rd 6th e Av N 6th Dr h 4t N 6th Ave N h 5t ackenzie Dr ro s N Central Ave W Catalina Dr te 58.13% Median Household Grand Cana l N/A N 1st Ave on N 2nd Ave M W Glenrosa Ave N 2nd Dr N W E Monterey Way $38,179 W Earll Dr E Mitchell Dr E Flower St 49.68% N 2nd Ave N 8th Ave a ta WC N 2nd Ave N 2nd Ave N 6th Ave r aD E Mitchell Dr E Mulberry St E Lexington Ave $26,934 E Whitton Ave 45.44% 44.67% E Morris Dr W United Bank Dr arll Dr WWEMon tecito Ave lin 57.35% W Avalon Dr Glenrosa Ave N 9th Ave W Turney Ave N 2nd Dr N 5th Ave N 8th Ave Cam p ry W Chee W Earll Dr Montecito Ave N 9th Ave t wer S W Roma Ave Lynn Rd W Flo E Osborn Rd N 1st Ave us D r W N Valerie Pl l r lberry D Ave MuCampbell W E Whitton Ave N 5th St W Osborn Rd 44.04% ana dC E Mitchell Dr N 3rd St hell D r E Columbus Ave N 2n $31,337 N 4th tton A ve Data Not Available Less than 45% 45% and Greater E Oak St Central and Thomas Housing and Transportation Affordability 85 N Country Club Dr N 9th St N 8th St E Cam N 6th St N 8th St St N 8th E Virginia Cir 15.41% 21.48% E Clarendon Ave N 8th St E Whitton Ave W Earll Dr E Cheery Lynn Rd E Earll Dr r aD W Catalina Dr E Catalina Dr W Merrell St N 1st Ave W Thomas Rd W Edgemont Ave E Roanoke Ave W Windsor Ave W Cambridge Ave N 5th Ave N 8th Ave E Flower St 22.80% 22.71% E Woodward Dr W Wilshire Dr W Lewis Ave W Vernon Ave E Verde Ln E Thomas Rd E E Roanoke Ave E Windsor Ave E Cam E Virginia Cir 21.49% n Enca r NE to D ve N 12th A Central and Thomas Housing and Transportation Affordability E Virgin E Ashland Ave E Sheridan St E Vernon Ave E Hoover Ave Map and Data from Center for Neighborhood Technology www.cnt.org. May 2012. W Encanto Blvd bridge E Oak St E Oak St Maps and data from the Center for Neighborhood E Alvarado Rd Technology (CNT) using Regional Typical data as this target 28.22% 28.41% W Cypress St area has a median income which is greater than 80% of the regional median. For an explanation of their methods and data as well as links to their website, see pgs 225-226. N Richland St lin l Dr 22.54% E N 8th St N 6th Ave a ta WC W Earl E Monterey Way 20.92% E Mitch E Alvarado Rd E Mulberry St E N Country Club Dr W United Bank Dr Rd ry Lynn W Chee EV E Weldon Ave E E Weldon SheridanAve St EEColumbus Vernon Ave Ave bridEgeF N Richland St N 4th St N 2nd St 29.85% E Lexington Ave t wer S W Flo E E Ame E Windsor Ave E Woodward Dr W Wilshire Dr W Weldon Ave E Weldon E Ashland Ave Ave erry D r N 8th Pl N 8th St N 5th St N 7th St N 3rd St Shodes Cir Scattergood N Central Ave N 1st Ave N 2nd Ave E Roanoke Ave N 7th St W Mulb N 8th Ave e N 8th Ave EC E Indian School Rd E Morris Dr N 3rd Ave N 8th Ave th Av N 9th Ave E Verde Ln N 5th St N 10th Ave N 11th Ave N 11th Ave N 8th Ave N 13 N 11th Ave ED E Mitchell Map and Data from Center for Neighborhood Technology www.cnt.org. May 2012. W Encanto Blvd EDr Oak St E Oak St Target Area West Virginia Ave Light Rail Stop W Wilshire Dr W Monte Vista Rd E Montecito E Roanoke Ave N/A E E Thomas Rd N/A 2 Grand C E Catalina Dr Parker Row HooverDr Ave E EMitchell www.cnt.org Transportation Costs, % Income % Income Target Area, AverageW Edgemont Ave22.2 Phoenix 24.8 Maricopa County 25.7 N 2nd Ave W Vernon Ave E Mitc E Rom E Cheery Lynn Rd N 3rd St Transportation Cost as a Percentage of Income Household Transportation Costs W Flower St are calculated as the sum of auto Campus Dr ownership costs, auto Wuse costs, and public transit costs. Dividing W Earll Dr these costs by representative regional incomes illustrates theW Avalon Dr Dr cost burden placed on aW Catalina typical W Verde Ln household by transportation costs. N 13th Ave N 2nd Ave N 3rd Ave 4th Ave NW 20.43% chell Dr E Mitchell Dr 24.00% N/A N 2nd St W Mit W Lewis Ave N 4th Ave itton A ve E Earll Dr W Edgemont Ave W Cambridge Ave e nola Av W India N 5th Ave N 5th Ave N 7th Ave ldon A ve N 8th Ave W We E Whit E Mulberry St 20.54% E Midway St WW Monterosa Merrell StSt 29.34% Target Area West Virginia Ave n Ave 21.46% LightolaRail W Clarendon Ave W Wilshire Dr Stop W India W Wh Data Not Available Less than 15% 15 to 18% 18 to 20% 20 to 28% 28% and Greater St W Amelia Ave W Windsor Ave W Osborn Rd 86 N 2nd Dr W Catalina Dr a N 1st Ave N 6th Ave N 6th Ave N 6th Dr ro s E Whitton Ave E Flower St E Monterey Way N 2nd St N Valerie Pl N 5th Ave N 8th Ave us D r N 9th Ave N 9th Ave N 8th Ave N 8th Ave N 8th Ave ount Ave N 6th Ave N 11th Ave NW N 12th Ave te e Av N 13th Ave on h 4t W N N 13th Ave M W Glenrosa Ave N e Av N 14th Ave N W e Av h 6t Data Not Available Less than 20% 20 to 30% 30 to 40% 40 to 45% 45% and Greater W Fairm lin E Morris Dr W United Bank Dr N 2nd Ave a ta WC E Weldon Av 29.93% E Lexington Ave 15.98% 26.11% W Earll Dr W Montecito r l DAve W Earl E Weldon Ave E Osborn Rd W Campbell Ave W St Roma Ave 29.71% r aD E Mitchell Dr W Osborn Rd nn RdAve W Turney ry Ly W Chee N 14th Ave WC am p N 14th Ave N 10th Ave wer W Flo Housing Costs, % Income % IncomeW Thomas Rd Target Area, Average W Indian23.9 School Rd Phoenix 25.8 W Am W Amelia Ave Maricopa County 27.3 elia Av e dilly Rd erry D r 28.11% N 1st Ave W Mulb h 5t W Monterosa St N 2nd 28.50% Grand Csr 28.11% N 8th Ave www.cnt.org W Mackenzie Dr E Columbus Ave Redwine chell Dr Housing Cost as a ell Ave b mp Ca l Percentage of Income W ana dC ran G r lls D Housing costs ave W Se factored as A a om R W percent of income has widely been utilized as a measure of Montecito Ave W Earll Dr affordability. Traditionally, aW home is considered affordable when the W Glenrosa Ave W Avalon Dr costs consumeWno more than 30% Heatherbrae Dr of household income. W Pica N 4th Ave 17.50% N 6th Ave N 11th Ave N 12th Dr N 12th Ave N 13th Ave itton A ve N ldon A ve W Wh W Mit Ave W We EM N 2nd St N 1st Ave N 3rd Ave N 5th Ave W Cambridge Ave 12475/yr 12423/yr E Woodward Dr W Wilshire Dr W Wilshire Dr W Lewis Ave W Vernon Ave N 10th St N 9th St N 10th St E Verde Ln N 10th St N 10th St N 9th N St9th Pl N Richland St Household Annual Transportation Costs are calculated as the sum of Auto Ownership Costs, Auto Use Costs and Public Transit Costs. On average, Transportation Costs are the second largest household expenditure. E Country Club Dr www.cnt.org E Thomas Rd E E dg E Roanoke Ave N 10th St N Country Club Dr E Catalina Dr W Edgemont Ave W Windsor Ave N 8th N St 8th St N 7th St N 5th St Dr W Merrell St West Virginia Ave E Flower St E Cheery Lynn Rd Data Not Available Less than 1% 1 to 4% 4 to 8% 8 to 14% 14% and Greater Household Annual Transportation Cost E Mulberry St E Earll Dr W Catalina Dr E Mitchell Dr E Roanoke Ave E Windsor Ave E Cam E Virginia Cir 12900/yr E Ashland Ave E Sheridan St E Vernon Ave E Hoover Ave Map and DataWfrom Center Encanto Blvd for Neighborhood Technology E Oak St www.cnt.org. May 2012. N/A E Alvarado Rd N/A Maps and data from the Center for Neighborhood Technology (CNT) using Regional Typical data as this target area has a median income which is greater than 80% of the regional median. For an explanation of their methods and data as well as links to their website, see pgs 225-226. E Oak St em o nt Av e Annual Transportation Costs $ Target Area, Average 12,674 Phoenix 13,547 Maricopa County 14,033 bridge Ave E Virginia Ave Target Area Light Rail Stop N 10th St W Earll Dr E Mitchell Dr E Oak St N 9th St lina 12330/yr E Whitton Ave N Richland St N 6th Ave N 8th Ave W Thomas Rd a ta WC Dr N 6th Ave W Avalon Dr W Earll E Monterey Way 11443/yr N 8th St N 6th St E Whitton Ave E Osborn E RdAlvarado Rd Target Area E Virginia Ave Light Rail Stop E Weldon Ave E Weldon Ave E Sheridan St N Country Club Dr W United Bank Dr N 7th St N 4th St E Clarendon Ave E Lexington Ave N 10th St N 5th St N 3rd St N 2nd St Scattergood N Central Ave Redwine Shodes Cir 16.09% E Morris Dr y Dr Mulberr Rd ry Lynn W Chee Earll Dr N/A E CaEmFairmount Ave bridge Ave E Virginia Cir EEMitchell HooverDr Ave W Osborn Rd t wer S W Flo N 8th Ave E Windsor Ave Transit Ridership, % of Workers % of Workers E Edg Area, Average 15.2 Target emon t Ave 5.7 Phoenix 4.2 Maricopa County E Amelia Ave N 8th St us D r W N 8th Ave E Roanoke Ave Encanto Map and DataWfrom Center Blvd for Neighborhood Technology E Oak St www.cnt.org. May 2012. N/A N 8th Ave E Indian School Rd E Columbus Ave E Vernon Ave www.cnt.org E Country Club Dr E Thomas Rd N 3rd St W Vernon Ave E Devonshire Ave E Verde Ln 11750/yr N 2nd Ave ll Dr N 4th Ave N 7th Ave N 8th Ave N 6th Ave 11176/yr on Av e Percentage of Workers Transit Ridership represents the percentage of workers in a E Turney Ave Block Group who utilize Public Ave E Montecito Transportation (Transit) as their primary mode of transportation to work. Parker Row E Woodward Dr W Wilshire W Weldon Ave Dr E Weldon Ave E Ashland Ave W Wilshire Dr W Lewis Ave E Catalina Dr 15.50% 14.20% 11740/yr Transit Ridership as a 13356/yr Grand Cana l E Roma Ave E Roanoke Ave W Cambridge Ave nola Ave W India 11960/yr N/A N 2nd St N 6th Ave W Amelia Ave W Windsor Ave West Virginia Ave W Clarendon Ave N 8th Ave W Edgemont Ave E Mitchell Dr E Cheery Lynn Rd 15.04% E Midway St N 1st Ave W Indian School Rd ount Ave n Ave W Monterosa St W Merrell St N 3rd Ave NW N 5th Ave N 5th Ave N 6th Dr lly Rd St NW Ave W Catalina Dr a e Av e Av Av e ro s E Mitchell Dr E Flower St E Monterey Way E Earll Dr E Whitton Ave E Mulberry St E Lexington Ave N 1st Ave te N 2nd Dr on h 4t W Thomas Rd 6t h N 6th Ave N 9th Ave M W Glenrosa Ave N 2nd Ave N W h 5t kenzie Dr a N N 8th Ave lin a ta WC E Morris Dr 15.93% W Earll Dr 10612/yr W Montecito l DrAve W Earl 12188/yr Dr E Osborn Rd W United Bank Dr N 2nd Ave N 6th Ave nn Rd Ave LyTurney ryW W Chee nrosa Ave W Avalon Dr N 8th Ave N 2nd Dr N Valerie Pl N 5th Ave N 8th Ave t Roma Ave W wer S W Flo ontecito Ave Earll Dr N 8th Ave W Osborn Rd N 1st Ave W Campbell Ave erry D r W Mulb us D r a E Whitton Ave E Mitchell Dr 11661/yr nal E Columbus Ave N 2nd Ave N 2nd Ave 16.19% ll Dr E Weldon Ave N 2n N 4th Ave N e n Ave on Av e Data Not Available Less than 8750 $/year 8750 to 9600 $/year 9600 to 10500 $/year 10500 to 11250 $/year 11250 $/year and greater Central and Thomas Housing and Transportation Affordability 87 W Earll Dr N 8th Ave N 7th St N 5th St N 3rd St E Earll Dr N 2nd St E Catalina Dr N 1st Ave W Merrell St 15436 Miles 15675 Miles W Vernon Ave E Roanoke Ave E Windsor Ave E Cam E Virginia Cir E Woodward Dr W Wilshire Dr W Lewis Ave E E Thomas Rd E Roanoke Ave W Cambridge Ave N 5th Ave E Verde Ln W Edgemont Ave W Windsor Ave Target Area West Virginia Ave Light Rail Stop W Wilshire Dr N 8th Ave E Cheery Lynn Rd r aD W Catalina Dr N 8th Ave E Flower St 16295 Miles E Ashland Ave E Sheridan St E Vernon Ave E Hoover Ave W Encanto Blvd E Oak St E Oak St Map andN/A Data from Center for NeighborhoodN/A Technology www.cnt.org. May 2012. E Alvarado Rd Travel Time to Work Travel time to work is measured in minutes and represents an average of the total time it takes commuters in a block group to get to work by their primary mode used. Includes auto, biking, walking, and public transit. www.cnt.org Travel Time to Work Minutes Target Area, Average 16.1 Phoenix 26.0 Maricopa County 26.0 Data Not Available Less than 22 minutes 22 to 25 minutes 25 to 29 minutes 29 to 33 minutes 33 minutes and greater Target Area Light Rail Stop Central and Thomas Housing and Transportation Affordability Map and Data from Center for Neighborhood Technology www.cnt.org. January 2012. Maps and data from the Center for Neighborhood Technology (CNT) using Regional Typical data as this target area has a median income which is greater than 80% of the regional median. For an explanation of their methods and data as well as links to their website, see pgs 225-226. brid E N Richland St lin 15426 Miles 14597 Miles Dr E Monterey Way N Country Club Dr a ta WC Vehicle Miles Traveled/Household Annual Miles Target Area, Average 15,284 Phoenix 16,732 Maricopa County 17,937 88 W United Bank Dr N 3rd Ave N 9th Ave W Thomas Rd t wer S EM E Mulberry St E Lexington Ave Rd ry Lynn W Chee W Earll E Osborn Rd E Morris Dr erry D r W Flo N 6th Ave WC am p N 8th Ave www.cnt.org W Osborn Rd E Mitchell Dr N 8th St W Mulb us D r Vehicle Miles Traveled per Household Vehicle miles traveled per household models the average W Earll Dr annual auto travel by households in a block group. This includes W Avalon Dr commute travel, but also all other daily auto trips made by all members of the household. Data Not Available Less than 12,000 annual miles 12,000 to 14,000 annual miles 14,000 to 16,000 annual miles 16,000 to 18,000 annual miles 18,000 annual miles and greater E Mitchell Dr N 4th Ave chell Dr N 6th Ave N 10th Ave W Mit Central & McDowell Description and Impressions 90 Photographs 91 Stakeholder Information 92 Location Map 93 Market/Demographic Information 94 Aerial Image 95 Parcel Map 96 Building Footprint 97 Zoning 98 Proposed/Future Zoning 99 Land Use 100 Historic Districts and Properties 101 Political and Neighborhood Boundaries 102 Landmarks and Natural/Man-made Features 103 Transportation and Circulation 104 Floodplain and Environmental 105 Ownership 106 Vacant Land and Parking 107 Business Districts and Development Organizations 108 Events and Temporary Installations 109 Utilities and Planned Public Improvements 110 Housing and Transportation Affordability 111 89 Central and McDowell Description and Impressions Located just north of the sunken Interstate 10, the half-mile area at the McDowell light rail stop is a mixed-use area comprised of the Phoenix Art Museum, the central branch of the Phoenix public library, a park, small commercial spaces for businesses, schools, and vacant land. The area offers very little housing. The Central City Village Planning Committee is currently looking at proposed maximum heights to be allowed in the area. This area includes large expanses of open, vacant, parking, and play yard spaces to support the uses of the museum, library, and schools. 90 City of Phoenix Public Library Interstate 10 91 Moreland and 2nd Street, looking west Cancer Survivors Park 2nd Street and Willetta, looking west 2nd Street and Willetta St, looking north Central and McDowell Photographs Stakeholders The following is a list of individuals or groups to contact to participate in planning or other events for the half mile area surrounding the light rail stop. The list was created through searches on the internet and conversations with City of Phoenix staff. City Offices Encanto City Village Planning Committee Central City Village Planning Committee City of Phoenix Historic Preservation Office City Council District 7 Business Groups and Individuals Phoenix Community Alliance Phoenix Community United Coalition of East Phoenix Neighborhood Associations 92 Midtown Museum District Neighborhood Association Willo Neighborhood Association Roosevelt Action Association Greater Roosevelt Neighborhood Association Schools, Churches, and other Cultural Institutions Arizona School for the Arts Phoenix Museum of Art Grace Lutheran Church Burton Barr Central Library Central and McDowell Stakeholders 93 Phoenix Tempe Mesa north light rail stop Central and McDowell Location Map 94 north City of Phoenix Census Tract 1118 / 1130 Population 1,536,632 Median Household Income $47,085 Homeowner Occupied 59.1% Renter Occupied 40.9% Public Transportation Use 3.2% Personal Vehicle Use 74.5% Travel Time 24.2 3,573 / 2,392 $72,926 / $41,615 63.0% / 24.1% 37.0% / 75.9% 6.3% / 3.7% 72.4% / 62.8% 18.2 / 24.5 2009 American Community Survey 2005-2009 American Community Survey 5-year Estimates Central and McDowell Demographics 1/2 mile area 1118 1130 3rd St 2nd St CENTRAL 3rd Ave E Palm E Coronado McDOWELL E Willetta 95 Culver St I-10 light rail stop north light rail one quarter mile Central and McDowell Aerial 3rd St 2nd St CENTRAL 3rd Ave E Palm E Coronado McDOWELL E Willetta 96 Culver St I-10 light rail stop north light rail one quarter Central and McDowell Parcel Map mile 3rd St 2nd St CENTRAL 3rd Ave E Palm E Coronado McDOWELL E Willetta 97 Culver St I-10 light rail stop light rail north structures one quarter mile Central and McDowell Building Footprint R1-10 R-4 HRI 3rd St P-1 2nd St CENTRAL 3rd Ave P-2 C-1 HR E Palm C-O R-3 R-3 C-2 HRI R1-6 C-2 HRI E Coronado P-2 HRI R-3 RI C-O R-4 C-O R-3 DTCMcDowell Corridor 1 HP DTCMcDowell Corridor 2 McDOWELL DTCMcDowell Corridor 1 DTCRoosevelt HP DTCTownsend Park DTCRoosevelt E Willetta DTCDowntown Gateway 98 Culver St DTCDowntown Gateway HP DTCRoosevelt I-10 DTC-West Evans Churchill Source: City of Phoenix Planning Department. September 2011. light rail stop light rail north For information on Phoenix zoning and overlay descriptions, see pg 222 one quarter Central and McDowell Zoning mile overlays commercial residential historic zone C-O R1-10 TOD-1 C-1 HR R1-6 SPD C-2 HRI R-3 parking R-3 RI P-1 R-4 P-2 downtown core P-2 HRI DTC 3rd St 2nd St CENTRAL 3rd Ave E Palm E Coronado McDOWELL E Willetta 99 Culver St I-10 Information obtained through internet searches and conversations with City of Phoenix staff. light rail stop According to current data, there is no proposed rezoning for this area. north light rail one quarter mile Central and McDowell Proposed / Future Zoning 3rd St 2nd St CENTRAL 3rd Ave E Palm E Coronado McDOWELL E Willetta 100 Culver St I-10 Drachman Institute. June 2011. surface parking light rail stop light rail structured parking residential - single family housing vacant residential - multifamily housing civic/cultural office north plaza/park/open space retail one quarter Central and McDowell Land Use mile medical educational religious 3rd St 2nd St CENTRAL 3rd Ave E Palm E Coronado McDOWELL E Willetta 101 1 Culver St 2 I-10 Information obtained through internet searches and conversations with City of Phoenix staff. light rail stop light rail Willo - local and national district Chelsea Place - national district Modifications to structures located within Local Historic Districts require review by City of Phoenix planning staff. Modifications to structures located within National Historic Districts may or may not require review by the State Historic Preservation Office. north Roosevelt - local district Blount - unknown type of district Villa del Coronado - national district 1 Temple Beth Israel local and national district 2 Ellis Shackelford House local and national register one quarter mile Central and McDowell Historic Districts and Properties 3rd St 2nd St CENTRAL 3rd Ave E Palm E Coronado McDOWELL E Willetta 102 Culver St I-10 Information obtained through internet searches and conversations with City of Phoenix staff. Entire half mile area includes: light rail stop City of Phoenix Council District 7 light rail Maricopa County District 5 Encanto Village Planning District Central City Village Planning District north Midtown Museum District Neighborhood Association Roosevelt Action Neighborhood Association one quarter mile Central and McDowell Political and Neighborhood Boundaries Greater Roosevelt Neighborhood Association Willo Neighborhood Association 3rd St 2nd St CENTRAL 3rd Ave E Palm Arizona Academy of Science & Technology E Coronado Horizon Challenge Charter School Phoenix Art Museum McDOWELL Arizona School for the Arts E Willetta 103 Summit Elementary School Culver St Burton Barr Central Library I-10 light rail stop Additional landmarks may be added through various activities to be held in the area. light rail school library north museum religious/church one quarter mile Central and McDowell Landmarks and Natural / Man-made Features 3rd St 2nd St CENTRAL 3rd Ave E Palm E Coronado McDOWELL E Willetta 104 Culver St I-10 Drachman Institute. June 2011. traffic signal light rail stop light rail plazas/parks/open space surface parking striped pedestrian crossing structured parking bicycle north bus route streets one quarter mile sheltered bus stop unsheltered bus stop Central and McDowell Transportation and Circulation 3rd St 2nd St CENTRAL 3rd Ave E Palm E Coronado McDOWELL E Willetta 105 Culver St I-10 Information obtained through internet searches and conversations with City of Phoenix staff. light rail stop There are no known floodplains or environmental sites. light rail floodplain 10 year floodplain 100 year north superfund site landfill recycling center waste center one quarter mile Central and McDowell Floodplain and Environmental 3rd St 2nd St CENTRAL 3rd Ave E Palm E Coronado McDOWELL E Willetta 106 Culver St I-10 Source: Maricopa County Assessor’s Office. July 2011. light rail stop light rail private individual private LLC - multiple owners north private LLC - individual owner government owned one quarter mile private multiple holdings religious Central and McDowell Ownership contiguously owned properties 3rd St 2nd St CENTRAL 3rd Ave E Palm E Coronado McDOWELL E Willetta 107 Culver St I-10 Drachman Institute. June 2011. light rail stop light rail vacant land surface parking north structured parking one quarter mile Central and McDowell Vacant Land and Parking 3rd St 2nd St CENTRAL 3rd Ave E Palm E Coronado McDOWELL E Willetta 108 Culver St I-10 Information obtained through internet searches and conversations with City of Phoenix staff. Entire half mile area includes: light rail stop Phoenix Communities United light rail Phoenix Community Alliance north Coalition of East Phoenix Grace Lutheran Church Neighborhood Association one quarter mile Central and McDowell Business Districts and Development Organizations 3rd St 2nd St CENTRAL 3rd Ave E Palm E Coronado McDOWELL E Willetta 109 Culver St I-10 Information obtained through internet searches and conversations with City of Phoenix staff. light rail According to current data, there are no known temporary installations or events in this area. north light rail stop one quarter mile Central and McDowell Events and Temporary Installations 3rd St 2nd St CENTRAL 3rd Ave E Palm E Coronado McDOWELL E Willetta 110 Culver St I-10 Source: Phoenix Water Services Department. September 2011. This map includes: light rail stop water and wastewater utility lines. light rail north water wastewater one quarter mile Central and McDowell Utilities and Planned Public Improvements E Verde Ln E Coronado Rd W McDowell Rd E Moreland St E Portland St E Fillmore St N Dayton St N 10th St N 10th St N 8th St N 6th St N 4th St N 3rd St N 1st St N 1st Ave W Fillmore St W Taylor St N 2nd Ave N 4th Ave N 6th Ave W Fillmore St St Maps and data from the Center for Neighborhood Technology E Garfield St (CNT) using Regional Moderate data as this target area has a McKinley median income which is less W than 80%St of the regional median. For E McKinley St an explanation of their methods and data as well as links to their W Pierce St website, see pgs 225-226. E Pierce St E Roosevelt St N 5th St N 2nd St rd N3 N 8th Ave Map and Data from Center W Roosevelt St for Neighborhood Technology www.cnt.org. May 2012. Target Area Light Rail Stop Data Not Available Less than 45% 45% and Greater N 10th St W Portland St N 1st Dr 56.94% 47.36% N 10th St Papago Fwy Papago Fwy W Moreland St W Portland St www.cnt.org H+T Costs, % Income % Income E Culver St 55.7 I- 10Target Area, Average 63.2 Phoenix I10 Fro 66.2 E Maricopa Moreland St County E Culver St W Latham St land St N 9th St N 9th St N 5th St E Lynwood St 48.18% Central and McDowell E Pierce St Housing and Transportation Affordability 50.48% N 10th St eland St E Willetta St N 1st St W Culver St 46.61% N 2nd St 64.58% N 1st St E McDowell Rd W Lynwood St W Willetta St N 8th St E Taylor St N 9th St W Almeria Rd N 5th St E Fillmore St E Taylor St E Polk St N Richland St N 1st Ave E Palm Ln E Pierce St Housing and Transportation Cost as a Percentage of Income $28,893 H+T has been developed as E Monte Vista Rd E Pierce St a more complete measure of affordability beyond the standard E Fillmore St method of assessing only Housing E Taylor St Costs. It takes into account both E Granada Rd the$20,833 cost of Ehousing as well as the Polk St E Polk St of transportation associated cost E Coronado Rd with the location of the home. CNT has defined an affordable range for H+T as the combined costs consuming no more than E Brill St 45% of income. E Wi lletta St N 7th Pl Palmcroft Dr W Coronado Rd 45.28% N Alvarado Rd SE N 2nd Ave W Granada Rd W Polk St N 1st Ave W Fillmore St lm Ln W Taylor St 66.23% N 3rd St W Holly St ncanto Dr SE St W Fillmore E McKinley St N 6th St W Cypress W McKinley St St E Oak St E Garfield St E Alvarado Rd N 4th St E Oak St N 1st St e Vista Rd W Pierce St N 4th Ave r NE to D N 6th Ave n Enca W Encanto Blvd St N 8th Ave E Hoover Ave Map and Data from Center for Neighborhood Technology www.cnt.org. May 2012. N 10th St E PortlandStSt E Sheridan E Vernon Ave N 10th St N 3rd St $40,200 E CamE Culver St bridge I- 10AreaAve Data Not Available Target E Virginia Ave Light Rail Less 32,000 $/year I10 Fro E Moreland St Stop 32,000 to 42,000 $/year 42,000 to 53,000 $/year 53,000 to 69,000 $/year $/year and greater E Roosevelt69,000 St N 9th St E Ashland Ave rd N3 N 1st Dr Ave St W Portland $51,793 W Lewis W Portland St I- 10 36.89% E Moreland St N 2nd St N Alvarado Rd N 3rd Ave W Wilshire Dr W Latham St 52.56% Median Household Income Income, $ 45,669 Target Area, Average EPhoenix Willetta St 54,791 61,016 Maricopa County E Roanoke Ave E Windsor Ave E Culver St www.cnt.org e nt Av EgBrill emo St E Ed E Lynwood St N 9th St N 5th St $35,855 E Woodward Dr N Central Ave Papago West Fwy Virginia Ave Papago Fwy W Vernon Ave W Roosevelt St N 9th Ave E McDowell Rd E Thomas Rd E Virginia Cir 52.14% N N Country Club Dr 43.08% E Roanoke E Willetta St Ave W Cambridge Ave N 5th Ave N 7th Ave N 8th Ave N 8th Ave N Alvarado Rd $41,602 E Earll Dr E Coronado Rd E Catalina Dr N 2nd St W Edgemont Ave W Moreland St Portland St N 9th Ave N 1st Ave W McDowell Rd W Thomas Rd W Culver St N 9th Ave N 8th Ave W Merrell St N 1st St N 6th Ave W Almeria Rd W Willetta St W Windsor Ave Moreland St N 1st Ave Palmcroft Dr N 9th Ave t Ave W Catalina Dr N 1st St N 5th Ave N 6th Ave 36.90% W Coronado Rd W Lynwood St E Palm Ln W Earll Dr W Granada Rd N 8th Ave SE W Avalon Dr W Earll Dr E Cheery Lynn Rd N 1st Pl W Palm Ln arll Dr r $52,616 Median Household Income Rd E Monte Vista household Median income includes the income of the householder and all other individuals 15 years old and over in the household, whether they E Granada Rd are related to the householder E Coronado or not.Rd This value represents the median income within a block E Country Club Dr group. N 8th St W Holly St $52,464 N 7th St W Cypress St E Alvarado Rd N Richland St E Oak St W Monte Vista Rd ncanto Dr SE N 7t E Hoover Ave E Oak St N 7th Pl W Encanto Blvd N Alvarado Rd N Central Ave E Sheridan St E Vernon Ave N 2nd St N 3rd Ave N 7th A N 8th N 8th Ave W Vernon Ave E Ashland Ave W Lewis Ave 111 W Lewis Ave N 1st Dr N Central Ave N 3rd Ave N Richland St N Country Club Dr N 5th St N 8th St N 7th St N 3rd St E Virgin I- 10 I10 Fro 17.18% E Portland St E E Hoover Ave 28.22% E Monte Vista Rd E Pierce St N 3rd St E Palm Ln E Fillmore St 19. E Granada E Coronado Rd E Coronado N 5th St E Wi Papago Fwy Papago Fwy W Moreland St W Latham St 25.88% N 2nd St N 1st Dr E Portland St N 5th St E Fillmore St N 6th St N 4th St N 3rd St N 1st Ave N 2nd Ave N 1st St E Garfield St Maps and data from the Center for Neighborhood Technology (CNT) using Regional Moderate data as this target area has a W McKinley St E McKinley St median income which is less than 80% of the regional median. For an explanation of their methods and data as well as links to their E Pierce St website, see pgs 225-226. N 4th Ave E More E Roosevelt St Map and Data from Center for Neighborhood Technology www.cnt.org. May 2012. W Fillmore St E Cu I- 10 I10 Fro E Moreland St W Portland St E Brill S N 7th Pl N 2nd St N 1st St E Culver St E Lynwood St N 8th St 27.86% E Willetta St W Pierce St Central and McDowell Fillmore St Housing and TransportationWAffordability E Pi E McDowell Rd 28.02% 25.52% 16. N 6th St E McKinley St N 5th St E Garfield St N 8th St N Richland St E Oak St E Roosevelt St E Alvarado Rd N 4th St N Alvarado RdSt N 2nd N 2nd Ave N 4th Ave E Oak St W McDowell Rd N 6th Ave N 8th Ave E Vernon Ave W Almeria Rd N 9th Ave N 9th Ave Papago Fwy 21.49% Papago Fwy St N 10th Ave E Virginia Cir rd N3 N 11th Ave E Willetta S E Cam bridg E Sheridan St N Alvarado Rd SW Palmcroft Dr W Coronado Rd W Portland St W Taylor St E E Moreland St E Ashland Ave N 1st St Palmcroft Dr SE W Fillmore St W Granada Rd W Roosevelt St W Taylor St 22.71% N 1st St N 8th Ave N 6th Ave 28.41% W Culver St W McKinley St N 2nd St N 5th Ave N 7th Ave N 8th Ave N 11th Ave W McKinley St W Holly St Transportation Costs, % Income % Income W Lynwood St Target Area, Average 26.1 Phoenix 30.9 W Willetta St Maricopa County 32.1 W Portland St E Culver St St r NE to D W Cypress St www.cnt.org Target Area W Moreland St Light Rail I- 10Stop E Lynwood St E Windsor Ave rd N3 W Roosevelt St n Enca N 9th Ave W Portland St E Edgem Map and Data from Center for Neighborhood Technology www.cnt.org. May 2012. W Encanto Blvd Transportation Cost as a Percentage of Income W Monte Vista Rd Household Transportation Costs are calculated as the sum of Encanto autoWDrPierce SE St ownership costs, auto use costs, W Palm Ln W Fillmore St and public transit costs. Dividing these costs by representative W Taylor St regional incomes illustrates the cost burden placed on a typical household by transportation costs. N 10th Ave 25.13% E Corona E McDowell Rd 15.00% E Woodward Dr W Wilshire Dr W Latham St W Lewis Ave W Vernon Ave W Portland St E Thomas Rd E Willetta St West Virginia Ave E Grana E Verde Ln E Roanoke Ave W Cambridge Ave W Lewis Ave E Coronado Rd N 7th Pl 29.25% W Windsor Ave Target Area W Culver St 22.80% Light Rail reland St W Mo W Wilshire Dr W Moreland St Stop Data Not Available Less than 15% 15 to 18% 18 to 20% 20 to 28% 28% and Greater N 1st St W Edgemont Ave N 1st St N 6th Ave W McDowell Rd W Willetta St W Portland St E Catalina Dr W Merrell St W Almeria Rd E Earll Dr 22.54% N Alvarado Rd N 2nd St W Catalina Dr E Palm Ln N 1st Ave Palmcroft Dr SW N 9th Ave N 8th Ave N 1st Ave 20.92% W Coronado Rd 13.64% W Earll Dr N 1st Ave N 5th Ave N 6th Ave W Granada Rd E Mon N 5th St N 5th St 30.26% W Earll Dr SE Palmcroft Dr N 8th Ave N 9th Ave W Holly St E Alvarado Rd N 1st Pl N 11th Ave r NE to D W Cypress St Housing Costs, % Income % IncomeW Thomas Rd Target Area, AverageW Edgemont 22.0 Ave Phoenix 32.2 W Lynwood St Maricopa County 34.1 112 E Oak St E Oak St N Alvarado Rd n Enca W Encanto Blvd www.cnt.org W Verde Ln I- 10 E Sheridan St E Vernon Ave E Hoover Ave Housing Cost as a Percentage of Income Housing costs factored as a W Monte Vista Rd percent of income has widely been utilized as a measure ofEncanto Dr SE Earll Dr affordability. Traditionally, aWWhome Palm Ln is considered affordable whenWthe Avalon Dr costs consume no more than 30% of household income. Data Not Available Less than 20% 20 to 30% 30 to 40% 40 to 45% 45% and Greater E Ashland Ave N 1st Ave N 8th Ave W Vernon Ave N Central Ave N 3rd Ave N N 8th Ave W Wilshire Dr 27.92% E Pierce S 26.04% N 8th Ave W Vernon Ave W Lewis Ave N Richland St N 3rd St 21.50% E Portland E Sheridan StSt E Roosevelt St E Palm Ln N Alvarado Rd N 1st Ave W Almeria Rd E Culver St N Richland St E Lynwood St I- 10 Target Area I10 FroLight Rail E Moreland St Stop E Moreland St W Latham St E Portland St N 3rd St N 4th St N 1st St N 1st Ave W Fillmore St W Taylor St N 2nd Ave N 4th Ave N 6th Ave W Fillmore St N 8th St St Maps and data from the Center for Neighborhood Technology E Garfield St (CNT) using Regional Moderate data as this target area has a median income which isW less than median. For McKinley St 80% of the regional E McKinley St an explanation of their methods and data as well as links to their W Pierce St website, see pgs 225-226. E Pierce St E Roosevelt St N 5th St N 2nd St N 8th Ave rd N3 Map and Data from Center W Roosevelt St for Neighborhood Technology www.cnt.org. May 2012. E Fillmore St N 6th St 11329/yr W Portland St N 1st Dr 11171/yr E Culver St Papago Fwy Papago Fwy W Moreland St W Portland St Annual $ E Brill St Transportation Costs Target Area, Average 12,311 E Wil letta S Phoenix 12,732 t Maricopa County 13,217 N 9th St N 2nd St N 1st St W Culver St d St www.cnt.org N 9th St N 5th St N 1st St 12194/yr E Willetta St W Willetta St eland St N 5th St E Coronado Rd E McDowell Rd 12263/yr W Lynwood St Household Annual Transportation Costs are calculated as the sum of Auto Ownership Costs, Auto Use 19.80% Costs and Public Transit Costs. Rd E Granada On average, Transportation Costs are the second largest household E Coronado Rd expenditure. E Fillmore St W McDowell Rd Household Annual Transportation Cost N 7th Pl SE Palmcroft Dr W Coronado Rd 18.48% Data Not Available Less than 1% 1 to 4% 4 to 8% 8 to 14% 14% and Greater E Monte Vista Rd E Pierce St 12353/yr W Taylor St W Granada Rd N 6th St N 1st Ave E Pierce St 12434/yr W Fillmore St N 4th St N 2nd Ave E McKinley St W Holly St canto Dr SE W Fillmore St E Oak St E GarfieldESt Alvarado Rd N 3rd St N 4th Ave N 6th Ave W Cypress St W McKinley St N 1st St N 8th Ave r NE to D Vista Rd W Pierce St E Oak St N 9th St E Hoover Ave St n Enca W McKinley St Target Area E Virginia Ave Light Rail E Moreland St Stop I10 Fro E Vernon Ave Map and Data from Center for Neighborhood Technology www.cnt.org. May 2012. W Encanto Blvd E Cam EbCul ridgver e ASt ve I- 10 N 9th St N 2nd St E Virginia Cir Papago Fwy Papago Fwy rd N3 W Roosevelt St E Ashland Ave N 2nd St N Alvarado Rd W Vernon Ave N 1st Dr 22.48% W Portland St and St W Lewis Ave St W Portland E Willetta St 12900/yr E Moreland St E Woodward Dr W Wilshire Dr W Latham St N 3rd Ave W Wilshire Dr E Culver St www.cnt.org Transit Ridership, % of Workers % of Workers ve Target Area, Average 17.6 ont A gem E EEd Brill St Phoenix 5.7 Maricopa County 4.1 E Windsor Ave 12423/yr 12475/yr N Central Ave N 5th Ave N 7th Ave West Virginia Moreland St WAve oreland St E Lynwood St 19.05% N 1st St W Cambridge Ave W Culver St E McDowell Rd E Thomas Rd E Roanoke Ave E Willetta St W Windsor Ave W Willetta St E Verde Ln N 8th St W Edgemont Ave 18.65% W Lynwood St E Coronado Rd N 9th St N 1st St W McDowell Rd 12330/yr N Country Club Dr W Merrell St E Coronado Rd N 8th St E Catalina Dr Transit Ridership as a Percentage of Workers Transit Ridership represents E Monte Vista Rd the percentage of workers in a Block Group who utilize Public Transportation (Transit) as their primary mode of transportation to E Granada Rd work. N 5th St N 5th St N Alvarado Rd W Catalina Dr 11443/yr N 6th Ave E Palm Ln N 1st Ave SE Palmcroft Dr N 8th Ave W Coronado Rd W Almeria Rd s Rd N 8th Ave N 9th Ave 17.00% N 1st Ave W Granada Rd N 6th Ave W Avalon Dr E Alvarado Rd N 7th St N 7th Pl W Holly St W Earll Dr N 8th Ave N Alvarado Rd r NE to D W Cypress St 15.53% ve E Oak St E Oak St m Ln N 9th AveN 8th Ave E Sheridan St E Vernon Ave N 2nd St n Enca W Encanto Blvd Encanto Dr SE N 9th Ave E Ashland Ave E Hoover Ave Vista Rd Ln N Central Av N 3rd Ave W Lewis Ave Data Not Available Less than 8750 $/year 8750 to 9600 $/year 9600 to 10500 $/year 10500 to 11250 $/year 11250 $/year and greater 12221/yr Central and McDowell E Pierce St Housing and Transportation Affordability 113 r NE to D 14882 Miles E Palm Ln W Almeria Rd E Granad E Coronado Rd W McDowell Rd E Coronad E McDowell Rd N 1st St N 2nd St E Willetta St E Culver St E Lynwood St Papago Fwy Papago Fwy W Moreland St W Latham St 12680 Miles W Roosevelt St 13139 Miles W Portland St N 1st Dr W Portland St W Portland St E Portland St N 5th St N 6th St N 4th St N 2nd St N 1st St E McKinley St E Pierce St N 3rd St N 1st Ave N 2nd Ave N 4th Ave N 6th Ave N 8th Ave N 9th Ave St N 10th Ave rd N3 W Fillmore St W McKinley St E Garfield St E Taylor St E Taylor St Travel Time to Work Minutes Target Area, Average 16.1 Phoenix 26.0 Maricopa County 26.0 Target Area Light Rail Stop Central and McDowell Housing and Transportation Affordability EC E Mo 14206 M E Pierce E Fillmore St www.cnt.org Data Not Available Less than 22 minutes 22 to 25 minutes 25 to 29 minutes 29 to 33 minutes 33 minutes and greater I- 10 E Roosevelt St Map and Data from Center for Neighborhood Technology www.cnt.org. May 2012. Travel Time to Work Travel time to work is measured W Pierce St in minutes and represents an W Fillmore St average of the total time it takes Taylor St to W Taylor St commuters in a blockWgroup get to work by their primaryW Polk St mode used. Includes auto, biking, walking, and public transit. letta S t I10 Fro E Moreland St I- 10 E Brill E Wil N 8th St 14438 Miles N 5th St N 9th Ave 14245 Miles N 1st St SW N Alvarado Rd W Coronado Rd Palmcroft Dr 18265 Miles N 1st Ave SE W Granada Rd Target Area W Willetta St Light Rail Stop W Culver St N 11th Ave E Monte Vista Rd N 7th Pl N 11th Ave Palmcroft Dr 114 E Alvarado Rd W Holly St Vehicle Miles Traveled/Household Annual Miles Target Area, Average 15,458 Phoenix 16,732 W Lynwood St Maricopa County 17,937 W Moreland St E Oak St W Cypress St www.cnt.org Data Not Available Less than 12,000 annual miles 12,000 to 14,000 annual miles 14,000 to 16,000 annual miles 16,000 to 18,000 annual miles 18,000 annual miles and greater E Hoover Ave E Oak St N Richland St n Enca W Encanto Blvd E Sheridan St E Vernon Ave N Alvarado Rd Vehicle Miles Traveled per Household Vehicle miles traveled per W Monte Vista Rd household models the average annual auto travel by households Encanto Dr SE in a block group. This includes W Palm commute travel, but also all Ln other daily auto trips made by all members of the household. E Ashland Ave N Central Ave N 3rd Ave N N 8th N 8th Ave W Vernon Ave W Lewis Ave Map and Data from Center for Neighborhood Technology www.cnt.org. January 2012. Maps and data from the Center for Neighborhood Technology (CNT) using Regional Moderate data as this target area has a median income which is less than 80% of the regional median. For an explanation of their methods and data as well as links to their website, see pgs 225-226. 13253 M Washington & 12th Description and Impressions 116 Photographs 117 Stakeholder Information 118 Location Map 119 Market/Demographic Information 120 Aerial Image 121 Parcel Map 122 Building Footprint 123 Zoning 124 Proposed/Future Zoning 125 Land Use 126 Historic Districts and Properties 127 Political and Neighborhood Boundaries 128 Landmarks and Natural/Man-made Features 129 Transportation and Circulation 130 Floodplain and Environmental 131 Ownership 132 Vacant Land and Parking 133 Business Districts and Development Organizations 134 Events and Temporary Installations 135 Utilities and Planned Public Improvements 136 Housing and Transportation Affordability 137 115 Washington and 12th Description and Impressions The half-mile area surrounding the 12th and Washington light rail stop includes a variety of non-profit organization offices and services, a City of Phoenix transportation office building, school facilities, and large surface parking lots. There are also small law office buildings and a legal services facility that includes fleet parking. Numerous buildings large and small have “for lease” signs. Small and very large church buildings are also located here. The area in general is not unpleasant for walking although there is limited access to easily cross the rail line. The smaller-scale buildings such as those housing non-profits and law offices have nice landscaping. The larger-scale industrial style buildings and parking lots lack landscaping and offer an unfriendly presence. Although 116 Washington carries much traffic through this area, many pedestrians were encountered. One block north of Washington and the rail line are a mix of older one-story single-family housing and newer low-rise (three or four-story) multi-family housing. An attractive development of newer one-story single-family homes along curving streets is located at the west end of this area, with the towering buildings of downtown Phoenix and Chase Field in the background. 12th Street stop, looking east 12th and Washington, looking west 117 Adams and 13th Street, looking west 12th Street stop, looking west Monroe and 12th Street, looking west 12th and Washington, looking northwest Washington and 12th Photographs Stakeholders The following is a list of individuals or groups to contact to participate in planning or other events for the half mile area surrounding the light rail stop. The list was created through searches on the internet and conversations with City of Phoenix Staff. City Offices Central City Village Planning Committee City of Phoenix Historic Preservation Office City Council District 8 Business Groups and Individuals Phoenix Community Alliance Phoenix Community United Grace Lutheran Church Mike Lafferty Neighborhood Associations 118 Eastlake Park Neighborhood Association Schools, Churches, and other cultural institutions Baptist Church Pilgrim Church Azteca Plaza Shaw Food Program Washington and 12th Stakeholders 119 Phoenix Tempe Mesa north light rail stop Washington and 12th Location Map 120 north City of Phoenix Census Tract 1140 Population 1,536,632 Median Household Income $47,085 Homeowner Occupied 59.1% Renter Occupied 40.9% Public Transportation Use 3.2% Personal Vehicle Use 74.5% Travel Time 24.2 2,156 $25,208 17.4% 82.6% 15.6% 68.8% 19.5 2009 American Community Survey 2005-2009 American Community Survey 5-year Estimates Washington and 12th Demographics 1/2 mile area 1140 14th St 13th St 12TH ST 11th St 10th St Van Buren St Monroe St Adams St WASHINGTON ST JEFFERSON ST Madison St Jackson St light rail stop north light rail one quarter mile Washington and 12th Aerial 121 14th St 13th St 12TH ST 11th St 10th St Van Buren St Monroe St Adams St WASHINGTON ST JEFFERSON ST 122 Madison St Jackson St light rail stop north light rail one quarter Washington and 12th Parcel Map mile 14th St 13th St 12TH ST 11th St 10th St Van Buren St Monroe St Adams St WASHINGTON ST JEFFERSON ST Madison St Jackson St light rail stop light rail north structures one quarter mile Washington and 12th Building Footprint 123 C-2 14th St 13th St 12TH ST 11th St 10th St C-3 C-2 R-5 RI Van Buren St C-3 R-5 Monroe St R-3 R-5 RI P-1 R-5 C-3 Adams St C-1 C-3 C-1 C-O C-O C-3 C-2 C-3 C-3 C-1 C-3 R-5 RI P-1 P-1 C-2 C-2 R-5 R-4A C-3 R1-6 C-2 R-5 R-5 R1-6 WASHINGTON ST C-3 C-2 HR C-3 R-5 RI R-5 C-3 JEFFERSON ST C-3 C-O 124 R-5 RI C-3 P-1 P-1 A-1 Madison St Jackson St A-2 Source: City of Phoenix Planing Department. September 2011. light rail stop north light rail one quarter Washington and 12th Zoning mile industrial commercial residential A-1 C-O R1-6 A-2 C-1 R-3 C-2 R-4A C-2 HR R-5 C-3 R-5 RI overlay parking historic zone P-1 TOD-1 14th St 13th St 12TH ST 11th St 10th St Van Buren St Monroe St Adams St WASHINGTON ST JEFFERSON ST Madison St Jackson St Information obtained through internet searches and conversations with City of Phoenix staff. light rail There is no proposed rezoning for this area according to current data. north light rail stop one quarter mile Washington and 12th Proposed / Future Zoning 125 14th St 13th St 12TH ST 11th St 10th St Van Buren St Monroe St Adams St WASHINGTON ST JEFFERSON ST 126 Madison St Jackson St Drachman Institute. June 2011. surface parking light rail stop light rail structured parking residential - single family housing vacant residential - multifamily housing north civic/cultural one plaza/park/open space office warehouse retail quarter Washington and 12th Land Use mile medical educational religious 14th St 13th St 12TH ST 11th St 10th St Van Buren St Monroe St Adams St 2 WASHINGTON ST 1 3 4 JEFFERSON ST Madison St Jackson St Information obtained through internet searches and conversations with City of Phoenix staff. light rail 1 Garfield (northwest of target area) - local and national district Ong’s Market - local and national listing 2 Swindell House - local and national listing 3 Booker School - local listing 4 Aldridge House - local listing Modifications to structures located within Local Historic Districts require review by City of Phoenix planning staff. Modifications to structures located within National Historic Districts may or may not require review by the State Historic Preservation Office. north light rail stop one quarter mile Washington and 12th Historic Districts and Properties 127 14th St 13th St 12TH ST 11th St 10th St Van Buren St Monroe St Adams St WASHINGTON ST JEFFERSON ST 128 Madison St Jackson St Information obtained through internet searches and conversations with City of Phoenix staff. Entire half mile area includes: light rail stop City of Phoenix Council District 8 light rail Maricopa County District 5 Eastlake Park Neighborhood Association north Central City Village Planning District one quarter mile Washington and 12th Political and Neighborhood Boundaries 14th St 13th St 12TH ST 11th St 10th St Van Buren St Monroe St Adams St Agustus H Shaw Jr Elementary School Rio Salado College Dental WASHINGTON ST Tertulia PreCollege Community Intermediate Campus JEFFERSON ST Madison St Phoenix Fire Department Jackson St Additional landmarks may be added through various activities to be held in the area. light rail stop light rail school higher education north fire department religious/church one quarter mile Washington and 12th Landmarks and Natural / Man-made Features 129 14th St 13th St 12TH ST 11th St 10th St Van Buren St Monroe St Adams St WASHINGTON ST JEFFERSON ST 130 Madison St Jackson St Drachman Institute. June 2011. traffic signal light rail stop light rail plazas/parks/open space surface parking striped pedestrian crossing structured parking bicycle north bus route streets one quarter mile sheltered bus stop unsheltered bus stop Washington and 12th Transportation and Circulation 14th St 13th St 12TH ST 11th St 10th St Van Buren St Monroe St Adams St WASHINGTON ST JEFFERSON ST Madison St Jackson St Information obtained through internet searches and conversations with City of Phoenix staff. light rail stop There are no known floodplains or environmental sites. light rail floodplain 10 year floodplain 100 year north superfund site landfill recycling center waste center one quarter mile Washington and 12th Floodplain and Environmental 131 14th St 13th St 12TH ST 11th St 10th St Van Buren St Monroe St Adams St WASHINGTON ST JEFFERSON ST 132 Madison St Jackson St Source: Maricopa County Assessor’s Office. July 2011. light rail stop light rail private individual private LLC - multiple owners north Private LLC - individual owner City of Phoenix one quarter mile private multiple holdings religious Washington and 12th Ownership contiguously owned properties 14th St 13th St 12TH ST 11th St 10th St Van Buren St Monroe St Adams St WASHINGTON ST JEFFERSON ST Madison St Jackson St Drachman Institute. June 2011. light rail stop light rail vacant land surface parking north structured parking one quarter mile Washington and 12th Vacant Land and Parking 133 14th St 13th St 12TH ST 11th St 10th St Van Buren St Monroe St Adams St WASHINGTON ST JEFFERSON ST 134 Madison St Jackson St Information obtained through internet searches and conversations with City of Phoenix staff. Entire half mile area includes: light rail stop Phoenix Communities United light rail Phoenix Community Alliance north Grace Lutheran Church Neighborhood Association one quarter mile Washington and 12th Business Districts and Development Organizations 14th St 13th St 12TH ST 11th St 10th St Van Buren St Monroe St Adams St WASHINGTON ST JEFFERSON ST Madison St Jackson St Information obtained through internet searches and conversations with City of Phoenix staff. light rail There are no known temporary installations or events in this area. north light rail stop one quarter mile Washington and 12th Events and Temporary Installations 135 14th St 13th St 12TH ST 11th St 10th St Van Buren St Monroe St Adams St WASHINGTON ST JEFFERSON ST 136 Madison St Jackson St Source: City of Phoenix Water Services Department. September 2011. This map includes: light rail stop water and wastewater utility lines. light rail north water wastewater one quarter mile Washington and 12th Utilities and Planned Public Improvements N 17th St St Pl St St th St St St S 12th St t N 18th St N 18th St N Patricio St S 18th St St 18thSt SN18th S Sky Harbor Cir S 18th St Data Not Available Less than 45% 45% and Greater Target Area Light Rail Stop E Lincoln St E Grant St S 18th St S ss S 16th St S 12th Pl S 11th St S 9th Pl S 9th Way S 9th St S 8th Pl S 8th Pl S 8th St N/A rman St E She Maps and data from the Center for Neighborhood Technology (CNT) using Regional Moderate data as this target area has a E Hadley St St than 80% of the regional median. For E Had median income which isleyless an explanation of their methods and data as well as links to their St website, see pgsE Tonto 225-226. S 8th St S 16th Pl S 15th St S 14th Pl Map and Data from Center for Neighborhood Technology www.cnt.org. May 2012. S 7th St S 6th St S 10th Pl rant St eye Rd RR E Southern Pacific Dr coln St ce Ac www.cnt.org H+T Costs, % Income % Income 45.2 Target Area, Average 63.2 Phoenix 66.2 Maricopa County E Harrison St S 15th St S 6th St nan St S 14th St S 13th St E Madison St E Jackson St Housing and Transportation Cost St E Taylor as a Percentage of Income H+T has been developed as E Polk St a more complete measure of affordability beyond the standard method of assessing only Housing Costs. It takes into account both the cost of housing as well as the cost of transportation associated with the location of the home. CNT has defined an affordable range for H+T as the combined costs consuming no more than 45% of income. N 16th Pl E Adams St St Data Not Available Less 32,000 $/year 32,000 to 42,000 $/year 42,000 to 53,000 $/year 53,000 to 69,000 $/year 69,000 $/year and greater Washington and 12th Housing and Transportation Affordability Harbor Cir S St 14th St N 14th E Monroe St 44.05% S 12th St S 11th St S 10th St S 9th St S 8th St S 8th St S 5th St 46.31% N Patricio St illa EV N 15th St N 13th Pl N 13th St E Polk St N Patricio St E Grant St E Washington St E Jefferson St N 17th St N 17th St E Lincoln St StSt 16th SN 16th S 15th St 48.50% S 17th St Target Area Light Rail Stop E Hadley St S 13th Pl E Yuma E Monroe StSt 47.09% S St 13th St N 13th S 12th St N 12th St N 12th St N 11th Way N 11th Pl N 11th St S 11th St S 12th Pl S 11th St S 9th Way N 9th Pl St S 9th S 8th St S 9th St S 10th St S 8th St S 8th Pl N 8th St N 8th St E Polk St E Van Buren St St E Adams St E Hadley StE Taylor St N 10th N 5th St S 5th St E Monroe St N/A E Fillmore St E Tonto St 50.48% E Polk St S 7th St S 6th St E Taylor St E Sherman St S 9th St S 8th St S 8th Pl Map and Data from Center for Neighborhood Technology www.cnt.org. May 2012. ore St ckeye Rd E Pierce St S 14th Pl 48.18% N 10th St S 10th Pl Grant St erce St E McKinley St N 14th St E Southern Pacific Dr St ss ce Ac St E Garfield RR N 13th St N 10th St N 8th St S 6th St N 6th St ncoln St N 7th St d St E Garfield St N 16th Pl E Diamond St E Roosevelt St hanan St E Portland St www.cnt.org Median Household Income Income, $ 25,357 Target Area, Average 54,791 Phoenix 61,016 Maricopa County E Moreland St N 17th St E Harrison St E Diamond St St Loop 202 N 17th St E Portland St Papago Fwy S 16th Pl N 15th S St15th St S 14th St N 13th Pl E Moreland St E Madison St E Portland E Jackson St St Papago Fwy I- 10 S 13th St S 9th St E Moreland St $13,735 N 12th S 12th St St I- 10 S 10th St N 7th Pl N 5th Pl 36% $36,979 S 11th St S 8th St S 8th St S 5th St I10 Fro nd St E Jefferson St S 17th St E Willetta St E Washington St N 15th St N 14th N St 14th St E Brill St N 16th Pl N 13th Pl N 13th St N 12th St N 11th Way N 11th Pl E Monroe St N 12th St N 10th St N 9th St 61% N 11Nth11th St St N 8th St N 8th St E Brill St E Adams St St N 5th St N 5th St E Van Buren St N 10th E Monroe St E Lynwood St E Polk St N 13th 13th St St N $20,833 E Polk St N 15th St E Taylor St E Taylor St illa EV Median Household $22,850 Income E Taylor St Median household income St E Polk includes the income of the E Polk St householder and all other individuals 15 years old and over in the household, whether they E Monroe St are related to the householder E Brill St E Adams St or not. This value represents the E Willetta St median income within a block group. E Culver St $24,396 E Fillmore St N 10th St N 9th St E Pierce St N 16th St E McKinley St $28,893 more St St E Garfield St N 13t N 10t E Garfield St N 14th St N 6th St Pierce St N 7th St N eld St 137 N 17th St N 16th St N 15th St N 17th St N 16th Pl S 16th Pl S 15th St N 15th St N 17th St S 17th St N 15th St N 14th N St 14th St S 14th St N 13th Pl N 17th St E Lincoln St E Grant S 16th StSt 16th SN S 14th Pl N 14th St N 13th St E Portland S St S 15th St E N 16th Pl E Polk St E Monroe St E Adams St E Washington St ce Ac S ss St Pl St S 12th St S 15th St S 12th Pl S 11th St St th St S 9th Pl S 9th Way St S 9th St St S 8th Pl S 8th St S 8th St S 8th Pl N/A Maps and data from the Center for Neighborhood Technology (CNT) using Regional Moderate data as this target area E Hadley St has a E Hadley St median income which is less than 80% of the regional median. For an explanation of their methods and data as well as links to their E Tonto St website, see pgs 225-226. E Sherman St S 17th St t E Lincoln St S 16th St RR S 14th Pl S 10th Pl S 16th Pl S 14th St S 13th St S 12th St E Harrison St S 4th St S 6th St S 15th St 28.80% 25.45% S 11th St S 10th St S 9th St S 8th St E Jefferson St Map and Data from Center for Neighborhood Technology www.cnt.org. May 2012 S 7th St N 17th St S 13th Pl E Polk St E Southern Pacific Dr Washington and 12th Housing and Transportation Affordability E N 15th St N 13th Pl N 13th St S 12th St N 12th St E Yuma E Monroe St St 27.93% E Hadley St N 14thSSt 14th St E Ad am s 28.93% 13th St N 13thSSt E Woodland Ave N 12th St N 11th Way N 11th Pl S 11th St N 8th St S 8th St S 9th St S 10th St E Van Buren St S 12th Pl S 11th St N 11th St E Polk St E Madison St E Hadley St S 6th St N 13th Pl S 13th St N 12th S 12th St St S 11th St S 10th Pl Pl St S 9th N 9th S 9th Way S 9th St S 8th St S 8th Pl S 8th Pl N 8th St S 8th St 26.04% E Tonto St S 8th St S 5th St N/A E Taylor St ley St E Had E Polk St E Grant St St N 13th 13th St St N N 13th St N 12th St N 12th St N 11th Way N 11th Pl N 10th St S 9th St N 10th St N 8th St N 7th St S 7th St E ShermanEStFillmore St E Jackson St S 4th St E Morelan E Diamond St t sS es cc A E Garfield St RR E McKinley St Target Area Light Rail Stop S 3rd St N 14th St N 13 N 11th St E Portland St E Harrison St Papago Fwy E Pierce St Map and Data from Center for Neighborhood Technology www.cnt.org. May 2012 E Jackson St E Buckeye Rd E Willetta St I- 10 I- 10 E Moreland St 27.92% Transportation Costs, % Income % Income Target Area, Average 27.1 E Madison St 30.9 Phoenix Maricopa County 32.1 E Lincoln St E Brill St E Adams St E Culver St 12.20% E Garfield St E Southern Pacific Dr E Polk St E Monroe St E Roosevelt St S 6th St N 5th St St S 5th S 6th St S 4th St E Moreland St E Diamond St www.cnt.org E Buchanan St E Polk St E Willetta St E Jefferson Papago St Fwy S 10th St N 7th Pl N 5th Pl E Grant St E Pierce St N 6th St E Lincoln St E Brill St E Madison St S 4th St St E Garfield St N 4th St N 11th St N 9th St S 8th St S 8th St S 5th St N 3rd St rd N3 E Buchanan St S 3rd St St E Jackson St St E Portland Target Area Light Rail Stop N 3rd St E Ad am s 16.69% I10 Fro Transportation Cost as a E Fillmore St Percentage ofEIncome Hadley St E Taylor St Household Transportation Costs are calculated as the sum of auto ownership costs, auto use costs, E Buckeye Rd and public transit costs. Dividing these costs by representative E Monroe St regional incomes illustrates the cost burden placed on a typical E Adams St household by transportation costs. Data Not Available Less than 15% 15 to 18% 18 to 20% 20 to 28% 28% and Greater E Monroe St E Washington St 25.88% 138 E Polk St E Woodland Ave E Brill St E 16.50% E E Van Buren St 27.86% Housing Costs, % Income % Income Target Area, Average 14.4 Phoenix 32.2 E Moreland St St Maricopa County E Madison 34.1 14.53% 19.55% E Polk St www.cnt.org Data Not Available Less than 20% 20 to 30% 30 to 40% 40 to 45% 45% and Greater E Fillmore St E Taylor St N 8th St N 5th StN 5th St N 9th St E Pierce St Housing Cost as a E Fillmore St Percentage of Income Housing costs factored as a E Taylor St percent of income has widely been utilized as a measure of affordability. Traditionally, a home is considered affordable when the E Monroe St costs consume no more than 30% E Lynwood St of household income. E Adams St E Jackson St E Garfield St E McKinley St 16.21% N 8th St E Pierce St E Garfield St N 10t N 7th St N 6th St N 3rd St N 4th St N E Garfield St E Grant S S 12th Pl S 11th St S 9th Pl t 0th St S 9th St S 8th Pl S 8th Pl S 8th St S 9th Way t E Yavapai St ce Ac N 17th St 17th St N 17thSSt N 16th Pl N 17th St SN16th 16thStSt N 17th St N 16th Pl S ss Annual Transportation Costs $ Target Area, Average 11,873 Phoenix 12,732 Maricopa County 13,217 Target Area Light Rail Stop t E Lincoln St S 16th St S 14th Pl S 10th Pl S 15th St RR N/A E Sherman St Maps and data from the Center for Neighborhood Technology (CNT) using Regional Moderate data as this target areaEhas a St Hadley E Hadley St median income which is less than 80% of the regional median. For an explanation of their methods and data as well as links to their E Tonto St website, see pgs 225-226. S 8th St S 16th Pl S 14th St S 13th St S 12th St E Jefferson St E Harrison St E Buckeye Rd Household Annual Transportation Cost www.cnt.org 11138/yr 12607/yr E Cocopah St S 11th St E Adams St S 15th St S 13th Pl S 14th N St 14th St S 12th Pl 13thStSt NS13th N 12th St S 12th St E Papago St St Data Not Available Less than 1% 1 to 4% 4 to 8% 8 to 14% 14% and Greater Household Annual Transportation E Polk St Costs are calculated as the sum of Auto Ownership Costs, Auto Use Costs and Public Transit Costs. On average, Transportation Costs are the second largest household expenditure. E Monroe St Map and Data from Center for Neighborhood Technology www.cnt.org. May 2012 7th St illa EV N 15th St N 13th Pl E Polk St S 15th St S 6th St S 6th St E Yavapai St 12225/yr E Southern Pacific Dr incoln St E Grant St E Hadley St N 13th St N 12th St N 11th Pl N 11th St S 11th St E Yuma St E Monroe St E Madison St Grant St 12663/yr E Lincoln St E Yavapai St S 10thSSt10th St S 9th St N 11th Way S 10th St S 9th St S 8th St S 12th Pl S 11th St 9thPlSt SN9th S 9th Way S 9th St S 8th Pl E Van Buren St N 8th St S 8th St N 8th St E Buckeye Rd S 8th St S 6th St E Polk St E Jackson St n St S 14th Pl N 10th StS 10th Pl E Pierce St N 14th St N 13th St N 10th St N 8th St S 8th Pl S 8th St S 8th St S 7th St S 6th St E Tonto St 11398/yr E Polk St St N 6th St E Hadley St E Taylor St E Washington St E Pima St N/A E Fillmore St N 10th N 5th St S 5th St E Yavapai St E Sherman St Target Area Light Rail Stop St ss ce Ac E Garfield St RR E McKinley St 12221/yr E Taylor St N 16th Pl E Diamond St Map and Data from Center for Neighborhood Technology www.cnt.org. May 2012 St S 5th St E Garfield St E Southern Pacific Dr N 7th St N 6th St Grant St e St S 6th St t N 17th St N 16th St E Portland St E Roosevelt St Lincoln St S 16th Pl S 15th St N 14th St S 14th St E Portland St E Harrison St Transit Ridership, % of Workers % of Workers Target Area, Average 16.5 Phoenix 5.7 Maricopa County 4.1 E Jefferson StI- 10 Papago Fwy E Moreland St N 13th Pl E Jackson St St E Portland S 13th St E Moreland St E Diamond St n St N 15th St N 13th Pl N 13th St N 12th St N 12th St N 12th StS 12th St S 11th St S 10th St S 9th St S 8th St Papago Fwy I- 10 E Madison St N 7th Pl N 5th Pl N 13th St N 11th St S 8th St S 5th St I10 Fro land St 13.06% 19.91% www.cnt.org E Adams St S 17th St N 10th St St N 6th St N 10th E Monroe St E Washington St 4/yr E Polk St E Monroe St N 8th St N 8th St E Van Buren St N 11th Way N 11th Pl E Polk St St Transit Ridership as a Percentage of Workers Transit Ridership represents Polk St Ethe percentage of workers in a Block Group who utilize Public Transportation (Transit) as their primary mode of transportation to work. illa EV 13.55% E Taylor St 19.80% E Polk St 14.61% E Fillmore St E Taylor St N 5th St N 13t N 10t E Pierce St e St 9/yr E Garfield St E McKinley St 18.48% N 9th St ce St E Garfield St N 14th St N 6th St N 7th St N St E Grant St Data Not Available Less than 8750 $/year 8750 to 9600 $/year 9600 to 10500 $/year 10500 to 11250 $/year 11250 $/year and greater Washington and 12th Housing and Transportation Affordability 139 N 10th St N 16th St S 12th Pl S 11th St E Hadley St E Hadley St S 14th St E Papago St S 12th Pl E Yuma St S 13th Pl S 13th St S 12th St S 11th St S 10th St S 8th St S 9th St E Buckeye Rd Travel Time to Work Minutes Target Area, Average 21.6 Phoenix 26.0 Maricopa County 26.0 Data Not Available Less than 22 minutes 22 to 25 minutes 25 to 29 minutes 29 to 33 minutes 33 minutes and greater Target Area Light Rail Stop Washington and 12th Housing and Transportation Affordability N 17th St N 16th Pl S 17th St S 16th Pl E Lincoln St S 16th St S 14th Pl S 10th Pl S 9th Pl S 9th Way S 9th St S 8th St S 8th Pl t E Tonto St S 8th Pl S 8th St N/A S ss n Stand Data from Center for Neighborhood Technology www.cnt.org. May 2012 E Sherma Map S 7th St E Pima St N 15th St S 15th St RR ce Ac S 15th St S 6th St S 5th St N 14th St E Harrison St E Southern Pacific Dr S 6th St S 4th St E Adams St S 14th St S 13th St S 12th St E Jackson St www.cnt.org E Polk St 15027 Miles S 4th St S 3rd St 140 Travel Time E Hadley St to Work Travel time to work is measured in minutes and represents an average of the total time it takes commuters in a block group to E Yavapai St get to work by their primary mode used. Includes auto, biking, walking, and public transit. N 13th Pl N 13th St N 13th St N 12th St N 11th St E Madison St S 11th St S 9th St S 8th St S 10th St S 5th St S 8th St 13012 Miles E Jefferson St E Polk St E Monroe St E Monroe St St St Data Not Available E JacksonTarget Area Less than 12,000 Light Rail Stop annual miles 12,000 to 14,000 E Buchanan St annual miles 14,000 to 16,000 annual miles E Lincoln St 16,000 to 18,000 annual miles E Grant St 18,000 annual miles and greater N 12th St N 11th Pl E Polk St N 11th Way N 9th St N 8th St N 8th St E Van Buren St N 6th St N 5th St 13253 Miles E Washington St Vehicle Miles Traveled/Household Annual Miles Target Area, Average 14,020 Phoenix 16,732 St ison E Mad Maricopa County 17,937 illa EV 14169 Miles E Taylor St N 10th www.cnt.org E Polk St 14753 Miles E Fillmore St N 14th St E Pierce St N 4th St Vehicle Miles Traveled E Fillmore St per Household Vehicle miles traveled per E Taylor St household models the average annual auto travel by households in a block group. This includes commute travel, but also all Monroe St other daily auto trips Emade by all members of the household. N 17th N N N 7th St N 6th St N 4th St N 3rd St E Pierce St E McKinley St 14206 Miles Map and Data from Center for Neighborhood Technology www.cnt.org. January 2012. Maps and data from the Center for Neighborhood Technology (CNT) using Regional Moderate data as this target area has a median income which is less than 80% of the regional median. For an explanation of their methods and data as well as links to their website, see pgs 225-226. E Grant St St Apache & McClintock Description and Impressions 142 Photographs 143 Stakeholder Information 144 Location Map 145 Market/Demographic Information 146 Aerial Image 147 Parcel Map 148 Building Footprint 149 Zoning 150 Proposed/Future Zoning 151 Land Use 152 Historic Districts and Properties 153 Political and Neighborhood Boundaries 154 Landmarks and Natural/Man-made Features 155 Transportation and Circulation 156 Floodplain and Environmental 157 Ownership 158 Vacant Land and Parking 159 Business Districts and Development Organizations 160 Events and Temporary Installations 161 Utilities and Planned Public Improvements 162 Housing and Transportation Affordability 163 141 Apache and McClintock Description and Impressions One mile from the eastern edge of Arizona State University, the half-mile area surrounding the Apache and McClintock light rail stop includes a variety of housing options, typical retail services (automobile repair, restaurants, small grocery stores, liquor stores and bars), and a police substation. The area has a combination of historically designated single-family neighborhoods to the northwest, older lower density multi-family residences, newer multi-family student housing developments along the corridor, and older mobile home communities to the east. Apache Boulevard served as an interstate highway until U.S. 60 was built to the south in the 1970s. As a result, the area was built for the automobile and is typical of many urban areas built between the 1950s and 1980s. Wide streets, narrow sidewalks, and parking lots make up the 142 built environment. The proximity to the University makes this a heavily travelled bicycle corridor. Lots on the west side of McClintock along the corridor are narrow and shallow, with smaller commercial buildings, the exception being the south west corner, which has two narrow and very deep properties. Lots to the east side of McClintock are also narrow, but much deeper. Lots on the north have access to both Apache, and the residential area to the north. Lots on the south have access to Apache, and are more than 1,200 feet deep, extending to the Union Pacific Railway to the south, which is adjacent to industrial properties. There are height restrictions on surrounding parcels, and a special district has been developed for this area. The area has a combination of all residential, mixed-use, commercial and industrial land uses within ½ mile of the intersection, providing unique living and employment opportunities. Apache and McClintock, looking southwest Apartments 143 McClintock and Hayden, looking west 8th and Una Apache and McClintock, looking west Residential Street Apache and McClintock Photographs Stakeholders The following is a list of individuals or groups to contact to participate in planning or other events for the half mile area surrounding the light rail stop. The list was created through searches on the internet and conversations with city of Tempe staff. City Offices Tempe City Council Neighborhood Associations Alegre Community Neighborhood Association Don Carlos Neighborhood Association Hudson Manor Neighborhood Association University Heights Neighborhood Association Churches Greater Phoenix Chinese Christian Church 144 Apache and McClintock Stakeholders 145 Phoenix Tempe Mesa north light rail stop Apache and McClintock Location Map 146 north City of Tempe Census Tract 3191.02 / 3192 Population 172,589 Median Household Income $48,585 Homeowner Occupied 51.0% Renter Occupied 49.0% Public Transportation Use 3.0% Personal Vehicle Use 72.9% Travel Time 20.4 10,708 / 9,661 $25,517 / $33,377 8.0% / 26.6% 92% / 73.4% 9.9% / 12.5% 49.6% / 62.6% 19.9 / 25.5 2009 American Community Survey 2005-2009 American Community Survey 5-year Estimates Apache and McClintock Demographics 1/2 mile area 3191.02 3191 Bonnie Ln McCLINTOCK DR Butte Ave Una Ave Orange St Don Carlos Ave 12th St APACHE BLVD Hudson Dr 147 Williams St Cedar St Railroad light rail stop north light rail one quarter mile Apache and McClintock Aerial Bonnie Ln McCLINTOCK DR Butte Ave Una Ave Orange St Don Carlos Ave 12th St APACHE BLVD Hudson Dr 148 Williams St Cedar St Railroad light rail stop north light rail one quarter Apache and McClintock Parcel Map mile Bonnie Ln McCLINTOCK DR Butte Ave Una Ave Orange St Don Carlos Ave 12th St APACHE BLVD Hudson Dr 149 Williams St Cedar St Railroad light rail stop light rail north structures one quarter mile Apache and McClintock Building Footprint R-3 R-2 R-4 R-4 R1-6 Bonnie Ln McCLINTOCK DR Butte Ave Una Ave R-4 R-3 Orange St R-1 PAD Don Carlos Ave R1-6 R-4 R-2 12th St R-4 MU-4 CSS TP CSS CSS APACHE BLVD MU-4 Hudson Dr CSS 150 CSS R-4 Williams St R1-6 GID Cedar St Railroad Source: City of Tempe Planning Division. September 2011. light rail stop north light rail one quarter mile commercial residential CSS R-1 PAD industrial R1-6 GID R-2 overlays R-3 historic zone R-4 PAD TP mixed use Apache and McClintock Zoning MU-4 Bonnie Ln McCLINTOCK DR Butte Ave Una Ave Orange St Don Carlos Ave 12th St APACHE BLVD Hudson Dr 151 Williams St Cedar St Railroad Information obtained through internet searches and conversations with City of Tempe staff. light rail There is no proposed rezoning for this area according to current data. north light rail stop one quarter mile Apache and McClintock Proposed and Future Zoning Bonnie Ln McCLINTOCK DR Butte Ave Una Ave Orange St Don Carlos Ave 12th St APACHE BLVD Hudson Dr 152 Williams St Cedar St Railroad Drachman Institute. June 2011. surface parking light rail stop light rail structured parking residential - single family housing vacant residential - multifamily housing north civic/cultural one plaza/park/open space office warehouse retail quarter Apache and McClintock Land Use mile medical educational religious Bonnie Ln McCLINTOCK DR Butte Ave Una Ave Orange St Don Carlos Ave 12th St APACHE BLVD Hudson Dr 153 Williams St Cedar St Railroad Information obtained through internet searches and conversations with City of Tempe staff. light rail Garfield - local and national district Note: To the west of the area, there are three potentially eligible historic districts: Tomlinson Estates 1950~1953 Hudson Park 1958~1959 Hudson Manor 1948~1955 Modifications to structures located within Local Historic Districts require review by City of Tempe planning staff. Modifications to structures located within National Historic Districts may or may not require review by the State Historic Preservation Office. north light rail stop one quarter mile Apache and McClintock Historic Districts and Properties Bonnie Ln McCLINTOCK DR Butte Ave Una Ave Orange St Don Carlos Ave 12th St APACHE BLVD Hudson Dr 154 Williams St Cedar St Railroad Information obtained through internet searches and conversations with City of Tempe staff. Entire half mile area includes: light rail stop City of Tempe Council District light rail Maricopa County District 1 University Heights Neighborhood Association Don Carlos Neighborhood Association north Hudson Manor Neighborhood Association Alegre Community Neighborhood Association one quarter mile McClintock and Apache Political and Neighborhood Boundaries Bonnie Ln McCLINTOCK DR Butte Ave Una Ave Orange St Don Carlos Ave 12th St APACHE BLVD Tempe Police Department Hudson Dr 155 Williams St Cedar St Railroad light rail stop Additional landmarks may be added through various activities to be held in the area. light rail railroad police department north religious/church one quarter mile Apache and McClintock Landmarks and Natural / Man-made Features Bonnie Ln McCLINTOCK DR Butte Ave Una Ave Orange St Don Carlos Ave 12th St APACHE BLVD Hudson Dr 156 Williams St Cedar St Railroad Drachman Institute. June 2011. traffic signal light rail stop light rail plazas/parks/open space surface parking striped pedestrian crossing structured parking bicycle north bus route streets one quarter Apache and McClintock Transportation and Circulation mile railroad sheltered bus stop unsheltered bus stop Bonnie Ln McCLINTOCK DR Butte Ave Una Ave Orange St Don Carlos Ave 12th St APACHE BLVD Hudson Dr 157 Williams St Cedar St Railroad light rail stop There are no known floodplains or environmental sites. light rail floodplain 10 year floodplain 100 year north superfund site landfill recycling center waste center one quarter mile Apache and McClintock Floodplain and Environmental Bonnie Ln McCLINTOCK DR Butte Ave Una Ave Una Ave Orange St Don Carlos Ave 12th St APACHE BLVD Hudson Dr 158 Williams St Cedar St Railroad Source: Maricopa County Assessor’s Office. July 2011. light rail stop light rail private individual private LLC - multiple owners north Private LLC - individual owner City of Tempe one quarter mile private multiple holdings religious Apache and McClintock Ownership contiguously owned properties Bonnie Ln McCLINTOCK DR Butte Ave Una Ave Orange St Don Carlos Ave 12th St APACHE BLVD Hudson Dr 159 Williams St Cedar St Railroad Drachman Institute. June 2011. light rail stop light rail vacant land surface parking north structured parking one quarter mile Apache and McClintock Vacant Land and Parking Bonnie Ln McCLINTOCK DR Butte Ave Una Ave Orange St Don Carlos Ave 12th St APACHE BLVD Hudson Dr 160 Williams St Cedar St Railroad light rail stop light rail north Information not available. one quarter mile Apache and McClintock Business Districts and Development Organizations Bonnie Ln McCLINTOCK DR Butte Ave Una Ave Orange St Don Carlos Ave 12th St APACHE BLVD Hudson Dr 161 Williams St Cedar St Railroad Information obtained through internet searches and conversations with City of Tempe staff. light rail There are no known temporary installations or events in this area. north light rail stop one quarter mile Apache and McClintock Events and Temporary Installations Bonnie Ln McCLINTOCK DR Butte Ave Una Ave Orange St Don Carlos Ave 12th St APACHE BLVD Hudson Dr 162 Williams St Cedar St Railroad Source: City of Tempe Engineering Department in Public Works. August 2011. This map includes: light rail stop water and wastewater utility lines light rail north water wastewater one quarter mile Apache and McClintock Utilities and Planned Public Improvements California Ohio Hawaii Price Fw S Lola Ln S George Dr S Cottonw ood Dr State Hwy 101 S Siesta Ln S Lola Ln S Lola Ln E Randall Dr E Victory Dr S Cottonwood Dr State Hwy 101 S River Dr E Don Carlos Ave E McArthur D $29,375 t en ar tm Ap pe Te m California S Indian Bend Rd Hwy 101 Price FwyState S Bala Dr S Lola Ln Iowa Al ex an S Siesta Ln S Siesta Ln S River Dr S Tempe Ct S River Dr S Smith Rd S Questa Vida S Perry Ln S Los Feliz Dr S Melody Ln S Country Club Way S Holbrook Ln S Kachina Dr E Center Ln Apartment S Dorsey S Dorsey Ln Ln Map and Data from Center for Neighborhood Technology www.cnt.org May 2012 Dr S Hacienda Dr E Broadway Rd E University Dr $31,542 EE 5th St Village Apartment Riviera E Riviera Village Apartment River Rockford $28,638 Data Not Available Less 32,000 $/year olin os Cir 32,000 to 42,000 E 6th St $/year S Sh 42,000 to 53,000 $/year an no nD 53,000 to 69,000 $/year r 69,000 $/year and greater Target Area ST or r Light Rail Stop eM E 6th St E Encanto Dr E Apartment S Tempe Ct S River Dr S Rockford Dr S Questa Vida S Martin Ln E Cedar St E Apartment E Maryland Dr Median Household Income Income, $ Dr 25,960 TargetE Wildermuth Area, Average 55,749 Tempe E Cedar St 61,016 Maricopa County S Rockford Dr $27,386 S Clark Dr S Hazelton Ln E 3rd St E Laird S www.cnt.org S Clark Dr S Melody Ln Apartment SS S Perry L $23,047 E Apartment E Hudson Dr S Mobile Home Park $27,723 US Hwy 89 E Williams St S Kenneth Pl E Don Carlos Ave E Lemon St S McClintock Dr S Gary Dr E 12th St $27,111 S Oak St S Cedar St E Apache Blvd E Randall Dr S Ve Ella Cir S Butte Ave S Una Ave E Don Carlos Ave E Hall St S Stanley Pl S Hacienda Dr S Dorsey Ln E Orange St ta Ln S Mariana St E Hayden Ln E Lemon St S Newberry Ln $37,985 E 8th St ve ate Ave State A E Kirkland Ln $25,931 Median Household Income E Center Ln E Questa Vida Median household income E 10th includes St the income of the householder and all other E Orange St individuals 15 years old and over in the household, whether they E Howe are related to Ave the householder E Lemon St or not. This value represents the median income within a block group. E Questa Vida S Sies 5,050 E Center Ln Dr E Center Ln River Rockford E University Dr e Or $27 W Birc W Broadw ttonwood Dr ttonwood Dr S Price RdS Co Price Fwy S Indian Bend Rd S Cottonw ood Dr E Aspen Dr S Price Rd S Price Rd S Pine St S Shannon Dr S River Dr E Aspen Dr annon Dr Dr Clark Dr S Taylor Dr S Kachina Dr S Butte Ave S Oak St t r es D E Aspen Dr SB E Bishop Dr r en D Dr r ta D Vis sp EA S Cottonwood Dr S Co S Price Rd Price Fwy State Hwy 101 S Siesta Ln S Siesta Ln S Bala Dr S Lola Ln S Lola Ln S Siesta Dr S River Dr S Clark Dr S Country Club Way S Holbrook Ln S Los Feliz Dr S Kachina Dr S Elm St S Dorsey Ln S Shannon Dr S River Dr S Country Club Way S Clark Dr S Martin Ln S Holbrook Ln S Hazelton Ln E Apartment S Los Feliz Dr E Apache Blvd S Alder Dr S McClintock Dr S Kachina Cir S Taylor Dr S Kachina Dr S VeSElla Cir Butte Ave S Butte Ave S Taylor Dr S Elm St S Oak St S Cedar St S Gary Dr S Elm St S Una Ave S Oak St S Pine St S Mariana St S Stanley Pl S Kenneth Pl E Verlea Dr l Data Not Available E Village Antigua Less thanApartment 45% 45% and Greater p Tem Rd Dr S Allred reen verg r red D S All Dr Cir Target AreaS Sha nn on Light Rail Stop Dr SE on Dr S Los Feliz l yP orda E el Parque Dr www.cnt.org E el Parque Dr Maps and data from the Center for Neighborhood Technology ft Dr Palmcro E E el Parque Drdata as this target area has a (CNT) using Regional Moderate E Palmcroft Dr median income Ewhich is less than 80% of the regional median. For Broadmor Dr E Broadmoor Dr Apache and McClintock an explanation of their methods and data as well as links to their r aD E Palmcroft Dr d r o Housing and Transportation Affordability website, see pgs 225-226. onc E Concorda Dr EC ve S Gary A tanle onc EC E Palmdale Dr nn E Broadway Rd Map and Data from Center for Neighborhood Technology www.cnt.org May 2012 ha E Encanto Dr 52.43% E Cedar St H+T Costs, % Income % Income Village Apartment E Riviera 49.1 Target Area, Average ST E Riviera Village Apartment 59.1 Tempe or r eM olin 66.2 Maricopa os County E Apartment 47.35% SS E Bishop Cir S Newberry Ln E el Parque Dr ana eC ve S Gary A E Cedar St E Apartment SS Cir E Center Ln p Tem Housing and Transportation Cost E Questa E el Vida Par que Dr E el Parque Dr as a Percentage of Income E el Parque Dr E Qu E Palmcroft Dr E Palmcrof esta Dr t Dr E Kirkland Ln Vida 163 arque H+T has been developed as E el P E Palmcroft Dr E56.55% Broadmor Dr Ln d E 8th St E Kirklan Dr E Broadmoor r i 51.47% C E 10thaStmore complete measure of Dr E Hayden Ln E Palmcroft Dr E 10th St orda onc E Concorda Dr EC affordability beyond the standard E Orange St E Victory Dr r E Orange St D E Randall Dr E Verlea Dr E Aspen Dr orda onc Dr n method of assessing only Housing Dr en EC e E Asp E Don Carlos Ave sp Ave Carlos E Don EA E Bishop Dr E Aspen Dr r 1.69% r ta D D Costs. It takes into account both s i s e V r r lo D a E Lemon St F w St Lemon E o d E om E M ea r E Howe Ave EL D n lo the cost of housing as well as the E Loma Vista Dr E G ay E Bishop Dr E Hall St E 12th St Dr cost of transportation associated E Lemon St nny E Bishop Dr e P E 45.06% E Alameda Dr 53.98% r with the location of the home. nny D E Pe E Apache Blvd US Hwy 89 E Balboa Dr CNT has defined an affordable 53.32% E Balboa Dr range for H+T as the combined 45.35% E Hudson Dr costs consuming no more than E Wildermuth Dr E Williams St 48.32% 45% of income. E Palmdale Dr E Lemon St 17.57% S Clark Dr S Smith Rd S Melody Ln S Hacienda Dr Map and Data from Center for Neighborhood Technology www.cnt.org May 2012 S Country Club Way 23.71% E Broadway Rd E University Dr S Holbrook Ln 21.85% E Encanto Dr E 6th St S Los Feliz Dr S Kachina Dr E Apartment S Questa Vida E 3rd St E Cedar St E Apartment 19.95% 14.82% S Perry Ln E Hudson Dr US Hwy 89 S Martin Ln E Apache Blvd S Clark Dr E 12th St E Apache Blvd S Cedar St E Don Carlos Ave 25.38% E Williams St S Kenneth Pl S Stanley Pl S Newberry Ln E Ora E Randall Dr S Hazelton Ln E Hall St S Dorsey Ln S Dorsey Ln S Jentilly Ln S Terrace Rd S Terrace Rd S Pv t D r S Questa Vida S Perry Ln E Lemon St Data Not Available Target Area Dr Cerro E Apartment E Vista del Light Rail Stop Less than 20% E Encanto Dr St 6th 30% 20E to E Granada Dr 30 to 40% EA lpha D Dr E Solana 40r to 45% E Broadway Ln 45% and Greater S la Rosa Dr S Ventura Dr iu m S Melody Ln S Dorsey Ln E Don Carlos Ave S Apartment S Apartment S Rural Rd S Sunset Dr Packard Dr E Orange St S McClintock Dr Rd ad E 10th St E Hayden Ln E Vista del Cerro Dr St 23.50% E 8th St S Gary Dr ce ra E Jen Tilly Ln E E Kirkland Ln 28.35% www.cnt.org Housing Costs, % Income % Income Target Area, Average 20.9 Tempe 29.8 E Spence Ave Maricopa County 20.01% 34.1 S McAllister Ave E Center Ln S Mariana St r Te Orange Mall S S McAllister Ave Tyler Mall Apartment E Center Ln E Krueger St E Krueger St S Ve Ella Cir Housing Cost as a Percentage of Income E Tyler St Housing costs factored21.86% as a E Terrace Rd percent of income has widely been utilized as a measure of affordability. Traditionally, a home is considered affordable when18.09% the E Lemon St costs consume no more than 30% of household income. 20.64% S Hacienda Dr E University Dr S Butte Ave Dr S Una Ave lpha Dr S Oak St EA ium S Terrace Rd ta d SP SS Dr S Clark Dr S Hazelton Ln S Clark Dr S Martin Ln E Apartment E Apache Blvd S Country Club Way S Holbrook Ln S Los Feliz Dr S Kachina Dr S Taylor Dr S Elm St E Bishop Dr onc EC E en Asp or Dr s Dr Clark Dr ista Apartment S Taylor Dr S Taylor Dr S Butte Ave S Ve Ella Cir S Butte Ave S McClintock Dr S Oak St S Oak St E Verlea Dr S Kachina Dr r aD cord r Feliz D Palm Dr Maps andDrdata from the Center for Neighborhood Technology E el Parque Dr E Palmdale (CNT) using Regional Moderate data as this target area has a E Palmcroft Dr el Parque Dr median incomeEwhich is less than 80% of the regional median. For E Broadmor an explanation of Dr their methods and data as well as links to their website, see pgsE 225-226. r Palmcroft Dr da D ve S Gary A l yP on EC S Kachina Dr S Elm St S Gary Dr S Una S Elm St Ave S Oak St S Pine St E Broadway Rd Map and Data from Center for Neighborhood Technology www.cnt.org May 2012 S Pine St S Dorsey Ln S Terrace Rd e Dr E el Parqu 28.72% S Los S Bonarden Ln S Granada Dr S Jentilly Ln S la Rosa Dr S la Rosa Dr 25.50% S Butte Ave S Stanley Pl S Newberry Ln S Cedar St S Apartment S Kenneth Pl S Bonarden Ln S Apartment S Rural Rd S Mariana St S Granada Dr S Sunset Dr S Palm Dr S McAllister Ave S la Rosa Dr S Ventura Dr S Sierra Vista Dr S McAllister Ave S Ventura Dr S Ventura Dr E Encanto Dr tanle E Concorda Dr SS S Sierra Vista Dr 28.37% 30.53% E Apartment Apache and McClintock o Cir d on E Benjamin Dr ed Housing and Transportation Affordability ER E Broadmor Dr r rda D E Hudson Dr E Cedar St E Vista del Cerro Dr Encanto Dr US Hwy 89 E Apache Blvd E Williams St Data Not Available Target Area Light Rail Stop Less than 15% E Apartment E Vista del Cerro Dr Dr E Encanto 15 to 18% E Granada 18 to Dr 20% 20 Dr to 28% E Solana E Broadway Ln 28% and Greater Dr Rd S Ventura Dr ce ra E Jen Tilly Ln S Los Feliz l yP r Te E 15th St ve S Gary A tanle S www.cnt.org Transportation Costs, % Income % Income Target Area, Average 26.4 E Spence Ave Tempe 27.90% 29.3 Maricopa County 32.1 E 14th St o Conc SS E el Parque Dr E Center Ln E Palmdale Dr Transportation Cost as a E Center Ln E Palmcroft Dr Percentage of Income E el Parque Dr Tyler Mall E Tyler St E E Tyler St 164 Ln E Kirkland 27.97% 25.00% E Broadmor Dr Household Transportation Costsir 28.20% C E 8th St do Dr on are Dr calculated E Benjamin E Palmcroft Dr E 10th St E Terrace Rdas the sum Rof rda ed auto E Hayden Ln Conco E E r ownership costs, auto use costs, D n Dr Broadmor E a E As E pe Ora Orange Mall ord E OrangeEStVerlea Dr r E Randall Dr onc en D EC p and public transit costs. Dividing s EA E Concorda Dr E Bishop Dr E rDon Carlos Ave E Don Carlos Ave ta D Dr 23.60% Vis these costs by representative res r a dow D E Loma Vista Dr E Flo Lom E M ea E Loma Vista Dr E Lemon St r St E Lemon E D E Lemon St n E Loma Vis lo y regional incomes illustrates the a E Loma Vista Dr EG E Hall St E 12th St cost burden placed on24.01% a typical 27.49% household by transpiration costs. 28.60% E Krueger St E Krueger St E Aspen California Ohio Hawaii Stat S Lola Ln d Dr S George Dr S Cottonwoo Price Fwy State Hwy 101 S Siesta Ln t en ar tm Ap Iowa S el Dorado E 7th St Hawaii Ohio S George Dr S Cottonwood Dr S Cottonw ood Dr S Cottonwoo S Price Rd d Dr State Hwy 101 S Siesta Ln S Bala Dr S Lola Ln S Lola Ln S Indian Bend Rd State Hwy 101 S Price Rd S Bala Dr S Lola Ln Price Fwy S Tempe Ct S River Dr pe Al ex an Te m S Siesta Ln S Siesta Ln S River Dr S River Dr S Shannon Dr E Loma Vista Dr E Aspen Dr t en ar tm Ap pe Te m Al ex an d Dr S Price Rd S Cottonwoo E Aspen Dr E Aspen Dr S el Dorado 10775/y S Price Rd S Bala Dr E Palmcroft Dr Apache and McClintock E Broadmoor Dr Housing and Transporation Affordabilty E Concorda Dr E Meadow Dr S Indian Bend Rd S Siesta Ln S Clark Dr E el Parque Dr S Shannon Dr S Taylor Dr S Kachina Dr S Pine St S Oak St S Butte Ave s Dr S Country Club Way S Dorsey Ln S Elm St E Dr Available Target Area Apartment Village Not E RivieraData Apartment Village Light SRail Riviera E Less than 8750 $/year Tor r Stope Molino s C 8750 to 9600 $/year ir S 9600 to 10500 $/year Sh an no n D 10500 to 11250 $/year r 11250 $/year and greater E Aspen Dr Rd l reen ana verg eC SE E Bishop Dr en Asp 12219/yr p Tem E Verlea Dr E McArthur Dr l Dr ve S Gary A orda eliz Dr S Los F Maps andE data from the Center for Neighborhood Technology E el Parque Dr Palmdale Dr (CNT) using Regional Moderate data as this target area has a E el Parque Dr median income which is less than 80% of the regional median. For ue Dr rq a P l Ee Dr their an explanation ofE Broadmor their methods and data as well EasPalmcroft links to Dr website, see pgs 225-226. E Palmcroft Dr E Don Carlos Ave ana eC Map and Data from Center for Neighborhood Technology www.cnt.org May 2012 E Randall Dr p Tem E Broadway Rd S Holbrook Ln 11755/yr S Los Feliz Dr 10344/yr E Encanto Dr S Kachina Dr E Apartment 165 www.cnt.org Annual Transportation Costs $ Target Area, Average 11,756 E Wildermuth Dr Tempe 12,025 Maricopa ECounty 13,217 Cedar St E Apartment E Apache Blvd S McClintock Dr E Cedar St E Palmcrof t Dr Dr E Maryland E Victory Dr Price Fwy 12549/yr 11603/yr S Rockford Dr US Hwy 89 S River Dr Apartment S Melody Ln 11219/yr E Hudson Dr S Questa Vida S Smith Rd r dow D E Apache Blvd S Oak St S Clark Dr E M ea E 12th St E Apartment onc EC S Country Club Way S Los Feliz Dr Dr S Hazelton Ln S Kachina Dr S Ve Ella Cir S Butte Ave S Butte Ave E r nD spe EA E Don Carlos Aver D res E Flo St Lemon ED r Gaylon 11703/yr E Williams St S Kenneth Pl S Stanley Pl S Newberry Ln S Cedar St S Gary Dr E Hall St Cir S Hacienda Dr S Elm St S Una Ave E Bishop Dr S Taylor Dr S Oak St S Pine St S Dorsey Ln S Dorsey Ln E Don Carlos Ave r ta D Vis E Lemon St orda E el Parqu E Laird St e Dr r red D a Lom E Randall Dr onc EC Vida on Oreg S All S Mariana St E OrangeEStVerlea Dr Household Annual Transportation E Broadmoor Dr E Kirkland Ln E 10t h St Costs are calculated as the sum of E Concorda DrE 10th St n Dr St pe Auto Ownership Costs, Auto Use EEAsOrange E Aspen Dr Costs and Public Transit Costs. E Aspen Dr On average, Transportation Costs E Loma Vista Dr Vista E Loma E Howe AveDr are the second largest household E Lemon St expenditure. 11428/yr E Hayden Ln esta Id R ana reen eC verg E 8th St E Palmcroft Dr E Qu ia p Tem 11527/yr Household E el ParqueAnnual Dr E Questa Vida Transportation Cost E Palmcroft Dr orn lif 9.71% Ca ah SE E Dr E KirklandELn Palmcroft Dr E Broadmor Dr r Feliz D 513/yr orda E el Parque Dr E el Parque Dr Nevada Utah nal l yP onc EC E Center Ln E Center Ln S Los ve S Gary A e Dr E el Parqu tanle ir oC SS r E Palmdale Dr Apartment VillageNot E Riviera Data Available Target Area E 5th St ST Riviera Village Apartment E o Light Rail Stop Less than 1% rre Mo lino sC 1 to 4% ir E 6th St S Sh 4 to 8% an no nD 8 to 14% r 14% and Greater Dr Map and Data from CenterDrfor Neighborhood Technology www.cnt.org May 2012 E University E Cedar St a StatemApve eC Te S Holbrook Ln 8.91% E Broadway Rd S Clark Dr S Clark Dr S Martin Ln E 6th StE Encanto Dr 6.47% Transit Ridership, % of Workers % of Workers Target Area, Average 10.9 Tempe 9.1 E Wildermuth Dr Maricopa County 4.1 River Rockford S Kachina Dr S McClintock Dr E Apartment E 3rd St E Cedar St 15.08% S Perry Ln 10.61% www.cnt.org Price Fwy US Hwy 89 E Apache Blvd 7.18% S Lola Ln S Lola Ln S River Dr 10.58% E Hudson Dr E Apartment E Lemon St S Shannon Dr E 12th St S River Dr E Lemon St E Apartment S Tempe Ct S River Dr S Questa Vida S Melody Ln Apartment S Hazelton Ln S Ve Ella Cir S Butte Ave S Una Ave S Gary Dr S Oak St S Cedar St E Don Carlos Ave 11.39% E Williams St S Kenneth Pl E Randall Dr E Apache Blvd S Mariana St E Orange St E Don Carlos Ave E Hall St S Stanley Pl 10.66% E 8th St Il Transit Ridership as a E Laird St E Questa Vida Percentage of Workers E Qu E Maryland Dr esta Vida Transit Ridership represents E Kirkland Ln E Randall Dr E 10tthe h St percentage of workers in a E 10th St Block Group who utilize Public E Victory Dr E Orange St Transportation (Transit) as their E Don Carlos Ave primary mode of transportation to E McArthur Dr E Howe Ave work. E Hayden Ln E Lemon St S Newberry Ln S Hacienda Dr S Dorsey Ln E Kirkland Ln 11.40% ve ate Ave State A 27.76% E Center Ln Dr E Center Ln River Rockford r O 14537 Miles S Gary Dr S Melody Ln S Questa Vida US Hwy 89 S Ve Ella Cir S Clark Dr E Apache Blvd S McClintock Dr ST o S Los Feliz Dr 14658 Miles S Holbrook Ln E Encanto Dr S Kachina Dr 12701 Miles E Apartment 16254 Miles E Hudson Dr 14736 Miles E el Parque Dr E el Parque Dr E Palmcroft Dr E Palmcroft Dr E Verlea Dr E Bishop Dr S Kachina Dr E Broadmor Dr S Taylor Dr S Elm St Map and Data from Center for Neighborhood Technology www.cnt.org May 2012 E Palmdale Dr S Oak St S Pine St S Dorsey Ln EL E Apache Blvd S Oak St S Cedar St S Kenneth Pl S Stanley Pl S Newberry Ln S Terrace Rd E Howe Av 13769 Miles 14380 Miles E Apartment S Jentilly Ln S Bonarden Ln E Lemon St sp EA eliz Dr S Los F S Palm Dr E Don Carlos Ave E Cedar St ve S Gary A Travel Time Dr arque to Work E Palmcroft Dr E el P r i C do Travel time to work is measured on ed R E in minutesE and represents an Broadmor Dr Dr orda onc C average of the total time it takesE commuters in a block group to get to work by their primary mode used. Includes auto, biking, walking, and public transit. E Orange E Randall Dr E 12th St E Williams St Data Not Available Target Area Less than 12,000 Light Rail Stop annual Cerro Dr miles E Vista del E Apartment E Vista del Cerro Dr 12,000 to 14,000 E Encanto Dr annual miles E Granada 14,000Dr to 16,000 annual miles E Solana Dr 16,000 to 18,000 E Broadway Ln annual miles E Broadway Rd 18,000 annual miles and greater S Granada Dr E 10th St E Aspen Dr r en D Dr res E Flo E E Meadow Dr www.cnt.org Travel Time to Work Minutes Target Area, Average 20.6 Tempe 20.5 Maricopa County 26.0 Data Not Available Less than 22 minutes 22 to 25 minutes 25 to 29 minutes 29 to 33 minutes 33 minutes and greater Target Area Light Rail Stop Apache and McClintock Housing and Transportation Affordability S Country Club Way E Hall St S Apartment S Apartment S Rural Rd S Sunset Dr Rd E Lemon St Vehicle Miles Traveled/Household Annual Miles Target Area, Average 14,295 Tempe 15,227 E Spence Ave Maricopa County 14144 Miles17,937 S la Rosa Dr E 8th St S Butte Ave ce ra E Don Carlos Ave S Butte Ave r Te S Una Ave E Orange St E E Qu 14153 Miles E Kirkland Ln E Hayden Ln www.cnt.org E Jen Tilly Ln Apartment E Center Ln S S McAllister Ave E Center Ln S Dorsey Ln Vehicle Miles Traveled per Household E Tyler St 12477 Vehicle miles traveled per Miles household models the average E Terrace Rd annual auto travel by households in a block group. This includes 12808 Miles commute travel, but also all E Lemon St other daily auto trips made by all members of the household. 12712 Miles E Krueger St E Krueger St 166 S Hacienda Dr S Terrace Rd SP r E Alpha D E University Dr Map and Data from Center for Neighborhood Technology www.cnt.org January 2012 Maps and data from the Center for Neighborhood Technology (CNT) using Regional Moderate data as this target area has a median income which is less than 80% of the regional median. For an explanation of their methods and data as well as links to their website, see pgs 225-226. Apache & Price Description and Impressions 168 Photographs 169 Stakeholder Information 170 Location Map 171 Market/Demographic Information 172 Aerial Image 173 Parcel Map 174 Building Footprint 175 Zoning 176 Proposed/Future Zoning 177 Land Use 178 Historic Districts and Properties 179 Political and Neighborhood Boundaries 180 Landmarks and Natural/Man-made Features 181 Transportation and Circulation 182 Floodplain and Environmental 183 Ownership 184 Vacant Land and Parking 185 Business Districts and Development Organizations 186 Events and Temporary Installations 187 Utilities and Planned Public Improvements 188 Housing and Transportation Affordability 189 167 Apache and Price Description and Impressions The half-mile area surrounding the Apache and Price light rail stop is two miles from Arizona State University and therefore less impacted by market forces related to the university. With freeway access and a park and ride lot, this intersection has a significant multi-modal transportation influence on the environment. The area is bounded by the canal to the east, the dividing line between Tempe and Mesa. The area is subdivided by the freeway in the middle, limiting east west pedestrian movement from the neighborhoods on either side of the freeway, and forcing pedestrian and bike traffic out onto the Boulevard. The land use patterns are more regular in this area compared to McClintock, with shallow commercial frontage on the north side, backing up to single family residences of cultural 168 significance. The south side has commercial properties that back up to both multi-family and industrial properties; the south side has greater density and lot sizes. The area includes a variety of housing options, lower-density suburban single-family lots and duplexes, to higher density apartments. There are fewer student housing or condominium properties in this area. There are height restrictions on surrounding parcels, and a special district has been developed for this area. A new multi-family affordable housing option has been built for deaf senior citizens; the second phase of this project is planned for owner-occupied units. Retail services include automobile repair, restaurants, flower shop, small grocery and convenience stores, liquor stores, and bars, and a Park’N Ride lot. The area is not pedestrian friendly, but a multi-use path exists beside the canal, providing a north-south path for non-vehicular travel. Apache and Price Station, looking southwest Residential area 169 Vacant land, McArthur Drive Apache and 101 Freeway, looking north Apache and Lebanon, looking south Apartment Homes Apache and Price Photographs Stakeholders The following is a list of individuals or groups to contact to participate in planning or other events for the half mile area surrounding the light rail stop. The list was created through searches on the internet and conversations with city of Tempe staff. City Council City of Mesa Council District 3 City of Tempe Council Neighborhood Associations Escalante Neighborhood Association Churches St. Margaret’s Church 170 Apache and Price Stakeholders 171 Phoenix Tempe Mesa north light rail stop Apache and Price Location Map 172 north City of Tempe Census Tract 3192 / 3193 Population 172,589 Median Household Income $48,585 Homeowner Occupied 51.0% Renter Occupied 49.0% Public Transportation Use 3.0% Personal Vehicle Use 72.9% Travel Time 20.4 9,661 / 2,570 $33,377 / 29,375 26.6% / 41.7% 73.4% / 58.3% 12.5% / 2.2% 62.6% / 82.3% 25.5 / 20.5 2009 American Community Survey 2005-2009 American Community Survey 5-year Estimates Apache and Price Demographics 1/2 mile area 3192 3193 Evergreen Rd Lebanon Ln George Dr 101 Price Rd PRICE RD Victory Dr Don Carlos Ave McArthur Dr APACHE BLVD Tempe 173 Mesa Railroad light rail stop light rail north Mesa/Tempe boundary one quarter mile Apache and Price Aerial Evergreen Rd Lebanon Ln George Dr 101 Price Rd PRICE RD Victory Dr Don Carlos Ave McArthur Dr APACHE BLVD 174 Railroad light rail stop light rail north Mesa/Tempe boundary one Apache and Price Parcel Map quarter mile Evergreen Rd Lebanon Ln George Dr 101 Price Rd PRICE RD Victory Dr Don Carlos Ave McArthur Dr APACHE BLVD 175 Railroad light rail stop light rail Mesa/Tempe boundary north structures one quarter mile Apache and Price Building Footprint E RANDALL DR E VICTORY DR Evergreen Rd George Dr R-O Lebanon Ln S COTT Loop 10 PRICE RD 101 Price Rd GE DR R-2 E MARYLAND DR Victory Dr E 10TH R-4 R1-6 R1-6 R-3 Don Carlos Ave E DON CARLOS AV McArthur Dr NA E MCARTHUR DR EL R-2 O EM R-4 R-3R R-3 R-4 CSS CSS MU-4 C-3 APACHE BLVD CSS CSS R-4 C-3 R-4 176 R-4 GID R-3 GID Railroad GID R-3 M-1 Source: City of Tempe Planning Division. September 2011. light rail stop light rail north Mesa/Tempe boundary one quarter mile TEMPE TEMPE (cont.) MESA commercial residential residential R-O R1-6 R-3 CSS R-2 R-4 industrial R-3 commercial GID R-3R C-3 mixed use R-4 industrial MU-4 Apache and Price Zoning M-1 Evergreen Rd Lebanon Ln George Dr 101 Price Rd PRICE RD Victory Dr Don Carlos Ave McArthur Dr APACHE BLVD 177 Railroad Information obtained through internet searches and conversations with City of Tempe staff. light rail stop light rail There is no proposed rezoning for this area according to current data. north Mesa/Tempe boundary one quarter mile Apache and Price Proposed and Future Zoning Evergreen Rd Lebanon Ln George Dr 101 Price Rd PRICE RD Victory Dr Don Carlos Ave McArthur Dr APACHE BLVD 178 Railroad Drachman Institute. June 2011. surface parking light rail stop light rail Mesa/Tempe boundary structured parking vacant residential - single family housing civic/cultural residential - multifamily housing north plaza/park/open space office warehouse one Apache and Price Land Use retail quarter mile medical educational religious Evergreen Rd Lebanon Ln George Dr PRICE RD 101 Price Rd Carlson Park 1957~1959 Victory Dr Don Carlos Ave McArthur Dr APACHE BLVD 179 Railroad Information obtained through internet searches and conversations with City of Tempe staff. light rail Mesa/Tempe boundary Carlson Park - potentially eligible Modifications to structures located within Local Historic Districts require review by City of Tempe planning staff. Modifications to structures located within National Historic Districts may or may not require review by the State Historic Preservation Office. north light rail stop one quarter mile Apache and Price Historic Districts and Properties Evergreen Rd Lebanon Ln George Dr 101 Price Rd PRICE RD Victory Dr Don Carlos Ave McArthur Dr APACHE BLVD 180 Railroad Information obtained through internet searches and conversations with City of Tempe staff. Entire half mile area includes: light rail stop Maricopa County District 1 light rail Tempe - Mesa Boundary City of Tempe Council District north City of Mesa Council District 3 Escalante Neighborhood Association one quarter mile Apache and Price Political and Neighborhood Boundaries Evergreen Rd Lebanon Ln George Dr 101 Price Rd PRICE RD Victory Dr Don Carlos Ave McArthur Dr APACHE BLVD 181 Railroad light rail stop Additional landmarks may be added through various activities to be held in the area. light rail Mesa/Tempe boundary freeway north railroad canal religious/church one quarter mile Apache and Price Landmarks and Natural / Man-made Features Evergreen Rd Lebanon Ln George Dr 101 Price Rd PRICE RD Victory Dr Don Carlos Ave McArthur Dr APACHE BLVD 182 Railroad Drachman Institute. June 2011. traffic signal plazas/parks/open space surface parking north structured parking one quarter Apache and Price Transportation and Circulation mile light rail stop light rail Tempe - Mesa Boundary striped pedestrian crossing bus route bicycle streets freeway railroad sheltered bus stop unsheltered bus stop Evergreen Rd Lebanon Ln George Dr 101 Price Rd PRICE RD Victory Dr Don Carlos Ave McArthur Dr APACHE BLVD 183 Railroad Information obtained through internet searches and conversations with City of Tempe staff. light rail stop light rail There are no known environmental sites other than what is indicated. Mesa/Tempe boundary floodplain 10 year north floodplain 100 year superfund site landfill recycling center waste center one quarter mile Apache and Price Floodplain and Environmental Evergreen Rd Lebanon Ln George Dr 101 Price Rd PRICE RD Victory Dr Don Carlos Ave McArthur Dr APACHE BLVD 184 Railroad Source: Maricopa County Assessor’s Office. July 2011. contiguously owned properties light rail stop light rail Mesa/Tempe boundary private individual north private LLC - multiple owners Private LLC - individual owner one Apache and Price Ownership quarter mile City of Tempe private multiple holdings religious Evergreen Rd Lebanon Ln George Dr 101 Price Rd PRICE RD Victory Dr Don Carlos Ave McArthur Dr APACHE BLVD 185 Railroad Drachman Institute. June 2011. light rail stop light rail Mesa/Tempe boundary vacant land north surface parking structured parking one quarter mile Apache and Price Vacant Land and Parking Evergreen Rd Lebanon Ln George Dr 101 Price Rd PRICE RD Victory Dr Don Carlos Ave McArthur Dr APACHE BLVD 186 Railroad light rail stop light rail Mesa/Tempe boundary north Information not available. one quarter mile Apache and Price Business Districts and Development Organizations Evergreen Rd Lebanon Ln George Dr 101 Price Rd PRICE RD Victory Dr Don Carlos Ave McArthur Dr APACHE BLVD 187 Railroad Information obtained through internet searches and conversations with City of Tempe staff. light rail stop light rail There are no known temporary installations or events in this area. north Mesa/Tempe boundary one quarter mile Apache and Price Events and Temporary Installations Evergreen Rd Lebanon Ln George Dr 101 Price Rd PRICE RD Victory Dr Don Carlos Ave McArthur Dr APACHE BLVD 188 Railroad Source: City of Tempe Engineering Department in Public Works. August 2011. This map includes: light rail stop water and wastewater utility lines light rail Mesa/Tempe boundary water north waste water one quarter mile Apache and Price Utilities and Planned Public Improvements Park ile Home Cibola Mob Evergreen Village N Sycamore N Cholla N Cholla Holiday Run Holiday Ter N Sycamore Holiday Vw Holiday Rd DobsonRd Rd SNDobson N Ir onw ood Holiday Cir W Holiday Trl Holiday Dr Holiday Ln S Skyview Mesa Un 2 www.cnt.org b S Visalia Holiday Run Holiday Vw ss P a nd ay d i l Be Ho ay un lid R Ho day li Ho Holiday Blvd Holiday Ter Holiday Rd liday Cir W y Trl ay Dr Ln esa Un 2 W del Oro Cir w Mesa Un 2 W de Palma Cir a Ave Data Not Available Less than 45% W Broadway Rd 45% and Greater Apache and Price Housing and Transportation Affordability San Jose W Catalin S Dobson Rd Access Driveway Target Area Light Rail Stop S Valencia S Roosevelt Rd S Cottonw ood Dr S Price Rd Dr N Ir onw ood N Santa Anna N Santa Barbara S Broadway Village W Shadow Ln S Broadway Village S Roosevelt Rd Sa W University Dr Pelican Bay Clu S Valencia W Robin Ave S Shannon Dr S Shannon Dr S River Dr N H+T Costs, % Income % Income N/A Target Area, Average 51.2 Tempe 59.1 Mesa 60.0 W K Mart Access Rd W Pvt Maricopa County 66.2 Way E Loma Vista Dr quire S Es ado Dor S el l ana d nR pe C Tem vergree SE E Aspen Dr St Less 32,000 $/year St Access Rd W K Mart 32,000 $/year 6th to 42,000 Pl W 5 th W 42,000 to 53,000 $/year St 5 th W 69,000 $/year 53,000 to W Broadway Rd 69,000 $/year and greater a nn WA Pvt n ta Maps and data from the Center for E el Parqu e DrNeighborhood Technology W Mesa Ridge (CNT) using Regional Moderate data as this target area has a Dr E Palmcroft E Palmcrof t Dr median income which is less than 80% of the regional median. For E Broadmor Dr W Hallcra an explanation of their methods and data as well as links to their ft Villas M esa W Concho Ave website, see pgs 225-226. E Concorda Dr E el Parque Dr E Aspen Dr i S Skyview Mesa Un 2 N Santa Anna W del Campo Cir S Roosevelt Rd Evergreen Apartment N May W del Oro Cir W Ella St Map and Data from Center for Neighborhood Technology www.cnt.org May 2012 pen Dr N Dobson R N Ma Qu ail Rd NP hy l lis N May Qu ail Rd NP s Driveway Acces hy l lis u Q n lL ai m Ca N San Jose The Oaks Mhp S Valencia S Roosevelt Rd th S Acorn Ave S Oakwood Dr Pa al pe al T em Ca n Te m t en ar tm Ap pe Te m S Indian Bend Rd Al ex an 48.99% W Birchwood Ave 5 th Housing and Transportation Cost W 3rd Pl as a Percentage of Income s s W 3rd aSt y P end W 3rd St lida B odeveloped y HW H+T has been as n a 2nd lid Pl Ru W Hallc o Pl Wra2nd y H da ft Villas M es i l a more acomplete Ho measure of W 2nd St W 2nd St Blvd Holiday affordability beyond the standard W 1st Pl method of assessing only Housing Costs. It takes into account both 1st St W Pl the cost of housingHolidasay well as the cost of transportation associated Holiday Cir E W 8th Ave with the location of the home. W Main St CNT has defined an affordable range for H+T as the combined costs consuming no more than 45% of income. W 1st Ave Robin Rd W Mesa Ridge 55.51% pe Price Fwy S Price Rd ST E Riviera Village Apartment or r eM olin os Cir S Sh an no E Village Antigua Apartment nD r Ca n S George Dr S Cottonw ood Dr Price Fwy State Hwy 101 S Cottonw ood Dr S Price Rd S Siesta Ln S Siesta Ln 52.43% E Riviera Village Apartment S Lebanon Ln S Lola Ln S Shannon Dr S River Dr S River Dr S Shannon Dr S Bala Dr S Lola Ln S Lola Ln S Siesta Dr 53.32% W Cactus Wren Rd S Valencia E Alameda Dr E McArthur Dr o E Cedar St E Bishop Dr ad Dor E Wildermuth Dr E Don Carlos Ave E Loma Vista Dr t a Ave W CatalinW Dora St E Orange St ill s y Ph Cir Ave W de Palma Carlos E Don Ave N W Robin S el 45.35% N San Jose ile Home Cibola Mob WC amin oS E Randall Dr W Concho Ave Dr meda Dr E Victory Dr Way ishop E DrLemon St E Randall Dr S Allred E Howe Ave E Aspen Dr N May Park Evergreen Village r Ci Light Rail Stop no W Los Racimos E Laird St E Oakleaf Dr quire S Es 51.47% E Concorda Dr E Palmcrof tDr Dr E Maryland E Laird St ado Dor S el l ana d nR pe C Tem vergree SE Vista Dr E Broadmor Dr ta Ln E Aspen Dr E Palmcroft Dr S Sies pen Dr St Orange Vida E el Parque Dr W 5t www.cnt.org N San Jose S San Jose E 7th St W Median Household Income Income, $ Target Area, Average 28,631 Tempe 55,749 W 1st Ave Mesa 52,117 b W Des Moines Cir County 61,016 Pelican Bay Clu Maricopa N/A W Decatur St Data Not Available Target Area S Visalia ho Ave W IBirchwood da n St o E 6th eg Or N Los Racimos S Roosevelt Rd S Evergreen Rd Illinois Iowa Ohio Hawaii S 5th Pl W Shadow Ln N San Jose S Oakwood Dr S Acorn Ave Pa al Ca n S Roosevelt Rd Evergreen Apartment $27,887 Ave esta W Dora St llis th St Dr E University Map and Data from Center for Neighborhood Technology www.cnt.org May 2012 E Qu n pe al T em Ca n pe Te m t en ar tm Nevada Utah California S Indian Bend Rd Al ex an Te m pe Ap S Siesta Ln E Village Antigua Apartment E el Parque Dr E Questa Vida il L W Ella St W Dartmou Sa Median Household W 3rd Pl Income W 3rd St W 3rd St Median household W 2nd Plincome W 2nd Pl includes theWincome of the 2nd St W 2nd St householder and all other W 1st Pl individuals $38,971 15 years old and over in the W 1st St household, whether they are related to the householder or not. This value represents the median income within a block W Main St group. Robin Rd th N N W University Dr The Oaks Mhp Il S Lebanon Ln S George Dr S Evergre California Ohio Hawaii State Hwy State Hwy 101 $29,375 State Hwy 101 nD r E Don Carlos Ave y Ph t Cactus Wren Rd ua Q E Orange St S Allred Dr no $31,542 E 6th St Dr S Questa Vida an Cir River Rockford Sh os E Randall Dr E Victory Dr State Ave State S olin S Price Rd ST or r eM E Laird St E Oakleaf Dr E McArthur Dr E Riviera Village Apartment E 5th St E Riviera Village Apartment S Tempe Ct S River Dr S Rockford Dr S Clark Dr E Cedar St Cam ino S E University Dr E Laird St E Don Carlos Ave $27,386 E Wildermuth Dr E Randall Dr Price Fwy E Lemon St E 6th E 7th St E Maryland Dr S Cottonw ood Dr S Siesta Ln S Lola Ln S Lola Ln S River Dr E Howe Ave ta Ln $37,985 S Sies Orange St Price Fwy S Lola Ln S Questa Vida S Tempe Ct S River Dr Vida o S Allred Dr Dr esta eg Or Ave River Rockford E Questa Vida E Qu State Ave State E 6th St 189 The Oaks Mhp N May Qu ail Rd NP hy l lis N San Jose N May Park ou N Santa Barbara ile Home Evergreen Village Cibola Mob rtm Da W N Los Racimos ce Tr th Pelican Bay Clu W Los Racimos t S Valencia The Oaks Mhp Robin Rd W Mesa Ridge S Visalia S Oakwood Dr S Acorn Ave Cactus Wren Rd m Ca in W W 3r Pelican Bay Clu b S Broadway Village Access Driveway W Birchwood Ave S Price Rd N Santa Barbara Park ile Home Cibola Mob S Roosevelt Rd W Main St S Roosevelt Rd Evergreen Apartment Evergreen Village pe Te m t en ar tm pe Te m Al ex an S Indian Bend Rd 26.48% W Ha a Ave n Jose W de Palma Cir S Visalia S Valencia S Roosevelt Rd S Price Rd S Cottonw ood Dr annon Dr W Robin Ave W Catalin S Valenc E Aspen Dr Way S Shannon Dr b W Shado N May S San Jose N San Jose th Pa al Ca n pe Ca n al T em 30.94% quire S Es S River Dr S Broadway Village no S W N May WC am i Qu ail Rds Driveway Acces N San Jose NP hy l lis S Roosevelt Rd S Roosevelt Rd S Evergreen Rd Illinois S Lebanon Ln 29.78% Ap S Siesta Ln S Roosevelt Rd S George Dr E Don Carlos Ave E Loma Vista Dr o Clark Dr N Santa Barbara S Oakwood Dr S Acorn Ave th Pa al Ca n pe al T em Ca n pe Te m Evergreen Apartment W Main St n W HallcraW 2nd Pl ft Villas M il L ua Q W Ha W 2nd S llcraft a Ave Villas W Catalin W Dora St E Orange St ill s hy W de PalmaPCir AveAve Carlos Don EW Robin N W 1st S W del Oro Cir W Ella St E McArthur Dr ad Dor S Los Feliz Dr W 2nd St W 1st St 24.57% E Laird St E Oakleaf Dr E Randall Dr S el E Aspen Dr E Aspen Dr W 3rd W 2nd Pl N San Jose N S Evergree Illi S Lebanon Ln S George Dr t en ar tm Ap pe Te m Iowa Ohio Hawaii California S Cottonw ood Dr Price Fwy State Hwy 101 S Siesta Ln S Lola Ln S Lola Ln S Shannon Dr S Clark Dr S Country Club Way S Holbrook Ln E Victory Dr l Rd ana reen eC verg SE s Dr W Ella St W Shadow Maps and data from the Center for Neighborhood Technology E el Moderate Parque Dr (CNT) using Regional data as this target area has a W Mesa Ridge E Palmcroft Dr median income which less than 80% of the regional median. For E Palmis croft Dr an explanation of their methods and data as well as links to their E Broadmoor Dr W Hallcra ft Villas website, see pgs 225-226. E el Parque Dr SB E llis W Broadway Rd Apache and Price Housing and Transportation Affordability E Concorda Dr r en D Asp E Randall Dr p Tem S Taylor Dr 28.72% E Village Antigua Apartment nD r E Laird St E Palmcrof tDr E Maryland Dr Price Fwy S Martin Ln E Apartment S Los Feliz Dr S Kachina Dr no W Dora St Map and Data from Center for Neighborhood Technology www.cnt.org May 2012 E Palmcroft Dr S Kachina Dr an S Indian Bend Rd Al ex an S Price Rd S Lola Ln S Shannon Dr S Clark Dr S Hazelton Ln S Mobile Home Park S River Dr S River Dr S Los Feliz Dr S Taylor Dr S Kachina Dr utte Ave S McClintock Dr Sh sC ir y Ph n lL ai S Valencia S lino Robin Rd W Broadway Rd Way Target Area E Riviera Village Apartment S T Stop E Riviera Village Apartment Light Rail or r e Mo E 7th St E t 6th S o E el Parque Dr E el Parque Dr ta Ln Transportation Costs, % Income % Income 30.53% Target Area, Average 28.1 Tempe 29.3 E Wildermuth Dr Mesa 31.9 E Cedar St Maricopa County 32.1 Data Not Available Less than 15% E Encanto Dr 15 to 18% 18 to 20% 20 to 28% 28% and Greater E Broadway Rd a Id on Ave W Birchwood eg Or ad Dor S Sies S Bala Dr www.cnt.org US Hwy 89 W Dr E University Map and Data from Center for Neighborhood Technology www.cnt.org May 2012 E el Parque Dr E el Parque Dr Transportation Cost as a E Questa Vida E Center Ln Percentage of Income E Palmcroft Dr E Qu 190E KirklandELn Palmcroft Dr Household Transportation Costs esta Vida E Broadmoor Dr 27.97% St r are calculated as the sum auto E 10th of St E Hayden Ln E Concorda Dr ownership costs, auto use costs, pen DrSt E As Orange r E Randall Dr en D Asp and Epublic transit costs. Dividing E Aspen Dr E Aspen Dr r E Don Carlos Ave sD Dr lore theseE Fcosts by representative w o d a E Me Dr St E lonLemon E Loma Vista Dr 27.49% E G ay E Howe Ave regional incomes illustrates the h St cost burden placed on a typical E Lemon St household by transportation costs. Blvd S Cottonw ood Dr Price Fwy State Hwy 101 E Village Antigua Apartment S 5th Pl 22.51% ho S el S Tempe Ct S River Dr nD r California Ohio Hawaii State H Price Fwy State Hwy 101 S Siesta Ln S Siesta Ln S River Dr S Rockford Dr no 23.71% E 6th St Nevada Utah quire S Es S Questa Vida an 23.54% l Rd ana reen eC verg SE S Country Club Way Sh Cir E McArthur Dr S Siesta Ln S Clark Dr S Clark Dr S Martin Ln S Holbrook Ln S Smith Rd E Apartment S Los Feliz Dr S Perry Ln S os N t Cactus Wren Rd u Q E Orange St E Don Carlos Ave p Tem S Melody Ln olin E Randall Dr Ave Apartment Village Apartment E Riviera Target Area E 5th St ST Riviera Village Apartment E o Light Rail Stop rre M E Laird St E Oakleaf Dr S Allred Dr S Kachina Dr E Cedar St Dr S Hacienda Dr E Wildermuth Dr WC amin oS E University Dr E Victory Dr State Ave State S McClintock Dr 14.82% River Rockford Data Not Available than 20% St E Encanto E 6thLess Dr 20 to 30% 30 to 40% 40 to 45% E Broadway Rd 45% and Greater E Center Ln S Lola Ln S Lola Ln S Lola Ln S Hazelton Ln S River Dr Apartment Housing Costs, % Income % Income Target Area, Average 23.0 Tempe 29.8 Mesa 28.2 Maricopa County 34.1 E Randall Dr St E Laird St E Don Carlos Ave S Cottonw ood DRd r S Price S Questa Vida S Tempe Ct S River Dr S Perry Ln S Melody Ln S Hacienda Dr S Mobile Home Park US Hwy 89 E 6th E 7th St E Maryland Dr ta Ln E 3rd St S Sies che Blvd on S Allred Dr Dr www.cnt.org eg Or Ave River Rockford Housing Cost as a E Questa Vida E Center Ln Percentage of Income d Ln Housing costs factored as a E Questa Vida E Kirklan E 8th St percent of income has widely E 10th St E Hayden Ln been utilized as a measure ofE Orange St 23.50% E Randall Dr affordability. Traditionally, a home Don Carlos Ave isEconsidered affordable when the E Lemon St costs 17.57% consume no more than 30% E Howe Ave E 12th St of household income. E Lemon St E Center Ln Id State Ave State E 6th St llcraft Vill ND S Sycamore N Santa Anna E Aspen Dr N Yucca Cir N Pecan N Cholla Holiday Run Holiday Ter N Sycamore Holiday Vw Holiday Rd Holiday Cir E Holiday Loop N Sycamore S Sycamore N Santa Barbara N Ir Holiday Lnonwoo d Household Annual W Bedford St W 3rd Pl Transportation Cost W Belfast St W 3rd St W 3rd St W Bentley W Robin Ave W de Palma Cir Holiday Loop S Dobson Rd S Broadway Village Access Driveway Holiday Run Holiday Vw un R Apache and Price ay lid Ho W Hallc and Transportation Housing Affordability Holiday Blvd raft V illas M W de Palma Cir es a Holiday Dr S Sycamore S Visalia a Ave Less than 8750 $/year 8750 to 9600 $/year 9600 to 10500 $/year 10500 to 11250 $/year 11250 $/year and greater W K Mart Access Rd Holiday Ln Cibola Mob S Valencia W Catalin www.cnt.org S Sycamore N Santa Barbara Park ile Home N San Jose N May Pa al S Roosevelt Rd W Main St Holiday Ter Holiday Rd Holiday Cir E E Loma Vista Dr E Aspen Dr S Roosevelt Rd E Aspen Dr S Cottonw ood Dr S Price Rd S Bala Dr E Concorda Dr N/A Data Not Available W 6th St Less than 1% W K Mart Access Rd W15th toPl4% W 5th 4Stto 8% 8 to 14% W 4th Pl 14% and Greater W University Dr Maps and data from the Center for Neighborhood Technology E el Parque Dr (CNT) using Regional Moderate data as this target area has a W Mesa Ridge E Palmcroft Dr median income which is less than 80% of the regional median. For an explanation E Broadmor Dr of their methods and data as well as links to their W Hallcra ft Villas M esa website, see pgs 225-226. Dr N Cholla N San Jose N Ir onw ood N Sycamore N May N May W Pvt Light Rail Stop W Pvt W Broadway Rd Way S River Dr i c De Annual Transportation Costs $ Target Area, Average 11,497 Tempe 12,025 W 1st Ave Mesa 13,145 b Maricopa County 13,217 Pelican Bay Clu DataN/A Not Available Target Area S Roosevelt Rd W Birchwood Ave quire S Es rque m Ca N San Jose S Visalia S Acorn Ave th S Roosevelt Rd Ln Ca n 10775/yr ado Dor S el l ana pe C en Rd Tem re verg SE en Dr l Pa W W Broadway Rd ge Rid esa Rd CactusMWren S Robin Rd W Shadow Ln W Mesa Ridge Map and Data from Center for Neighborhood Technology www.cnt.org May 2012 Ee W Target Area r CiStop Light Rail no Qu ail Rd NP hy l lis The Oaks Mhp S Valencia S Oakwood Dr t pe al T em Ca n Te m pe US Hwy 89 S Price Rd S Bala Dr 11755/yr Evergreen Apartment ar tm S Indian Bend Rd Al ex an Te m pe Ap S Siesta Ln E Riviera Village Apartment ST E Riviera Village Apartment or r eM olin os Cir S Sh an no nD r S Lebanon Ln S George Dr d Dr S Cottonwoo t State Hwy 101 en State Hwy 101 S Siesta Ln S Lola Ln S Lola Ln S River Dr E Cedar St S Cottonw Soo Price d DrRd Price Fwy S Lola Ln S Shannon Dr S River Dr E Wildermuth Dr 12219/yr Evergreen Village 12549/yr Qu ail Rd NP hy l lis ile Home Cibola Mob N Los Racimos WC amin oS W 1st S Ave ur at S Valencia Apache Blvd Way E Lemon St o we Ave E Aspen Dr b Pelican Bay Clu St Pl un W 2ndTransportation Annual R W HalHousehold Wra2nd Pl y lc l ft i a Vi E Randall Dr llas Mesa E Randall Dr W 2nd St lid ua Q W 2nd StHo as the sum of Costs are calculated W HaW 2nd St ll c Holiday Blvd raft V a Ave illas M E Victory Dr W CatalinW Dora St Auto Ownership Auto Use esa Holiday Costs, N/A E Orange St Dr is W 1st Pl l l y E Aspen Dr h Costs and Public Transit Costs. P Cir Palma de W Cir Palma de W Ave Carlos Don E N E Don Carlos Ave W Robin Ave St W 1st On average, Transportation Costs W Ella St W Alcott St E McArthur Dr are the second largest household expenditure. 12727/yr ad Dor E Loma Vista Dr ta Ln E Aspen Dr E Maryland Dr l Rd ana eC reen verg SE 11428/yr E Concorda Dr range Dr St en S Sies E Broadmor Dr ou W Los Racimos E Laird St E Oakleaf Dr quire S Es E Palmcroft Dr Vida E Laird St S el esta E el Parque Dr W Main St Transit Ridership, % of Workers % of Workers Target Area, Average 8.1 W Dixon St W Willow Park Tempe 9.1 W Devonshire St W Devonshire St Mesa 3.5 Maricopa County 4.1 St th t Park Evergreen Village S Roosevelt Rd Evergreen Apartment Illinois S Roosevelt Rd S Evergreen Rd Ohio Hawaii E 7th St rtm Da www.cnt.org Dobson Rd S DobsonNRd The Oaks Mhp S Oakwood Dr S Acorn Ave th Pa al Ca n pe al T em Ca n pe Te m t en ar tm Ap pe Te m Al ex an Iowa S Indian Bend Rd S 5th Pl 9.71% ho da n Ave W IBirchwood St o E 6th eg Or California Price Fwy Nevada Utah p Tem E Qu N Ma S Evergre I S Lebanon Ln Price Fwy S Siesta Ln S Siesta Ln S Bala Dr S Price Rd S Tempe Ct S River Dr 6.44% W Ave E el Parque Dr E Questa Vida W Dora St is W Ella St Map and Data from Center for Neighborhood Technology www.cnt.org May 2012 Dr E University Dr S Questa Vida E 6th St n on nD r 6.47% S Allred Dr no Cir il L od wo ron an os 8.91% yll Ph N Transit Ridership as a W 3rd Pl Percentage ofStWorkers W 3rd W Sycamore W 3rd St W Sycamore Transit Ridership represents Pl W 2nd W 2nd Pl the percentage of workers in a W 2nd St W 2nd St Block Group who utilize Public N/A Pl W 1stTransportation (Transit) as their primary mode of transportation to W 1st St work. W Shadow Ln NI olin E McArthur Dr State Ave State Sh E Riviera Village Apartment E 5th St E Riviera Village Apartment River Rockford S E Cedar St Robin Rd ua Q E Orange St E Don Carlos Ave W University Dr Cactus Wren Rd v De ST or r eM S River Dr E Wildermuth Dr E Laird St E Oakleaf Dr E Randall Dr E Don Carlos Ave W 5th St W 4th Pl E University Dr E Victory Dr t W S Rockford Dr 7.18% Cam ino S N San Jose State Hwy 101 S Siesta Ln S Lola Ln S Lola Ln S River Dr E Lemon St ta Ln we Ave S Cottonw ood Dr S Sies 10.66% range St E 7th St E Maryland Dr E Randall Dr E 6th E Laird St S George Dr California Ohio Hawaii S Price Fwy S Lola Ln S Questa Vida S Tempe Ct S River Dr Vida o od wo ron Dr esta eg Or S Allred Dr River Rockford E Questa Vida E Qu ve tate Ave State A E 6th St W 6th Dr 191 N S Ever Ca n pe Park W Main St ile Home S Roosevelt Rd Cibola Mob Ca n pe Pelican Bay Clu S Roosevelt Rd Evergreen Apartment Evergreen Village al T em 16072 Miles Te m t en ar tm Ap pe Te m Al ex an S Indian Bend Rd W 2nd St W 1st St 13779 Miles W Birchwood Ave b WP W Mesa Ridge W Catalin W de Palma Cir S Visalia S Valencia d Dr S Price Rd esa W Hallcra W Ha a Ave S Valencia z Dr W Robin Ave S Roosevelt Rd o S Cottonwoo Way ad Dor s Feli E Aspen Dr S el S Shannon Dr E el Parque Dr l Rd ana eC reen verg SE S River Dr SM quire S Es E el Parque Dr Travel Time to Work Minutes Target Area, Average 23.7 Tempe 20.3 Mesa 26.0 Maricopa County 26.0 Target Area Light Rail Stop Apache and Price Housing and Transportation Affordability ft Villas M llcraft Map and Data from Center for Neighborhood Technology www.cnt.org January 2012 Maps and data from the Center for Neighborhood Technology (CNT) using Regional Moderate data as this target area has a median income which is less than 80% of the regional median. For an explanation of their methods and data as well as links to their website, see pgs 225-226. es Villas M W de Palma Cir www.cnt.org Data Not Available Less than 22 minutes 22 to 25 minutes 25 to 29 minutes 29 to 33 minutes 33 minutes and greater W 2nd Pl W 1st Pl N May Pa W Ella St al E McArthur Dr N San Jose Qu ail Rd NP hy l lis llis th y Ph W Dora St W 3rd St N San Jose The Oaks Mhp S Oakwood Dr S Acorn Ave S Lebanon Ln S George Dr Californi Ohio Hawaii S Cottonw ood Dr State Hwy 101 N il Ln W Shadow Ln ge Map and Data from Center for Neighborhood Technology www.cnt.org May 2012 Rid Travel Time E Palmcroft Dr to Work E Palmcroft Dr E Broadmor Dr Travel timea Dto r work is measured d r o onc E Concorda Dr EC in minutes and represents an Dr E Aspen Dr the total time it takes Aspen Dr average nof E spe EA E Aspen Dr ow Dr to E Mead commuters in a block group E Loma Vista Dr get to work by their primary mode used. Includes auto, biking, walking, and public transit. S Taylor Dr Robin Rd ua Q E Orange St 15585 Miles Cactus Wren Rd W Broadway Rd S Price Rd S Bala Dr 14658 Miles S Country Club Way S Holbrook Ln S Siesta Ln S Clark Dr E Apartment S Los Feliz Dr S Kachina Dr E Riviera Village Apartment ST E Riviera Village Apartment or r eM olin os Cir S Sh an no nD r S Lo S Kachina Dr E Victory Dr p Tem 192 Target Area Light Rail Stop E Laird St E Oakleaf Dr E Randall Dr Price Fwy S Mobile Home Park S Siesta Ln S Lola Ln S Lola Ln S River Dr E Lemon St S McClintock Dr ta Ln Miles Data Not Available Less than 12,000 annual miles E Encanto 12,000 toDr14,000 annual miles 14,000 to 16,000 annual miles 16,000 to 18,000 annual milesE Broadway Rd 18,000 annual miles and greaterE el Parque Dr E Randall Dr E University Dr E Laird St E Maryland Dr S Cottonwood Dr S Lola Ln Apartment Price Fwy S Tempe Ct S River Dr S Questa Vida S Melody Ln S Hacienda Dr S Sies US Hwy 89 Vehicle Miles Traveled/Household Annual Miles 16254 Miles Target Area, Average 17,182 Tempe 15,227 E Wildermuth Dr Mesa 17,755 Maricopa County 17,937 E Cedar St Miles E 7th St S Allred Dr Dr www.cnt.org E Apache Blvd ve e Ave State A River Rockford Vehicle Miles Traveled E Questa Vida E Center Ln per Household 14153 Miles E Qu esta d Ln E KirklanVehicle Vida miles traveled per Miles household models the average E 10th St E Hayden Ln annual auto travel by households E Orange St in a block group. This includes E Don Carlos Ave commute travel, but also all 13769 Miles Howe other daily auto trips made Eby allAve members of the household. Miles E Lemon St E Center Ln St O Main & Sycamore Description and Impressions 194 Photographs 195 Stakeholder Information 196 Location Map 197 Market/Demographic Information 198 Aerial Image 199 Parcel Map 200 Building Footprint 201 Zoning 202 Proposed/Future Zoning 203 Land Use 204 Historic Districts and Properties 205 Political and Neighborhood Boundaries 206 Landmarks and Natural/Man-made Features 207 Transportation and Circulation 208 Floodplain and Environmental 209 Ownership 210 Vacant Land and Parking 211 Business Districts and Development Organizations 212 Events and Temporary Installations 213 Utilities and Planned Public Improvements 214 Housing and Transportation Affordability 215 193 Main and Sycamore Description and Impressions The half-mile area surrounding the Sycamore and Main light rail stop is typical low-scale/ impact suburban development with a variety of uses - it includes three large shopping centers, smaller strip centers, office parks, warehouses, apartments, technical trade schools, an elementary school, a bus transfer station and single family residential areas. Although the area offers a variety of retail services and uses and hosts a light rail transit station and a bus transfer station, it is not pedestrian friendly. The sidewalks are located at the edge of the street that offer little buffer between the pedestrian and fast moving traffic. The area has no multi-family housing units, but single family detached housing located on small 194 lots. Much planning work on the area was done through the West Main Street Area Plan and any work at this site should build off that process. Sycamore and Main, looking west Sycamore and Main, looking southeast 195 Webster Elementary, Sycamore and Argon, looking west Parking lot, Tri-City Mall, northeast corner Dobson and Main Residential area Bus Main and Sycamore Photographs Stakeholders The following is a list of individuals or groups to contact to participate in planning or other events for the half mile area surrounding the light rail stop. The list was created through searches on the internet and conversations with city of Mesa staff. City Offices City Council District 3 City of Mesa Parks and Recreation Business Groups and Individuals West Mesa CDC Greg Greenstein Schools The Sycamore School The East Valley Institute of Technology 196 Main and Sycamore Stakeholders 197 Phoenix Tempe Mesa north light rail stop Main and Sycamore Location Map 198 north City of Mesa Census Tract 4213.01 Population 459,742 Median Household Income $49,446 Homeowner Occupied 66.6% Renter Occupied 33.4% Public Transportation Use 1.4% Personal Vehicle Use 77% Travel Time 24.4 8,025 $34,464 35.4% 64.6% 5.5% 64.6% 27.0 2009 American Community Survey 2005-2009 American Community Survey 5-year Estimates Main and Sycamore Demographics 1/2 mile area 4213.01 Longmore SYCAMORE ST Dobson Rd 2nd St Auburn St Alcott St Pepper Pl MAIN ST 199 1st Ave Railroad light rail stop north light rail one quarter mile Main and Sycamore Aerial Longmore SYCAMORE ST Dobson Rd 2nd St Auburn St Alcott St Pepper Pl MAIN ST 200 1st Ave Railroad light rail stop north light rail one quarter Main and Sycamore Parcel Map mile Longmore SYCAMORE ST Dobson Rd 2nd St Auburn St Alcott St Pepper Pl MAIN ST 201 1st Ave Railroad light rail stop light rail north structures one quarter mile Main and Sycamore Building Footprint Longmore SYCAMORE ST Dobson Rd R1-6 2nd St Auburn St R1-6 C-2 C-1 Alcott St Pepper Pl C-3 MAIN ST C-3 202 PF M-1 1st Ave Railroad M-2 Source: City of Mesa Planning and Zoning Department. September 2011. light rail stop light rail commercial residential C-1 R1-6 C-2 industrial C-3 M-1 north M-2 public facilities one quarter Main and Sycamore Zoning mile PF Longmore SYCAMORE ST Dobson Rd 2nd St Auburn St Alcott St Pepper Pl MAIN ST 203 1st Ave Railroad Information obtained through internet searches and conversations with City of Mesa staff. light rail There is no proposed rezoning for this area according to current data north light rail stop one quarter mile Main and Sycamore Proposed / Zoning Longmore SYCAMORE ST Dobson Rd 2nd St Auburn St Alcott St Pepper Pl MAIN ST 204 1st Ave Railroad Drachman Institute. June 2011. surface parking light rail stop light rail structured parking residential - single family housing vacant residential - multifamily housing civic/cultural office north plaza/park/open space retail one quarter Main and Sycamore Land Use mile medical educational religious Longmore SYCAMORE ST Dobson Rd 2nd St Auburn St Alcott St Pepper Pl MAIN ST 205 1st Ave Railroad Information obtained through internet searches and conversations with City of Mesa staff. light rail stop light rail north historic properties as identified in the West Main study, City of Mesa one quarter mile Main and Sycamore Historic Districts and Properties Longmore SYCAMORE ST Dobson Rd 2nd St Auburn St Alcott St Pepper Pl MAIN ST 206 1st Ave Railroad Information obtained through internet searches and conversations with City of Mesa staff. Entire half mile area includes: light rail stop City of Mesa Council District 3 light rail Maricopa County District 2 north There are no neighborhood associations in the immediate area. one quarter mile Main and Sycamore Political and Neighborhood Boundaries Longmore SYCAMORE ST Dobson Rd 2nd St Auburn St Alcott St Pepper Pl MAIN ST The Sycamore School 207 East Valley Institute of Technology 1st Ave Railroad light rail stop Additional landmarks may be added through various activities to be held in the area. light rail railroad school north higher education shopping center one quarter mile Main and Sycamore Landmarks and Natural / Man-made Features Longmore SYCAMORE ST Dobson Rd 2nd St Auburn St Alcott St Pepper Pl MAIN ST 208 1st Ave Railroad Drachman Institute. June 2011. traffic signal light rail stop light rail plazas/parks/open space surface parking striped pedestrian crossing bus route structured parking north bicycle future bike/pedestrian way one quarter Main and Sycamore Transportation and Circulation mile railroad streets sheltered bus stop unsheltered bus stop Longmore SYCAMORE ST Dobson Rd 2nd St Auburn St Alcott St Pepper Pl MAIN ST 209 1st Ave Railroad Information obtained through internet searches and conversations with City of Mesa staff. light rail stop There are no known floodplains or environmental sites. light rail floodplain 10 year floodplain 100 year north superfund site landfill recycling center waste center one quarter mile Main and Sycamore Floodplain and Environmental Longmore SYCAMORE ST Dobson Rd 2nd St Auburn St Alcott St Pepper Pl MAIN ST 210 1st Ave Railroad Source: Maricopa County Assessor’s Office. July 2011. light rail stop light rail private individual private LLC - multiple owners north Private LLC - individual owner City of Mesa one quarter mile private multiple holdings religious Main and Sycamore Ownership contiguously owned properties Longmore SYCAMORE ST Dobson Rd 2nd St Auburn St Alcott St Pepper Pl MAIN ST 211 1st Ave Railroad Drachman Institute. June 2011. light rail stop light rail vacant land surface parking north structured parking one quarter mile Main and Sycamore Vacant Land and Parking Longmore SYCAMORE ST Dobson Rd 2nd St Auburn St Alcott St Pepper Pl MAIN ST 212 1st Ave Railroad Information obtained through internet searches and conversations with City of Mesa staff. Entire half mile area includes: light rail stop West Mesa CDC north light rail one quarter mile Main and Sycamore Business Districts and Development Organizations SYCAMORE ST Dobson Rd 2nd St Auburn St Alcott St Pepper Pl MAIN ST 213 1st Ave Railroad Information obtained through internet searches and conversations with City of Mesa staff. light rail stop light rail north special events occur at the parking lot of the shopping center located on the southwest corner of Main and Dobson one quarter mile Main and Sycamore Events and Temporary Installations Longmore SYCAMORE ST Dobson Rd 2nd St Auburn St Alcott St Pepper Pl MAIN ST 214 1st Ave Railroad Source: City of Tempe Planning Department. July 2011. This map includes: light rail stop north water, wastewater, storm water, and gas utility lines. The only known improvement at this time is a sewer upgrade along Main between Dobson and Sycamore. Refer to the West Main Street Area Plan. light rail water waste water storm water gas one quarter mile Main and Sycamore Utilities and Planned Public Improvements Dr N Clement W Apartment W Apartment N Westwood N Mobile Home Park W 6th Dr W 7th Ave N Clement S Nina Dr Access Rd W Apartment W Apartment W Apartment N Mobile Home Park N Beverly S Beverly N Pew 5th St S Nina Dr Access Rd S Westwood S Davis 4th St S Alma School Rd W 6th Ave W Dragoon Cir 3rd St Easy St 1st St Lazy Ln 215 S Westwood 6th St N Westwood S Broad way Gardens 5th St 3rd St N Beverly 4th St 2nd St S Elm Sunset Blvd S Stewart S Standage S Mulberry S Johnson S Longmore Holiday Loop Main and Sycamore South St W 6th Ave Housing and Transportation Affordability W Vine Ave Elm ay S Sycamore Ho lid S Rogers Holiday Run Holiday Vw sa y Ln s Me ay Cir W S Valencia an Jose ft Villa North St dos W Crescent Ave Maps and data from the Center for Neighborhood Technology (CNT) using Regional Typical data as thisAve target W Capri ass y P end is greater than 80% of area has a median income which a d li B W Carol Ave Ho ay un lidexplanation theW regional of their methods R Hallcraft Vi median. For an Ho day llas Mesa W Carmel Ave oli and Wdata as well as links toHtheir website, see pgs 225-226. Hallc ra S Westwood N Westwood N Emerson N Elm S Alma School Rd N Alma School Rd 1st St S Stewart N Stewart S Brooks S Ash Cir S Dobson Rd S Broadway Village Data Not Available Less than 45% 45% and Greater Target Area Light Rail Stop S Monterey Point Con Access Driveway S Mulberry W K Mart Access Rd H+T Costs, % Income % Income 44.8 Target Area, Average 48.0 Mesa W Birchwood Ave 52.9 MaricopaWCounty Birchwood Ave Map and Data from Center for Neighborhood Technology www.cnt.org May 2012 W Mesa Ridge S Visalia www.cnt.org W Dana Ave 6th St S Broadway Gardens W 1st Ave b Pelican Bay Clu a Ave Sunset Blvd S Mulberry S Standage N Standage S Johnson S Rogers N Rogers N Rogers 45.28% N/A N Henkel Cir S Longmore N Longmore W Pepper Pl 2nd St Cibola Mob WW Drake CirSt Alcott US Hwy 89 39.19% W Broadway Rd alma Cir l 44.41% W Pvt W Catalin P Holiday S Sycamore N Santa Anna N Santa Barbara W 1st St Housing and Transportation Cost as a Percentage St Income Northof Pl 2nd W Townhouses Madrid has MesaH+T been developed as W Bentley St Lazy Ln W Vine Ave South Stof a moreEasy complete measure St W 6th Ave W 2nd St the standard W 6th Aveaffordability beyond St 2nd W W 6th Dr method of Wassessing W 1st Pl W Auburn CirSt only Housing Dragoon Costs. It takes into account W 7th Ave Ave both W Drummer W 1st St Aveas the Drummer W 7th Dr the cost of housingW as well Pl W Pepper cost of transportation associated with the location of the home. W Main St CNT has defined an affordable range for H+T as the combined costs consuming no more than W 1st Ave 45% of income. W Main St es a W 1st Pl ile Home Park llcraft W 2ndVilSt las M Holiday Ter N ChollaHoliday Run Holiday Vw Holiday Rd Holiday Cir E Holiday Loop N Sycamore S Sycamore W Ha Holiday Cir W W 3rd St W Hallcra ft Vi s M esa W 2ndllaPl S Valencia n il L ua Q a Ave W Catalin W Dora St St is alma Cir yll h P N Oro Cir W Ella St W Shadow Ln Holiday Ln Ridge Mesa Rd W Robin W 6th Pl Data Not Available W 6th St W Birchwood Ave Private D r Less 32,000 $/year W 5th Pl W Birchwood Ave 32,000 to 42,000 $/year W 5th St 42,000 to 53,000 $/year W 4th Pl 53,000 to 69,000 $/year 69,000 $/year and greater N Beverly S Davis W Garden St W University Dr W Crescent Ave W Bedford W 3rd Pl St W Capri Ave ss a P Stnd W Belfast re y 3rd W mo ca Sy St W lida Be W Carol Ave Ho n ay lid PlRu W SycamoreW Bentley St W y Ho2nd a lid W Carmel Ave Ho W 2nd St W 2nd St Ho lida W Argon St yD r W Auburn St N Ir onw ood Cactus Wren Rd N Beverly N Beverly S Beverly N Stewart S Mulberry W 4th Pl N Pew N Stewart N Rogers N Standage Target Area Light Rail Stop S Brooks W 5th St W Apartment N Alma School Rd N Standage N Henkel Cir N Rogers W Main St W 4th Pl N Pecan W 5th St W 6th Pl W 5th Pl N Saguaro W 5th Pl N Longmore W Devon N Ash o W 7th St W Dell Cir N Ash S Ash Cir M W 6th St W K Mart Access Rd N Beverly N Ash N Pecan S Sycamore N Yucca Cir W ain Dr estwood N Sag N Longmore N Cholla N Ir onw ood N Santa Anna S Broadway Village r Ci ino m W Pvt a C W t un ew Vi Median Household Income Income, $ W 1st Ave WTarget Devonshire St Area, Average St W Devonshire39,110 52,117 Mesa W Dana Ave 61,016 Maricopa County W 7th St W 7th Pl dos S Visalia N May Qu ail S San Jose Rd N San Jose N San Jose N P Access Driveway hy l lis SThe Valencia Oaks Mhp b W 1st Ave St ur at c De www.cnt.org S Monterey Point Con S Oakwood Dr N/A Map and Data from Center for Neighborhood Technology www.cnt.org May 2012Old University Rd Dr S Valencia St $41,250 US Hwy 89 N Ironwood N May W W Broadway Rd Dr St W Auburn N Ash t W Argon W Pepper Pl $38,971 S Dobson Rd N Dobson Rd Pelican Bay Clu W Los Racimos t N Santa Anna N Santa Barbara St WC amin oS W 2nd St W Alcott St N Santa Barbara h Old University Rd Median Household Income W 2nd Pl Mesa Madrid Townhouses W Bentley St Median household income includes the income of the W 2nd St W 2nd householder and allStother W 1st Pl W Auburn St individuals 15 years old and over in the household, whether they W 1st St are related to the householder W Pepper Pl or not. This value represents the median income within a block W Main St group. St W 1st St $27,887 t ou W Garden St W Belfast St W Sycamore W SycamoreW Bentley St W 2nd St W 2nd St ile Home Cibola Mob W rtm Da W 2nd Pl W 2nd Pl W 4th Pl W 4th Pl W Bedford W 3rd Pl W 3rd St W 3rd St W 5th St W University Dr W 1st Pl Park W Ella St W Shadow Ln W 4th Pl N Sycamore W Dora St is yll N May N Ph n N San Jose Qu ail Rd NP hy l lis Robin Rd il L ua Q St N Dobs Cactus Wren Rd N San Jose S Oakwood Dr Dr W 5th St Holiday Ter oliday Rd liday Cir E The Oaks Mhp t t N Ironwood Dr N Ma Cam ino S N Sagua N Ash N Henkel Cir N Standage N Rogers W 2nd St W 1st W 1st St W Pepper Pl N Rogers W Main St W Garden St St N/A St 1st Ave W 7th W W 7th Dr W Pepper Pl 24.00% US Hwy 89 W Main St W 1st Ave W Dana A b Pelican Bay Clu S Brooks S Ash Cir S Dobson Rd S Broadway Village ay Dr S Mulberry S Johnson S Rogers S Longmore S Sycamore Ho lid ay Ln es a ay Cir W an Jose Villas M Holiday Ter Holiday Rd oliday Cir E S Visalia S Valencia S Roosevelt Rd W de Palma Cir llcraft a Ave S Valencia S Cottonw ood Dr Way W Robin Ave W Catalin W 6th Ave W 6th Dr W 7th Ave S Stewart S Standage Holiday Loop Map and Data from Center for Neighborhood Technology www.cnt.org May 2012 Holiday Run Holiday Vw W Broadway Rd S Mulberry W K Mart Access Rd W Pvt Access Driveway S Indian Bend Rd S Roosevelt Rd Target Area Light Rail Stop quire S Es ado Dor S el l ana pe C reen Rd Tem verg SE E Loma Vista Dr W 1st W 6th Dr N Stewart 24.75% S Johnson W 6th Ave W Alcott St W Drake Cir W Pepper Pl l S Rogers N Henkel Cir S Longmore W Vine Ave W 2nd St N Rogers St W Auburn Mesa Madrid T N Rogers P Holiday W Argon N Longmore Holiday Loop Holiday Vw N Cholla Holiday Run Dr 2nd St W CarmelWAve W Bentley St W Main St ay Holiday Ln N Santa Anna N Santa Barbara Ho lid Ave Capri WW Belfa st St W Sycamore W SycamoreW Bentley W CarolStAve Holiday Ter Holiday Rd Holiday Cir E N Sycamore S Sycamore W 3rdssSt a y P end lida o y BPl n H W 2nd a lid Ru Ho day oli W 2nd HSt W BedfoAve W Crescent rd St S Stewart W 4th Pl Rd Old University Map and Data from Center for Neighborhood Technology www.cnt.org May 2012 W University Dr W 3rd Pl N Stewart W 5th St N Ash S Ash Cir N Pecan W 5th St W 4th Pl W 5th Pl N Saguaro W K Mart Access Rd W 5th Pl W Dana A S Mulberry W 6th St W 6th Pl N Standage W Devon W Dell Cir S Mulberry ain W 7th St S Standage N Standage nt WD W 7th Pl Dr S Brooks M ou ew Vi N Ash S Sycamore W N Stewart N Pecan St N Longmore N Cholla N Sycamore W Auburn S Sycamore Evergreen Apartment St W Crescent Ave Maps and data from the Center for Neighborhood W Mesa Ridge Ave W Capri Technology (CNT) using Regional Typical data as this target s as E Palmcrof y P end t Dr amedian d area has a income which is greater than 80% of i l B W Carol Ave Ho ay un lid R W Hallcra For an explanation of their methods W Vine Ave y Main and Sycamore Ho dmedian. ft Villas M the regional a esa li W Carmel Ave Ho well as links to their website, see pgs 225-226. and data as W Housing and Transportation Affordability Ha E el Parque Dr S Price Rd W Argon N Longmore N Santa Anna N Santa Anna W Pvt W 21.18% Cibola Mob S Roosevelt Rd en ar tm Ap pe Te m Al ex an Data Not Available Less than 15% 15 to 18% W Birchwood Ave 18 to 20% 20 to 28% 28% and Greater E Broadway Rd W 2nd St 21.28% St W 1st ur Ave at c De Mesa Madrid T W Bentley St W Main St N Ir onw ood Qu a Park ile Home Evergreen Village pe Te m t Transportation Costs, % Income % Income Target Area, Average 24.4 Mesa 25.5 Maricopa County 25.7 St St W Pepper Pl N/A N San Jose S Visalia S Oakwood Dr S Acorn Ave www.cnt.org Ca n E Apache Blvd N May S San Jose N San Jose al T em pe Ca n al Pa th S Roosevelt Rd S Lebanon Ln S George Dr Price Fwy S CottoSnw Price ood Rd Dr S Cottonwood Dr S Cottonw ood Dr S Valencia State Hwy 101 Way ado Dor S el l ana pe C reen Rd Tem verg SE Price Fwy quire S Es 216 W SycamoreW Bentley St US Hwy 89 Transportation Cost as a Robin Rd E Laird St E Laird St W Shadow Ln Percentage of Income W Mesa Ridge E Oakleaf Dr EEPa W 3rd St Dr Maryland lmcroft Dr Household Transportation Costs n W 2nd Pl W Hallcra il L are calculated as Ethe sum Dr E Randall ft Villas M Dr of auto Randall esa ua Q W W Hallc 2nd St ownership costs, auto use costs, ina Ave ra ft Villa E Victory Dr W Catal W Dora St s Me sa E Orange St and public transit costs. Dividing W 1st Pl llis y h P Cir E Don Carlos Ave W de Palma E Don N Carlos Ave these costs by representative W Robin Ave W 1st St E Loma Vista Dr CirElla St del OroW Wthe regional29.78% incomes illustrates Dr E McArthur cost burden placed on a typical household by transportation costs. E el Parque Dr W Belfast W Sycamore 19.66% Holiday Cir W S Valencia The Oaks Mhp W Broadway Rd E University Dr Cactus Wren Rd ino W Garden St Old University Rd W Alcott St S Dobson Rd N Dobson Rd W m Ca r Ci W Bedford W 2nd St S Broadway Village t il R d N PAccess Driveway hy l lis WC amin oS N Santa Barbara Pe lican Bay Club N May N Los Racimos N Santa Barbara N San Jose N May Park Cibola Mob ile Home Evergreen Village S Roosevelt Rd S Roosevelt Rd S Evergreen Rd Illinois N San Jose Pa al Ca n pe al T em Ca n pe Te m Evergreen Apartment Iowa California Ohio Hawaii St N Ir onw ood Qu ail Rd NP hy l lis The Oaks Mhp S Oakwood Dr th S Acorn Ave S Lebanon Ln S George Dr t en ar tm Ap pe Te m Al ex an S Indian Bend Rd o St W 4th Pl W University Dr W 3rd St W 2nd Pl W 5th St N Ash S Allred Dr Ave E Broadway rtm Da h ut W 4th Pl W 3rd Pl 18.01% Target Area Light Rail Stop W Los Racimos S 5th Pl E 6th W W 5th St N Ironwood Data Not Available E 5th St Nevada20% Less than Utah 20 to 30% aho Id Ave W Birchwood on 30 to 40% eg Or 40 to 45% E 7th St 45% and Greater Rd State Ave State State Hwy 101 www.cnt.org Housing Costs, % Income % Income Target Area, Average 20.5 Mesa 22.5 Maricopa County 27.3 Price Fwy State Hwy 101 S Cottonw ood Dr S Cottonwood Dr Price Fwy Housing Cost as a Cactus Wren Rd Robin Rd E Laird St E Laird St W Shadow Ln Percentage of Income E Oakleaf Dr W 3rd St Housing E Maryland Dr costs factored as a n percent of income has widely W 2nd Pl il L E Randall Dr E Randall Dr ua Q been utilized as a measure of W 2nd St E Victory Dr W Dora St affordability. Traditionally, a home e St E Orang is W 1st Pl yll Ph is considered affordable when the Ave E Don Carlos E Don Carlos Ave N W 1st St costs consume no more than 30% W Ella St 23.54% E McArthur Dr of household income. E Apache Blvd W 5th Pl N Dobson t C N Yucca Cir E University Dr W N May S Evergreen NL Illin Ave California Ohio Hawaii E 7th St WC amin oS N Ironwood State Hw St E 6th S Allred Dr State Ave State ah Id on eg Or N Clement W Apartment W Apartment N Mobile Home Park W Apartment N Westwood N Beverly S Beverly Access Rd N Clement S Nina Dr S WestwoodN Westwood W Apartment N Beverly S Davis S Westwood W Apartment S Beverly 5th St 4th St N Beverly 3rd St N Beverly 2nd St 1st St S Elm Annual Transportation Costs $ Target Area, Average 13,337W 1st Ave Mesa 13,960 W Dana AveMaricopa County 14,033 W 1st Ave Dr S Westwood S Nina Dr Access Rd 4th St 5th St 6th St S Broadway Gardens S Davis 3rd St 2nd St 1st St Sunset Blvd S Stewart S Mulberry S Standage S Longmore Holiday Loop S Johnson W 6th Ave W 6th Dr W 7th Ave Lazy Ln Easy St W Dragoon Cir e Westwood ay Main and Sycamore South St W 6th Ave Housing and Transportation Affordability W Vine Ave Elm Ho lid S Sycamore sa ay Ln s Me ay Cir W S Valencia an Jose ft Villa Holiday Ter oliday Rd oliday Cir E S Visalia allcra a Ave North St dos W Crescent Ave Maps and data from the Center for Neighborhood W Mesa Ridge Technology (CNT) using Regional Typical dataWasCapri thisAvetarget ss P a nd aywhich e area has a median income is greater than 80% of d i l W Carol Ave yB Ho da Run W Hregional oli explanation the an of their methods allcraft Villa median. For H y a s Mesa lid W Carmel Ave Hotheir website, see pgs 225-226. andWdata as well as links to H S Rogers Holiday Run Holiday Vw Map and Data from Center for Neighborhood Technology www.cnt.org May 2012 S Alma School Rd S Brooks S Ash Cir S Dobson Rd S Broadway Village S Mulberry W K Mart Access Rd Data Not Available Less than 8750 $/year W Birchwood Ave W Birchwood 8750 toAve9600 $/year 9600 to 10500 $/year 10500 to 11250 $/year 11250 $/year and greater S Monterey Point Con Access Driveway W Broadway Rd Target Area Light Rail Stop W Apartment S Alma Schoo l RdSchool Rd N Alma Sunset Blvd 6th St N Westwood S Broad way Gardens N Emerson N Elm S Stewart SN Stand age Standage S Johnson W Main St S Sycamore www.cnt.org b Pelican Bay Clu W Pvt W Catalin S Rogers W Main St N/A St North2nd Pl W N Mobile Home Park 13132/yr US Hwy 89 Mesa Madrid Townhouses Household Annual Transportation Lazy Ln Ave W VineCosts St Southsum are Easy calculated as the of St W 6th Ave W 2nd St St 2nd W Ownership Costs, Auto Use Ave W 6th Auto W 1st Pl W Auburn St Costs and Public Transit Costs. W 6th Dr W Dragoon Cir WW1st Costs 7thStAve On average, Transportation W Drummer Ave Ave W Drummer household W 7th Dr are the second largest W Pepper Pl expenditure. W Bentley St N Pew W Pepper Pl 13542/yr N Henkel Cir S Longmore W Alcott St W Drake Cir Household Annual Transportation Cost N Stewart St N Stewart W Garden St N Rogers l St W Auburn W 6th Pl Data Not Available Target Area W 6th St Light Rail StopPrivate Dr Less than 1% W 5th Pl W Birchwood Ave 1 to 4% W Birchwood Ave W 5th St 4 to 8% W 4th Pl 8 to 14% 14% and Greater N Rogers P Holiday W Argon N Longmore Crescent WW BedfordAve St Holiday Ter Holiday Rd Holiday Cir E N Sycamore S Sycamore Dr Holiday Ln Holiday Cir W ay 11590/yr Cibola Mob Holiday Loop N Cholla Holiday Run Holiday Vw N Ir onw ood Ho lid es a W 1st St N Santa Barbara N San Jose N May W HW St allc2nd raft V illas M W 3rd Pl W WCapri BelfaAve W 3rdaSt ss st St W Sycamore P nd ay e d i Sycamore W l B W BeW Ave o Carol ntl ey y St HW 2nd aPl un lid R Ho day li W Carmel Ave W 2n o d St W 2nd StH W 3rd St W 1st Pl ile Home Park W Shadow Ln W Dana Ave W 7th St S Mulberry S Brooks W 4th Pl N Pew N Stewart N Rogers N Standage W 6th Pl S Mulberry N Longmore N Ash W 5th St N Ash S Ash Cir W 4th Pl W 7th St W 5th Pl N Saguaro W 5th St N Beverly N Rogers W 7th Pl W Dell Cir W 6th St W K Mart Access Rd W 5th Pl N Alma School Rd N Standage N Henkel Cir Transit Ridership, % of Workers % of Workers Target Area, Average 6.6 Mesa 3.6 1st Ave WMaricopa Devonshire StCounty W Devonshire St W4.2 W Main St S Sycamore Dr ew St Ave Vi W 1st r n tu ai ca nt ou De M W W W Devon N Beverly N Ash W Main St www.cnt.org dos S Valencia Cir el Oro W Ella St alma Cir N N Sagu N Pecan N Sycamore N Longmore N Cholla N Ir onw ood S Broadway Village W Pvt W HalW lcra2nd ft ViPl llas Mesa a Ave W CatalinW Dora St il s l y Ph Cir Palma N St N San Jose n S San Jose il L S Visalia Robin Rd W Mesa Ridge ua Q S Valencia 6.67% N/A Dobson Rd S DobsonNRd Qu ail Rd NP hAcces ylli s Driveway s The Oaks Mhp S Valencia r Ci W Pepper Pl S Monterey Point Con S Oakwood Dr m Ca ino W 1st St Old University Rd Map and Data from Center for Neighborhood Technology www.cnt.org May 2012 W University Dr Cactus Wren Rd Dr St W 2nd St W Pepper Pl N Ironwood N May W W Broadway Rd t W Auburn N Ash W Los Racimos Dr St N Pecan b Pelican Bay Clu t W 2nd St W Argon Transit Ridership as a Percentage of Workers W 2nd Pl Townhouses Madrid Mesa Transit Ridership represents the percentage of workers in a Block Group who utilize Public W 2nd St Transportation (Transit) as their W 1st Pl W Auburn St primary mode of transportation to work. W Bentley St US Hwy 89 N Yucca Cir N Santa Barbara St WC amin oS St W Alcott St N Santa Anna Park o Old University Rd W 1st St ile Home Cibola Mob rtm Da W 4th Pl W Garden St W Belfast St W Sycamore W SycamoreW Bentley St 6.51% W 5th St W 4th Pl W Bedford W 1st Pl 9.78% h ut W 5th St W University Dr W 2nd St W 2nd St N Santa Anna llis W Ella St W N Dobson N May W Dora St W 2nd Pl W 2nd Pl W 4th Pl W 3rd Pl W 3rd St W 3rd St N Santa Anna y Ph n W Shadow Ln N Santa Barbara N lL ai N San Jose Qu ail Rd NP hy l lis Robin Rd u Q St W 5th Pl W 5th St Cactus Wren Rd N May S Oakwood Dr f Dr W N San Jose St t N Ironwood y Dr The Oaks Mhp WC amin oS 217 N Henkel Cir N Rogers W 1st P W 1st St N Rogers 16598 Miles US Hwy 89 N Stewart W Pepper Pl W Pepper Pl 17206 Miles N/A N Standage N Pecan N Ash N Longmore N Cholla N Sycamore St W 2nd St W Main St W Main St N Santa Anna N Santa Barbara W Auburn S Sycamore ile Home W Dana Ave S Brooks S Ash Cir S Dobson Rd S Broadway Village ay Dr P Holiday l W 6th Dr W 7th Dr www.cnt.org Travel Time to Work Minutes Target Area, Average 25.5 Mesa 26.0 Maricopa County 26.0 Data Not Available Less than 22 minutes 22 to 25 minutes 25 to 29 minutes 29 to 33 minutes 33 minutes and greater Target Area Light Rail Stop Main and Sycamore Housing and Transportation Affordability S Stewart S Standage W 6th Ave W 7th Ave W Drake Cir S Mulberry S Johnson S Rogers W Vine Ave Sunset Blvd W Carmel Ave S Longmore W Capri Ave W Carol Ave Map and Data from Center for Neighborhood Technology www.cnt.org January 2012 Maps and data from the Center for Neighborhood Technology (CNT) using Regional Typical data as this target area has a median income which is greater than 80% of the regional median. For an explanation of their methods and data as well as links to their website, see pgs 225-226. S Elm Holiday Cir W Ho lid Holiday Loop ass y P end lida B o H ay un lid R Ho day li Ho W Crescent Ave S Sycamore Holiday Run Holiday Vw Map and Data from Center for Neighborhood Technology www.cnt.org May 2012 Holiday Ter Holiday Rd Holiday Cir E Access Driveway S San Jose S Mulberry W K Mart Access Rd S Visalia S Valencia S Roosevelt Rd S Valencia S Cottonw ood Dr St lican Bay Club S Roosevelt Rd Pe W Broadway Rd Way S Price Rd W 2nd St W Argon Mesa Madrid Tow W Bentley St W Alcott St W Pvt quire S Es ado Dor S el l ana pe C reen Rd Tem verg SE 218 W 2nd St Travel Time W Mesa Ridge E Palmcrof to Work t Dr Travel time to work is measured W Hallcra ft Villas M esa in minutes and represents an W Ha ll c ra e ft Villa a Av W Catalin s Me sa average of the total time it takes W de commuters in a block group toPalma Cir W Robin Ave E Loma Vista Dr get to work by their primaryW del Oro Cir mode used. Includes auto, biking, walking, and public transit. E el Parque Dr St W Belfast St W Sycamore W Sycamore W Bentley St W 1st Ave Target Area Light Rail Stop S Indian Bend Rd Al ex an Data Not Available Less than 12,000 annual miles 12,000 to 14,000 annual miles 14,000 WtoBirchwood 16,000Ave annual miles 16,000 to 18,000 annual miles E Broadway Rd 18,000 annual miles and greater W Garden St Old University Rd W University Dr W 3rd St 14913 Miles Cibola Mob Evergreen Apartment Te m pe Ap ar tm en S Roosevelt Rd t Te m pe Vehicle Miles Traveled/Household Annual Miles Target Area, Average 16,903 Mesa 18,888 Maricopa County 19,071 W 4th Pl W Bedford W 3rd Pl W 2nd Pl N San Jose N May Park Evergreen Village www.cnt.org N San Jose Pa al Ca n pe Ca n E Apache Blvd N Ir onw ood Qu ail Rd NP hy l lis The Oaks Mhp S Oakwood Dr th S Acorn Ave S George Dr S Lebanon Ln al T em State Hwy 101 State Hwy 101 S Cottonw ood Dr S Cottonwood Dr Price Fwy Vehicle Miles Traveled Cactus Wren Rd Robin Rd E Laird St per Household E Laird St W Shadow Ln E Oakleaf Dr Vehicle miles traveled per W 3rd St E Maryland Dr n household models the average W 2nd Pl lL E Randall Dr E Randall Dr ai annual auto travel by households Qu W 2nd St E Victory Dr W Dora St in a block group. This includes E Orange St W 1st Pl llis commute travel, but also all N Phy W 1st St Milestrips made by all other 15585 daily auto W Ella St E McArthur Dr members of the household. W 5th St W 4th Pl W 5th St N Sag N Dobs t Holiday Ln E University Dr N May N WC amin oS N Ironwood E 7th St St S Evergree E 6th Il on Ave California Ohio Hawaii Pric eg Or S Allred Dr State Ave State I Resources 219 RESOURCES LOCAL RESOURCES: City of Phoenix Sustainability Program http://phoenix.gov/greenphoenix/sustainability/index.html ASU Global Institute of Sustainability http://sustainability.asu.edu/index.php Sustainable Cities Network http://sustainablecities.asu.edu AZ Stardust Center, Public Education Campaign “Growing Sustainable Communities in the Valley of the Sun” http://stardust.asu.edu/research_resources/ detail.php?id=31 Valley Forward http://www.valleyforward.org City of Mesa Sustainability Program http://www.mesaaz.gov/sustainability/ 220 Maricopa County Green Government Program http://www.maricopa.gov/GreenGovernment/ Maricopa Association of Governments, Sustainable Transportation and Land Use Integration Study http://www.bqaz.org/sustainOverview. asp?mS=m16 Local First Arizona http://www.localfirstaz.com/index.php Connecting Phoenix http://www.connectingphoenix.com/ Sustainable Arizona Resource and Education Council http://www.sustainablearizona.org/ City of Tempe, “A Sustainable Tempe” http://www.tempe.gov/greenprograms/pdfs/ SustainabilityBrochure2011.pdf Valley Metro, Transit Oriented Development http://www.valleymetro.org/metro_projects_ planning/transit_oriented_development/ RESOURCES (CONT.) LOCAL RESOURCES: Friends of Transit http://www.friendsoftransit.org/ Arizona Transit Association http://www.azta.org/ South West Transit Association http://www.swta.org/Default.aspx Discovery Triangle Development Corporation http://www.discoverytriangle.org/ NATIONAL RESOURCES: U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development, Office of Sustainable Housing and Communities http://portal.hud.gov:80/hudportal/HUD?src=/ program_offices/sustainable_housing_communities Department of Housing and Urban Development, Department of Transportation, and the Environmental Protection Agency, Partnership for Sustainable Communities http://www.epa.gov/dced/partnership/ The U.S. Partnership for Education for Sustainable Development http://www.uspartnership.org/main/view_archive/1 Environmental Protection Agency, Smart Growth Online http://www.smartgrowth.org/ US Dept of Agriculture: National Institute of Food And Agriculture, Sustainable Living Education National Network http://www.csrees.usda.gov/nea/nre/in_focus/ susdev_if_living.html Local Initiatives Support Corporation http://www.lisc.org/ INTERNATIONAL RESOURCES: ICLEI-Local Governments For Sustainability (International Council for Local Environmental Initiatives) http://www.iclei.org/ 221 SELECTED ZONING AND OVERLAY CLASSIFICATIONS CITY OF PHOENIX 222 ZONING A-1: light industrial A-2: industrial C-1: commercial - neighborhood retail C-2: commercial - intermediate commercial C-3: commercial - general commercial C-O: commercial office - restricted commercial C-O/G-O: commercial office - general office option (minimum 1 gross acre) DTC: Downtown Core P-1: passenger automobile parking, limited (surface parking) P-2: parking (surface parking and parking structures) R1-10: single family residential with a density range of 3 to 3.5 dwelling units per gross acre R1-6: single family residential with a density range of 5 to 5.5 dwelling units per gross acre R-3: multi-family residential with a density range of 14.5 to 15.23 dwelling units per gross acre R-4: multi-family residential with a density range of 29 to 30.45 dwelling units per gross acre R-4A: multi-family residential (dependant on lot area and unit type) R-5: multi-family residential with a density range of 43.5 to 45.68 dwelling units per gross acre R-O: residential office - restricted commercial OVERLAY DC: downtown core district (underlying zoning for Fillmore to Harrison and 7th St. to 3rd Ave.) HP: historic preservation overlay (combined with underlying zoning) HR: high-rise and high density (combined with underlying zoning) HRI: high-rise incentive - high-rise and mixed use (combined with underlying zoning) RI: residential infill (combined with underlying zoning) SPD: North Central Avenue Special Planning District overlay district TOD-1: transit oriented development (combined with underlying zoning) For more information on Phoenix Zoning Classifications, see the City of Phoenix website at: http://phoenix.gov/PLANNING/zondistr.html and Zoning Ordinance of the City of Phoenix, chapter 6 at: http://www.codepublishing.com/ az/phoenix/ SELECTED ZONING AND OVERLAY CLASSIFICATIONS CITY OF TEMPE ZONING CSS: commercial shopping and service GID: general industrial district MU-4: mixed-use, high density (requires a PAD overlay) R1-6: single family residential with a density of 4 dwelling units per acre R1-PAD: single family residential Planned Area Development (requires a PAD overly) with a density of up to 9 dwelling units per acre R-2: multi-family residential with a density of 10 dwelling units per acre R-3: multi-family residential limited with a density of 20 dwelling units per acre R-3R: multi-family residential restricted with a density of 15 dwelling units per acre R-4: multi-family residential general with a density of 25 dwelling units per acre R/O: residential/office TP: trailer park with a density of 14 dwelling units per acre OVERLAY HP: historic preservation overlay district PAD: planned area development overlay district For more information on Tempe Zoning Classifications, see City of Tempe’s Zoning and Development Code at: http://www.tempe.gov/ zoning/ZDCode/ADCpart2.pdf 223 SELECTED ZONING AND OVERLAY CLASSIFICATIONS CITY OF MESA ZONING C-1: neighborhood commercial - large-scale offices, small-scale retail C-2: limited commercial - indoor retail, shopping centers, group commercial developments C-3: general commercial - variety of outdoor and indoor commercial activity M-1: limited industrial - limited manufacturing, processing, warehousing M-2: general industrial - intensive industrial, manufacturing, indoor and outdoor storage PF: public facilities - large-scale government, public utility, recreational, and educational facilities on a minimum of 10 acre lot R-3: multi-family residential - medium density, with a maximum of 17 dwelling units per acre R-4: multi-family residential - high density, with a maximum of 25 dwelling units per acre 224 OVERLAY HP: historic preservation - historic, visually or architecturally significant area at least fifty years old with a minimum of seven contiguous properties or 300 feet of street frontage For more information on Mesa Zoning Classifications, see pgs 27-28 of City of Mesa’s General Plan at: http://www.mesaaz.gov/ planning/PDF/GeneralPlan/MesaGeneralPlan. pdf THIRD PARTY ANALYSIS: CENTER FOR NEIGHBORHOOD TECHNOLOGY Drachman Institute utilized data analyses by the Center for Neighborhood Technology (CNT). A brief explanation of their methods and data as well as links to their website, are provided below: MEDIAN INCOME Median Income refers to Median Household Income in 1999 (P53) obtained at the block group level as well as at the regional level (MSA or PMSA) to define the Area Median Income (AMI). For more information see http:// htaindex.cnt.org/downloads/Methods.3.3.11. pdf HOUSING COSTS Housing Costs were determined using the 2000 US Census Summary File 3 variables Selected Monthly Owner Costs for All Owner-Occupied Housing Units with a Mortgage and Gross Rent for Renters Paying Cash. For more information see http://htaindex.cnt.org/downloads/ Methods.3.3.11.pdf TRANSPORTATION COSTS The transportation model was used to estimate auto ownership (vehicles per household), auto use (annual vehicle miles traveled), and transit use for each block group. To calculate total transportation costs, values for the per unit cost of each component were determined and then aggregated for the specific transportation components in each block group. For more information see http://htaindex.cnt.org/ downloads/Methods.3.3.11.pdf TRANSIT USE Because no direct measure of transit use was available at the block group level, a proxy was utilized for the measured data representing the dependent variable of transit use. From the US Census Summary File 3, Means of Transportation to Work (P30) was used to calculate a percent of commuters utilizing public transit. For more information see http:// htaindex.cnt.org/downloads/Methods.3.3.11. pdf 225 THIRD PARTY ANALYSIS: CENTER FOR NEIGHBORHOOD TECHNOLOGY (CONT.) AVERAGE JOURNEY TO WORK TIME Average Journey to Work Time was calculated using Aggregate Travel Time to Work (in minutes) by Travel Time to Work by Means of Transportation to Work (P30 from 2000 U.S. Census Summary File 3) to define the universe of Worker 16 Years and Over Who Did Not Work at Home. Average journey to work time was calculated at the block group level in minutes. For more information see http://htaindex.cnt. org/downloads/Methods.3.3.11.pdf 226 VEHICLE MILES TRAVELED For the dependent variable of auto use, the regression analysis was fit using measured data representing the total amount that households drive their autos, or vehicle miles traveled (VMT) per automobile. In order to determine the amount that households drive their autos, odometer readings are utilized. Data are obtained for one region of the country, the optimum formula is determined using the independent variables in that region, and these formula are then applied to the study area. Odometer readings for the time period of 20052007 were obtained from the Massachusetts Department of Transportation for the entire state at a 250 meter grid cell level. A similar data set for the greater Chicago area was analyzed at the zip code level and compared with the Massachusetts data set resulting in similar relationships with the independent variables. Due to the geographic scale of the Massachusetts data set, the regression analysis is fit using these data. For more information see http://htaindex.cnt.org/downloads/ Methods.3.3.11.pdf